News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bee_rider on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:41AM (#43926497)
Personally I’m skeptical of nuclear power given how much easier it is to incrementally add renewable capacity (sure, intermittence is a problem, but I think we can deal with it by being cleverer).

But anyway, if anybody (other than the government, which gave up long ago) can pay the upfront costs of nuclear, it is the big tech companies like Google.

> […] Google has set 2030 goals to reach net zero emissions across its operations and value chain, […]

Man, I remember when 2030 seemed like the future. But now it seems downright aggressive. Good luck Google.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by nandomrumber on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:16AM (#43926907)
You’re skeptical of nuclear, a proven technology with excellent safety record, the only power generation that has a completely closed fuel life cycle, and believe in a technology we don’t have.

If we (the West) had built out nuclear to satisfy our electricity needs, implementing new nuclear power tech as it improved, we could have electricity subscriptions like we have mobile / home internet planes.

You’d just pay for amps, say 50 amp, 150 amp, 300 amp, all you can consume.

But instead we have expensive electricity (at least here in Australia), where your mind is constantly loaded wit being aware of your energy consumption.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:19AM (#43926947)
You do know that nuclear power has experienced negative learning by doing throughout its entire life?

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03014...

You don’t get ”free electricity” with absolutely massive handouts to the nuclear industry.

Instead renewables and storage are delivering on the ”too cheap to meter” promise.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by belorn on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:49AM (#43927330)
It was promised that by now half the grid of EU should had been operated under green hydrogen. Instead we had yesterday in Sweden news the opening of a freshly new built natural gas power plant as the solution to that intermittence problem. Of course, those natural gas power plants are paid through subsidizes as grid stability is the government responsibility, and thus the bill for that natural gas is put on taxes and connection fees.

I have said it before, but in order for me to believe the claims that renewables and storage are delivering in places like europe, you first have to stop investing and building new natural gas power plants. Rather than classify natural gas as "green", as Germany pushed through in EU, we should have laws to prevent new natural gas power plants from being built and existing fleet should be slowly dismantled. If renewables and storage can deliver on the ”too cheap to meter” promise, they should do so in an environment without natural gas being used behind the scene.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:58AM (#43927457)
Love how the goalposts magically shifted to ”green hydrogen deployed today!!” even though many grids still don’t even reach saturation from renewables. Storage or green hydrogen is an enormous waste of money in Poland given their grid composition.

That renewable buildout leads to larger fossil emissions being wrong is trivial to verify. The UK as one example of many:

- Coal has gone from 150 TWh to zero. - Fossil gas from 175 TWh to 85 TWh. - Nuclear from 80 TWh to 40 TWh.

Massively decreasing all fossil fueled electricity production of course "extends the life" of these plants. All those plants that were shut down had their "life extended".

You can do the same for Denmark, Portugal, California, South Australia and everywhere else. First renewables offset coal followed by cutting into gas usage.

After hitting a plateau storage is now unlocking massive reductions in fossil gas usage in California:

- Gas is down 45% v '23 and 25% v '24

- Batteries up 198% v '23 and 73.4% v '24

https://bsky.app/profile/mzjacobson.bsky.social/post/3lnw3hs...

Storage is exploding globally. China installed 74 GW comprising 134 GWh of storage in 2024. Increasing their yearly installation rate by 250%. The US is looking at installing 18 GW in 2025 making up 30% of all grid additions. Well, before Trump came with a sledgehammer of insanity.

Storage delivers. For the last bit of "emergency reserves" we can run some gas turbines. First our existing fleet and then when it becomes the most pressing issue to decarbonize we can utilize the solution aviation and shipping settled on.

Or just run the gas turbines on biofuels, green hydrogen or whatever. Start collecting food waste and create biogas from it.

Doesn't really matter, we're talking single percent of total energy demand.

I love how completely insignificant issues becomes blown up to enormous proportions try to force nuclear power into the conversation.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by belorn on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:48PM (#43929841)
Lets then have a ban on all new natural gas power plants until its down to a single percent. That should not be a problem if that is all that is needed.

Using UK as an example, the majority of energy is not renewables. Why should they build new natural gas power plants? Natural gas produce more energy than any other source in the UK. They are not going from 98% renewables, 2% natural gas. (https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-uks-electricity-was-cle...)

UK should increase the production of renewables energy, but they should also decommission their fossil fuel plants. If they want to use non-fossil fuel solutions, then they should do so and compete fairly and without subsidizes. Same goes for nuclear.

The cost of intermittence should not be paid by the environment or subsidizes, otherwise they are just hiding the true cost that society have to pay.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:11PM (#43930139)
You seem to advocate for some holier than thou perfect path rather than the messy reality that is a transition of the entire energy system to a new cheaper source while upholding our modern society.

Let’s look at the area under the curve?

You know, we need to decarbonize agriculture, construction, transportation etc. as well.

Let look at what the UK has done:

- Coal has gone from 150 TWh to zero.

- Fossil gas from 175 TWh to 85 TWh.

- Nuclear from 80 TWh to 40 TWh.

Would you say this reduction in fossil fuel usage insignificant because they obviously aren’t done yet?

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by belorn on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:32PM (#43932393)
If we want to talk messy reality, then the only realistic way to prevent critical point in global warming is to build everything that is non-fossil fuel, that being renewables, nuclear, experimental storage and so on, while at the same time utilizing market forces and use risk-benefit analysis for each government intervention in order to spend government subsidies as cost effective as possible. Everything is needed in order to do as much as possible to reduce emissions.

For EU regulation that requires lower emissions and environmental issues with hydro power, the messy reality is also that the cost of breaking the law and paying the fines are currently cheaper than the economical and political costs of complying with the law. So that is what the Swedish government are doing. The Paris Agreement is just a goal and clearly there is a lot of voters who see it as incompatible with modern society.

It is also the messy reality that many current governments in EU got their votes in the last election because they bailed out the citizens when the power crisis happened and paid the power bills through taxes, causing major harm in the market and further inflated prices. Building out more natural gas power plants will reduce the cost of the next crisis, which is also the stated goal of the new one that got built in Sweden.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:25AM (#43935134)
You still haven’t been able to answer why we should waste money on new built nuclear power.

It costs 5-10x as much, does not integrate well with renewables due to the capital structure and takes 15-20 years to build from political decision to operational plant.

We need to decarbonize now. Not extend the life of fossil assets for decades waiting for nuclear power to come online. With this nuclear power producing a fraction of the TWh compared to if the same money went into renewables and storage.

Wasting money on enormous handouts to the nuclear industry is not ”doing as much as possible to reduce emissions”. It is a dogwhistle from climate change deniers to extend the life of fossil assets to stymie their disruption by renewables.

I don’t think you’ve kept up with the renewable industry. The absolute explosion we are seeing is because renewables and storage today are cheaper than fossil fuels.

It started as feelgood moonshot decades ago. Today companies and countries are at a competitive advantage if they can retool their fossil dependent processes and systems to renewables.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by crote on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:36PM (#43927933)
> It was promised that by now half the grid of EU should had been operated under green hydrogen

The only one promising that was the fossil industry, trying to stay relevant by pushing hydrogen as "green" and doing a switcheroo to "blue" fossil-derived hydrogen when green hydrogen inevitably turns out to be nonviable for silly things like mid-term energy storage.

> If renewables and storage can deliver on the ”too cheap to meter” promise, they should do so in an environment without natural gas being used behind the scene.

No. Remember, the goal is to minimize the total greenhouse gas emissions! We're in a transition phase, if that means operating on 97.5% renewables and 2.5% natural gas until we figure out those last 2.5%, then that is totally fine. At the moment natural gas is excellent for peaker plants - especially if you implement carbon capture. Would you rather stay on the current ~50% fossil mix, solely because the transition mix isn't "green enough"? We're trying to save the environment, not trying to be holier than the pope.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by belorn on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:30PM (#43929596)
If you want to present the plan as renewables and subsidized natural gas as being better than nuclear than be open about it and present it as that. It is not the same as a subsidize free renewables and storage solution.

Those 97.5% sounds very nice. Denmark has well over 100% renewables production from wind and solar, but in terms of consumption only get around 50%. The rest they need to import. 97.5 vs 50 means there is some work to be done.

I recently posted this link (https://svensksolenergi.se/statistik/elproduktion-fran-solen...) that illustrate how much energy that solar farms produce in Sweden. Getting 97.5% from that would be a nice challenge, especially around the winter months. December and January had around 3% production compared to the best previous month (which we could use as a stand-in for 100% capacity but that would be incorrect).

Natural gas is not fine. The geopolitical consequences are terrible, the environmental impact are not sustainable, and the cost are carried almost exclusively through subsidizes. Trying to sell natural gas as "saving the environment" is a political message that I do not agree with.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by derriz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @04:04PM (#43930722)
You're including a bunch of different generation technologies which have vastly different operating characteristics which means they are not substitutes for each other.

For example, nuclear takes days to start from cold and is really only economic if operating at a constant output. Thus you need complimentary sources to help meet changes in demand. These days, typically this means gas turbines.

Whether your grid has nuclear or renewables, it will also have natural gas capacity.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:45AM (#43935763)
> Whether your grid has nuclear or renewables, it will also have natural gas capacity.

No, turbo-alternators 'burning' hydrogen do exist. And green hydrogen (produced by renewables) is cheaper than pink hydrogen (produced by a nuclear reactor) because the total cost of renewables' electricity is lower than nuclear's.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by derriz on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:13PM (#43939612)
I don’t see the connection with my comment but hydrogen is irrelevant and contributes less than a rounding error to global electricity generation. The technical components for a hydrogen based energy market do exist but are simply unviable financially. Nuclear also struggles to compete on the basis of price in competitive markets but is a genuinely low-carbon source of electricity. You could argue (I personally would not) that the higher cost of nuclear can be justified on this basis but the fact that hydrogen is an extremely potent greenhouse gas and is prone to leakage means it doesn’t even have that going for it.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Saturday May 10, 2025 @01:18AM (#43943404)
The connection is that "it will also have natural gas capacity" seems false to me as backup turbo-alternators can 'burn' hydrogen ( => no natural gas capacity).

> hydrogen > contributes less than a rounding error to global electricity generation

True, however it doesn't imply that it will remain irrelevant.

> unviable financially

For the time being, and less and less. Bloomberg NEF predicts that green hydrogen will cost approximately 1.2€/kg in 2050. Carbon taxes or oil prices may also play a role as nearly all hydrogen is now produced thanks to some fossil fuel.

> nuclear > is a genuinely low-carbon source of electricity

Green hydrogen could also be.

> prone to leakage

This is a major challenge for transportation-related usages, especially in small or not-intensively used vehicles. This isn't in the "gridpower backup" role, as mass and volume of storage isn't a major parameter.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by derriz on Saturday May 10, 2025 @10:00AM (#43945701)
I see what you meant now but still see little scope for hydrogen to have a role in the energy sector.

One reason for my skepticism is that I've been hearing optimistic predictions around hydrogen as an energy store for decades at this stage (I'm old) and for a long time believed them but here we are, with little to show for it. In fact, at historical scales, hydrogen's significance as an energy store today is less than it was in the 19th century. As a result, I've adopted "I'll believe it when I see it" approach so I just ignore hydrogen predictions - particularly ones 25 years into the future.

But the main reason is simple physics. It simply has NONE of the physical attributes you'd want in a gas to be used to store energy. It's like if you picked all the attributes you WOULDN'T want in such a gas.

Storage and transport are incredibly expensive and technically difficult. Everything it comes into contact with needs special materials to avoid embrittlement. It's prone to leakage.

It has dreadful energy density. The worst.

It has potent green house gas effects when leaked into the atmosphere.

It's dangerous and highly explosive and burns with such high intensity (and invisibly) that it requires specialist fire-fighting equipment.

Roundtrip efficiency (electricity to H to electricity) is abysmal - a fraction of that of batteries.

In summary, hydrogen as energy store makes no sense to me. And it's completely hypothetical. If we are going to talk about hypothetical approaches to storing energy in the form of a gas, then green methane makes a lot more sense. Not that I'd advocate for either but I see some potential for green methane but none for hydrogen given its physical attributes.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Saturday May 10, 2025 @09:41PM (#43950543)
> I've been hearing optimistic predictions around hydrogen

Fair point, same here (I was born in 1967), however fossil fuels are so effective and adequate as energy sources, as long as we ignored/neglected their dubious effect on the climate, that there was no real attempt to explore other ways.

> Storage and transport are incredibly expensive and technically difficult

For the "gridpower backup" application there is no transport needed, and storage doesn't have to be compact nor mobile (those are a major challenge for hydrogen in transportation).

> dreadful energy density

This is not a show-stopper for the "gridpower backup" application. For huge volumes or very long-term (not sure this will be necessary) it may be stored in salt caverns ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_storage#Underground_h... )

> potent green house gas effects > dangerous

Granted, however we are used to store huge volumes of dangerous materials, some gaseous at ambiant pressure/temp (methane...), even into salt caverns, albeit when we began to do so (in the 1950's) it was quite a challenge.

> Roundtrip efficiency (electricity to H to electricity) is abysmal

Various new ways to obtain H2 from electricity offer impressive yield in realistic conditions (check SOECs), and other advances are promising ( https://liten.cea.fr/cea-tech/liten/english/Pages/Strategic-... ).

> green methane makes a lot more sense

As does ammonia, in some contexts. There is no one-size-fits-all here!

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by dporter on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:34AM (#43927139)
Renewable power is cheap because it also receives massive government handouts in the form of tax credits.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:38AM (#43927205)
Still built at absolutely massive scale around the world without subsidies. With many countries phasing out their renewable subsidies because they aren’t needed anymore.

Unsubsidized solar and storage is today in much of the world cheaper than coal and fossil gas.

The renewable subsidies stil existing simply add fuel to the already raging fire that is renewable buildout.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by nandomrumber on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:57AM (#43927438)
What storage? Where? At what price?

Where are all these 14 day full load capable storage plants being built?

I’m not saying they aren’t, I am saying I don’t see the data.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:32PM (#43927884)
We are at the point in the S-curve where storage goes from nowhere to everywhere in the blink of an eye.

Here BESS for $63/kWh installed and serviced for 20 years.

https://www.ess-news.com/2025/01/15/chinas-cgn-new-energy-an...

https://www.ess-news.com/2024/12/09/powerchina-receives-bids...

China installed 74 GW comprising 168 GWh in 2024. In increase of 250% compared to 2023.

https://www.ess-news.com/2025/01/23/chinas-new-energy-storag...

After hitting a plateau storage is now unlocking massive reductions in fossil gas usage in California:

- Gas is down 45% v '23 and 25% v '24

- Batteries up 198% v '23 and 73.4% v '24

https://bsky.app/profile/mzjacobson.bsky.social/post/3lnw3hs...

In the US in 2025 storage was expected to make up 30% of all grid additions. Before Trump came with his sledgehammer of insanity.

https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=64586

No one generally expects more than a couple of hours of storage to be needed. But for the fun exercise let’s calculate what spending Vogtles $36.8B on equivalent renewables, as in TWh delivered, and the storage gives.

That makes the renewables come out to about $9B.

With storage costing $0.063B GWh and having $28B to spend we can build 444 GWh storage.

That is the equivalent to running Vogtles two new reactors for 10 days straight.

In this calculation we don’t even bother with Vogtles O&M costs compared to near zero for renewables and storage.

Do you now understand how incredibly expensive new built western nuclear power is?

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bryanlarsen on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:58PM (#43928248)
Never, because we don't need 14 days of full load capable storage. Most models say we need about 3 days to get 99.99% coverage with a reasonable amount of overbuild & interconnect.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by notTooFarGone on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:01AM (#43935019)
why not make it a lifetime of storage if we are here just spouting nonsense numbers.

storage for 12 hours and we are 80% there. If you don't like 80% solutions then please don't participate in society as it's only working on those.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bee_rider on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:04PM (#43929269)
Renewable suffers a little bit from having renewable infrastructure costs considered a new subsidy, while fossil fuel costs are just kind of baked in.

If we included the cost of cleaning up fossil fuel byproducts… well, we don’t even know how much it will cost to clean up all that carbon.

Then we will have to work out how we bill the international relations cost of having to deal with petrochemical producers…

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by EasyMark on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:55PM (#43933417)
that used to be true, but it's not really true any longer; they could even do well without subsidies, but no industry will ever give up free money.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by chermi on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:41PM (#43928011)
Are you really denying the learning curve based on one paper about France? You don't think maybe there's other confounding factors*? A single survey of a single country isn't counterfactual. Are you really certain that with a relatively fixed design the learning curve wouldn't apply at sufficient scale, all else being equal. The learning curve is one of the most time-tested laws in construction.

*Yes, I understand it's inflation adjusted. There are so many possible explanations for the observed negative curve that go beyond the bold, broad claim that learning curve theory doesn't hold in nuclear.

In my mind, an (at least) equally reasonable explanation is that the conditions for the learning curve weren't met. (This probably sounds like "no true Scotsman". I admit that the learning curve is a function of scale and relative to mass-production examples, the "signal" for the learning curve is probably weaker to begin with given how many facilities of the same design were actually built.)

-Changes in design pull you backward on the curve. There were lots of changes in French design

-Unsteady expansion timeline messes with the workforce expertise part of the hypothesis. You want ideally an accelerated or at least constant build rate, not large gaps where the workforce either respecializes in another field or retires.

- regulations increase over time. Part of the conditions for the theory are implicitly "all else being equal".

-while inflation adjustment partially accounts for this, labor becomes more expensive as gdp per capital increases (see, for example, low skill manufacturing leaving China as it becomes wealthier). I don't know the details, but given the rapid post-war growth, I'm guessing gdp/capital was growing pretty quickly during the French build out

For relatively low volume manufacturing, the learning curve effects are probably smaller to begin with, so it's easier to get an effective negative learning rate. With so many confounding factors that violate the premise of theory, I find it rather unscientific to definitively claim the theory is just wrong in an entire industry.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:04PM (#43928345)
It also includes the US seeing the same negative learning by doing.

We have research on when we have achieved learning effects.

> If you look at the data specifically you're going to find learning but for that there's a several requirements:

> - It has to be the same site

> - It has to be the same constructor

> - It has to be at least two years of of gap between one construction to the next

> - It has to be constant labor laws

> - It has to be a constant regulatory regime

> When you add these five you only get like four or five examples in the world.

From a nuclear energy professor at MIT in a nuclear power industry podcast, giving an overly positive but still sober image regarding the nuclear industry as it exists today.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDzaSucDg7k

In the meantime renewables and storage have gone from nascent industries to today be the vast majority of all new energy production in TWh and while costing a fraction of new built nuclear power.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by chermi on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:23PM (#43938550)
Again, I'd say based on the conditions for the theory to hold, the US couldn't prove or disprove the theory either way. I guess to summarize my stance: we don't know what the learning curve for nuclear is because data that is too messy. That being the case, my prior would weight the theory holding, maybe weakly, given the evidence for it elsewhere. Maybe in a few years we can infer some honest data from China.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by GolfPopper on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:37AM (#43927191)
I can't speak for the prior poster, but I am highly skeptical that the current business ecosystem in the United States is capable of effectively and safely building new nuclear power infrastructure, particularly if and when the ever-popular but, to the best of my knowledge, never-completed Small Modular Reactor pitch gets involved.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by XorNot on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:07PM (#43927583)
Conversely China has built a lot of new nuclear capacity, and has projects for SMRs in the works too.

The problem as you allude to isn't the technology.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bee_rider on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:20PM (#43927734)
Yeah, we have political issues around infrastructure in the US, but those probably aren’t going away. If we can do nuclear with just technology (no politics), then it might be viable. So, as I said, good luck Google!
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by derriz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @04:20PM (#43930885)
I wouldn't call it "a lot" when you put it into perspective.

China has about 60GW of nuclear generation capacity - this is after 70 years of building their first nuclear plant. It has about 1600GW of wind and solar after about 10 years.

In 2024, China added 80GW of wind capacity and 277GW of solar. In the first 3 months of 2025 alone, 60GW of new solar capacity and 15GW of new wind capacity were added. In 2024, 4.3GW of nuclear was added.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bee_rider on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:05PM (#43927557)
Due to political issues, the US doesn’t have the capacity to engage in infrastructure projects that take more than ~2 years to complete, unfortunately.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by energy123 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:29AM (#43927078)
Yeah, if we went back in time and built nuclear then we'd have nuclear today, and the fixed costs would have been paid by a previous generation. Is that surprising?

But that doesn't inform us on what the optimal policy decision is in the current year of 2025 given 2025 prices and time-to-build of the various options.

In Australia renewables have the perfect confluence of multiple factors:

- low seasonable variability of insolation in the north

- high wind speeds in the south

- land availability for solar

- high statistical diversification of renewables due to size

- higher than normal costs of nuclear due to first-of-a-kind costs dominating the total build-out costs due to the small energy needs of the country, and higher labor costs

The CSIRO studied this for Australia and released a report about it. Even when you factor in storage and transmission costs, renewables are significantly cheaper than nuclear.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by nandomrumber on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:14PM (#43927657)
The whole argument is like going back 40 years and claiming there’s no point thinking about deploying nor researching & developing solar / wind because we don’t have the expertise nor technology.

We still don’t. Australia doesn’t manufacture solar panels, and other than building the wind turbine masts locally, we don’t manufacture wind turbines either.

Refusing to commit to developing a domestic nuclear power industry commits future generations from having that knowledge and skill base.

And I struggle to understand how anyone can, with a straight face, claim nuclear is too expensive, as though more solar and wind is going make retail electricity prices in Australia cheaper.

AU$0.325 per kWh is ridiculous. We export more coal to China than we use locally, and their electricity is cheaper (around half the cost) and dominated by coal, hydro, and nuclear.

CSIRO perfidy.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ZeroGravitas on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:59PM (#43929210)
How did nuclear slip into your list of power sources that dominate the Chinese grid? You skipped over two other sources that generate double what nuclear does and are growing faster:

Coal 58.2%

Hydro 13%

Wind 9.8%

Solar 8.3%

Nuclear 4.4%

https://ember-energy.org/countries-and-regions/china/

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by hannob on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:31AM (#43927107)
> the only power generation that has a completely closed fuel life cycle

What exactly are you talking about? It does not sound like it describes the way nuclear power, uranium mining, and nuclear waste storage works.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by nandomrumber on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:02PM (#43927503)
Explaine how nuclear waste is dealt with.

Detail how nuclear waste is continuously pumped in to the atmosphere. Or shredded and buried like wind turbine blades which are entirely waste with no recycling value.

Hint: it isn’t.

There’s so little of it, it’s still all predominantly stored on site at the power plants.

Highly radioactive reactive waste isn’t highly reactive for very long. And long lasting waste isn’t very reactive at all. Vitrified it’s chemically non-reactive.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by pfdietz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:12PM (#43927636)
Nuclear waste is essentially a non-issue today. Even if there was a way to magically make spent nuclear fuel disappear it would not materially change the prospects for nuclear energy. And if all other issues with nuclear were resolved (the primary one being cost), storage of spent fuel in dry casks for several centuries is a fine and economical solution.

The only scenario in which waste processing becomes an issue is if nuclear is so wildly successful we start running out of cheap uranium and need to do reprocessing and breeding. That is not the world we live in (this is also why thorium is a non-solution.)

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bee_rider on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:53PM (#43928177)
The comment they were replying to went out of its way to say “completely closed” which is, of course, not correct.

If we want to say nuclear generates not much in terms of byproducts, that seems like a potentially viable argument. But then, renewables don’t consume any fuel (but the installations are a lot less durable). We’re rapidly approaching the point where we might have to admit that sweeping dramatic statements about either one being universally superior are hard to justify and the differences are complicated…

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by Propelloni on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:01PM (#43927481)
You mean like France?
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by pfdietz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:05PM (#43927541)
It's proven to not be competitive.

All these nuclear announcements are smoke screens to cover construction of large amounts of gas fired capacity. Anyone expecting dramatic near term increases in electricity demand will need to go with gas (or renewables, but tariffs make that less competitive); nuclear, especially new designs, cannot be rolled out quickly.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by crote on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:25PM (#43927790)
> a proven technology with excellent safety record

Excellent safety, if you ignore Chernobyl, Fukushima, Three Mile Island, the Tokaimura accidents, the Church Rock spill, the beaches near Dounreay, and dozens more.

Nuclear power rarely kills anyone, but when (not if) things go wrong, it tends to create a massive mess which costs billions to clean up - if a cleanup is even possible at all. It is the only power source which has made entire cities impossible to live in.

I personally don't believe this is necessarily a dealbreaker with modern nuclear plants in rich countries, but if you want to convince people of its safety you probably shouldn't be mentioning its historical record.

> a completely closed fuel life cycle

Only if you completely ignore the huge amount of pollution and waste generated by mining, reprocessing, and disposal.

Again, I personally don't believe this has to be a dealbreaker, but the waste generated by the nuclear industry is still an unsolved problem. We've been operating nuclear reactors for 80 years now, but permanent waste disposal and reactor decommissioning is still in its infancy. The current state-of-the-art is essentially "let it rot in place and hope nothing goes wrong while we figure out a way to deal with it". I think it can be solved, but unless we've done so you probably shouldn't make it part of your argument.

> If we (the West) had built out nuclear to satisfy our electricity needs

We did. France hit 80% nuclear, for example. 9% of global power is supplied by nuclear plants. There are over 400 plants currently operational, and 700 have been decommissioned. We aren't on "baby's first nuclear reactor" anymore.

> implementing new nuclear power tech as it improved

We did. It made the plants too expensive to be commercially viable.

> You’d just pay for amps, say 50 amp, 150 amp, 300 amp, all you can consume.

Not a chance. Although fuel would indeed be quite cheap, power still isn't going to be free: someone has to pay off the massive construction loans.

Consumer power consumption is also a lot more flexible than something like internet. People don't suddenly start to consume a lot more data when their internet gets faster - a single person is still only going to watch one Netflix stream at a time, and that'll work just as fine on a 100Mbps connection as on a 8Gbps one. And all the equipment is already prepared for the faster connection, so it's not like they are saving any money by keeping it slow.

But if your power is free, why bother with gas heating? Why go for a heat pump when resistive heating has cheaper equipment? Why bother isolating your home? Why shut off your lights when you leave your home? Making electricity free means we'll be using a lot more of it, which means having to build significantly more expensive nuclear power plants.

If this was an option, countries with abundant hydro would be providing free power. And they aren't.

> But instead we have expensive electricity

Taking all costs into account, nuclear is currently the most expensive form of generating electricity. While building additional nuclear could get us (mostly) off fossil fuel, it is definitely not going to make your power bill any cheaper. Nuclear power is only viable with hefty subsidies - which in practice means turning off dirt-cheap solar and wind to run expensive nuclear plants.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by blibble on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:27PM (#43929561)
> Excellent safety, if you ignore Chernobyl, Fukushima, Three Mile Island, the Tokaimura accidents, the Church Rock spill, the beaches near Dounreay, and dozens more.

no, these are included in the calculations of "deaths per kilowatt-hour"

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-d...

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by jenadine on Thursday May 08, 2025 @06:09PM (#43931879)
> the waste generated by the nuclear industry is still an unsolved problem

No it's not unsolved. There are burial sites. The spent fuel is kept on the power plant for years so it cools down.

Also even without nuclear power, there would still be nuclear waste to take care of because of the medical, defence, research, and other industries.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by Mawr on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:44AM (#43935386)
> Excellent safety, if you ignore Chernobyl, Fukushima, [...]

Nope, it's all included, how could it not be?

> Nuclear power rarely kills anyone, but when (not if) things go wrong, it tends to create a massive mess which costs billions to clean up

Yep, yet it's still the safest, which means your argument has to be wrong.

Just to show you the magnitude of your error, the Fukushima accident was directly caused by a tsunami which killed 20,000 people. But your main concern from that event is the cost of cleanup of radioactive material.

More people die from falling off roofs while installing solar panels than from nuclear accidents.

> but if you want to convince people of its safety you probably shouldn't be mentioning its historical record.

Well you're not technically wrong. As you've inadvertently demonstrated with your irrational arguments, since people didn't use reason to arrive at their conclusions, they would not be likely to be persuaded by it.

> Only if you completely ignore the huge amount of pollution and waste generated by mining, reprocessing, and disposal.

Do you mean to say the waste is significantly worse than for solar panels, wind turbines, etc.?

> Again, I personally don't believe this has to be a dealbreaker, but the waste generated by the nuclear industry is still an unsolved problem.

Inert solid waste sitting in a barrel somewhere is not a problem that is worth talking about.

Again, the magnitude of your error is outstanding. We've been simply releasing all the, radioactive mind you, products of burning coal into the atmosphere for the past few hundreds of years but you're concerned about a tiny amount of solid waste.

> > If we (the West) had built out nuclear to satisfy our electricity needs

>

> We did. France hit 80% nuclear, for example.

You cherry-picked the single country with the biggest share of nuclear by far.

> > implementing new nuclear power tech as it improved

>

> We did. It made the plants too expensive to be commercially viable.

Ironically, that's because the standards for nuclear plant safety are determined by the sort of irrational thinking you're presenting here.

> Taking all costs into account, nuclear is currently the most expensive form of generating electricity.

And that's where the issue is buried, I don't believe you're taking all costs into account.

Is coal really cheaper when you include the health and environmental damage it creates? It literally can't be, the costs of human created climate change will be eye-watering.

Are renewables really cheaper once you consider the end goal of a 90%+ renewable grid? The costs of accounting for the inherent intermittency of solar and wind go up exponentially as you increase the share of renewables in the grid.

Adding the first 10% of renewables is trivial, you need no extra storage since the grid itself will simply absorb the difference.

Adding the last 10% is horribly expensive and I don't believe you're accounting for that at all.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:41AM (#43935733)
> proven technology with excellent safety record

The real long-term effect of past nuclear accidents is a subject of debate, and the potential worst case a concern for all.

> the only power generation that has a completely closed fuel life cycle

Not at industrial-scale.

> and believe in a technology we don’t have.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-fossil-renewa...

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by barbazoo on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:16PM (#43927673)
We’re not adding solar fast enough and are still struggling with storage. This would be a great way to bridge the gap. Not if the data centers consume all this new energy of course which seems to be what’s happening. Maybe after everyone has turned their own portrait into a studio ghibli picture we can go back and use that new, clean energy to solve the climate crisis.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by mmooss on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:19PM (#43927722)
> We’re not adding solar fast enough and are still struggling with storage. This would be a great way to bridge the gap.

Will it be built before we have sufficient renewable capacity?

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by crote on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:15PM (#43928513)
The deployment of solar is growing exponentially, with its total capacity doubling roughly every three years. Wind is growing at a similar rate. Renewables currently already account for 30% of the global electricity production, and we're seeing projections of over 45% in 2030.

Assuming the projected 2025-2030 installation speed is realistic and flattens out - bit "if", but not completely unrealistic - that means we'd be looking at 75% renewables in 2040 and 90% renewables in 2045.

Nuclear reactors take 15 to 20 years to build, and it'd take an additional year or 5-10 to scale up construction capacity. If we go all-out on nuclear now, that means significant nuclear power starts coming online in 20-25 years - so 2045-2050. At that point there is no more renewables gap left to bridge. There might be a small niche left for it if there is going to be essentially zero innovation in storage and short-term peaker plants, but who's going to bet billions on that?

Nuclear would've been nice if we built massive amounts of it 30 years ago, but we didn't. But starting a large-scale nuclear rollout in 2025? It just doesn't make sense.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by barbazoo on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:12PM (#43932274)
> Nuclear reactors take 15 to 20 years to build, and it'd take an additional year or 5-10 to scale up construction capacity.

I just don't know if that assumption is true.

Looking at https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/small-modular-reactor...

> The timeline is to finish construction of the first reactor by the end of 2029, and connect it to the grid in 2030.

Sure, let's add 100% buffer because it's a major project, that's between 8-10 years from now. Not bad.

Are we talking about different kinds of reactors maybe?

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by notTooFarGone on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:10AM (#43935061)
I'm also building a nuclear power plant within the next 5 years. You can get 100% share for a mere 20.9 billion - trust me bro.

That is what I read in this announcement. History will not be kind on taxpayer money > /dev/null

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by dmm on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:55AM (#43926664)
> intermittence is a problem, but I think we can deal with it by being cleverer

Solar power is great but intermittence is the main issue with it. If you look at 30 year historical weather data, many highly populated regions have two week periods with almost complete cloud cover. Storage and intercontinental power transmission are usually listed as the solutions to this, but the costs of these solutions are rarely included.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by titzer on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:33AM (#43927127)
Solar can still generate up to 25% of their peak power with full cloud cover.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by CooCooCaCha on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:35AM (#43927153)
The issue is renewables are not a complete solution no matter how good it feelz
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by titzer on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:39AM (#43927216)
I was just injecting facts into the discussion without taking a side. I know that's confusing behavior.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by notTooFarGone on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:05AM (#43935032)
people really take offense in how energy gets produced even...
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bryanlarsen on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:02AM (#43926758)
> the costs of these solutions are rarely included.

Solar plus storage is included in all the major levelized cost reports, like from the NREL.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by PaulHoule on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:24AM (#43927020)
Not in any realistic sense. This report

https://www.eia.gov/analysis/studies/powerplants/capitalcost...

just mashes together a PV array with about an hour of storage and quotes a price for that which is low and is certainly not going to get you through the night.

So many things drive me nuts about that report and the discourse around it that, I think, contribute to people talking past each other. For instance, quoting one price for solar energy is nonsensical when the same solar panel is going to give much more energy in Arizona than it is in upstate New York. The cost of a solar + battery system is going to be different in different places. In upstate NY we deal with a lot of retailers that are based in places like Bentonville, AK who just can't believe you might need an electric space heater in late April or otherwise your chickens might die. Since 95% of the world's population lives in a milder climate it's no wonder our needs don't get taken seriously.

The intermittency problem involves: (1) diurnal variation (overnight), (2) seasonal variation (do you overbuild solar panels 3x so you have enough generation in the winter or do you invest in very long term storage?) and (3) Dunkelflaute conditions when you are unlucky and get a few bad weeks of weather.

I've seen analyses of the cost of a grid that consider just smoothing out one day, but not one that covers seasonal variation. (So much of it comes down to: "how many days of blackout a year can people tolerate?")

With a significant overbuild or weeks worth of storage capacity costs are not going to be so favorable against nuclear energy. The overbuild offers the possibility that you could do something useful with the extra power but it is easier said than done because "free" power from renewables is like a free puppy. You have to build power lines to transmit it, or batteries to store it, or you have to feed it into some machine whose capital costs are low enough that you're not going to worry about the economics of only running it 20% of the time. (Go tell a Chemical Engineer about your plan to run a chemical factory 20% of the time and that's probably the last time you'll hear from them.)

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bee_rider on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:17PM (#43927689)
Cryptocurrency is mostly bullshit I think, but for whatever reason people keep buying it. That could be a nice endlessly-dispatchable economically rewarded (despite all reason) workload.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:34AM (#43927132)
A case study for Denmark. Not even using the latest plummet in price of BESS.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626192...

Generally: Renewables and storage solve somewhere high in the 90s percent.

Then throw some gas turbines on it. Low CAPEX high OPEX. Just like we’ve done for the past decades with the previous ”base load and peaking” paradigm.

Those gas turbines will be a minuscule part of the total energy supply.

When it finally becomes the most pressing issue the gas turbines can trivially be fueled by green hydrogen, green hydrogen derivatives, biofuels or biogas from collecting food waste. If they are still needed.

Lets wait and see what aviation and shipping settles on before attempting to solve a future issue today.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:10PM (#43927610)
I love how green hydrogen is assumed to become abundant and trivially easy to retrofit into existing infrastructure but fast neutron reactors are automatically considered infeasible by comparison.

Or that by far the easiest way to produce massive amounts hydrogen without emitting carbon into the atmosphere is… wait for it… nuclear power.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by pfdietz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:17PM (#43927688)
Yes, hydrogen is clearly a much easier technology to make work than fast reactors. Why is this even a question? For example, fast reactors have the issue that in an accident, if fuel melts and rearranges, one can have potentially have a configuration that is prompt supercritical on fast neutrons. This is functionally an atomic bomb.

Also, even in a Fallout Future where everything is nuclear powered, hydrogen is still needed! Some 6% of today's global natural gas consumption goes to making hydrogen, and a good chunk of that is for ammonia synthesis, which is necessary to feed eight billion people.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by PaulHoule on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:40PM (#43927999)
The main hang ups for fast reactors in the US are: (1) our regulators are less sanguine about occupational safety for plutonium workers then the French and Russians (carcinogenic Pu nanoparticles —- the high energy ball mill can make sand deadly, just think what it can do for Pu) and (2) fear of nuclear proliferation if the “plutonium economy” expands. There is also (3) the economics will never be attractive with a steam turbine and all the heat exchangers that entails, but a power set like

https://www.swri.org/markets/energy-environment/power-genera...

could fit in the employee break room of the turbine house of an LWR and could make it competitive. It’s a big if though.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:27PM (#43927820)
"Functionally an atomic bomb"?

Why do you speak on topics you obviously know so little about? Where did you get this nonsense?

Fast neutron designs aren't without their challenges, but causing an atomic explosion is not on that list. Hydrogen explosions? Possible. Steam explosions? Possible.

Atomic explosions? Not even theoretically can you get enough U-235 to clump together to do that without cancelling known basic laws of physics.

To build a bomb, you need a purity of 90%+ U-235. Nuclear power plants have what? 2%? 3%? Might even go as high as 5%? Might as well expect a pack of bubble gum to spontaneously explode.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by PaulHoule on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:43PM (#43928040)
The more detailed simulations have gotten the less bad a meltdown looks in a fast reactors. Usually some of the molten core flows away and no more critical mass. If it goes over critical there can be some energy release but over time it looks less and less and not a problem to contain.

Sodium has its problems (burns in carbon dioxide!) but the chemistry is favorable for a meltdown because the most dangerous fission products are iodine and cesium. The former reacts with the sodium to make a salt that dissolves in the sodium, the second alloys with the sodium. Either way they stay put and don’t go into the environment.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by pfdietz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:39PM (#43930459)
The problem is you need to ensure it's not bad in any possible configuration from an accident. This is hard to do. Will the energy release at criticality drive the material into an even more critical configuration? Such "autocatalytic" systems were considered for bomb design, but weren't chosen because of the large amounts of plutonium needed. But a fast reactor might have the plutonium of hundreds of atomic bombs.

Edward Teller famously warned about this is a nuclear industry trade publication in 1967.

The only fast reactors I'd trust would be ones with fuel dissolved in molten salt; it's hard to see how that could become concentrated in an accident that doesn't boil the salt. But such reactors have their own problems, in particular exposure of reactor structures to intense fast neutron fluxes (not as bad as in fusion reactors, but worse than LWRs.)

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Thursday May 08, 2025 @06:38PM (#43932065)
Increasing the heat past a certain threshold reduces the nuclear reactivity. Read up on "passive safety".

Teller may have warned about this in 1967, but nuclear technology hasn't been stagnant since 1967. Folks read his stuff and designed systems specifically to fail safe, not run away. Stop fear mongering based upon a 60-year-old supposition. Stop assuming everyone working in the nuclear industry is an idiot that hasn't thought about safety.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by pfdietz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:16PM (#43932296)
> Increasing the heat past a certain threshold reduces the nuclear reactivity. Read up on "passive safety".

The safety arguments for fast reactors are typically that a serious scenario will not occur, for example that fuel won't melt, not that if it does occur the results won't be bad. Do you trust that sort of argument? I don't.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:37PM (#43940258)
Nice straw man you've constructed and burnt down.

Those are NOT the safety arguments used within the industry. For example in a molten salt reactor, the fuel is already melted! If it gets too hot, thermal expansion moves the radioactive isotopes further away from one another, reducing reactivity. If heat increases past a certain point, plugs at the bottom of the tanks will melt, allowing gravity to dump the fuel into multiple separated storage vessels sized to prevent further activity.

You do not know what you're talking about. You've read a bunch of fear mongering, and bought it. Do you really believe the entire industry of nuclear engineers and support staff are just blindly YOLOing their way through their jobs, damn the consequences?

I swear, you sound like the power production equivalent of antivaxers convinced the medical industry is trying to poison all of us.

"Passive safety" doesn't mean "stuff shouldn't go wrong."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_nuclear_safety

It means "we're actively exploring everything that could go wrong and having the worst case scenarios fail to a safe state without requiring human intervention."

Those two positions couldn't be further apart.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by pfdietz on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:24PM (#43941483)
So, how exactly do you claim conclusively that molten fuel (in a fast reactor with sold fuel elements) will not flow into a bad configuration? I don't see how one can possibly do that analysis. Teller didn't see how either.

I already said MSRs would be the one kind of fast reactor I could see the analysis work, so thank you for agreeing with me on that.

As a charitable act toward you I will ignore the rest of your comment.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:49PM (#43947040)
> I don't see how one can possibly do that analysis.

Classic argument from ignorance fallacy. Because YOU cannot see how it could be done, no one has ever figured out how it could be done.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by pfdietz on Saturday May 10, 2025 @08:04PM (#43950066)
You didn't answer the question.

All the analyses I've seen for fast reactor safety are about avoiding fuel melting, not what happens if the fuel does melt. The variability in this latter scenario is so great that conclusive analysis ruling out disaster doesn't seem possible. Maybe you could explain the unexpected principle that enables one to do that? Or, lacking that, point me to a paper where such analysis has been performed.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ben_w on Thursday May 08, 2025 @06:12PM (#43931897)
> Or that by far the easiest way to produce massive amounts hydrogen without emitting carbon into the atmosphere is… wait for it… nuclear power.

No, that isn't the easiest way.

The easiest — not best, easiest — way to produce massive amounts of hydrogen is whatever your electrical power source is plus some low corrosion rods in a river.

If you want the cheapest, well, in most cases PV is the cheapest source of electricity — there's variance, sometimes it's wind.

Nuclear is so expensive that it's the same range of prices as PV plus batteries. And when you're using the electricity to make hydrogen, with the hydrogen as the storage system, batteries are redundant.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Thursday May 08, 2025 @06:33PM (#43932033)
Since PV needs batteries to be grid-useful (duck curve and all that), it's perfectly reasonable to have both.

And no, hydrogen as the storage system doesn't make batteries redundant. Law of conservation of energy. You are talking about using electricity to split water molecules, presumably more electricity to compress and store the collected hydrogen, and then you have the losses associated with converting back to electricity in a fuel cell or conversion to mechanical energy through combustion.

A square meter of PV provides a theoretical maximum of ~1KW at 100%. Even the experimental perovskite cells only get 45% of that. 450W/m^2. Whereas nuclear is measured in gigawatts per reactor with multiple reactors per plant.

Then a storm hits. Far less sunlight. Then something like hail hits. Damage to panels. Then there's the issue of security if someone wanted to cripple the grid.

Nuclear is 24/7, rain or shine, wind or no, impervious to even hurricanes, and already has a robust security and logistics apparatus around it.

I have PV panels on my home. I love the idea of decentralized power. But the hydrogen economy is pretty theoretical at this point. Hard to store for any length of time, comparatively low combustion energy, low energy density overall, etc. It may happen, but "may" is a bad bet for long term national policy. I'd rather push more toward electrified high speed trains than hydrogen.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ben_w on Thursday May 08, 2025 @06:57PM (#43932183)
> Since PV needs batteries to be grid-useful (duck curve and all that), it's perfectly reasonable to have both.

Needs storage*, what that storage is depends on other factors.

(* there's a "well technically" for just a grid, in that China makes enough aluminium they could build an actually useful global power grid with negligible resistance, but it doesn't matter in practice)

As it happens, I agree with one crucial part of your final paragraph — hydrogen is hard to store for any length of time (not sure you're right about comparatively low combustion energy but that doesn't matter, low energy density overall is accurate but I don't think matters).

I favour batteries for that because battery cars beat hydrogen cars, and the storage requirements for a power grid are smaller than the requirements for transport, so we can just use the big (and expanding) pile of existing factories to do this.

But hydrogen has other uses than power, and where it's an emergency extra storage system you don't necessarily need a huge efficiency. That said, because one of the main other uses of hydrogen is to make ammonia, I expect emergency backup power to be something which burns ammonia rather than hydrogen gas — not only is it much more stable and much easier to store, it's something you'd be stockpiling anyway because fertiliser isn't applied all year around anyway.

But you could do hydrogen, if you wanted. And some people probably will, because of this sort of thing.

> A square meter of PV provides a theoretical maximum of ~1KW at 100%. Even the experimental perovskite cells only get 45% of that. 450W/m^2. Whereas nuclear is measured in gigawatts per reactor with multiple reactors per plant.

This is completely irrelevant for countries that aren't tiny islands or independent cities.

Even then, and even with lower 20% efficient cells, and also adding in the capacity factor of 10% that's slightly worse than the current global average, Vatican City* has the capacity for 11.1 kW/capita: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=0.5km%5E2+*+1kW%2Fm%5E2...

They are of course not going to tile their architecture in PV — there's a reason I wrote "that aren't … independent cities" — but this is a sense of scale.

(* Number 7 on the Wikipedia "List of countries and dependencies by population density": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependen...)

> Then a storm hits. Far less sunlight.

That's what the storage is for

> Then something like hail hits. Damage to panels.

Panels are as strong as you want them to be for the weather you get locally. If you need bullet-proof (FSVO), you can put them behind a bullet-proof screen.

> Then there's the issue of security if someone wanted to cripple the grid.

The grid isn't the source; if you want to cripple a grid, doesn't matter if the source is nuclear, PV, coal, or hamster wheels.

> Nuclear is 24/7, rain or shine, wind or no, impervious to even hurricanes, and already has a robust security and logistics apparatus around it.

Really isn't 24/7, it's 70-80%: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Worldwide_Nuclear_Power_C...

And mis-estimating the environmental risks is exactly what went wrong with Fukushima.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:25PM (#43940176)
> And mis-estimating the environmental risks is exactly what went wrong with Fukushima.

It took a massive earthquake and tsunami to cause this, and the number of deaths/injuries due to the power plant is a rounding error compared to the earthquake and tsunami. Fukushima actually did most things right with the notable exception of not putting the backup generators on the roof. Had they put the generators on the roof, neither of us would have ever known the name "Fukushima".

When evaluating the Fukushima exclusion zone, compare it to the Exxon Valdez oil spill of 1989. In that case, we still haven't cleaned up all the oil, and up to 450 miles from the initial spill. By comparison you want to transition to ammonia as a fuel source, which you correctly note is easier to store long term than molecular hydrogen and far more energy dense. Sounds like a good deal since molecular nitrogen is incredibly abundant as well.

Now I want you to imagine there's an ammonia spill in the magnitude of Exxon Valdez. Long term, the ammonia would almost certainly dissipate faster than crude oil, but the immediate acute toxicity would be far worse. You're killing basically all sea life in the area, the fumes would take out most birds and even quite a few people. If the spill were on land, it could severely compromise the ability to grow crops in the region for a long time. And that's not in the face of a massive earthquake and tsunami, but inattentiveness on the part of a single ship's crew.

The point being that large scale energy production and storage will NEVER be fuzzy and completely safe. The most common metric is deaths per unit of electricity. If a power source is small, even one death can be unforgivable. For massive amounts of power, statistics matter.

https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy

Note that the nuclear stats include both Chernobyl and Fukushima. This is notable since Chernobyl was a worst case scenario with a flawed design that has never existed in Western commercial reactors precisely because it was so unacceptably dangerous: no containment vessel, graphite moderation, graphite fuel rod tips, lack of education for its staff, a culture of secrecy, etc.

In the meantime, nuclear has provided obscenely large amounts of electricity since its inception. I'm all for expanding solar and wind, but folks really need to understand the real enemy is fossil fuels: coal, oil, natural gas, etc. The single largest threat to our survival as a species isn't a multi-kilometer exclusion zone but a CO2-laden atmosphere that makes the entire equatorial zone uninhabitable, and that's precisely what we're looking at within a century.

The faster we can move off carbon-based fuels by any means necessary, the better. That includes nuclear. Excluding nuclear from the conversation out of hand is lunacy.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:22AM (#43935964)
Hydrogen is already used in many industrial processes (~1e8 metric tons/year), including turbo-alternators, while there is not a single ready-to-be-built model of industrial breeder reactor.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Saturday May 10, 2025 @12:44PM (#43946998)
Not only was a design ready to be built, it was built. Went online 39 years ago. Produced 1.2GWe at peak. Not only produced power on its own but reprocessed spent fuel from other nuclear reactors.

Decommissioned 28 years ago. Because it didn't work? No. Because it wasn't safe? No. Because it wasn't reliable? No, it had a 95% availability rate.

It was taken out of service due to political pressure and legal maneuvering, not technical reasons.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superph%C3%A9nix

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Saturday May 10, 2025 @09:14PM (#43950407)
Facts: Superphénix was a prototype. It didn't reach its goal (reaching the industrial stage). Not a single model of breeder reactor reached it. Mentioning its high availability rate neglects planned shutdowns (planning enough of them improves it). Its load factor in 1996 (just before its shutdown), more relevant, was 0.31, thus well below the minimum viable for an industrial reactor. Some people consider the project to be a success, but no expert or its operator has ever said so (they proclaimed their confidence in their ability to achieve industrial operation by an unspecified date), and its successor, named "ASTRID", launched 12 years later, which was supposed to design and build a reactor for €5 billion, spent more than €700 million on studies alone before being put on hold, so "it worked, but everything has to be redesigned...".
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ZeroGravitas on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:41PM (#43929742)
That report you say has 1 hour of storage has four hours of battery in all the systems it compares.

It's a bit of a weird measure anyway, since it's just the ratio of storage to inverter, so it's the time it could run for when working flat out.

For your wider point, if anyone, anywhere was really contemplating a near full nuclear grid they'd have the exact same issues. Do you overbuild and curtail? Export? Store in batteries? The problems and solutions are incredibly similar now batteries have basically solved the daily variation for solar.

The fact that no one is even bothering to think that far ahead for nuclear is a recognition of how totally out of the race it is.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by linhns on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:09PM (#43928432)
Yes, and people have been as clever as possible dealing with this issue. There is just no good way to solve it.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:01PM (#43927493)
"…by being cleverer."

Like harnessing the atom for enormous amounts of 24/7 power per unit volume of fuel and not emitting CO2 while we do it? Yes! Let's do that! And work on making reprocessing more affordable, so we don't even have to mine any more fuel (at least for the next 150 years).

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by rcpt on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:48AM (#43926573)
Renewables are only easy if you ignore regulations. For whatever stupid reason local busybodies lose their shit about windmills regularly and they are frustratingly hard to ignore.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by pjc50 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:04AM (#43926783)
Nuclear has an even worse local credibility problem, but I suppose you need fewer plants.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by worldsayshi on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:50AM (#43926607)
Doesn't revenue sharing often turn those frowns upside down? More inclusive business models might help?
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by tough on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:24AM (#43927007)
Usually what happens is they buy out one local government, pay them, and usually fuck up the neighbors as the local government being paid not only has the incentive of money but can say put that hazardous facility just at the circumvention to their neighboring places, which get 0.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ryathal on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:34PM (#43928824)
For the farmer that owns the land the windmill got built on it's great. The handful of houses in the area get fuck all though and actually have to deal with the externalities.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by melling on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:45AM (#43926539)
US Net Zero is 2050. With 25 years remaining, I think shooting for 2030 seems reasonable.

We’ve just about hit peak coal.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/dec/18/coal-use-to...

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by titzer on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:31AM (#43927105)
> The world’s coal use is expected to reach a fresh high of 8.7bn tonnes this year, and remain at near-record levels for years as a result of a global gas crisis triggered by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

Not sure that counts as "just about hit peak coal".

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by 1980phipsi on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:48AM (#43926574)
Google can’t have blackouts. So helps to have some nuclear in the energy mix.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by blitzar on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:15AM (#43926894)
Why not?

At this point optimising their electricity cost by load balancing their compute to where electricity is cheap, free or negative on a minute by minute basis would be a sizeable cost saving. Savings that would possibly offset the hardware overprovisioning that they would need.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by jeffbee on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:00PM (#43927474)
Yeah, I would say of the organizations in the world that care about power outages, Google would rank among those most prepared to deal with them and the least flustered when they happen. If it has been too long between power outages Google will cause one intentionally, as an exercise.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by croes on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:13AM (#43926864)
France has nuclear and had a blackout.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ttfkam on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:17PM (#43927695)
The last time France had a blackout on the scale of Spain and Portugal was 1978. France has been and remains one of the top electricity exporters for Western Europe.

Because of nuclear.

By comparison, Germany dropped its nuclear power industry in favor of focus on renewables. Now they import electricity generated by nuclear from France and buy fossil fuels from Russia despite recent Russian aggression.

Who isn't dependent on fossil fuel imports from Russia? France. Who is looking to ban all internal combustion engines from their largest city by 2030? France.

Because of nuclear.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:56PM (#43929156)
You do know that the French grid would crash during every cold spell without 30 GW of fossil fueled power production? With the majority coming from their neighbors, reversing said flow?

What they have done is outsourced the management of their grid to their neighbors fossil fuel power plants, and then only when they truly have to they reduce the output of their nuclear power.

Stick two French next to each other and they would in short order crash.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by wewxjfq on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:22PM (#43928644)
Germany does not receive Russian pipeline gas and has banned Russian LNG from its ports. It receives a tiny share of Russian gas from Dutch and Belgian ports, but to my knowledge Germany has no control over this. France on the other hand is the top destination for Russian LNG in the EU, sharing the lead only with countries that refuse to support Ukraine.

Germany became a net importer of electricity in 2023, but it took the vast majority of its nuclear power plants offline long before that, when Germany still was a net exporter of electricity. Even in 2022, during the gas crisis with barely any nuclear power left, Germany net exported records amounts of electricity to other European countries, with France at the top of the receiving end because half of their nuclear reactor fleet was offline.

Lastly, Germany has one of the most stable grids in the world, while France does issue blackout warnings when demand peaks.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by croes on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:41PM (#43928019)
Germany is a net importer since 2023, what was also 2023 in France?

>2023 when several reactors were switched off for longer unexpected maintenance periods.

Who exploited Niger for four decades for its Uranium?

France

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/les-decodeurs/article/2023/08/04/h...

Who is the main buyer in the EU of Russian Uranium?

France

https://bellona.org/news/nuclear-issues/2025-01-eu-and-us-re...

If they aren’t dependent on Russian fossile fuels why do they still buy from Russia?

https://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20250414-greenpeace-report-reve...

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by barbazoo on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:18PM (#43927717)
Misleading I’d say

> Residents of Andorra and parts of France bordering Spain were also reporting being hit by the blackout.

https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2025/04/28/spain-portugal...

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by croes on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:43PM (#43928039)
My point is blackouts habe more to do with net stability then with the power source.

A sudden rise in demand would have the same effect because nuclear power plants can’t react that quickly.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by preisschild on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:48AM (#43926585)
> given how much easier it is to incrementally add renewable capacity

The problem is, the weather dependency makes it harder the more you add, because you will have too much when the weather is optimal and next to nothing when it isn't.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ivan_gammel on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:02AM (#43926756)
This reminded me of how France had to limit nuclear outputs because of the heatwave. New designs can probably mitigate the risk but it will inevitably add to the operational and construction costs.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/warming-rivers-threa...

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by preisschild on Sunday May 11, 2025 @02:12PM (#43955713)
Its not about "new" vs "old" designs. Cooling towers have been a feature for decades, which those french nuclear power plants just didn't have before, because it wasn't necessary yet. Thanks to climate change it now is.

Also it isn't as bad as it sounds. They had to throttle some nuclear power plants slightly. This lead to a loss of less than 0.2% of the total 2022 nuclear generation in france.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:59AM (#43926724)
Storage is absolutely exploding. With China adding 74 GW in 2024 [1] alone and for the US it was expected to make up 30% of grid additions [2] before Trump came with his sledgehammer of insanity.

Replacing Vogtle with renewables TWh for TWh and then building $63/kWh [3] storage with the money leftover leads to enough storage to supply the equivalent to Vogtles two new reactors for 10 days.

That is how utterly truly insanely expensive new build western nuclear power is.

[1]: https://www.ess-news.com/2025/01/23/chinas-new-energy-storag...

[2]: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=64586

[3]: https://www.ess-news.com/2025/01/15/chinas-cgn-new-energy-an...

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by PaulHoule on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:07PM (#43927578)
That's a reasonable way to think about it, but is 10 days enough? It seems 12-24 hours would be needed to smooth out diurnal variations, but there is also the seasonal variation of 2x-3x in many places which either requires a large investment in overgeneration or huge amounts of storage. There is also this problem

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunkelflaute

which means the storage requirements will be a bit more than you'd think otherwise. You can't get reputable people to quote a price on a whole power grid because of all sorts of uncertainties such as "how many days of outage will people tolerate a year?"

If we use electricity to drive other decarbonization efforts, lets say green steel, or "petrochemical" manufacturing, or sustainable aviation fuels, the grid might become less tolerant of variation rather than more. Use the word "start-up" around a chemical engineer and they're likely to jump out of their skin because starting up a chemical factory is an unprofitable and sometimes dangerous operation. In an oil refinery, for instance, there are systems that produce hydrogen and others that consume it and it reaches a steady state. During startup you may have to make up inputs that aren't available and dispose or store outputs that don't have consumers. There are heat exchangers all over the place to recycle heat but you're going to have to supply steam to some of them and cooling water to others. The system is dynamically stable when it is running but during start-up vulnerable to all sorts of problems, plus people are crawling all over it doing various operations opening up the possibility of human errors such as sucking in storage tanks. In particularly the chemistry used to make jet fuel from syngas or methanol is horribly capital intensive to begin with, increasing that cost 5x by only running the factory 20% of the time takes something that's probably a non-starter to begin with [1]

So far as Voglte a lot of the cost overrun might go away if we just "stayed the course" and built more reactors of the same design. The real sticker cost is probably a bit more than they say it is, but if you could build one bungling free you'd think it could be made for less. It's not just a "western" problem, as the AP1000 is built as a number of "modules" in a factories in China and they waited for years for those factories to figure out how to build the parts and sometimes when they got those parts they were built wrong. If China is succeeding where we are failing it is because they can, politically, raise people's electric bills in the short term in order to dominate an industry in the long term. The main build they are doing now is

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hualong_One

which is an improved reactor of the kind the French were building back when the French were building large numbers of reactors reliably.

[1] when they really are forced to aviation will probably line up with ground transportation around some single entity fuel like methane or DME

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:52PM (#43928168)
Throw some gas turbines on it. Low CAPEX high OPEX. Just like we’ve done for the past decades with the previous ”base load and peaking” paradigm.

Those gas turbines will be a minuscule part of the total energy supply.

When it finally becomes the most pressing issue the gas turbines can trivially be fueled by green hydrogen, green hydrogen derivatives, biofuels or biogas from collecting food waste. If they are still needed.

Lets wait and see what aviation and shipping settles on before attempting to solve a future issue today.

Yes we already have a solution for all those industries which require stable power: buy an electricity future.

But somehow we need to treat the grid differently and handout untold trillions to the nuclear industry.

We have research on when we achieve learning effects.

> If you look at the data specifically you're going to find learning but for that there's a several requirements:

> - It has to be the same site

> - It has to be the same constructor

> - It has to be at least two years of of gap between one construction to the next

> - It has to be constant labor laws

> - It has to be a constant regulatory regime

> When you add these five you only get like four or five examples in the world.

From a nuclear energy professor at MIT in a nuclear power industry podcast, giving an overly positive but still sober image regarding the nuclear industry as it exists today.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDzaSucDg7k

China is not succeeding? They have been averaging 4-5 construction starts per year since 2020 which tracks to a 2-3% nuclear power in their electricity mix.

From their 2011 target of building 300 GW nuclear power in the next 10-20 years they have so far managed to complete 46 GW. But surely those final 254 GW will show up before 2031.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bee_rider on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:57AM (#43926701)
Skill issue, there’s no such thing as too much energy, we need to get better at steering the stuff.