If you must have that sort of system, there probably ought to be an obligation on the buyer to first pay to have the entire existing structure demolished.
I think the offer is supposed to be on the improved value (IE including the value of the building) but the tax is on the unimproved value, so you do get the value of your house if they buy the land.
Perhaps more reasonable would, if we imagine a new Georgist Charter city, to require that every building is detachable from the land; IE it is attached to its foundations, by twistlocks, like intermodal containers, with the utilities also being supplied via some standardised connector. Not only would you then just be able to move your house to somewhere else, but it would have several other advantages. It would be a universal argument against NIMBYism - if you don't like new infrastructure being built near you, you can just move your house elsewhere. It would make it less disruptive to build new infrastructure anyway, as houses could be moved out of the way instead of being demolished.
If you now say that we need to provide two different valuations (land + structure) but we're only taxed on one, don't you think we'll find that everyone lives in very expensive houses on worthless plots of land?
What are you suggesting as an alternative?
- Both taxation and offer on the improved value - this is consistent, but it's no longer Georgism so it doesn't solve the problem of how to estimate and tax the unimproved value
- Both taxation and offer on the unimproved value - this is now unfair to the owner as you're not paying for the value of their house, and also they have the incentive to include the value of the house in the land value
No mandatory acceptance of offers, land valuation by fiat.
WHAT? This is ridiculous. What happens if someone buys the land out from under your skyscraper, and you can't afford to move it a couple blocks over? Do you live in a LEGO world?
Then you could "value" the land at £200k and pay a higher property tax to secure that preference. In other words, your property is more valuable, to you.
>If you must have that sort of system, there probably ought to be an obligation on the buyer to first pay to have the entire existing structure demolished.
I think you are right, which is a problem. Or you could stipulate that all the buildings are demolished before the land bought in this manner is used.
I think this system would evolve into people overvaluing their land to be between the land and the land+building value, and then keeping a public offer for the land+building value. That strategy would minimize the land-only sales and encourage buyers to buy the entire building instead.
That's fine, but then it becomes a property tax rather than a land value tax.
The hard part is that its implementation would cause a significant (& possibly violent) backlash from land owners intent on defending their privilege.
I already pay a land value tax. I also pay a tax on the house.
The same goes for commercial properties here.
Is this really not common? I constantly see internet claims about how it would cause violent uproar from evil land owners if we taxed land value, but as a land owner I can tell you it’s already happening.
Switching to a full land value tax would just redistribute the taxation entirely on to the land and make the structure tax free. That would be awesome for the people with giant, new construction houses around me but not so good for those of us with smaller, older construction buildings in the same neighborhoods. It would be really bad for the old people living out their final years in their modest old houses which need a lot of repairs (and therefore have low structure grades in the tax system and low structure taxation).
LVT does exist in several places in the world but it's usually around ~3-5%. Unusually for most taxes, it can be raised probably to almost 100% without any economic ill effects, but the land ownership classes would raise absolute hell.
This is how their propaganda mouthpieces reacted in the UK at the proposal: https://archive.ph/6gtRC
>That would be awesome for the people with giant, new construction houses around me but not so good for those of us with smaller, older construction buildings
Not sure why you feel specifically singled out, but ok.
It would be most awesome for people living in high density apartments and least awesome for people who live in crappy low density housing in high value areas which ought to be converted to apartments.
>It would be really bad for the old people living out their final years in their modest old houses which need a lot of repairs (and therefore have low structure grades in the tax system and low structure taxation).
Only if you pretend that those people can't move, and they would. Those people would just downshift to apartments in response - this used to be a lot more common anyway - my grandmother did this.
If you want somebody to feel sorry for, though, feel sorry for old people living out their final years in rented accomodation. If you rent, by definition, you have to pay LVT (to a private landlord), and if you can't pay - to the street for you.
If you are low-balling the price to save on taxes, you run the risk that someone swoops up your property for cheap.
You can't submit bids in this system without the intention of buying, if you have the highest bid you're forced to buy.
If you can demonstrate that the purchase offer is made because of personal animus, or the buyer has no reasonable and specific plans for the property (i.e. the billionaire buying out a small town without a workable business plan), then the courts would overturn it.
Ultimately, billionaires have lots of ways to mess with someone they don't like. If we don't like that, we should circumscribe what billionaires can do with their power.
It's not fine for grandma. She doesn't have a team of analysts, she just wants her house. The main criticism of capitalism is that it's bad for the little people. Replacing it with something else that's also bad for the little people isn't really any better.
You could try to find compromises like locking the family home until death or voluntary sale... then you have extra complications like making it legal for someone to start a small business at their family home without also creating a grey market for people to rent their family homes for other people to start businesses in (or just to live in) and getting the system we already have.
This is how you end up with homeless seniors and disabled people. In my opinion, we shouldn't be working up schemes to force people out of their property. Otherwise you get a developer that comes in and offers you a price you literally can't refuse, pushing the market entirely in favor of the wealthy.
Not really. You might be forcing someone out of a 2.5% mortgage into a 6% mortgage on a new property, incurring property transfer taxes, moving costs, loan underwriting, and other fees. You very well could lose money in some situations. Your argument also assumes they are not in the cheapest homes already. If they are, they could be forced out of the geographic area altogether if there are no cheaper homes (and inherently rents will be more expensive than the cheapest mortgages under that system).
We had a family farm that had our taxes go from under $4,000 to around $25,0000 in a single year. There was no warning it just happened. We ended up selling the farm in a few years at a value it was being taxed.
I also think that NIMBY/YIMBY is a strawman argument used to keep the conversation from developing.
Distracted from what? I do in fact view NIMBYs as the biggest roadblock to expansion of housing supply, so I must be part of the distracted masses you're referring to. What am I missing?
One example would be allowing mobile homes with HUD certification. Advocates for this idea would argue that it would provide affordable housing which is true if one looks at initial costs of just shelter. The problem is that currently HUD divides their housing standards by geography and north west Massachusetts and Virginia are considered the same region. This causes the insulation requirements are really inadequate for our winters. This was further complicated by mobile home providers supplying air sourced heat pumps as the heating and cooling. The mobile home was then able to marketed as energy efficient. The problem was that heating system would be completely inadequate without intense insulation upgrades.
The HUD certification comes along with the inability for any local building codes to be enforced. In 2006 as a town we voted to impose "Stretch Codes" for energy efficiency. We voted for that knowing it was going to add at 25% for any building project in town.
My opinion was that the result would unsustainable electric bills and inadequate heating for our vulnerable population. I believed that we would create a two tiered housing system and our vulnerable population would have inadequate housing. I have nothing against mobile homes and believed we could use mobile homes as housing under the current building codes if they had permanent foundation and were sheathed in an extra layer of insulation.
I saw the label of NIMBY as dismissive and distracting from actual issues and the conversation never developed.
I have experience with both air sourced heat pumps and insulation in our area. I have developed an abandoned school into studio apartments that use heat pumps exclusively for heating.
I find catchy labels like NIMBY and YIMBY close to meaningless and hamper dialog and the development of ideas.
Thank you for the comment I updated it to sound less conspiratorial.
Your mileage my vary.
Maybe in Southern California they can work but most everywhere else you end up spending lot rent + heating and it’s more than an apartment would be.
The other driver is that there is plenty of affordable(good deals) in neighboring towns 15 minutes aways.
Of course some modular homes that have a technical mobile part are a different story.
Around here the “live while building” is usually done with a garage with a small apartment above it.
Tenement housing is pretty horrible but way better than not being able to afford anything.
Boarding house rooms are horrible but better than not having a low cost/low commitment option while you figure things out.
Pretty much all of these existed a generation or two ago where I am from but are now completely gone and outright banned by city code. All done by supposed do-good era who had the best of intentions in mind.
We have completely removed the bottom rung of housing for anyone who needs to get started or fallen upon hard times. Once you fall you are simply not getting back up again.
Sometimes perfect is the enemy of good enough for now. I’d much rather live in a trailer home in Minnesota (and have!) than a tent or homeless on the street or in my car. There were very few other options available at the time. Less so now. Dealing with frozen pipes and only being able to afford to marginally heat one bedroom to 50 degrees during a cold spell is luxury to some folks.
I think they should be pushed out by the wealthy. If you're holding onto residential land in a developing city, and someone wants to build a skyscraper there they should be able to buy you out at a reasonable price. You shouldn't be able to hold land hostage while also paying low property tax
It's quite likely that once you can legally build a skyscraper on any piece of earth you own, that resorting to a tax extortion fest for old people in desirable areas will seem far more absurd than it already does.
High land values are in large part because zoning requires oversized land ownership for a token to build a housing unit, creating mass artificial demand. The other piece is in places like some of California the regulatory / licensing / permit costs cost more than it cost me to build my whole house.
If you cut off the profit motive by disenfranchising property owners in this respect, the building regulation will return to the level needed for (actual) public safety and wellness (as opposed to just racketeering).
The world is full of land that is held by sellers who won’t sell it “for what it’s worth” - for any number of reasons.
Heck, moving hassle alone means you’d need to hit me with a 50% premium to get me to sell my house, because I don’t want to move right now.
"You shouldn't be able to hold land hostage while also paying low property tax"
What property are you holding hostage that I can liberate from you?
Because the taxes aren't reasonable. Land is a limited resource.
Imagine a regulation that limited factories by taxing them on the amount of smog they produce. Your argument is like saying "old factories should be able to produce smog at the same tax rate as when they started, it's unreasonable to expect companies to just rebuild factories around new technology"
>What property are you holding hostage that I can liberate from you?
I don't own any property. But if I did, you would be free to liberate it for a pretty penny.
Parting with friends is a sadness. A place is only a place.
Taxes seem high to me in my area. Land is a limited resource, but not as limited as you are implying. There is plenty of land in other areas that could be developed. Instead, we have people with a preference for homes in existing areas favoring using the government to force people out.
Your smog example is completely off base and doesn't represent the way the taxes work in many areas outside of California. My taxes go up every year and will eventually be reassessed for additonal increase. However, that assessment goes up based on reasonable evaluation and not on someone potentially targeting you or your property by bidding it up.
"I don't own any property."
I assume you live somewhere. Perhaps you will be forced out when a wealthy company buys up all the rentals and raises rents.
If you put a $10m/yr property tax on the local Walmart, that money simply comes from slightly higher prices on everything (or most non-nationally advertised things).
Landlords aren’t paying property tax out of the goodness of their hearts, they’re paying them out of the rents, and if they go high enough they’ll either raise rents or sell-abandon the building.
Which may be the goal, after all.
Much more now taxes are behavioral rather than income for the government (especially given the deficits). And credits are explicitly so.
At least income taxes stop when your income stops. Many others don’t.
They shouldn't be forced to do it, but they seem to love it. You'd be suprised how many people would prefer a one room shack given the option, lots of people don't actually want the kind of houses zoning and codes require in more dystopian parts of the US, they would rather spend that money on leisure or their children, or their own health.
> I think they should be pushed out by the wealthy.
This pretty well summarizes why there is so much opposition..
Seriously? Dump the elderly and disabled on the street to favor the very rich?
This is despite Prop 13 and all the laws on top of it that are designed to keep seniors in their forever homes. Feels like maybe handouts to real estate investment is not the way to give people a roof over their head.
This was already done in every place I’ve ever lived. The local assessor has rules and algorithms for valuing land and valuing structures for tax purposes.
Insurers do the same.
It’s so common that I’m confused about why it’s a sticking point in these conversations. I think a lot of LVT proponents don’t even understand that land is currently taxed in many (most?) places. Switching to a pure LVT would just make the structures free from taxation and redistribute the missing tax revenue on to the pure land value.
Great for people with big, nice, new houses who would get to shift some of their tax burden to their neighbors with smaller, older, less nice houses on similar land.
If I see an Apple shop across from a parking lot, it may not be immediately obvious that the land part of the valuations should be similar. I could see the crowd systematically getting this wrong.
Having said that, it's not a damning criticism. I think LVT is a good idea, and people are generally going to know what piece of land is worth more than another. You can then stitch the relative values to some sort of exchange-based anchoring to give your map real dollar values.
I do tend to think a Harberger system makes a lot of sense, though. Maybe something a little bit like:
- Everyone puts a value on their land. We take the total, figure out what percentage needs to be taken, and everyone pays their share of the tax take accordingly.
- Your land is for sale at the price you put, but you can change up the price if you don't want to sell it, and thus pay up extra tax. If you have land set at 1M and someone comes and offers 1M, but you don't want to sell, you can pay the tax at whatever price is too high for him, eg 2M would double your tax. The offer needs to be firm so that you have an actual choice, someone can't just double your tax bill on a whim.