News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by beeflet on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:31AM (#44150725)
seniors and disabled people can't just live somewhere cheaper?

I think they should be pushed out by the wealthy. If you're holding onto residential land in a developing city, and someone wants to build a skyscraper there they should be able to buy you out at a reasonable price. You shouldn't be able to hold land hostage while also paying low property tax

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by ty6853 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:41AM (#44150798)
Implementing Georgism before deregulating land use seems like putting the cart before the horse.

It's quite likely that once you can legally build a skyscraper on any piece of earth you own, that resorting to a tax extortion fest for old people in desirable areas will seem far more absurd than it already does.

High land values are in large part because zoning requires oversized land ownership for a token to build a housing unit, creating mass artificial demand. The other piece is in places like some of California the regulatory / licensing / permit costs cost more than it cost me to build my whole house.

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by beeflet on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:10AM (#44151016)
Is it putting the cart before the horse? those zoning laws are a result of property owners trying to benefit from the unimproved value of the land by locally restricting the supply of property.

If you cut off the profit motive by disenfranchising property owners in this respect, the building regulation will return to the level needed for (actual) public safety and wellness (as opposed to just racketeering).

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by HDThoreaun on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:16AM (#44151062)
Under LVT there are huge inventive to keeping your land value low. Densifying causes land values to increase so rational actors who dont want to move will oppose density.
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by beeflet on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:46AM (#44151274)
If the value of their land is low, you can buy them out for cheap and change the local regulation.
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by bombcar on Sunday June 01, 2025 @01:03PM (#44152267)
Only if you can force them to sell.

The world is full of land that is held by sellers who won’t sell it “for what it’s worth” - for any number of reasons.

Heck, moving hassle alone means you’d need to hit me with a 50% premium to get me to sell my house, because I don’t want to move right now.

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by rcpt on Sunday June 01, 2025 @03:46PM (#44153326)
You can not control the value of your land.
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by HDThoreaun on Sunday June 01, 2025 @04:04PM (#44153418)
You can by being a nimby.
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by giantg2 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @06:47PM (#44154318)
Of course you can. You can put all sorts of deed restrictions on it, foster some sort of habitat for protected animals,turn it into a wetland (protected), etc.
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by giantg2 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:40AM (#44150792)
It sounds like you want to just move the undesirables to a ghetto (in the real sense of the word). Why shouldn't someone be able to buy a home and live there until they die if they can pay reasonable taxes? Redevelop the land as the population turns over instead of marginalizing people.

"You shouldn't be able to hold land hostage while also paying low property tax"

What property are you holding hostage that I can liberate from you?

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by beeflet on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:00AM (#44150926)
>Why shouldn't someone be able to buy a home and live there until they die if they can pay reasonable taxes?

Because the taxes aren't reasonable. Land is a limited resource.

Imagine a regulation that limited factories by taxing them on the amount of smog they produce. Your argument is like saying "old factories should be able to produce smog at the same tax rate as when they started, it's unreasonable to expect companies to just rebuild factories around new technology"

>What property are you holding hostage that I can liberate from you?

I don't own any property. But if I did, you would be free to liberate it for a pretty penny.

Parting with friends is a sadness. A place is only a place.

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by giantg2 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @10:13AM (#44151032)
"Because the taxes aren't reasonable. Land is a limited resource."

Taxes seem high to me in my area. Land is a limited resource, but not as limited as you are implying. There is plenty of land in other areas that could be developed. Instead, we have people with a preference for homes in existing areas favoring using the government to force people out.

Your smog example is completely off base and doesn't represent the way the taxes work in many areas outside of California. My taxes go up every year and will eventually be reassessed for additonal increase. However, that assessment goes up based on reasonable evaluation and not on someone potentially targeting you or your property by bidding it up.

"I don't own any property."

I assume you live somewhere. Perhaps you will be forced out when a wealthy company buys up all the rentals and raises rents.

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by bombcar on Sunday June 01, 2025 @01:01PM (#44152253)
People don’t realize that all property tax levied is paid for … by people.

If you put a $10m/yr property tax on the local Walmart, that money simply comes from slightly higher prices on everything (or most non-nationally advertised things).

Landlords aren’t paying property tax out of the goodness of their hearts, they’re paying them out of the rents, and if they go high enough they’ll either raise rents or sell-abandon the building.

Which may be the goal, after all.

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by giantg2 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @01:51PM (#44152597)
I think the even more hidden thing is that taxes are more about policy than revenue. If it was just about revenue, then they would tax it at the source - income tax on people and companies. But just imagine the reaction people would have when 50% of their paycheck was gone. They even hid the cost of social security and Medicare by making the employer pay half so it doesn't show on the paycheck. Break it up and people don't add it up and you can use it to control their behavior on different subjects.
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by bombcar on Sunday June 01, 2025 @02:04PM (#44152685)
John Marshall - “The power to tax is the power to destroy”

Much more now taxes are behavioral rather than income for the government (especially given the deficits). And credits are explicitly so.

At least income taxes stop when your income stops. Many others don’t.

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by snarf21 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:39AM (#44150783)
Serious question: What about when you are old? Okay being forced to live in a one room shack in the middle of nowhere just because you are retired?
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by ty6853 on Sunday June 01, 2025 @09:45AM (#44150817)
I live in the middle of nowhere where lots of people build one room shacks in the desert, because we allow that here. You can build whatever the fuck you want. Some are living in mud huts (yes in the USA).

They shouldn't be forced to do it, but they seem to love it. You'd be suprised how many people would prefer a one room shack given the option, lots of people don't actually want the kind of houses zoning and codes require in more dystopian parts of the US, they would rather spend that money on leisure or their children, or their own health.

Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by BeFlatXIII on Sunday June 01, 2025 @12:33PM (#44152066)
That's great for everyone who likes asceticism, but what about everyone else?
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by rcpt on Sunday June 01, 2025 @03:45PM (#44153321)
How about being forced to stay put forever in the same two story 4 bedroom house in a busy job center?
Re:Georgists Valued Land in the 1900s by jjav on Sunday June 01, 2025 @12:30PM (#44152034)
> seniors and disabled people can't just live somewhere cheaper?

> I think they should be pushed out by the wealthy.

This pretty well summarizes why there is so much opposition..

Seriously? Dump the elderly and disabled on the street to favor the very rich?