News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by chvid on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:22PM (#43976611)
Identity providing is a natural monopoly and should be provided by the state in same manner as a passport is provided.

We can discuss the implementation but in Denmark and quite a few other countries, the login problem in online government services and banking is solved by a single state run identity provider (MitID) and hopefully the EU will be succesful with their EIDAS initiative and provide a solution that works across country boundaries.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EIDAS

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by snowwrestler on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:29PM (#43976679)
In the U.S., identity providing is not a role the government fills. Not everyone has to have a passport, for example. A passport is merely a purpose-specific tool for crossing borders, not general identity.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by loeg on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:17PM (#43977215)
And it is a significant flaw of the US model!
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by kortilla on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:52PM (#43977598)
Not if you ask people who specifically don’t want the government tracking everything
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by tart-lemonade on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:40PM (#43978054)
And the worst part is a federal ID would not enable tracking any more than your employers withholding wages for tax purposes and paying into Social Security does, but every time a federal ID has been proposed (which would be really useful as a way to keep SSNs from becoming something you have to disclose to everyone and their dog) it's been shut down by the "it's all a road to tyranny" crowd.

I could get a Real ID that reads "1060 W Addison St" today. All I have to do is pirate Acrobat, change the addresses on PDFs downloaded from the websites of my bank and power company, and walk into an Illinois Secretary of State office, as that's enough for the residency portion of a Real ID. They do not double-check any of this information, and I know this works because I had to edit a power bill PDF so my SO would have a second document for proof of residency. All it would take is one phone call to find out I'm the only one listed on the account, but it was never verified.

Why anyone thinks a federal ID would enable mass surveillance and tracking is beyond me. The NSA doesn't need a unified federal ID to track us, and law enforcement isn't exactly foiled by people who hold fake IDs or who have no IDs whatsoever (unless being undocumented or Amish is some magical "get out of jail free" card).

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by const_cast on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:51PM (#43979181)
The government is already tracking things like your financial investments. Except now, they're doing it in a disconnected and sprawling way, centered around your SSN. Which is insecure.

I'm very paranoid about tracking and privacy, but the reality is that identity verification is just a necessary part of some services. Like opening a brokerage account, or riding a plane. So, if we HAVE to do it, we should have a more secure way of doing it. There's no reason we should be relying on easily-gathered 9 digit numbers.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by kortilla on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @08:03PM (#43979266)
Riding on a plane doesn’t require centralized identification. Well at least it didn’t until real ID, but flying was perfectly fine without it before.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by loeg on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @10:38PM (#43980159)
Actually, it does. They verify who you are before they let you board, even if you don't bring ID documents.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by lxgr on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:07PM (#43978818)
Ironically, lax to nonexistent data privacy laws and the ubiquitous use of SSNs as globally unique identifiers are achieving exactly the outcome that the lack of government ID verification purportedly achieves.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by kortilla on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @08:04PM (#43979270)
You don’t need an externally generated globally unique ID verified by the government.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by lxgr on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @08:19PM (#43979382)
You definitely need a unique ID assigned by the government for pretty much anything involving money or healthcare in the US.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by loeg on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:32PM (#43977965)
They are deluded if they think the lack of federal ID (ignoring Social Security) provides any privacy benefit, and the cost is immense.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by chvid on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:54PM (#43976977)
You have plenty of government id's in the US as well. Driver licenses, tax number, birth certificates ...

I think often people mess up the subjects of privacy, freedom and a government provided id. You can have privacy and freedom even if you have a government issued id. And you can have your privacy and freedom taken away from you without the government giving you standardized way of proving your id.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by kortilla on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:54PM (#43977619)
You can’t have privacy if everyone uses the government as an SSO.

People might be more amenable if SSO wasn’t implemented as these stupid OIDC flows where the govt gets to know every time you login to your bank and what IP you’re using, etc.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by lxgr on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:06PM (#43978807)
> You can’t have privacy if everyone uses the government as an SSO.

Why not? Anonymous cryptographic attestation methods (e.g. of only the fact that you are over 18 years old, that you are a permanent resident etc.) exist.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by nly on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:54PM (#43979207)
Mozilla's one died a death
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by kortilla on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:58PM (#43979238)
It’s technically possible but none of the govt implementations I’ve seen do this.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by lxgr on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @08:20PM (#43979387)
The German ID card has been supporting privacy-preserving remote age attestation for over a decade, for example.

These days, every smartphone with an ISO 1443 interface ("NFC") can act as a reader.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by chvid on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:17PM (#43977829)
But you can if you live in a well functioning democratic society - remember the alternative is not no id but privatized for profit identity providers like Google and Facebook.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by Muromec on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:42PM (#43978074)
Well functioning democratic society is and idea that US explicitly rejects, because democratic society can point a finger at you and that doesn't feel nice.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by kortilla on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @08:01PM (#43979260)
A well functioning democratic society is one of the valid states before an autocratic regime. The Nazi party was elected.

Apart from regime changes, being a functional democratic society doesn’t protect you from technical incompetence nor does it limit the ability for people with access to the DB from abusing it.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by lxgr on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:05PM (#43978795)
A tax number isn't an identity document (it's an identifier), nor is a birth certificate (since it doesn't have a photo).

Driver's licenses (or non-driver IDs) are the US's de facto ID standard.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by snowwrestler on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @09:20PM (#43979727)
About a quarter of the U.S. population does not have a drivers license.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by Muromec on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:37PM (#43976783)
Federal government or governmemts in general? As far as I get, driver licenses are doing in US what id cards are doing in Europe and are issued by governments too.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by Brybry on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:04PM (#43977092)
While a driver's license does normally fill that role, it's not mandated and not everyone has a driver's license (or even a state issued ID).

Some stuff like voting you can use something like a utility bill. Some stuff will want your birth certificate. Some stuff will want multiple types of documents.

Americans have historically been against mandated government IDs (though mostly with the concept of a federal/national ID).

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by deathanatos on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @06:32PM (#43978490)
This whole thread is going to motte & bailey between the various forms of US gov ID. Between the union of {SSN, birth cert, driver's license (or ID in lieu thereof)}, it seems to be there's the equivalent of a federal ID. Just, like everything else we do, a terrible incomprehensible mess to Europeans.

My employer requires an SSN when I start a job. TSA keeps alleging they're going to require Real ID any day now. Voting, if I have my jurisdiction's requirements right, requires an SSN, though most people will experience that in the form of driver's license, since getting a license is usually automatic voter registration where I've lived.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by Workaccount2 on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:50PM (#43976933)
In the US you don't need to have any form of ID. Your life will be very difficult, but you don't legally need it. ID is an optional service here.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by ikiris on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:52PM (#43977597)
Well as long as you have specific skin colors this is true. Don't let ICE catch you with no valid form of ID if you don't look European.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by Muromec on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:38PM (#43978029)
Well, what I was replying to is about who is providing the service. Whether or not the service is mandatory is a different one. I know places on the European continent where having id and registered address is mandatory, but the fine for noncomplience is about 1 EUR.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by einarfd on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:04PM (#43977718)
In Norway our BankID system, which is similar to what the Danes have, is owned by the banks, and is a run by a private company. While I personally think that in principle it should be run by the government. It works well enough, and it is imo. proof that it does not have to be run by the government.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by nand_gate on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:27PM (#43979003)
Isn't being run by a bank just a roundabout way to be run by the gov't?

Your root of trust for said bank id is gov't documents, right?

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by matthewdgreen on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:03PM (#43978782)
Android and iOS now support driving licenses for seven states. They’re working on an anonymous credential library to allow you to authenticate and verify to websites, and you can use tap-to-ID with TSA. You’re right that not everyone has a DMV-issued ID but other than that, we’re pretty close to having an optional national electronic ID.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by riffraff on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:31PM (#43976713)
italy has quite an interesting system[0] where multiple identity providers (authorized by the State) can be used to provide identification against the central database. It'll probably be phased out at some point, but it's quite cool.

[0] https://www.spid.gov.it/en/citizens/ it integrates with eIDAS too

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by lxgr on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:08PM (#43978835)
If it integrates with eIDAS, it doesn't necessarily have to be phased out. A very good pragmatic decision of eIDAS was recognizing that many member countries have different existing eID schemes, and federating them is easier than rolling out a new one from scratch.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by riffraff on Wednesday May 14, 2025 @04:29AM (#43982230)
it doesn't, but there is already a competing system based on the national id card, which is just simpler to explain to people ("you log in with your ID card" vs "you log in with a third party identity provider where you need to create an account"), and the people who championed the old system are no longer around.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by magicalhippo on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @09:36PM (#43979807)
Similar for gov't stuff here in Norway, where you can use the govt's own ID system (MinID), the common bank ID system (BankID), and a couple of commercial smart card solutions (Comfides, Buypass).
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by sneak on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:40PM (#43976824)
Absolutely not! The moment you have universal state-issued identity, you will be expected to provide it for everything, including tons of stuff that doesn’t require identity. Don’t be a privacy defeatist, the fight isn’t lost yet.

Resist every single effort to make it easier for merchants and private entities to strongly identify users. The rows go into databases and they never go away.

State-issued identity is one of the fundamental building blocks of a totalitarian police state that has universal surveillance.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by stef25 on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:59PM (#43977029)
We have universal ID cards here in Belgium. They have a chip and along with a special card reader usb device you can log in to govt websites related to taxes, pension and basically everything else.

If you have a smartphone you can use an app to scan a QR and log in that way. It's super convenient.

Where is the privacy problem if you use this system to consult your own civil data ? Privacy is a thing in the EU and it's a complex issue mainly because of these tech behemoths that need to know your shoe size before you can use their todo list app.

> Resist every single effort to make it easier for merchants and private entities to strongly identify users

How is this related to govt issued ID cards ?

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by Dylan16807 on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:06PM (#43977113)
If it's easy enough to connect such an ID with arbitrary companies, I don't trust US privacy laws to prevent them from requiring it.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by Muromec on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:48PM (#43978146)
Maybe not having IDs is the reason why US doesn't have privacy protections and everybody can buy all the data anyway for 5 bucks from ad tech and telecoms.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by sneak on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @09:37PM (#43979812)
The moment private entities can avoid spending money on auth and anti-sybil, they will simply default to using the government IdP, because auth is hard and fixing exceptions is expensive (CSRs, etc).

Then, you will simply have to provide full government ID to every business for every transaction. Instant surveillance state (given that they can access all business records).

This is not a world in which you wish to live. It is very important that you be able to transact without ID.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by hosteur on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:05PM (#43977093)
> Absolutely not! The moment you have universal state-issued identity, you will be expected to provide it for everything, including tons of stuff that doesn’t require identity.

Indeed this has happened in Denmark already where for example DBA (Danish version of ebay) started soft-mandating MitID verification. Soon to be actually mandatory.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by einarfd on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:16PM (#43977820)
At one point I was researching using the Norwegian BankID system to ensure that accounts where real people. The pricing model didn't make that look like a reasonable choice. While I'm not surprised an eBay like service would be fine to pay to combat fraud. For a lot of offerings, paying the cost of using such services will not be worth it.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by layer8 on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:43PM (#43977488)
The way identity providers are supposed to work is to not necessarily divulge your identity, but properties necessary for the respective service. For example, they can attest that you are an adult and a citizen of $country, but don’t need to disclose any further information. When using an identity provider with a third-party service, the attested attributes are displayed to the user to approve their disclosure. This is a bit like app permissions, where you can specify which app should be able to have which permission.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by kortilla on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:58PM (#43977657)
But most sites will just require you to attest your full name. Additionally, they will require a unique ID that the govt might not bother changing between websites.

Real name and central ID requirements are anti privacy and have the tracking problems OP highlighted.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by patja on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:13PM (#43977796)
I'm so sick of retail clerks who insist on scanning the barcode of my driver's license. To verify I am 21 you don't need my height, weight, eye color, and home address. You can ascertain that my visually inspecting just the first two digits of my birth year.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by mixmastamyk on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:43PM (#43978086)
Sounds like you may be aware, but no one should allow that to happen. When showing ID in retail situations I don't allow it to be removed from my hand.
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by ptman on Wednesday May 14, 2025 @06:37AM (#43982912)
Do they actually compare the picture on the driver's license to your face or do they only scan the barcode? In some cases the barcode is on the backside. I've many times seen that they don't even look at the side of the card with the picture. So you can just present a suitable barcode for them to scan. "Verification" indeed...
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by lxgr on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @07:09PM (#43978847)
I've lived both in countries that have state-issued IDs and in the US, and I don't have much doubt about where I've felt better protected in terms of data privacy...
Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by k4rli on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:54PM (#43978198)
This yet another USA defaultism post.

I have developed for several banks in Europe and EIDAS + other national ID based systems are the standard. Some also allow authentication with their own apps, but still having alternate options smartcard with reader or smartcard based national app.

Most seem to favour using apereo CAS for it even though it seems overkill and overly complicated (especially upgrading it, lacking documentation) most of the time.

Re:Why are banks still getting authentication so wrong? by lq9AJ8yrfs on Wednesday May 14, 2025 @09:43AM (#43984444)
Hard disagree. If the only the state can give you an identity, then the state can take away your identity.