News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by MostlyStable on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @02:04PM (#43415374)
Elections are one way of selecting government officials. Authoritarianism is a political philosophy that can be pursued no matter how one was selected. Yes, many/most authoritarians arise either not in democracies, or else in situations where the elections are mostly/entirely a sham, but that is not a requirement.

You could, at least in principle, have an authoritarian surveillance state where the government watches and controls everything you do...and the people could consistently (and freely!) be electing the officials enacting that state. In other words, authoritarian and democracy/election are not antonyms.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @02:31PM (#43415669)
you are not responding to the point about the phrase “authoritarian regime“ which was the term used.

Nevertheless, either possible assertion - that this is a single-party regime akin to Iraq or North Korea, or that the government is authoritarian, is both incredibly bold and evidently false.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by MostlyStable on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:03PM (#43416052)
"regime" just means government. You are taking common associations and turning them into hard and fast rules when they aren't. "Biden regime" was a completely accurate (and frequently used) description of the last administration (and almost every other preceding administration).

As for your second sentence, while it is often dramatically overstated, I think that Trump having authoritarian tendencies is pretty obviously true. The extent to which he has successfully instantiated those tendencies is up for considerable debate. I think the answer is probably not "not at all".

In case it needs to be said, I think that almost every modern presidency has, (to quite varying extents) had some amount of authoritarian tendencies, in the sense that they have all sought to increase the unchecked power of the executive branch at the expense of both the other two branches, and the rights of the populace. I think Trump would, were he able, pretty dramatically extend this trend, but he won't have started it, and it remains to be seen how much farther he succeeds at going than other recent presidents.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @03:34PM (#43416382)
> You are taking common associations and turning them into hard and fast rules when they aren't.

No, "authoritarian regime" has a common meaning. Common meanings exist, it is silly to pretend they do not.

This might help: https://www.google.com/search?q=examples+of+authoritarian+re...

Here's Britannica:

> The most notable authoritarian regimes of the 20th century were characterized by a charismatic leader, a mass party, and a powerful secret police force. Regimes that use state institutions to brainwash and completely control their populations are categorized as totalitarian. Totalitarian regimes aim to instill in their citizens an undying loyalty to the regime and its leader. Children are indoctrinated from a young age, learning about the heroics of their leaders and the superiority of the regime’s guiding ideology. No dissent is tolerated, and all of the opposition is either exiled, killed, or imprisoned. Political trust is low, as citizens are encouraged to spy on each other and to serve as informants for the regime.

https://www.britannica.com/topic/authoritarianism

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:55PM (#43417237)
Nothing you pasted here suggests that those attributes are required for the definition of "authoritarian regime", it is just a characterization of "the most notable authoritarian regimes" as it itself says in the text.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:44PM (#43418031)
The most notable examples of ‘authoritarian regimes’ all being dictatorships absolutely establishes that is what the term commonly means.

I think probably 90% of the people in this thread arguing otherwise speak English natively and are thus already aware of this, they just dislike being contradicted.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:55PM (#43418536)
You're right that most people in this thread are likely native english speakers, but that just means that we can understand that the weird narrow read of the words "authoritarian regime" is silly and, based on other comments you've made, very likely just you being purposely obtuse for partisan reasons.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:22PM (#43418711)
I’m not sure why you feel the need to respond to me on multiple threads. As mentioned elsewhere, I am not the source of the common meaning of the term, I do not edit the encyclopaedia, the newspapers, take the photos or anything else you will see on the front page of Google when you search for “authoritarian regime”.

You know what an authoritarian regime commonly means, and you know what you were trying to do, and you just don’t like being called on it. Someone is indeed using HN for partisan advocacy and we both know it’s you.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:07PM (#43419579)
Because you're responding about different things in different threads, so I'm responding to those responses.

You're just wrong about the common meaning of the term, and you seem to think that just asserting the same thing over and over is somehow going to make you right about it, but it won't. And I'll keep pointing out that you're wrong about it as long as you keep repeating the same thing.

I'm not being partisan. You're not being partisan in this thread either, you're just repeating this silly assertion about what "authoritarian regime" means. So I'm continuing to rebut that.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:18AM (#43421409)
Every result you see in Google is an accurate reflection of how the terminator is commonly meant, you are wrong and you know you are wrong.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by fc417fc802 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:54PM (#43418895)
> I am not the source of the common meaning of the term,

The accuracy of your claim regarding common meaning is being disputed. You might notice that well over half of the quote you pasted from Britannica is referring to totalitarian, not authoritarian, regimes.

Nowhere does it say anything like "the term authoritarian regime is commonly taken to imply".

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:30AM (#43421476)
As mentioned, the most notable examples all conform to the common definition as does every other result on the front page of Google for the term. You are welcome to dispute all of them if you want to, but I’m not going to spend time on it.

You are using hyperbole at best and simply lying at worst and you know this. You can jump on any English language search engine, discover what the common meaning of the term ‘authoritarian regime’ is and reflect which behaviour you’re involved in.

Bing produces a very nice summary for the term which also doesn’t describe the US government. You can read that and argue with it if you like.

Here’s Oxford, also from the front page of bing:

https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/41327/chapter/3523271...

> Authoritarian regimes must be distinguished from “authoritarianism,” which is a significantly broader concept

Which accurately reflects the OP attempting to reduce what they wrote earlier :

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43412541

and also this person:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43416052

I’m not spending any more time on this thread. Pigs, mud.

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by fc417fc802 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @08:28PM (#43430618)
I don't think the way you're approaching this is in keeping with HN guidelines.

You seem to have jumped straight from "everyone agrees with my view" to "the people who disagree with me are acting in bad faith", skipping the much more likely "other people hold views that differ from my own".

As a native English speaker who lives in the US I don't need to check a search engine to understand the common meaning of the term. Sometimes people have different impressions of these things. About the only thing you could attempt to argue is that I'm in the extreme minority. I don't think you'd get very far with that though because it's unlikely that you have the evidence to back up such a claim.

For all your apparent outrage the Oxford example that you cited is the closest you've come to presenting valid evidence in support of your position. However if you examine the paragraph just above your quote you will see that it is rather academic in nature. Having glanced at it I can't say that the description presented matches what I encounter in common usage by laymen. (I include myself in that category. I am by no means a political scientist or remotely well studied.)

More generally, I think you've picked a fundamentally unwinnable position here. All it takes for me to be correct (and you to be demonstrably in the wrong) is for people in the area where I live to commonly use the terminology in the way I'm describing. And indeed they do, because I'm in a fairly far left part of the country.

Now you can certainly object that the population at large where I live is misusing the term. But without a central governing body for the language that's going to be extremely difficult to argue. Either way it won't change common usage here. It's simply the difference between "commonly used in that manner" versus "commonly used in that manner, incorrectly".

Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:51PM (#43417206)
Nobody in this thread has said "this is a single-party regime akin to Iraq or North Korea".
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:43PM (#43418022)
No, they used the term ‘authoritarian regime’ which commonly means this. See the references I have posted elsewhere in this thread.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:56PM (#43418539)
It doesn't though. You are the only one who has brought up these other countries.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:21PM (#43418702)
I am not Encyclopaedia Brittanica.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by sanderjd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:08PM (#43419583)
No, you're just the person misrepresenting what it says.
Re:Crew-9 Returns to Earth by nailer on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:19AM (#43421412)
I’m quoting it. There’s not much I could possibly do to misrepresent it, and as I’ve mentioned, I don’t control every other result on Google which is also entirely similar.