News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by johndhi on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:24AM (#43411627)
One thing I'm confused by is that we need to do "reporting" to figure out what the truth is here. Can't we just ask the astronauts, or NASA, or something? Why is there no official statement on the matter?

There's actually a video of Butch, from the station, saying Musk's description was "entirely factual" - although he then sort of backtracked that. Seems like no one wants to outright explain what happened.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:37AM (#43411807)
Yeah, "no one wants to outright explain what happened" is called "chilling effects" and is one of the explicit goals of an authoritarian regime like the one we have in the US now.

Nobody wants to get fired and get death threats just for speaking plainly, so most people don't. Every once in awhile someone will decide it's worth the cost, but most people most of the time will decide it isn't.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:45AM (#43411913)
> authoritarian regime

There was an election. Someone won. Someone lost. HN is not a place for baseless conspiracy theories. You’ve been here long enough to know better.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:34AM (#43412541)
"Authoritarian" is a philosophy of how to govern. It is orthogonal to whether the government was fairly elected.

(It's true that many authoritarian regimes seek to eliminate or corrupt elections, but being fairly elected is compatible with being authoritarian.)

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:50AM (#43413591)
"authoritarian regime" implies the governnent was not fairly elected and I think you probably know that.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by ttw44 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:20PM (#43414793)
I'm not sure if he's arguing that they were not fairly elected.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:55PM (#43417242)
I'm definitely not! That was a weird leap by your parent commenter that has nothing to do with what I said.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by 1shooner on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:43PM (#43415099)
This is an interesting misconception, I had never considered one would think authoritarians can't be fairly elected. Is the thinking that the electorate would just never elect an authoritarian?
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:58PM (#43415317)
The term was 'authoritarian regime', which is generally used for autocratic leaders.

Although 'authoritarian' is also false - political freedoms for the general population are exactly where they were prior to the election, as I'm sure you are aware.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by 1shooner on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:25PM (#43416890)
I guess I'm not nearly as sure of what others are aware of, so I'll just provide https://www.project2025.observer as a great resource for tracking actions of the current administration.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:42PM (#43417106)
Project 2025 is a project from the Heritage foundation, there was a conspiracy during the election to say this was the platform of the Republican Party, the GOP platform is Agenda 47.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:50PM (#43417188)
Dude, you really need to take the partisan blinders off.

They are actively, and extremely obviously, executing on the Project 2025 plan, which they wrote up for exactly this reason. This is primarily being driven by Russell Vought, whose plan this is, through his role at the head of the Office of Management and Budget. There was no "conspiracy" about this, there was only a candidate who brazenly lied about his connection to that plan.

Stop trying to gaslight us. We're not idiots, it won't work.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:36PM (#43417972)
Yes there is, the idea that Project 2025 was the GOP platform is provably false. You can read Agenda 47 yourself on the GOP website. The false allegation relies on the fact that very few people will know to do that.

As you believe Vought is conspiring - you have stated this yourself, the only gaslighting is pretending you have not - and presumably that publishing Agenda 47 was also a conspiracy to hide a secret alternative platform, provide evidence of the conspiracy.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:00PM (#43418572)
Look, if someone writes up "here's what our party's candidate is gonna do when we win the presidency", and then that party's candidate wins the presidency, hires the person who wrote that up to be the budgetary gatekeeper for the administration, and proceeds to do all the stuff that they wrote up, then that was the plan.

If the candidate said "that isn't the plan!", then they were just lying about that.

This isn't some wild coincidence. Vought isn't "conspiring", he's just straightforwardly executing what the plan was all along.

The Republican party and its candidate just lied about what the platform was. That happens, politicians and their parties lie.

But what I won't abide is people who lie to me about what is obviously happening in the present, which I can easily see with my own eyes. That is what you're doing here. It's just propaganda. It just makes you a liar.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:46PM (#43417143)
To your first sentence, again, I really think you just have these definitional questions wrong. You seem to be using a vibes-based reading of "authoritarian regime" rather than a "what the words mean" based reading.

To your second paragraph: I'm not going to go into a bunch of examples of things the administration has done, though it would not be hard to do. I'll just reiterate that the thing this thread was originally about is the chilling effect that threats and intimidation has on people's speech. That is just an indirect way to infringe on the right to free expression.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by MostlyStable on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @02:04PM (#43415374)
Elections are one way of selecting government officials. Authoritarianism is a political philosophy that can be pursued no matter how one was selected. Yes, many/most authoritarians arise either not in democracies, or else in situations where the elections are mostly/entirely a sham, but that is not a requirement.

You could, at least in principle, have an authoritarian surveillance state where the government watches and controls everything you do...and the people could consistently (and freely!) be electing the officials enacting that state. In other words, authoritarian and democracy/election are not antonyms.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @02:31PM (#43415669)
you are not responding to the point about the phrase “authoritarian regime“ which was the term used.

Nevertheless, either possible assertion - that this is a single-party regime akin to Iraq or North Korea, or that the government is authoritarian, is both incredibly bold and evidently false.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by MostlyStable on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:03PM (#43416052)
"regime" just means government. You are taking common associations and turning them into hard and fast rules when they aren't. "Biden regime" was a completely accurate (and frequently used) description of the last administration (and almost every other preceding administration).

As for your second sentence, while it is often dramatically overstated, I think that Trump having authoritarian tendencies is pretty obviously true. The extent to which he has successfully instantiated those tendencies is up for considerable debate. I think the answer is probably not "not at all".

In case it needs to be said, I think that almost every modern presidency has, (to quite varying extents) had some amount of authoritarian tendencies, in the sense that they have all sought to increase the unchecked power of the executive branch at the expense of both the other two branches, and the rights of the populace. I think Trump would, were he able, pretty dramatically extend this trend, but he won't have started it, and it remains to be seen how much farther he succeeds at going than other recent presidents.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:34PM (#43416382)
> You are taking common associations and turning them into hard and fast rules when they aren't.

No, "authoritarian regime" has a common meaning. Common meanings exist, it is silly to pretend they do not.

This might help: https://www.google.com/search?q=examples+of+authoritarian+re...

Here's Britannica:

> The most notable authoritarian regimes of the 20th century were characterized by a charismatic leader, a mass party, and a powerful secret police force. Regimes that use state institutions to brainwash and completely control their populations are categorized as totalitarian. Totalitarian regimes aim to instill in their citizens an undying loyalty to the regime and its leader. Children are indoctrinated from a young age, learning about the heroics of their leaders and the superiority of the regime’s guiding ideology. No dissent is tolerated, and all of the opposition is either exiled, killed, or imprisoned. Political trust is low, as citizens are encouraged to spy on each other and to serve as informants for the regime.

https://www.britannica.com/topic/authoritarianism

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:55PM (#43417237)
Nothing you pasted here suggests that those attributes are required for the definition of "authoritarian regime", it is just a characterization of "the most notable authoritarian regimes" as it itself says in the text.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:44PM (#43418031)
The most notable examples of ‘authoritarian regimes’ all being dictatorships absolutely establishes that is what the term commonly means.

I think probably 90% of the people in this thread arguing otherwise speak English natively and are thus already aware of this, they just dislike being contradicted.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:55PM (#43418536)
You're right that most people in this thread are likely native english speakers, but that just means that we can understand that the weird narrow read of the words "authoritarian regime" is silly and, based on other comments you've made, very likely just you being purposely obtuse for partisan reasons.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:22PM (#43418711)
I’m not sure why you feel the need to respond to me on multiple threads. As mentioned elsewhere, I am not the source of the common meaning of the term, I do not edit the encyclopaedia, the newspapers, take the photos or anything else you will see on the front page of Google when you search for “authoritarian regime”.

You know what an authoritarian regime commonly means, and you know what you were trying to do, and you just don’t like being called on it. Someone is indeed using HN for partisan advocacy and we both know it’s you.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:07PM (#43419579)
Because you're responding about different things in different threads, so I'm responding to those responses.

You're just wrong about the common meaning of the term, and you seem to think that just asserting the same thing over and over is somehow going to make you right about it, but it won't. And I'll keep pointing out that you're wrong about it as long as you keep repeating the same thing.

I'm not being partisan. You're not being partisan in this thread either, you're just repeating this silly assertion about what "authoritarian regime" means. So I'm continuing to rebut that.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:18AM (#43421409)
Every result you see in Google is an accurate reflection of how the terminator is commonly meant, you are wrong and you know you are wrong.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:54PM (#43418895)
> I am not the source of the common meaning of the term,

The accuracy of your claim regarding common meaning is being disputed. You might notice that well over half of the quote you pasted from Britannica is referring to totalitarian, not authoritarian, regimes.

Nowhere does it say anything like "the term authoritarian regime is commonly taken to imply".

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:30AM (#43421476)
As mentioned, the most notable examples all conform to the common definition as does every other result on the front page of Google for the term. You are welcome to dispute all of them if you want to, but I’m not going to spend time on it.

You are using hyperbole at best and simply lying at worst and you know this. You can jump on any English language search engine, discover what the common meaning of the term ‘authoritarian regime’ is and reflect which behaviour you’re involved in.

Bing produces a very nice summary for the term which also doesn’t describe the US government. You can read that and argue with it if you like.

Here’s Oxford, also from the front page of bing:

https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/41327/chapter/3523271...

> Authoritarian regimes must be distinguished from “authoritarianism,” which is a significantly broader concept

Which accurately reflects the OP attempting to reduce what they wrote earlier :

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43412541

and also this person:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43416052

I’m not spending any more time on this thread. Pigs, mud.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by fc417fc802 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @08:28PM (#43430618)
I don't think the way you're approaching this is in keeping with HN guidelines.

You seem to have jumped straight from "everyone agrees with my view" to "the people who disagree with me are acting in bad faith", skipping the much more likely "other people hold views that differ from my own".

As a native English speaker who lives in the US I don't need to check a search engine to understand the common meaning of the term. Sometimes people have different impressions of these things. About the only thing you could attempt to argue is that I'm in the extreme minority. I don't think you'd get very far with that though because it's unlikely that you have the evidence to back up such a claim.

For all your apparent outrage the Oxford example that you cited is the closest you've come to presenting valid evidence in support of your position. However if you examine the paragraph just above your quote you will see that it is rather academic in nature. Having glanced at it I can't say that the description presented matches what I encounter in common usage by laymen. (I include myself in that category. I am by no means a political scientist or remotely well studied.)

More generally, I think you've picked a fundamentally unwinnable position here. All it takes for me to be correct (and you to be demonstrably in the wrong) is for people in the area where I live to commonly use the terminology in the way I'm describing. And indeed they do, because I'm in a fairly far left part of the country.

Now you can certainly object that the population at large where I live is misusing the term. But without a central governing body for the language that's going to be extremely difficult to argue. Either way it won't change common usage here. It's simply the difference between "commonly used in that manner" versus "commonly used in that manner, incorrectly".

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:51PM (#43417206)
Nobody in this thread has said "this is a single-party regime akin to Iraq or North Korea".
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:43PM (#43418022)
No, they used the term ‘authoritarian regime’ which commonly means this. See the references I have posted elsewhere in this thread.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:56PM (#43418539)
It doesn't though. You are the only one who has brought up these other countries.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:21PM (#43418702)
I am not Encyclopaedia Brittanica.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:08PM (#43419583)
No, you're just the person misrepresenting what it says.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:19AM (#43421412)
I’m quoting it. There’s not much I could possibly do to misrepresent it, and as I’ve mentioned, I don’t control every other result on Google which is also entirely similar.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:23PM (#43416268)
This is simply incorrect.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by MiiMe19 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @02:57PM (#43415999)
>authoritarian is when the government does thing I don't like
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by AcerbicZero on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:36PM (#43417025)
Look as long as they keep being this salty about authoritarianism when a guy with a different letter next to his name shows up and does it, I'm fine with it.

My concern is that many won't.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:57PM (#43417249)
Funny how all the replies to me are pure defensiveness about the word "authoritarian", rather than the point of my post (the chilling effects on speech).
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by winrid on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:44PM (#43418828)
Biden signed 162 executive orders.

Is Trump somehow different here?

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by justsid on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:08PM (#43418977)
Without any value judgement on the actual orders, Trump signed 89 since taking office this year. Biden signed 77 in his first year in office. There certainly seems to be a difference unless this is comin to a stop relatively quickly.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:03PM (#43419562)
Yes.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by winrid on Thursday March 20, 2025 @02:48AM (#43420365)
How?
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:29AM (#43423035)
In many ways that you can easily find information on in other more appropriate venues.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by winrid on Friday March 21, 2025 @06:54PM (#43441596)
If it's not appropriate here don't bring it up.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Friday March 21, 2025 @09:03PM (#43442365)
I brought up something different.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by campl3r on Thursday March 20, 2025 @04:17AM (#43420777)
Is this just rage bait or a serious question? If it's the latter please explain how you see these two the same. The numbers don't match.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by winrid on Friday March 21, 2025 @06:53PM (#43441591)
Executive orders in general are pretty authoritarian IMO.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by philwelch on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:12AM (#43424505)
Yes, because it’s actually him signing the executive order and not the autopen.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by johndhi on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:11AM (#43423784)
Part of the irony here is that Elon Musk himself seems to be "speaking plainly" and receiving death threats for doing so. But I assume you'd prefer he didn't speak plainly...?
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by wcfields on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:57AM (#43424331)
I mean, if someone is saying plainly "I'm going to ruin your life and critically endanger your health." then one should expect some pushback.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by johndhi on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:59AM (#43424357)
"Pushback" being death threats, yes?

In what ways is Elon ruining lives and critically endangering health?

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Thursday March 20, 2025 @01:48PM (#43426464)
Oh this is an easy one! Ruining lives by firing lots of people while destroying the economy, and endangering health by doing things like eliminating Ebola prevention funding and totally screwing up the NIH health research structure.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Thursday March 20, 2025 @01:42PM (#43426370)
Funny how the richest person in the world feels less of a chilling effect than career staff at federal agencies!

What makes you think I'd prefer that he not speak plainly?

I'd certainly prefer that he:

1. Not break a bunch of laws while running the government (while having a totally unclear official role?).

2. Not use his control of twitter's algorithm to push his own political priorities.

3. Not use his wealth and bully pulpit to intimidate people (like judges) who don't just bow to whatever he wants.

But beyond that, I have absolutely no issue with him speaking plainly. And I think death threats are bad, always.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by johndhi on Thursday March 20, 2025 @08:12PM (#43430536)
Thanks for clarifying. I totally understand that you would feel that way and have those preferences.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by n4r9 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:16PM (#43429647)
I guess it depends how you define "plainly". Musk is right at the forefront of spreading exaggerated or misleading claims. Condoms to Gaza, Power's 30M, tens of millions of dead people receiving social security. He's not new to it either - remember him alleging that the scuba diver who saved those Thai kids was a paedophile?
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by enragedcacti on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:44AM (#43411894)
The need for reporting on this stems from the massive blatant lies coming from the admin backed up by the media parroting the narrative. From NASA on Aug 7, 2024:

> Wilmore and Williams will continue their work formally as part of the Expedition 71/72 crew through February 2025. They will fly home aboard a Dragon spacecraft with two other crew members assigned to the agency’s SpaceX Crew-9 mission. Starliner is expected to depart from the space station and make a safe, controlled autonomous re-entry and landing in early September.

The only change in plan was that Crew 10 was pushed back by a month because of delays at SpaceX and a swap to an existing dragon rather than the new one as planned.

> There's actually a video of Butch, from the station, saying Musk's description was "entirely factual"

His entire career hinges on keeping musk and trump happy

https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-decides-to-bring-star...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Crew-10

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by _cs2017_ on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:01PM (#43416030)
The fault in the Starliner was known in June 2024 (https://www.space.com/nasa-boeing-starliner-crew-flight-test...). By August 2024, NASA said that the crew would stay until Feb 2025. That was not the original plan like you claim. See also: https://www.reuters.com/technology/space/nasa-astronauts-hea....
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by enragedcacti on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:36PM (#43417965)
It's mind-numbingly obvious from context that the plan I was referring to was the rescue plan announced in August, not the starliner mission as a whole.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by _cs2017_ on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:47PM (#43418846)
I see. So the timeline was:

1 Ship broken and delay announced until 2025

2 Musk offers his ship for return before 2025

3 Offer not accepted,

4 Pro-Musk claims the refusal was for political reasons, anti-Musk crowd claims it's not for political reasons but simply to comply with the original plan

Is that correct? If so, both groups agree with your comment, right?

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by peeters on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:25AM (#43412442)
When you have a President that fires, deports, sues, and calls for the impeachment of anyone who challenges him, why on Earth (pun intended) would you take the word of someone whose life is in his hands at face value?

Get on the ground, then tell the truth. The moment Trump politicized those astronauts they became political hostages.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by russdill on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:08PM (#43416116)
NASA answered a number of direct questions on this during the crew-10 pressers. So they were asked directly. The problem is the Musk claim is that he took the offer directly to the White House, bypassing NASA. From the crew-10 pressers, NASA was completely unaware.

I'd read the Butch quote very carefully:

I can only say that Mr. Musk, what he says, is absolutely factual. We have no information on that, though, whatsoever; what was offered, what was not offered; who it was offered to, how that process went. That's information that we simply don't have. So I believe him. I don't know all those details, and I don't think any of us really can give you the answer that maybe that you would be hoping for.

He makes it absolutely clear that he can't answer the question because he doesn't have any of the information. But he believes Musk and that what Musk says is "Absolutely factual".

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by iNic on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:11AM (#43421362)
NASA is adhering to not biting the hand that feeds it, since they can no longer build their own rockets.