News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by jxjnskkzxxhx on Friday March 28, 2025 @10:02AM (#43505562)
It makes my blood boil that my kid comes from the nursery saying things like "I did an ouchie". Kids don't naturally speak like this, they are taught like this. He's 3. At home he speaks his parents languages and he sounds like a 5 year old because we don't dumb it down for him. In English he sounds like every other English 3 year old in the nursery.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by ikanreed on Friday March 28, 2025 @10:11AM (#43505651)
And preschool teachers talk this way because they're desperately afraid of hurting parents' feelings
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by uoaei on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:18AM (#43506532)
Please don't inflame these otherwise reasonable comment sections with low effort culture war rhetoric.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by bongodongobob on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:34PM (#43507346)
It's true though. Talk to any teacher or childcare provider.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by uoaei on Friday March 28, 2025 @04:19PM (#43509482)
I'm not denying the phenomenon exists. But to try to say that adults would be upset if teachers spoke to their children like they weren't developmentally challenged is completely ridiculous.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by DiggyJohnson on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:01PM (#43507680)
How does this have anything to do with the culture war? This is just a discussion of culture and how its changing unrelated to what you are referring to.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by uoaei on Friday March 28, 2025 @04:20PM (#43509489)
Do you even understand the argument being made by the person I was replying to?
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by andrepd on Friday March 28, 2025 @10:48AM (#43506114)
I really think baby talk is a phenomenon that pre-dates helicopter parenting
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by bombcar on Friday March 28, 2025 @10:56AM (#43506246)
Baby Todd is a real phenomenon caused by kids not being able to say complex words. You want to say those complex words to them and they will repeat them back and they may make a baby version of it which is fine but it’s good to for you to keep using the complex words and the correct pronunciation so they learn.

Every one of my kids has a name that is hard for a baby to pronounce so they have a baby nickname, but we let them grow out of it.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by phatfish on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:01PM (#43507677)
I blame Ms Rachel.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by dismalaf on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:35AM (#43506740)
As someone who has a 2.5 year old learning multiple languages, I think a problem with English is that it's very verbose; we use full sentences to express things that can be expressed in other languages with only 1-2 words. And of course shorter sentences are easier for children as there's less grammar to be learned.

And specifically for expressing you hurt yourself, we teach children to express that they're hurt far earlier than they learn actual speech. So from ~1 we teach them to say "Ow" (or some variation), but then the words change from that to "hurt", and into a full sentence "I hurt myself", which is also redundant (myself and I imply the same thing, so why do we use both in that sentence in English?).

Anyhow just a thought as I'm feeding my son breakfast. "Would you like some breakfast" in English turns into 2 words in his second language.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by deadbabe on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:06PM (#43507082)
I don’t get it, you can’t just ask “want breakfast?”
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by dismalaf on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:24PM (#43507257)
You can and you do but it sounds "babyish". That's my point. Whereas in some other languages it's idiomatic.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by thfuran on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:54PM (#43507569)
"Would you like some breakfast" isn't quite so overly wordy that I'd say it sounds unnatural, but it absolutely is not the bare minimum for idiomatic English.

"Do you want breakfast?" is perfectly grammatical, and "Want breakfast?" would be a totally normal phrasing, even if some might argue that eliding the subject isn't technically correct.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by Izkata on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:30PM (#43508587)
There's even the in-between "You want breakfast?" that relies on the tonal shift at the end of the sentence used for questions.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by dgfitz on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:44PM (#43507463)
I think you’re overthinking it. I’ve been talking to my kids like they’re just normal people since they were born.

“Oh how old are they, 5? Nope, just turned 3. They speak so well!” shrug

The second language must be biasing you somehow, it’s not hard to talk to your kids.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by dismalaf on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:49PM (#43508748)
It's not about how I talk to my kid; he's picking up 2 languages just fine (trying a third but I'll admit I'm slacking a little on that one).

It's about the perception of how children speak in English.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by dgfitz on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:30PM (#43510527)
> The second language must be biasing you somehow
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by bongodongobob on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:36PM (#43507373)
No it doesn't. I don't ask my colleague "Would you care to go to the bar and drink a beer after work?" I say "Grab a beer later?" As does every other normal person I know. "Get lunch?" Etc.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by deadbabe on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:03PM (#43507713)
Even “Lunch?” is enough with someone you know well.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by elgenie on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:02PM (#43507697)
Your understanding of how formality levels in English function is perhaps not entirely complete: native speakers of English convey usually convey the sentiment with as little as "Breakfast?" or "Hungry?" when talking with family. In the child's second language, would the maitre'd at the restaurant of a fine hotel ask a two word question, or rather bury those in respectful filler?

"Ow" and friends, by the way, are interjections to express sudden pain, functioning analogously to an adult's swearing. They're not full sentences about the pain and its source.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by dismalaf on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:45PM (#43508722)
> Your understanding of how formality levels in English function is perhaps not entirely complete: native speakers of English convey usually convey

It's kind of hilarious that you assume I'm not a native English speaker because I speak more languages... I'm a native English speaker who just happens to have grown up with 2 other languages and have a wife that speaks 4+ languages. On top of that I've taken a bunch of university level English courses.

Yes, I'm aware that people shorten sentences into statements when speaking to those they're familiar with. I do it as well.

Here's a thought experiment:

- If a toddler speaks in short statements it's "baby talk"

- If an immigrant speaks in short statements it's "broken English"

- If a native speaker speaks in short statements it's vernacular or slang

Or:

- If a toddler makes up words it's "baby talk"

- If an immigrant makes up words they're uneducated

- If a native speaker makes up words it's a dialect

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by elgenie on Friday March 28, 2025 @04:58PM (#43509758)
Most of those incorrectly use the linguistic terminology (in particular, "dialect", "baby talk", "slang") but, yes, congratulations on discovering that context plays a role in communication.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by dismalaf on Friday March 28, 2025 @05:52PM (#43510188)
Ah so you want to be snarky to try assert intellectual superiority but actually have nothing to say. Gotcha.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by watwut on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:23AM (#43506588)
It is just a different sound for the same thing. There is nothing dumber about "I did an ouchie" then "I got hurt". Ouchie is more infantile, but not stupider.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by sorcerer-mar on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:37AM (#43506760)
"I did [a noun]" is 'stupider', i.e. not grammatically correct English, i.e. a formulation that people will look down on you for using as you age. Sometimes you have to teach children things they'll eventually have to unlearn, but this is not one of those occasions.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by dragonwriter on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:45AM (#43506845)
“I did [a noun]” is grammatically correct English object-verb-direct-object sentence structure.

Depending on the noun, it may not the most idiomatic way of expressing the sentiment it intends to communicate, but that is a different issue. (On the other hand, idiom is context dependent, and the objection here seems to be that it is idiomatic in at least one context, but that people prefer that children exclusively learn some other preferred idiom. But if you don't have this diversity, children don't get to learn and practice context switching as early, and that's an important skill, too.)

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by carom on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:07PM (#43507102)
>“I did [a noun]” is grammatically correct English object-verb-direct-object sentence structure.

I'm going to need some examples here because I'm filling in nouns to that structure and it does not sound correct. "I did [a] water." Huh?

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by RandallBrown on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:38PM (#43507394)
I did a dance.

I did a presentation.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by sorcerer-mar on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:01PM (#43507678)
So things that people do, of which "ouchies" is not
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by RandallBrown on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:27PM (#43508557)
Why can't you do an ouchie? It sounds weird, but I also know exactly what it means.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by sorcerer-mar on Friday March 28, 2025 @03:15PM (#43509001)
Feel free to teach your child whatever you’d like, language is totally fungible.

The reason I’d suggest not to is because speaking in this way will, in fact, cause people to think less highly of you.

It’s not a matter of principle and “formal correctness” is pretty meaningless in human language, but “don’t speak in a way that a substantial number of people regard as incorrect” is a meaningful goal!

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by watwut on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:11PM (#43510365)
I would argue that people who think less of a three or five years old because the kid said "I did an ouchie" are simultaneously irrelevant and frankly dumb themselves. Kids life wont be affected at all.

Your claim is really based on fairly absurd notion that a sentence normally used in relation to the kids will somehow set the kid apart from their peers ... who listen to the exact same sentences. As in, the problem of kids speech somehow damaging kids long term is literally non existent in real world.

Miniscule percentage of parents takes offense on it and nobody else cares.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by sorcerer-mar on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:17PM (#43510417)
Obviously we’re talking about kids acquiring language, I.e. should the response be to nudge them toward more accepted language as they develop, or make up silly overintellectualized arguments like “hmm, well I can understand what they mean! [insightful face emoji]”

“Aww cute!” responses to incorrect language is how kids develop speech impediments.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by stonemetal12 on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:44PM (#43507451)
"I did a runner" British idiom means I ran away without paying. The only problem with "I did a water" is I don't know what "a water" is without context. If person A said "I did a shot" and person B said "I did a water", it would make perfect sense.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by thfuran on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:02PM (#43507686)
I can't offhand think of a case where that construction is appropriate for a noun that isn't a nominalized verb.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by quesera on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:55PM (#43507588)
I did art. I did postgrad. I did work(n). I did dishes. I did Paris. I did the walls, but hired someone who did the roof.

Not idiomatic for all nouns, esp those for which there's a more applicable verb.

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by sorcerer-mar on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:33PM (#43507341)
Please provide examples
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by losvedir on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:55PM (#43507592)
Off the top of my head:

* I did a puzzle.

* I did a bad thing.

* I did a backflip.

Or, since this is just normal English, it's exactly the kind of thing that ChatGPT is good at, so here's a dozen more examples if you want: https://chatgpt.com/share/67e6d457-5ff4-8002-a5c7-15040f3d22... .

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by sorcerer-mar on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:00PM (#43507665)
Ah yes, "I did a [thing that a person performs or does]" is valid.

Is "an ouchie" a thing that someone performs or does?

Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by thanatropism on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:19PM (#43510432)
"1;
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests by zdragnar on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:37AM (#43506761)
Well, it is grammatically wrong.