Here's an example: as I said in my original message, I was a complete stranger to the dotnet ecosystem, and I learned the F# language at the same time. And I decided to develop the app as a library project to be used by the web app. I completely missed the prevalence of the async approach in the dotnet, and all my code was synchronous. One day, about half-way in the project, I realised I needed to switch to async code. Had this happened in a dynamically typed project, it would have been hell for me. Maybe it's me that can't grasp a project well enough, but I need the type-guardrails to find my way in large refactorings. And with the strong types, large refactorings can be done confidently. They don't replace tests, but make the refactoring process much more smooth.
The app is open source and its code is at: https://gitlab.com/myowndb/myowndb It doesn't have a lot of users, not the least due to lack of marketing and polishing the user experience. But I am satisfied of what I learned developing it!
[0]: https://gleam.run/
Even if is slower, the runtime model is incredibly resilient and it’s cheap to scale up and down, easy to hot update, and generally does asynchronous work extremely well across a lot of different processes.
F# has really good async ergonomics but it doesn’t have the same task/processing flexibility and Websockets are kind of a pain compared to elixir or even erlang
[0] https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/aspnet/core/signalr/hubs?v...
[1] https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/products/signalr-service
In the past, I found it wonky
On the other hand, "strong typing" isn't as quite as standardized in type systems terminology, but broadly speaking, it tends to be used to describe things like how "sound" a type system is (which is a well-defined concept in type systems theory), whether or not implicit type coercions can occur in the language, or other things that roughly translate to whether or not its possible for things to get misused as the wrong type without an explicit error occurring. Two examples that are commonly cited are JavaScript[0], with its sometimes confusion implicit conversions to allow things like adding an empty object and an empty array and getting the number 0 as the result (but not if added in the other order!) and C, with it being possible to interpret a value as whatever the equivalent underlying bytes would represent in an arbitrary type depending on the context its used.
[0]: I normally don't like to link to videos, but this famous comedic talk demonstrating a few of these JavaScript quirks is so thoroughly entertaining to watch again every few years that I feel like it's worth it so that those who haven't seen it before get a chance: https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/wat
static typing: 2 + "2" does not compile/parse (e.g. Python vs mypy, Typescript vs JS)
this is a very simplistic example, but should get you to feel the difference.
I think this example is not correct, because static typing doesn’t affect how values of different types interact. And while I don’t know of any staticly typed language where specifically `2 + “2”` is a valid expression, statically typed languages definitely can be weakly typed: the most prominent example is C where one can combine values of different types without explicitly converting them to the same type (`2 + 2.0`).
I believe strong/weak and static/dynamic are orthogonal. And my examples are:
- Strong: `2 + “2”` is a error,
- Weak: `2 + “2”` makes 4 (or something else, see the language spec),
- Static: `var x = 2; x = “2”` is an error,
- Dynamic: `var x = 2; x = “2”` is fine.
But a dynamic language can have types associated with variables, and it can forbid changing those types after their types have been checked the first time.
So, like C++ with `auto`?
F# on the JVM would be great though!
One caveat though: it seems FP matches my way of thinking. As an example, I always liked recursion, while some others saw it as complexifying things.
Try fsharp as fsx scripts to avoid boilerplate (see blog post linked in other comment) and you'll rapidly feel if you like it or not.
Even intellij has no idea sometimes about what the hell is going on. It throws up compile errors when there none.
However, the best functional programming language is, of course, Elixir. :D
But they still miss the computation expressions, which open interesting possibilities like https://github.com/CaptnCodr/Fli and https://github.com/fsprojects/FsHttp
- Hot updates.
- Full distributed system support.
– Low-level process manipulation.
- Named processes.
- Advanced supervision strategies.
- Behaviours other than GenServer.
- Type-safe distributed messaging.
- And several other things that I value in BEAM and OTP.
I can't justify trading the full power of BEAM and OTP for static typing. To be fair, though, I've written a lot of code in both statically and dynamically typed languages, and static typing isn't something I value much (to the point that you might say I don't care about it at all :D).
Funny how preferences and priorities vary among devs, I need my static type system! :-) But note even in static type systems there are variations. I'm talking about an hindley milner type system with its type inference like the one in fsharp
(I am genuinely curious and not trying to be snarky.)
Is there something about that that has bothered you? Working in Scala codebases, I've found the best ones to work in are the ones that embrace Scala's multiparadigm nature. When programmers try to solve every problem with OO, they end up adding more and more layers to get the job done. When programmers try to solve every problem with FP, they end up resorting to sophisticated techniques that are unapproachable for other engineers. I think the simple parts of OO and the simple parts of FP go much, much further together than simple OO or simple FP can go by themselves. Have you seen something different?
it is functional (value) programming first. there are tools to hook in the object jvm stuff but this is not the natural grain of the language.
clojure is pretty much all values and functions (and some macroes).
+ some concurrency stuff
there is no class, there is no inheritance, you don't even have information hiding (no private etc.). you have protocols and multimethods.
(well technically there is private because java but it is not obvious to use and not what you expect, you will very rarely see that in clojure codebases)
honestly it is a nice small yet powerful language, with not too many kludges. my personal coding is either clojure or rust (which has way more kludges, but better than the other stuff in the typed fast compiled world at least for me).
Having used Haskell in production for a bit now, I don't even notice its purity. Most functions are in some kind of I/O context making it similar as other languages, except with the option of running without I/O capabilities for functions that shouldn't need it.
Another thing that was hard to grasp for me were the special operators like =<<, ., $, etc. I was using Xmonad, but those operators create a barrier to understanding exactly what happened in the file.
In the end, F# was in my (personal) experience much more approachable, and it let me learn the functional concepts along the way.
A few years ago on here I had an interesting conversation with someone who wasn't going to use rescript for something because they didn't like how it handled object types. I can't remember ever using an object type in rescript; we all just convert js objects to record type in the extern binding. But that's not information easily available to someone who has never used the language.
Same thing here I think. If you don't already have familiarity with this paradigm, it's hard to imagine what using an IO monad for side effects is like. It's not easy to tell how hard it'll be to learn it, how much it may affect the rest of your code, etc. It's easy to imagine someone (shit even me a few years ago) going "eh I'll take the language with the big easy escape hatches just in case."
This is a good observation.
As someone who writes a lot of Lisp, I'm inclined to agree as the amount of people that have never written any Lisp yet immediately reject it over syntax over fears that it somehow hampers development is a (to me) surprisingly large number of people.
If I recall correctly, one of the motivating factors for Rescript was to reduce the perceived/real distance between Reason and JS in order to attract more JS devs, as Reason was so heavily associated with OCaml.
These days I'd just do such a task more-or-less imperatively in Haskell, and I would be well guided by the types in doing so. But I also feel like you have to make a few such mistakes if you want to get a good intuition and taste for when it's good do things purely and when imperatively.
Even so the complexity here and the sheer number of mind bending concepts makes me not want to use it.
Being a stranger to Microsoft technologies, F# was the least likely to be chosen, but easily became the first choice. Haskell's purity made it hard to adopt (for me), Ocaml's ecosystem is subpar (there wasn't even a clear choice for a library to interact with postgresql, I couldn't install the latest version due to its reliance on an obscure tool whose name I forgot and didn't get help on the forum), and Scala is seems complex....
F# was surprisingly easy to get started with. The community is mis-managed by a corporate-minded approach (requiring people to become member of the F# software foundation to get access to the official slack!), but its members are friendly, smart and ready to help. The ecosystem is great with access to all the dotnet libraries (some complain there's a mismatch as most of those are developed for use with C#, but I rarely got in trouble for using them).
There are also great libs and frameworks available. Like https://github.com/SchlenkR/FsHttp to easily interact with http servers, to the point that I find it easier to use than a dedicated library. Or https://github.com/CaptnCodr/Fli , to run commands. And last but not least, https://www.websharper.com/ is the best web framework I have encountered across all ecosystems. Their reactive approach to web ui really allows me to develop complex interfaces in a maintainable way.
This became a longer message than I thought, probably due to my enthousiasm for the language. For complete transparency, the situation is not perfect, and in my experience the tooling is not the best.
If you want more info, I blogged about it a couple of months ago: https://www.asfaload.com/blog/consider-fsharp/