News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:19AM (#43926947)
You do know that nuclear power has experienced negative learning by doing throughout its entire life?

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03014...

You don’t get ”free electricity” with absolutely massive handouts to the nuclear industry.

Instead renewables and storage are delivering on the ”too cheap to meter” promise.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by belorn on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:49AM (#43927330)
It was promised that by now half the grid of EU should had been operated under green hydrogen. Instead we had yesterday in Sweden news the opening of a freshly new built natural gas power plant as the solution to that intermittence problem. Of course, those natural gas power plants are paid through subsidizes as grid stability is the government responsibility, and thus the bill for that natural gas is put on taxes and connection fees.

I have said it before, but in order for me to believe the claims that renewables and storage are delivering in places like europe, you first have to stop investing and building new natural gas power plants. Rather than classify natural gas as "green", as Germany pushed through in EU, we should have laws to prevent new natural gas power plants from being built and existing fleet should be slowly dismantled. If renewables and storage can deliver on the ”too cheap to meter” promise, they should do so in an environment without natural gas being used behind the scene.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:58AM (#43927457)
Love how the goalposts magically shifted to ”green hydrogen deployed today!!” even though many grids still don’t even reach saturation from renewables. Storage or green hydrogen is an enormous waste of money in Poland given their grid composition.

That renewable buildout leads to larger fossil emissions being wrong is trivial to verify. The UK as one example of many:

- Coal has gone from 150 TWh to zero. - Fossil gas from 175 TWh to 85 TWh. - Nuclear from 80 TWh to 40 TWh.

Massively decreasing all fossil fueled electricity production of course "extends the life" of these plants. All those plants that were shut down had their "life extended".

You can do the same for Denmark, Portugal, California, South Australia and everywhere else. First renewables offset coal followed by cutting into gas usage.

After hitting a plateau storage is now unlocking massive reductions in fossil gas usage in California:

- Gas is down 45% v '23 and 25% v '24

- Batteries up 198% v '23 and 73.4% v '24

https://bsky.app/profile/mzjacobson.bsky.social/post/3lnw3hs...

Storage is exploding globally. China installed 74 GW comprising 134 GWh of storage in 2024. Increasing their yearly installation rate by 250%. The US is looking at installing 18 GW in 2025 making up 30% of all grid additions. Well, before Trump came with a sledgehammer of insanity.

Storage delivers. For the last bit of "emergency reserves" we can run some gas turbines. First our existing fleet and then when it becomes the most pressing issue to decarbonize we can utilize the solution aviation and shipping settled on.

Or just run the gas turbines on biofuels, green hydrogen or whatever. Start collecting food waste and create biogas from it.

Doesn't really matter, we're talking single percent of total energy demand.

I love how completely insignificant issues becomes blown up to enormous proportions try to force nuclear power into the conversation.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by belorn on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:48PM (#43929841)
Lets then have a ban on all new natural gas power plants until its down to a single percent. That should not be a problem if that is all that is needed.

Using UK as an example, the majority of energy is not renewables. Why should they build new natural gas power plants? Natural gas produce more energy than any other source in the UK. They are not going from 98% renewables, 2% natural gas. (https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-uks-electricity-was-cle...)

UK should increase the production of renewables energy, but they should also decommission their fossil fuel plants. If they want to use non-fossil fuel solutions, then they should do so and compete fairly and without subsidizes. Same goes for nuclear.

The cost of intermittence should not be paid by the environment or subsidizes, otherwise they are just hiding the true cost that society have to pay.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @03:11PM (#43930139)
You seem to advocate for some holier than thou perfect path rather than the messy reality that is a transition of the entire energy system to a new cheaper source while upholding our modern society.

Let’s look at the area under the curve?

You know, we need to decarbonize agriculture, construction, transportation etc. as well.

Let look at what the UK has done:

- Coal has gone from 150 TWh to zero.

- Fossil gas from 175 TWh to 85 TWh.

- Nuclear from 80 TWh to 40 TWh.

Would you say this reduction in fossil fuel usage insignificant because they obviously aren’t done yet?

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by belorn on Thursday May 08, 2025 @07:32PM (#43932393)
If we want to talk messy reality, then the only realistic way to prevent critical point in global warming is to build everything that is non-fossil fuel, that being renewables, nuclear, experimental storage and so on, while at the same time utilizing market forces and use risk-benefit analysis for each government intervention in order to spend government subsidies as cost effective as possible. Everything is needed in order to do as much as possible to reduce emissions.

For EU regulation that requires lower emissions and environmental issues with hydro power, the messy reality is also that the cost of breaking the law and paying the fines are currently cheaper than the economical and political costs of complying with the law. So that is what the Swedish government are doing. The Paris Agreement is just a goal and clearly there is a lot of voters who see it as incompatible with modern society.

It is also the messy reality that many current governments in EU got their votes in the last election because they bailed out the citizens when the power crisis happened and paid the power bills through taxes, causing major harm in the market and further inflated prices. Building out more natural gas power plants will reduce the cost of the next crisis, which is also the stated goal of the new one that got built in Sweden.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:25AM (#43935134)
You still haven’t been able to answer why we should waste money on new built nuclear power.

It costs 5-10x as much, does not integrate well with renewables due to the capital structure and takes 15-20 years to build from political decision to operational plant.

We need to decarbonize now. Not extend the life of fossil assets for decades waiting for nuclear power to come online. With this nuclear power producing a fraction of the TWh compared to if the same money went into renewables and storage.

Wasting money on enormous handouts to the nuclear industry is not ”doing as much as possible to reduce emissions”. It is a dogwhistle from climate change deniers to extend the life of fossil assets to stymie their disruption by renewables.

I don’t think you’ve kept up with the renewable industry. The absolute explosion we are seeing is because renewables and storage today are cheaper than fossil fuels.

It started as feelgood moonshot decades ago. Today companies and countries are at a competitive advantage if they can retool their fossil dependent processes and systems to renewables.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by crote on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:36PM (#43927933)
> It was promised that by now half the grid of EU should had been operated under green hydrogen

The only one promising that was the fossil industry, trying to stay relevant by pushing hydrogen as "green" and doing a switcheroo to "blue" fossil-derived hydrogen when green hydrogen inevitably turns out to be nonviable for silly things like mid-term energy storage.

> If renewables and storage can deliver on the ”too cheap to meter” promise, they should do so in an environment without natural gas being used behind the scene.

No. Remember, the goal is to minimize the total greenhouse gas emissions! We're in a transition phase, if that means operating on 97.5% renewables and 2.5% natural gas until we figure out those last 2.5%, then that is totally fine. At the moment natural gas is excellent for peaker plants - especially if you implement carbon capture. Would you rather stay on the current ~50% fossil mix, solely because the transition mix isn't "green enough"? We're trying to save the environment, not trying to be holier than the pope.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by belorn on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:30PM (#43929596)
If you want to present the plan as renewables and subsidized natural gas as being better than nuclear than be open about it and present it as that. It is not the same as a subsidize free renewables and storage solution.

Those 97.5% sounds very nice. Denmark has well over 100% renewables production from wind and solar, but in terms of consumption only get around 50%. The rest they need to import. 97.5 vs 50 means there is some work to be done.

I recently posted this link (https://svensksolenergi.se/statistik/elproduktion-fran-solen...) that illustrate how much energy that solar farms produce in Sweden. Getting 97.5% from that would be a nice challenge, especially around the winter months. December and January had around 3% production compared to the best previous month (which we could use as a stand-in for 100% capacity but that would be incorrect).

Natural gas is not fine. The geopolitical consequences are terrible, the environmental impact are not sustainable, and the cost are carried almost exclusively through subsidizes. Trying to sell natural gas as "saving the environment" is a political message that I do not agree with.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by derriz on Thursday May 08, 2025 @04:04PM (#43930722)
You're including a bunch of different generation technologies which have vastly different operating characteristics which means they are not substitutes for each other.

For example, nuclear takes days to start from cold and is really only economic if operating at a constant output. Thus you need complimentary sources to help meet changes in demand. These days, typically this means gas turbines.

Whether your grid has nuclear or renewables, it will also have natural gas capacity.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:45AM (#43935763)
> Whether your grid has nuclear or renewables, it will also have natural gas capacity.

No, turbo-alternators 'burning' hydrogen do exist. And green hydrogen (produced by renewables) is cheaper than pink hydrogen (produced by a nuclear reactor) because the total cost of renewables' electricity is lower than nuclear's.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by derriz on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:13PM (#43939612)
I don’t see the connection with my comment but hydrogen is irrelevant and contributes less than a rounding error to global electricity generation. The technical components for a hydrogen based energy market do exist but are simply unviable financially. Nuclear also struggles to compete on the basis of price in competitive markets but is a genuinely low-carbon source of electricity. You could argue (I personally would not) that the higher cost of nuclear can be justified on this basis but the fact that hydrogen is an extremely potent greenhouse gas and is prone to leakage means it doesn’t even have that going for it.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Saturday May 10, 2025 @01:18AM (#43943404)
The connection is that "it will also have natural gas capacity" seems false to me as backup turbo-alternators can 'burn' hydrogen ( => no natural gas capacity).

> hydrogen > contributes less than a rounding error to global electricity generation

True, however it doesn't imply that it will remain irrelevant.

> unviable financially

For the time being, and less and less. Bloomberg NEF predicts that green hydrogen will cost approximately 1.2€/kg in 2050. Carbon taxes or oil prices may also play a role as nearly all hydrogen is now produced thanks to some fossil fuel.

> nuclear > is a genuinely low-carbon source of electricity

Green hydrogen could also be.

> prone to leakage

This is a major challenge for transportation-related usages, especially in small or not-intensively used vehicles. This isn't in the "gridpower backup" role, as mass and volume of storage isn't a major parameter.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by derriz on Saturday May 10, 2025 @10:00AM (#43945701)
I see what you meant now but still see little scope for hydrogen to have a role in the energy sector.

One reason for my skepticism is that I've been hearing optimistic predictions around hydrogen as an energy store for decades at this stage (I'm old) and for a long time believed them but here we are, with little to show for it. In fact, at historical scales, hydrogen's significance as an energy store today is less than it was in the 19th century. As a result, I've adopted "I'll believe it when I see it" approach so I just ignore hydrogen predictions - particularly ones 25 years into the future.

But the main reason is simple physics. It simply has NONE of the physical attributes you'd want in a gas to be used to store energy. It's like if you picked all the attributes you WOULDN'T want in such a gas.

Storage and transport are incredibly expensive and technically difficult. Everything it comes into contact with needs special materials to avoid embrittlement. It's prone to leakage.

It has dreadful energy density. The worst.

It has potent green house gas effects when leaked into the atmosphere.

It's dangerous and highly explosive and burns with such high intensity (and invisibly) that it requires specialist fire-fighting equipment.

Roundtrip efficiency (electricity to H to electricity) is abysmal - a fraction of that of batteries.

In summary, hydrogen as energy store makes no sense to me. And it's completely hypothetical. If we are going to talk about hypothetical approaches to storing energy in the form of a gas, then green methane makes a lot more sense. Not that I'd advocate for either but I see some potential for green methane but none for hydrogen given its physical attributes.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by natmaka on Saturday May 10, 2025 @09:41PM (#43950543)
> I've been hearing optimistic predictions around hydrogen

Fair point, same here (I was born in 1967), however fossil fuels are so effective and adequate as energy sources, as long as we ignored/neglected their dubious effect on the climate, that there was no real attempt to explore other ways.

> Storage and transport are incredibly expensive and technically difficult

For the "gridpower backup" application there is no transport needed, and storage doesn't have to be compact nor mobile (those are a major challenge for hydrogen in transportation).

> dreadful energy density

This is not a show-stopper for the "gridpower backup" application. For huge volumes or very long-term (not sure this will be necessary) it may be stored in salt caverns ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_storage#Underground_h... )

> potent green house gas effects > dangerous

Granted, however we are used to store huge volumes of dangerous materials, some gaseous at ambiant pressure/temp (methane...), even into salt caverns, albeit when we began to do so (in the 1950's) it was quite a challenge.

> Roundtrip efficiency (electricity to H to electricity) is abysmal

Various new ways to obtain H2 from electricity offer impressive yield in realistic conditions (check SOECs), and other advances are promising ( https://liten.cea.fr/cea-tech/liten/english/Pages/Strategic-... ).

> green methane makes a lot more sense

As does ammonia, in some contexts. There is no one-size-fits-all here!

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by dporter on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:34AM (#43927139)
Renewable power is cheap because it also receives massive government handouts in the form of tax credits.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:38AM (#43927205)
Still built at absolutely massive scale around the world without subsidies. With many countries phasing out their renewable subsidies because they aren’t needed anymore.

Unsubsidized solar and storage is today in much of the world cheaper than coal and fossil gas.

The renewable subsidies stil existing simply add fuel to the already raging fire that is renewable buildout.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by nandomrumber on Thursday May 08, 2025 @11:57AM (#43927438)
What storage? Where? At what price?

Where are all these 14 day full load capable storage plants being built?

I’m not saying they aren’t, I am saying I don’t see the data.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:32PM (#43927884)
We are at the point in the S-curve where storage goes from nowhere to everywhere in the blink of an eye.

Here BESS for $63/kWh installed and serviced for 20 years.

https://www.ess-news.com/2025/01/15/chinas-cgn-new-energy-an...

https://www.ess-news.com/2024/12/09/powerchina-receives-bids...

China installed 74 GW comprising 168 GWh in 2024. In increase of 250% compared to 2023.

https://www.ess-news.com/2025/01/23/chinas-new-energy-storag...

After hitting a plateau storage is now unlocking massive reductions in fossil gas usage in California:

- Gas is down 45% v '23 and 25% v '24

- Batteries up 198% v '23 and 73.4% v '24

https://bsky.app/profile/mzjacobson.bsky.social/post/3lnw3hs...

In the US in 2025 storage was expected to make up 30% of all grid additions. Before Trump came with his sledgehammer of insanity.

https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=64586

No one generally expects more than a couple of hours of storage to be needed. But for the fun exercise let’s calculate what spending Vogtles $36.8B on equivalent renewables, as in TWh delivered, and the storage gives.

That makes the renewables come out to about $9B.

With storage costing $0.063B GWh and having $28B to spend we can build 444 GWh storage.

That is the equivalent to running Vogtles two new reactors for 10 days straight.

In this calculation we don’t even bother with Vogtles O&M costs compared to near zero for renewables and storage.

Do you now understand how incredibly expensive new built western nuclear power is?

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bryanlarsen on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:58PM (#43928248)
Never, because we don't need 14 days of full load capable storage. Most models say we need about 3 days to get 99.99% coverage with a reasonable amount of overbuild & interconnect.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by notTooFarGone on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:01AM (#43935019)
why not make it a lifetime of storage if we are here just spouting nonsense numbers.

storage for 12 hours and we are 80% there. If you don't like 80% solutions then please don't participate in society as it's only working on those.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by bee_rider on Thursday May 08, 2025 @02:04PM (#43929269)
Renewable suffers a little bit from having renewable infrastructure costs considered a new subsidy, while fossil fuel costs are just kind of baked in.

If we included the cost of cleaning up fossil fuel byproducts… well, we don’t even know how much it will cost to clean up all that carbon.

Then we will have to work out how we bill the international relations cost of having to deal with petrochemical producers…

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by EasyMark on Thursday May 08, 2025 @10:55PM (#43933417)
that used to be true, but it's not really true any longer; they could even do well without subsidies, but no industry will ever give up free money.
Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by chermi on Thursday May 08, 2025 @12:41PM (#43928011)
Are you really denying the learning curve based on one paper about France? You don't think maybe there's other confounding factors*? A single survey of a single country isn't counterfactual. Are you really certain that with a relatively fixed design the learning curve wouldn't apply at sufficient scale, all else being equal. The learning curve is one of the most time-tested laws in construction.

*Yes, I understand it's inflation adjusted. There are so many possible explanations for the observed negative curve that go beyond the bold, broad claim that learning curve theory doesn't hold in nuclear.

In my mind, an (at least) equally reasonable explanation is that the conditions for the learning curve weren't met. (This probably sounds like "no true Scotsman". I admit that the learning curve is a function of scale and relative to mass-production examples, the "signal" for the learning curve is probably weaker to begin with given how many facilities of the same design were actually built.)

-Changes in design pull you backward on the curve. There were lots of changes in French design

-Unsteady expansion timeline messes with the workforce expertise part of the hypothesis. You want ideally an accelerated or at least constant build rate, not large gaps where the workforce either respecializes in another field or retires.

- regulations increase over time. Part of the conditions for the theory are implicitly "all else being equal".

-while inflation adjustment partially accounts for this, labor becomes more expensive as gdp per capital increases (see, for example, low skill manufacturing leaving China as it becomes wealthier). I don't know the details, but given the rapid post-war growth, I'm guessing gdp/capital was growing pretty quickly during the French build out

For relatively low volume manufacturing, the learning curve effects are probably smaller to begin with, so it's easier to get an effective negative learning rate. With so many confounding factors that violate the premise of theory, I find it rather unscientific to definitively claim the theory is just wrong in an entire industry.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by ViewTrick1002 on Thursday May 08, 2025 @01:04PM (#43928345)
It also includes the US seeing the same negative learning by doing.

We have research on when we have achieved learning effects.

> If you look at the data specifically you're going to find learning but for that there's a several requirements:

> - It has to be the same site

> - It has to be the same constructor

> - It has to be at least two years of of gap between one construction to the next

> - It has to be constant labor laws

> - It has to be a constant regulatory regime

> When you add these five you only get like four or five examples in the world.

From a nuclear energy professor at MIT in a nuclear power industry podcast, giving an overly positive but still sober image regarding the nuclear industry as it exists today.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDzaSucDg7k

In the meantime renewables and storage have gone from nascent industries to today be the vast majority of all new energy production in TWh and while costing a fraction of new built nuclear power.

Re:Google to Back Three New Advanced Nuclear Projects by chermi on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:23PM (#43938550)
Again, I'd say based on the conditions for the theory to hold, the US couldn't prove or disprove the theory either way. I guess to summarize my stance: we don't know what the learning curve for nuclear is because data that is too messy. That being the case, my prior would weight the theory holding, maybe weakly, given the evidence for it elsewhere. Maybe in a few years we can infer some honest data from China.