Creating domestic jobs this way doesn't have a great track record however. They are usually quite expensive. And they don't help the geopolitical uncertainty at all, which is at least hinted at being something of an end goal.
Sure, you can ship parts all over the phone and have assembly in the final country. But what does that solve? What people usually think of when discussing where products are "produced", the components or at least a majority thereof, is the same.
Where do you source OLED screens in necessary quantity to produce a popular mobile phone model in the US, or any other Western country? Or the batteries? It's not a question of cost. It a question of non-existence.
Changing global production is a not a singular problem but something that would require laser focus during several decades and many different areas just to be something that could be taken seriously.
Especially when you gut the DoE and make zero effort to invest in either higher education or trades training.
If US wants a manufacturing revolution it needs to start with an education revolution.
A better way (IMO) to do it would have been tax incentives to build US plants to move manufacturing back in the US, have research university programs as feeders for tech innovation centers, and funding for technical colleges to expand their programs for skilled labor needed instead of gutting multiple agencies that would have overseen/guided this expansion. And oversight, of course. And attainable goals set in contracts to receive funding, not just, "here's a pile of money we'll forget about in 4 years."
In China they have the manufacturer down the street from the distributor who is down the street from your factory.
With Digikey we are paying $80 to overnight a $5 part from Minnesota. We need to be able to go send a guy to pick it up in an hour.
In China, you can just go down the street to the factory.
As for shipping overnight, it's incredibly common in R&D and repair.
The concept of having centralized full-chain production for enormous productivity boosts is not some wild concept, it's ancient and well known. Industries have clusters because it benefits everyone in the cluster. The US has very few and weak manufacturing clusters.
The article does, in fact. Their US made phone is manufactured, not just assembled, in the United States, and also attempts to source nearly all parts and materials from US suppliers as well.
They don't manufacture their important components. Not even Apple does that. No one does. There is roughly zero chance that any of the non-interchangable bits, the SoC, the battery or the screen, is manufactured in the US.
And there is nothing wrong with that. It's just silly to pretend otherwise.
If you're just thinking of price, the farther down the supply chain you go the less impact of tariffs.
If you're sincerely interested in the answer to that question, I'd highly recommend reading the article, because a good portion is dedicated specifically to answering that.
There is zero chance that a smartphone will ever be made out of 100% US-manufactured parts, or even close to it. And the evidence is right in this article, if this is the best effort to manufacture a "US phone."
Also, there is nothing in the article that talks about the quality of the phone. Being manufactured in the US does not automatically make it a high quality product. I'd take an iPhone manufactured anywhere in the world than this Liberty phone.
Economists selling people on free trade like to omit this, but production capacity, efficiency, cost, and technical know-how, aren't static, but improve based on demand.
In other words, people won’t just buy multiple iPhones just because it’s made locally.
> You can look at our concrete numbers. We sell a Chinese made Librem 5 phone for $799. We sell the Liberty phone for $2,000. When you're looking at just those numbers alone, that looks like a giant leap in cost. But there's a couple of factors that are not publicly known when you're looking at just those prices. When you're looking at COGS, cost of goods sold, our Librem 5 phone is equivalent in cost to about an iPhone. It's about $500 and some odd dollars, $550. So we can see that the Librem 5 phone doesn't have a very high margin when we sell it. The Liberty phone, same COGS componentry wise, but to produce it on US soil, we're adding not quite a hundred dollars. So it's about $650 to produce that entire phone. But what we're doing by selling it for greater originally, we're looking at a lot of differentiators for us. It wasn't just made in the USA. It's the fact that it's a secure supply chain, that you know, staff that's completely auditing every component, which means we're selling to a government security market with all those additional layers that we've added on top.
From https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/cogs.asp
> Cost of goods sold (COGS) refers to the direct costs of producing the goods sold by a company. This amount includes the cost of the materials and labor directly used to create the good. It excludes indirect expenses, such as distribution costs and sales force costs.
So the $550 or $650 COGS includes the cost of labor for manufacturing, but excludes (say) marketing and auditing costs.
This is a guess, but the argument is probably that it took way more R&D effort for them to figure out how to produce it efficiently in the US, and they've chosen to increase the cost of the US phone variant to offset this particular R&D expenditure that the Chinese variant didn't have.
> So it's about $650 to produce that entire phone. But what we're doing by selling it for greater originally, we're looking at a lot of differentiators for us. It wasn't just made in the USA. It's the fact that it's a secure supply chain, that you know, staff that's completely auditing every component, which means we're selling to a government security market with all those additional layers that we've added on top.
So I guess the answer is that they're selling to the "government security market" so they can charge whatever the hell they want.
I assume that the answer is much simpler than the "evil capitalist" narrative: the respective company is much smaller, and produces on a much smaller scale.
Thus it is an economic necessity that some part of the money is better used to build up reserves to be able to survive worse times.
Additionally, the smaller scale means that the development costs are a much larger cost proportion than for a company that produces on a huge scale.
The fact that they sell both the made in china model and the USA model shows it is not about building up reserves, as if they wanted to do that they would have higher prices on both models, not selective pricing, thus we are looking for a factor which affects their USA model but not China model.
Development costs are not really a factor here, they specifically say they developed both versions simulatenously, but yes if they didn/t it would be a factor.
They actually back up my first point by giving the reason for the pricing: "It's the fact that it's a secure supply chain, that you know, staff that's completely auditing every component, which means we're selling to a government security market with all those additional layers that we've added on top."
If you distill this down it is saying that basically securing the supply chain costs more, but also that it adds value. The government is willing to pay a whole lot more for the same product for that extra supply chain security even if it doesn't cost that much more for the manufacturer to produce because no one else can offer something like this.
In a world in which you do, you pay more for the machines, the materials, the components you can't make in the US (a phone is thousands of component, phone makers don't make most of them), etc.
It's probably $650 to design it, build half the parts, ordering most other parts and assemble them.
Now what's interesting with the tariffs is that it's not just it will make the parts you can order more expensive, it will make the supply of such parts available to you restricted since you are now competing with buyers that don't have tariffs and can outbid you easily.
Or course, all this include rare earth supply which China already restricted for US export, so even the part you can make are going to be super expensive. The premium is going to be way more than the tariff ones.
Finally, since you are not going to be able to sell to the Chinese market of 1.5M of people, you will sell fewer phones, meaning your volume effect will be lower.
Meanwhile, competitors from Asia and Europe will be able to sell to the rest of the world, unrestricted by such problems, so much more price competitive and with a more robust cash flow. So you will lose markets in other areas too, hitting your volume effect even more, possibly sending you spiraling.
So, it's definitely pop corn time.
It's good they are being transparent. This is the future. Does "produce" include staff salaries involved in manufacture? Does it include salaries for staff in R&D?
I think it's essentially if you had all the designs for a product and asked someone else to manufacture it for you, everything they would spend and charge you for producing the product and delivering it to your ship (or whatever), at which point you take over all the rest of the costs including the shipping.
As I mentioned elsewhere in this thread already, while the Librem 5 is becoming dated, there's still no upgrade path on the market. You need to switch to a completely different category of devices in order to get something more performant than that. I hope that'll change soon, regardless of whether it will be Purism coming up with L5v2 or someone else with their own thing.
It's fairly obvious that trade barriers are good and necessary for a country, not sure why we've allowed this to go on for so long. It's truly fascinating.
And both cases have investment in the OS/schematics which are open.
Taking just those figures in mind, they shouldn't be at all worried about tariffs - anything more than an 18% tariff, it's cheaper for them to build in the US than China for US customers. Honestly, that's much lower than I expected, especially considering they're even more restrictive in their component sourcing than most companies would need to be because they're catering to a security-focused group.
I guess the real issue is that they don't have any more production capacity in the US, rather than it just being a cost issue.