News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by Animats on Monday May 12, 2025 @05:37PM (#43967699)
A war in Taiwan?
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by starspangled on Monday May 12, 2025 @08:16PM (#43968647)
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by bgnn on Monday May 12, 2025 @05:39PM (#43967714)
Well, we stil have enough know-how outside Taiwan on everything to produce any semiconductors. A bigger world war is most likely what it takes to bring the supply chain to a halt. Even then, nobody magically forgets these things.
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by TimorousBestie on Monday May 12, 2025 @05:54PM (#43967831)
I kinda doubt it. The theoretical knowledge is there, but there’s a huge gulf between that and all the practical knowledge/trade secrets held by TSMC.

Another view on this topic is https://gwern.net/slowing-moores-law

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by voidspark on Monday May 12, 2025 @08:12PM (#43968630)
TSMC factories use ASML hardware (designed and built in the Netherlands), that actually produces the chips.

https://www.asml.com/en

TSMC is running a successful business but they're not the only customers of ASML.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by bgnn on Monday May 12, 2025 @06:36PM (#43968102)
I might be biased, being an insider of semiconductor industry, to think that there gulf isn't that huge. Virtuakly everything is known down to what, 28nm or so. That's still a fairly good process and pretty impossible to forget.
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by rcxdude on Monday May 12, 2025 @06:52PM (#43968214)
If you wanna make something that's competitive with the latest and greatest, sure. But there's literally thousands of fabs that can make _a_ CPU, and hundreds that can make something that is usable in a PC, even if not very fast. There's a huge span of semiconductor fabrication beyond the bleeding edge of digital logic.
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by AnotherGoodName on Monday May 12, 2025 @10:06PM (#43969119)
One thing the above did have though was a mention that the high end would quickly be worth its weight in gold.

The nvidia dgx b200 is already selling for half a million. The nearest non tsmc produced competitor doesn’t come close. Imagine no more supply!

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by bgnn on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:44PM (#43978104)
Aren't they worth more tgan their weight in gold already?
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by rcxdude on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @06:47PM (#43978619)
Depends if you just count the die or the rest of the rack. Processed silicon wafers will tend to beat that easily, but so does low-volume short-turnaround machined aluminium.
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by chasil on Monday May 12, 2025 @06:34PM (#43968083)
Intel still knows 14nm quite well, and would likely sell access to the line if asked.

If Taiwan ceased to exist, that would put us a decade back.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by bgnn on Monday May 12, 2025 @06:37PM (#43968112)
Samsung is just tiny bit behind TSMC.

The gap isn't a decade, more like 12-18 months.

Also, TSMC has 5nm production in the US. There are actual people with know how of this process in the US.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by voidspark on Monday May 12, 2025 @08:14PM (#43968638)
All of their photolithography equipment is manufactured in the Netherlands by ASML

https://www.asml.com/en

Other companies are using the same equipment (Samsung and Intel) but TSMC has deeper expertise and got more out of the same equipment so far.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by squigz on Monday May 12, 2025 @06:08PM (#43967913)
There are other semiconductor manufacturers, right? Certainly it would be catastrophic to the industry, and would likely set progress back a while, but it would hardly be insurmountable. This discussion also assumes TSMC wouldn't sell/trade knowledge/processes, or they'd not be stolen, which wouldn't be crazy, given the hypothetical war in the region
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by alabastervlog on Monday May 12, 2025 @09:23PM (#43968927)
The stuff that really matters is mostly on microcontrollers.

The few industries that push computing out of need would suffer. Certain kinds of research, 3D modeling.

But most of what we use computers for in offices and our day-to-day should work about as well on slightly beefed up (say, dual or quad CPU) typical early ‘90s gear.

We’re using 30 years of hardware advancements to run JavaScript instead of doing new, helpful stuff. 30 years of hardware development to let businesses save a little on software development while pushing a significant multiple larger than that cost onto users.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by voidspark on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @03:18PM (#43976565)
> slightly beefed up (say, dual or quad CPU) typical early ‘90s gear.

Early 90's Intel was the 486 33 Mhz. It barely had enough performance to run the TCP/IP stack at a few hundred KB/sec, using all of the CPU just for that task. I think you forgot how slow it was. Pentium II is where it starts to get reasonably modern in the late 90's. Pentium Pro (1995) was their first with multiprocessor support. It was moving so fast back then that early/mid/late 90's was like comparing decades apart at todays pace of improvement.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by alabastervlog on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:43PM (#43977489)
166MHz pentium with 128MB (not a typo, kids!) of memory felt luxuriously snappy and spacious, including with tabbed web browsing in Phoenix/Firebird/Firefox… running BeOS or QNX-Photon. Not so much under Linux or Windows.

Not so far removed from a multi-CPU Pentium at 90 or 100MHz, from the very early Pentium days.

I guess what I had in mind was first-gen Pentiums. They’re solidly in the first half of the ‘90s but “early 90s” does cover a broader period, and yeah, 486 wouldn’t quite cut it. They’re the oldest machines I can recall multitasking very comfortably on… given the right software.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by voidspark on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:17PM (#43977831)
128 MB was almost unheard of back then.

Pentium 66 - 1993

Pentium 90 - 1994

Pentium 166 - 1996

More than doubled the performance in 3 years. Two orders of magnitude from 1990 - 2000.

There was no multi-CPU Pentium. Not until the Pentium Pro in 1996.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday May 12, 2025 @05:51PM (#43967817)
Not magically, they forget naturally. No one human knows the whole sequence, from start to finish, no one can really write it down (or shoot a how-to video). Distributed, institutional knowledge is extraordinarily brittle.
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by bgnn on Monday May 12, 2025 @06:30PM (#43968051)
I agree, forgetting happens naturally. For example, it would be pretty difficult to produce vacuum tubes now. But I doubt this is applicable for CMOS technologies. Most of the steps down to finfets (TSMC 16nm) are rather well known. Yes we don't know the exact recipe of TSMC, Samsung or Intel, but it's not like alien technology. I read technical papers from all these fabs regularly and it's more open than what would people expect. Of course they keep their secrets too, for the cutting edge. There's so much knowhow out there that it's quite probable we can get there again in a short time if TSMC vanished fron earth all of a sudden.
Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday May 12, 2025 @08:18PM (#43968655)
It's not just about secrets... it's about how many techniques and processes simply aren't documented. There's no need (someone knows how, and is in the business of training new hires), no capacity (they're not exactly idle), and no perception that any of this is important (things have kept working so far).

Could they eventually replicate a CMOS technology? No one doubts this, but the latest lith process took how many years to develop, and only one company makes those machines anywhere in the world? Nearly microscopic molten tin droplets being flattened mid-air so that it can radiate a particular wavelength of UV?

That's not something they'll have up and running again in 6 months, and if it were lost, regression to other technologies would be difficult or impossible too. We might have to start from scratch, so to speak.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by insaneirish on Monday May 12, 2025 @08:22PM (#43968678)
> For example, it would be pretty difficult to produce vacuum tubes now.

Vacuum tubes are still made. They’re used extensively in instrument amplification.

But I think this bolsters your point!

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by grues-dinner on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @04:31AM (#43970781)
There's a guy who makes them in his garage. They're not really conceptually hard to make as such, they're just fiddly, delicate, labour-intensive and mostly replaced by astoundingly cheaper and often better (outside of a few niches) solid state options.

If there were some kind of interdiction on silicon (an evil genie or some kind of Butlerian Jihad perhaps?), the market would remember and/or rediscover the thermoelectric effect and throw money/postapocalyptic bartered goods at glassblowers pretty sharpish.

If that status continued, I'm sure we'd see developments in that space in terms of miniaturisation, robustness, efficiency, performance, etc., that would seem as improbable to us as a modern CPU would seem to someone in the no-silicon timeline. You may never get to "most of a teraflops in your pocket, runs all day on 4000mAh and costs three figures" but you could still do a meaningfully large amount of computation with valves.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @10:00AM (#43973080)
>There's a guy who makes them in his garage.

Savant-tier, obsessive, dedicates his life to it "guy" does it in his garage over a period of how many years, and has succeeded to what point yet? Has he managed even a single little 8-bit or even 4-bit cpu? I'm cheering that guy on, you know, but he's hardly cranking out the next-gen GPUs.

>the market would remember

Markets don't remember squat. The market might try to re-discover, but this shit's path dependent. Re-discovery isn't guaranteed, and it's even less likely when a civilization that is desperate to have previously-manufacturable technology can't afford to dump trillions of dollars of research into it because it's also a poor civilization due to its inability to manufacture these things.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by grues-dinner on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @10:35AM (#43973441)
You don't need trillions of dollars to start making tubes again. And it wouldn't be that one guy doing it for funsies, would it? If the question was "can one hobbyist bootstrap everything on his own" then I would agree. Maybe you completely lose even the insight that a small electric current can be used to switch or modulate a larger one. But if you're also losing mid-high-school physics knowledge, that's a different issue.

As I said, you probably won't ever get to where we are now with the technology, but then again probably 99.999% of computing power is wasted on gimmicks and inefficiency. Probably more these days. You could certainly run a vaguely modern society on only electromechanical and thermionic gear - you have power switching with things like thyrotrons, obviously radios, and there were computers made that way, such as the Harwell Witch in 1952.

Maybe you don't get 4K AI video generation or petabyte-scale advertising analytics but you could have quite a lot.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by fragmede on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @11:01AM (#43973733)
Looking at the Ryzen 7 9800X running at 5.2 GHz, if you chopped off 99.999% of that, you'd get a 52 kHz CPU, with 6.6 megaflops vs the original 6.6 gigaflops.

For reference, the original 4004 Intel CPU from 1971 ran at 740 kHz, so 52 kHz isn't even enough computing to do a secure TLS web connection without an excessively long wait. The 4004 did not do floating point, however, and it wouldn't be until between the 486 (1989) and the Pentium (1993) that we see 5-10 MFLOPS of performance.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by vardump on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @05:55PM (#43978203)
> 6.6 megaflops vs the original 6.6 gigaflops.

Hmm... I think 9800X should be able to do at least 32 FLOPS per cycle per core. So 1.3 TFLOPS is the ceiling for the CPU. 1/100000 leaves you... 12 MFLOPS.

Then there's the iGPU for even more FLOPS.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by grues-dinner on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @06:29PM (#43978463)
99.999 may be an ass-pull of a figure, but I was thinking more in terms of having whole datacentres screaming along doing crypto, billions of cat videos, Big Data on "this guy bought a dishwasher, give him more dishwasher adverts", spinning up a whole virtual server to compile a million line codebase on every change, and AI services for pictures of a chipmunk wearing sunglasses. There's a good chunk of computation that we as a society could just go without. I know of embedded systems that run at hundreds of MHz and could replaced by no CPU at all and still fulfill the main task to some extent. Because early models indeed used no CPU. Many fewer functions, but they still fundamentally worked.

Many things we now take for granted would indeed be impossible. I suppose the good news is that in some electropunk timeline where everyone had to use tubes, your TLS connection might not be practical, but the NSA datacentre would be even less practical. On the other hand, there'd be huge pressure on efficiency in code and hardware use. Just before transistorisation, amazing things were done with tubes or electromechanically, and if that had been at the forefront of research for the last 70 years, who knows what the state of the at would look like. Strowger switches would look like Duplo.

Probably there would still be a lot of physical paperwork, though!

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by fragmede on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @09:37PM (#43979813)
> 99.999 may be an ass-pull of a figure,

Comparisons to old technology is just something I do for fun, don't read too much into it. :)

Fun fact: A usb-C to HDMI dongle for has more computing power than the computer that took us to the moon.

As far as the NSA being even less practical, they're among the few who have the staff that could eke every last cycle of performance out of what remained. Maybe the Utah datacenter wouldn't work, but Room 641A long predates that.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by spencerflem on Monday May 12, 2025 @05:39PM (#43967710)
Chips are made elsewhere too. At worst, we (civilization) would lose the cutting edge if that happened.

It would be a sad thing but not as sad as everything else that would happen in a war.

Re:What if humanity forgot how to make CPUs? by PlunderBunny on Monday May 12, 2025 @05:50PM (#43967808)
We would go back to brick phones, with gears stuck on the side. Awesome!