Especially when you gut the DoE and make zero effort to invest in either higher education or trades training.
If US wants a manufacturing revolution it needs to start with an education revolution.
A better way (IMO) to do it would have been tax incentives to build US plants to move manufacturing back in the US, have research university programs as feeders for tech innovation centers, and funding for technical colleges to expand their programs for skilled labor needed instead of gutting multiple agencies that would have overseen/guided this expansion. And oversight, of course. And attainable goals set in contracts to receive funding, not just, "here's a pile of money we'll forget about in 4 years."
In China they have the manufacturer down the street from the distributor who is down the street from your factory.
With Digikey we are paying $80 to overnight a $5 part from Minnesota. We need to be able to go send a guy to pick it up in an hour.
In China, you can just go down the street to the factory.
As for shipping overnight, it's incredibly common in R&D and repair.
The concept of having centralized full-chain production for enormous productivity boosts is not some wild concept, it's ancient and well known. Industries have clusters because it benefits everyone in the cluster. The US has very few and weak manufacturing clusters.
The article does, in fact. Their US made phone is manufactured, not just assembled, in the United States, and also attempts to source nearly all parts and materials from US suppliers as well.
They don't manufacture their important components. Not even Apple does that. No one does. There is roughly zero chance that any of the non-interchangable bits, the SoC, the battery or the screen, is manufactured in the US.
And there is nothing wrong with that. It's just silly to pretend otherwise.
If you're just thinking of price, the farther down the supply chain you go the less impact of tariffs.
If you're sincerely interested in the answer to that question, I'd highly recommend reading the article, because a good portion is dedicated specifically to answering that.
There is zero chance that a smartphone will ever be made out of 100% US-manufactured parts, or even close to it. And the evidence is right in this article, if this is the best effort to manufacture a "US phone."
Creating domestic jobs this way doesn't have a great track record however. They are usually quite expensive. And they don't help the geopolitical uncertainty at all, which is at least hinted at being something of an end goal.
Sure, you can ship parts all over the phone and have assembly in the final country. But what does that solve? What people usually think of when discussing where products are "produced", the components or at least a majority thereof, is the same.
Where do you source OLED screens in necessary quantity to produce a popular mobile phone model in the US, or any other Western country? Or the batteries? It's not a question of cost. It a question of non-existence.
Changing global production is a not a singular problem but something that would require laser focus during several decades and many different areas just to be something that could be taken seriously.