Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
by dismalaf on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:24PM
(#43507257)
You can and you do but it sounds "babyish". That's my point. Whereas in some other languages it's idiomatic.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
by thfuran on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:54PM
(#43507569)
"Would you like some breakfast" isn't quite so overly wordy that I'd say it sounds unnatural, but it absolutely is not the bare minimum for idiomatic English.
"Do you want breakfast?" is perfectly grammatical, and "Want breakfast?" would be a totally normal phrasing, even if some might argue that eliding the subject isn't technically correct.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
by Izkata on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:30PM
(#43508587)
There's even the in-between "You want breakfast?" that relies on the tonal shift at the end of the sentence used for questions.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
by dgfitz on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:44PM
(#43507463)
I think you’re overthinking it. I’ve been talking to my kids like they’re just normal people since they were born.
“Oh how old are they, 5? Nope, just turned 3. They speak so well!” shrug
The second language must be biasing you somehow, it’s not hard to talk to your kids.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
by dismalaf on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:49PM
(#43508748)
It's not about how I talk to my kid; he's picking up 2 languages just fine (trying a third but I'll admit I'm slacking a little on that one).
It's about the perception of how children speak in English.
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
by dgfitz on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:30PM
(#43510527)
> The second language must be biasing you somehow
Re:Preschoolers can reason better than we think, study suggests
by bongodongobob on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:36PM
(#43507373)
No it doesn't. I don't ask my colleague "Would you care to go to the bar and drink a beer after work?" I say "Grab a beer later?" As does every other normal person I know. "Get lunch?" Etc.