You are a walking, talking embodiment of a Principal Skinner meme. That fact that the massively sophisticated UX team of the world's most popular website disagrees with your conclusions does mean something, just not what you're thinking.
The YouTube team has been blindly chasing monetization at the expense of their website being useful and pleasant for a while now. Unfortunately it seems they can get away with it. I wrote this post to just shake my fist at the cloud
This is called "appeal to authority" and it's a pretty unintelligent logical fallacy. Do better next time. Maybe read a book or two?
This is called ad hominem, and has no place here.
In this case there's an insult inside the argument, but importantly the insult is not the argument being made. Therefore it is not ad hominem.
I don't want to ban you, but you're making it increasingly difficult not to.
You have a history of abusing HN and we need you to stop doing that. You also have a history of posting good things, which is why I'd prefer not to ban you.
Unfortunately UX teams aren't actually paid to make great UX, especially at large corps and any place ad-driven. They're paid to move the metrics and move the revenue line.
The fewer videos they have in focus at a time, the more accurate their algorithms can be.
this is the story of the big company web sites
- huge budget
- best programmers
- terrible design
- terrible usability
- doesnt make sense
- gets worse over time
it's unreal. seen on many major sites.
Some of the revelations from the various lawsuits against Google by the US and other governments over the years have been about this.
The company replaced leaders who cared about users with leaders who cared about revenue optimization and those leaders changed the direction of the company to what we all see in all of their products these days.
Relevant articles:
https://www.nngroup.com/articles/simplicity-vs-choice/
https://www.nngroup.com/articles/short-term-memory-and-web-u...
https://www.nngroup.com/articles/working-memory-external-mem...
I'm also starting to think that no large company will ever act in the best interest of their customers unless required to do so by regulation. As long as those customers are individuals.
Maybe the regulation we need is that companies like Google can't have "ad supported" products that are simultaneously sold as products to users. Either you're selling a product to users, or really running an advertising platform. It can't be both.
As a result I installed the "Control Panel for Youtube" chrome plugin and Im able to fix it back to 6 videos per row. I also found I could make shorts play in the traditional youtube player by default - which is an added relief.