News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by tacker2000 on Monday April 21, 2025 @04:26PM (#43756094)
Now that you got caught you are fixing it and writing fancy PR fluff. An org the size of MS should have clear policies and processes of how to handle open source forks like this. Unless we assume “bad faith” here. This is a pretty bad look.

I wonder how many other projects are not attributed correctly. Are you checking up on them also or just waiting for the next HN post?

That said, the author of Spegel should have used another license if he wanted more “recognition” or the like.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by aleph_minus_one on Monday April 21, 2025 @04:37PM (#43756203)
> I wonder how many other projects are not attributed correctly. Are you checking up on them also or just waiting for the next HN post?

As I wrote in my parallel post (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43756102): these copyright violations (not giving proper attribution of the license requires it is copyright violation) from Microsoft's side (the more, the "better", and the clearer the message) can be considered de-facto, implicitly stated corporate messages from Microsoft's side that they are from now on officially fine with copyright violations, and thus everybody is from now on free to violate the copyright on every software product that Microsoft has ever produced.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by leoqa on Monday April 21, 2025 @08:01PM (#43757766)
Sounds like a very expensive legal gambit.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by xwolfi on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @04:27AM (#43760120)
You have to prove the mens rea, and even then, people committing crimes don't automatically deserve crimes committed upon them.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by johnisgood on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @07:11AM (#43760823)
In reality they do, in some cases, e.g. capital punishment.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by johnisgood on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @11:29AM (#43763344)
I think I am being misunderstood here. I do not agree with it, I am just referring to practices in some countries.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by wilg on Monday April 21, 2025 @06:30PM (#43757219)
I mean what else are they supposed to say or do to correct a mistake other than "sorry, here's what happened, we have fixed it, we are taking steps to reduce the chances of it happening again"? Sometimes you just have to correct an error.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by epanchin on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:17PM (#43757546)
Ideally a list of other projects they have since found and attributed.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by NewsaHackO on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:38PM (#43757652)
From the tone of the response to Microsoft response, people will not be happy unless Microsoft publicly executed the engineers that did it.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by kshahkshah on Monday April 21, 2025 @07:53PM (#43757726)
I think people tend to forget that large companies are made up of flawed individuals and their policies mitigate but don't eliminate mistakes
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by oatmeal1 on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @03:11AM (#43759755)
They are also fully funded to compensate when they do something wrong. An apology from a Fortune 500 company with a history of unethical behavior is worthless.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by Fraterkes on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @03:43AM (#43759937)
That would be a start yeah
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by wilg on Monday April 21, 2025 @08:02PM (#43757775)
What if there aren't any or they have not yet done that because they wanted to respond to this person first?
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by toobulkeh on Friday April 25, 2025 @09:23PM (#43800090)
I think financial damages are realistic here. They materially damaged another brand, it’s all business at the end of the day.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by beefnugs on Monday April 21, 2025 @05:45PM (#43756855)
He is lucky microsoft doesn't have 30,000 ai-agents out there just stealing everything he has ever done and spinning up 10 competitors to each project all with new license and money flow into microsoft in any number of ways.

I mean they made sure to get all the consent from all authors on github before training on it right

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by gscott on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @12:05AM (#43758992)
I am on this affiliate list and one of the things they're pitching right now is an AI website cloner. Steals the other person's website switches out their content to something similar with new images... Profit!!!
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by arkh on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @02:47AM (#43759638)
> Now that you got caught you are fixing it and writing fancy PR fluff.

Nope, "the revenge of Clippy" is doing the writing.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by averageRoyalty on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @10:16AM (#43762490)
> Now that you got caught you are fixing it and writing fancy PR fluff. An org the size of MS should have clear policies and processes of how to handle open source forks like this. Unless we assume “bad faith” here. This is a pretty bad look.

What would you prefer them do? A public flogging? Bring back the stocks?

I agree with the sentiment with these types of comments (I hate PR fluff too), but the aggression when a company has screwed up and not only admits it but tells you their plan going forward is silly. The best case scenario is it does nothing, worst case it encourages them to ignore it next time it happrns.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by cycomanic on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @11:43AM (#43763493)
Well how does Microsoft react if some company "forgets" to licence windows/office/some other product? Because that is what happened here a clear licence violation so Microsoft essentially pirated the software.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by davidron on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @08:26PM (#43767564)
I bet Microsoft would do something similar. If Microsoft entered an agreement with another company, Apple for instance, to build a version of word for the Mac, a fork, and part of the license has a requirement to attribute in the help file or something like branding requirements, and then Apple doesn't do it right, then Microsoft reaches out to Apple and tells them to fix it else be in breach of the license. They fix it, happy happy. They don't fix it and lawyers get paid.

This was MIT licensed open source software and an attribution clause was not properly respected. Hardly piracy.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by Vegenoid on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @12:23PM (#43763861)
Their plan? “We hear you loud and clear and are going to make sure we improve our processes to help us be better stewards in the open-source community”? That’s not a plan. It’s PR fluff.

Nobody is expecting this one incident to make Microsoft change. It’s about reputation, which can take a long time to shift, but can be important in the long term.

We don’t have to just accept it when a company issues a statement apologizing for their screwup. It’s perfectly acceptable to say “this apology means little to me, and if you want your reputation to change you need to do more”.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by user_7832 on Wednesday April 23, 2025 @01:01AM (#43768740)
I’d like them to explicitly set out how they’re going to avoid such an issue occurring in the future, rather than symptomatically commenting on an HN post that’s now a top post.

They say:

> We hear you loud and clear and are going to make sure we improve our processes to help us be better stewards in the open-source community. Thanks again for bringing this to our attention. We will improve the way we work and collaborate in open source and are always open to feedback.

…which is a lot of nice words with absolutely NO accountability. They could write a sticky note “do better” and technically that’s all that’s required from their side. Is that okay with you?

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by mauer1361 on Wednesday April 23, 2025 @10:07AM (#43772406)
>A public flogging? Bring back the stocks? Yes, great idea.
Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by hmottestad on Wednesday April 23, 2025 @12:35PM (#43773938)
What would Microsoft do if I forked their repo, removed all the licenses and then held talks at conferences about my amazing new tool?

Pretty sure their legal department would have my fork obliterated from the face of the earth and I would be crossing my fingers that all I got was a cease and desist letter instead of a lawsuit in Texas.

Re:Getting Forked by Microsoft by optymizer on Tuesday April 22, 2025 @02:51PM (#43765110)
This tsk-tsk is misguided. There's a time and place to shame companies for acting in bad faith, and we should do it, but I don't think it's the case here. It does not seem like damage control for intentional malice.

The TL on the project should have done better, but it was a good sign that they had originally taken the time to acknowledge Spegel's author's help. It's very likely that someone else dealt with the actual code and license text and didn't know any better.

The PR text is reviewed by lawyers. The default advice from lawyers is "do not admit any wrongdoing". They probably suggested that the license text be fixed silently with no apology. The PR department likely convinced them that a public apology would be good for optics and it doesn't seem soulless either.

They should have done better. They admitted that. They may or may not change their internal processes, but it's now in the record book. Case closed.

And the author of Spegel should not have used a different license if he wanted "more <<recognition>>". He wanted the recognition specified by the MIT license.