News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by cm2187 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:37AM (#43351335)
It's going to be interesting to see the AI generation arriving in the workplace, ie kids who grew up with ChatGPT, and have never learned to find something in a source document themselves. Not even just about coding, about any other knowledge.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by motorest on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:57AM (#43351432)
> It's going to be interesting to see the AI generation arriving in the workplace, ie kids who grew up with ChatGPT, and have never learned to find something in a source document themselves.

I am from the generation whose only options on the table were RTFM and/or read the source code. Your blend of comment was also directed at the likes of Google and StackOverflow. Apparently SO is not a problem anymore, but chatbots are.

I welcome chatbots. They greatly simplify research tasks. We are no longer bound to stake/poorly written docs.

I think we have a lot of old timers ramping up on their version of "I walked 10 miles to school uphill both ways". Not a good look. We old timers need to do better.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by usrbinbash on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:18AM (#43351542)
> Your blend of comment was also directed at the likes of Google and StackOverflow.

No, it wasn't.

What such comments were directed at, and with good reason, where 'SO-"Coders"', aka. people when faced with any problem, just googled a vague description of it, copypasted the code from the highest scoring SO answer into their project, and called it a day.

SO is a valueable resource. AI Systems are a valueable resource. I use both every day, same as I almost always have one screen dedicated to some documentation page.

The problem is not using the tools available. The problem is relying 100% on these tools, with no skill or care of ones own.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by jstummbillig on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:24AM (#43351580)
But skill will be needed. It's everything that is still necessary between nothing and (good) software existing. It will just rapidly be something that we are not used to, and the rate of change will be challenging, specially for those with specialized, hard earned skills and knowledge that become irrelevant.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by strken on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:56AM (#43351724)
Yes, they were, for reasons that have turned out to be half-right and half-wrong. At least by some people. Ctrl-c ctrl-v programming was widely derided, but people were also worried about a general inability to RTFM.

I had the good fortune to work with a man who convinced me to go read the spec of some of the programming languages I used. I'm told this was reasonably common in the days of yore, but I've only rarely worked on a team with someone else who does it.

Reading a spec or manual helps me understand the language and aids with navigating the text later when I use it as documentation. That said, if all the other programmers can do their jobs anyway, is it really so awful for them to learn from StackOverflow and Google? Probably not.

I imagine the same is true of LLMs.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by jon-wood on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:30AM (#43351909)
I also try to read the specification or manual for tools I use, and find the biggest benefit is simply knowing what that tool is capable of, and what the recommended approach to a given problem is when using that tool. Even just skimming the modules available in a language's standard library can get you a long way.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by Tainnor on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:21AM (#43352193)
I was once able to significantly reduce the effort for some feature just by reading the elasticsearch docs and finding that there was a feature (aliases) that did more or less exactly what we needed (it still needed some custom code, but much less than initially thought). Nobody else had bothered to look at the docs in detail.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by johnisgood on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:20AM (#43351561)
I agree. Claude is very useful to me because I know what I am doing and I know what I want it to do. Additionally, I keep telling my friend who is studying data science to use LLMs to his advantage. He could learn a lot and be productive.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by motorest on Thursday March 13, 2025 @08:56AM (#43352824)
> SO is a valueable resource.

Chatbots like Copilot, Cursor, Mistral, etc serve the same purpose that StackOverflow does. They do a far better job at it, too.

> The problem is not using the tools available. The problem is relying 100% on these tools, with no skill or care of ones own.

Nonsense. The same blend of criticism was at one point directed at IDEs and autocompletion. The common thread is ladder-pullers complaining how the new generation doesn't use the ladders they've used.

I repeat: we old timers need to do better.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by ookblah on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:27AM (#43351602)
at risk of sounding like a grandpa this is nothing like SO. AI is just a tool for sure, one that "can" behave like an super enhanced SO and Google, but for the first time ever it can actually write for you and not just piddly lines but entire codebases.

i think that represents a huge paradigm shift that we need to contend with. it isn't just "better" research. and i say this as someone who welcomes all of this that has come.

IMO the skill gap just widens exponentially now. you will either have the competent developers who use these tools accelerate their learning and/or output some X factor, and on the other hand you will have literally garbage being created or people who just figure out they can now expend 1/10 the effort and time to do something and just coast, never bother to even understand what they wrote.

just encountered that with some interviews where people can now scaffold something up in record time but can't be bothered to refine it because they don't know how. (ex. you have someone prompting to create some component and it does it in a minute. if you request a tweak, because they don't understand it they just keep trying re-prompt and micromanage the LLM to get the right output when it should only take another minute for someone experienced.)

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by nkrisc on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:41AM (#43352306)
> ex. you have someone prompting to create some component and it does it in a minute. if you request a tweak, because they don't understand it they just keep trying re-prompt and micromanage the LLM to get the right output when it should only take another minute for someone experienced.

This is it. You will have real developers, as you do today, and developers who are only capable of creating what the latest AI model is capable of creating. They’re just a meat interface for the AI.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by vaylian on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:53AM (#43351707)
> this is nothing like SO

Strong agree. There have been people who blindly copied answers from Stack Overflow without understanding the code, but most of us took the time to read the explanations that accompanied the answers.

While you can ask the AI to give you additional explanations, these explanations might be hallucinations and no one will tell you. On SO other people can point out that an answer or a comment is wrong.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by motorest on Friday March 14, 2025 @02:31AM (#43360118)
> Strong agree. There have been people who blindly copied answers from Stack Overflow without understanding the code, but most of us took the time to read the explanations that accompanied the answers.

Are you sure? Because chatbots are used exactly like SO, with the exception of usecases like a) using as glorified template and refactoring engines, b) explain existing codebases, c) automatically add unit tests and context-based documentation. Just open SO and check any random question: how to get a framework to do something, how to configure something, why something worked like this or like that, why did a code block had a bug, etc.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by TiredOfLife on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:46AM (#43352001)
> this is nothing like SO

Agree. Ai answers actually work and are less out of date

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by motorest on Friday March 14, 2025 @02:35AM (#43360136)
> Agree. Ai answers actually work and are less out of date

Jokes aside, I feel this is really the case. Chatbots have the exact same usecases, but as their response time is measured in seconds instead of days and the responses reflects the context from that moment, this opens the door for more interactive experience and more iterations over the same output.

I feel this anger towards LLMs comes from gatekeepers who felt slighted by having to spend so much effort to reach positions where people with chatbots take instances, and as they can no longer close gates or pull ladders they start to bitch and whine against LLMs. It's as simple as that.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by nerdponx on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:11AM (#43351508)
> Your blend of comment was also directed at the likes of Google and StackOverflow. Apparently SO is not a problem anymore

And it kind of was a problem. There was an underclass of people who simply could not get anything done if it wasn't already done for them in a Stackoverflow answer or a blog post or (more recently and bafflingly) a Youtube video. These people never learned to read a manual and spent their days flailing around wondering why programming seemed so hard for them.

Now with AI there will be more of these people, and they will make it farther in their careers before their lack of ability will be noticeable by hiring managers.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by stereolambda on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:09AM (#43352127)
I would even say there's a type of comment along the lines of "we've been adding Roentgens for decades, surely adding some more will be fine so stop complaining".

As a second-order effect, I think there's a decline in expected docs quality (of course depends on the area). Libraries and such don't expect people to read through them, so they are spotty and haphazard, with only some random things mentioned. No wider overviews and explanations, and somewhat rightly so, why try to write it if (nearly) no one will read it. So only tutorials and Q&A sites remain besides of API dumps.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by eMPee584 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:40AM (#43351966)
.. for the brief period of time before machines will take care of the whole production cycle.

Which is a great opportunity btw to drive forward a transition to a post-monetary, non-commercial post-scarcity open-source open-access commons economy.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by opan on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:03AM (#43351460)
The issues I see are that private chats are information blackholes whereas public stuff like SO can show up in a search and help more than just the original asker (can also be easily referenced / shared). Also the fact that these chatbots are wrong / make stuff up a lot.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by fowlie on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:37AM (#43351635)
Are you saying that black holes don't share any information? xD
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by andyferris on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:07AM (#43351485)
I had never thought about that - I guess the privacy cuts both ways.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:28AM (#43351607)
That's not really a problem with LLMs, which are trained on material that is, or was, otherwise accessible on the Internet, and they themselves remain accessible.

No, the problem is created and perpetuated by people defaulting to building communities around Discord servers or closed WhatsApp groups. Those are true information black holes.

And yes, privacy and commons are in opposition. There is a balance to be had. IMHO, in the past few years, we've overcorrected way too much in the privacy direction.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by K0balt on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:59AM (#43352069)
Unfortunately though it isn’t actually privacy in most cases. It’s just a walled garden where the visibility is limited to users and some big tech goons who eventually will sell it all.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by block_dagger on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:20AM (#43351559)
LLMs are trained on public data though.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by ncruces on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:57AM (#43352390)
Only if for as long as public data continues to exist.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by maxbaines on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:05AM (#43351771)
Less and less now actually. Synthetic data is now being used on most new models as the public data runs out.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by sevenseacat on Friday March 14, 2025 @07:15AM (#43361478)
I'm sorry, are you suggesting that AIs are being trained on AI-generated data?

What can possibly go wrong?!?

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by megadata on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:31AM (#43352238)
SO was never a problem. Low effort questions were. "This doesn't work, why?" followed by 300 lines of code.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by javcasas on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:12AM (#43352150)
We old timers read the source code, which is a good proxy for what runs on the computer. From that, we construct a mental model of how it works. It is not "walking uphill 10 miles both ways". It is "understanding what the code actually does vs what it is supposed to do".

So far, AI cannot do that. But it can pretend to, very convincingly.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:19AM (#43351553)
I think it's unwise to naively copy code from either stack overflow or an AI, but if I had to choose, I'd pick the one that had been peer-reviewed by other humans every time.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by eMPee584 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:41AM (#43351968)
Ooh, the quality of "review" on SO also varies a whole lot..
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:55AM (#43352382)
Sure, I was more thinking of the original intent, and the early-days quality, than the current state of it. But I'd still take some review over none!
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:07AM (#43351486)
Oh, heck. We didn’t need AI to do that. That’s been happening forever.

It’s not just bad optics; it’s destructive. It discourages folks from learning.

AI is just another tool. There’s folks that sneer at you if you use an IDE, a GUI, a WYSIWYG editor, or a symbolic debugger.

They aren’t always boomers, either. As a high school dropout, with a GED, I’ve been looking up noses, my entire life. Often, from folks much younger than me.

It’s really about basic human personal insecurity, and we all have that, to some degree. Getting around it, is a big part of growing up, so a lot of older folks are actually a lot less likely to pull that crap than you might think.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by dijksterhuis on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:42AM (#43351660)
> We are no longer bound to stake/poorly written docs.

from what i gather, the training data often contains those same poorly written docs and often a lot of poorly written public code examples, so… YMMV with this statement as it is often fruit from the same tree.

(to me LLMs are just a different interface to the same data, with some additional issues thrown in, which is why i don’t care for them).

> I think we have a lot of old timers ramping up on their version of "I walked 10 miles to school uphill both ways". Not a good look. We old timers need to do better.

it’s a question of trust for me. with great power (new tools) comes great responsibility — and juniors ain’t always learned enough about being responsible yet.

i had a guy i was doing arma game dev with recently. he would use chatgpt and i would always warn him about not blindly trusting the output. he knew it, but i would remind him anyway. several of his early PRs had obvious issues that were just chatgpt not understanding the code at all. i’d point them out at review, he’d fix them and beat himself up for it (and i’d explain to him it’s fine don’t beat yourself up, remember next time blah blah).

he was honest about it. he and i were both aware he was very new to coding. he wanted to learn. he wanted to be a “coder”. he learned to mostly use chatgpt as an expensive interface for the arma3 docs site. that kind of person using the tools i have no problem with. he was honest and upfront about it, but also wanted to learn the craft.

conversely, i had a guy in a coffee shop recently claim to want to learn how to be a dev. but after an hour of talking with him it became increasingly clear he wanted me to write everything for him.

that kind of short sighted/short term gain dishonesty seems to be the new-age copy/pasting answers from SO. i do not trust coffee shop guy. i would not trust any PR from him until he demonstrates that he can be trusted (if we were working together, which we won’t be).

so, i get your point about doom and gloom naysaying. but there’s a reason for the naysaying from my perspective. and it comes down whether i can trust individuals to be honest about their work and how they got there and being willing to learn, or whether they just want to skip to end.

essentially, it’s the same copy/pasting directly from SO problem that came before (and we’re all guilty of).

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by breakfastduck on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:34AM (#43352257)
And they were right. People who just blindly copy and paste code from SO are absolutely useless when it comes to handling real world problems, bugs etc.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by aprilthird2021 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @08:29AM (#43352600)
> Apparently SO is not a problem anymore, but chatbots are.

I think the same tendency of some programmers to just script kiddie their way out of problems using SO answers without understanding the issue will be exacerbated by the proliferation of AI which is much more convincing about wrong answers.

It's not a binary. You don't have to hate or welcome chatbots, no in between. We all use them, but we all also worry about the negatives, same with SO.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by croes on Thursday March 13, 2025 @08:30AM (#43352615)
SO and Google are still a problem especially they are one of the sources of LLMs.

So now we can get wrong code but written in a more confident language.

If you are lucky it’s a hallucination and the error is obvious.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by aleph_minus_one on Thursday March 13, 2025 @10:01AM (#43353453)
> So now we can get wrong code but written in a more confident language.

The lesson to learn is rather that also in "real life", you shouldn't trust confident people.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by croes on Thursday March 13, 2025 @12:58PM (#43355151)
Mean’s don’t trust AI
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by dagw on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:47AM (#43351379)
Apparently from what I've read, universities are already starting to see this. More and more students are incapable of acquiring knowledge from books. Once they reach a point where the information they need cannot be found in ChatGPT or YouTube videos they're stuck.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by thinkingemote on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:02AM (#43351456)
I wonder if Google Gemini is trained on all the millions of books that were scanned and that Google were not able to be used for their original purposes?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Books

As other AI companies argue, copyright doesn't apply when training, it should give Google a huge advantage to be able to use all the worlds books they scanned.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by harvey9 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:52AM (#43351403)
Interesting if that's literally true since you have to _search_ YouTube, unless maybe people ask chatgpt what search terms to use.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by nerdponx on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:15AM (#43351525)
It's about putting together individual pieces of information to come up with an idea about something. You could get 5 books from the library and spend an afternoon skimming them, putting sticky notes on things that look interesting/relevant, or you could hope that some guy on Youtube has already done that for you and has a 7 minute video summarizing whatever it is you were supposed to be looking up.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by Inviz on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:18AM (#43351541)
I am unable to acquire knowledge from the books since 35 years ago. Had to get by with self-directed learning. The result is patchy understanding, but lot of faith in myself
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by roygbiv2 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:51AM (#43351397)
If AI can't find it, how do we?
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by pif on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:12AM (#43351511)
The actual intelligence in artificial intelligence is zero. Even idiots can do better than AI, if they want. Lazy idiots, on the other end...
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:57AM (#43352388)
We need to optimise for lazy though — lazy programmers are the best! Idiots, though, less so.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by immibis on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:48AM (#43352343)
We don't know what intelligence is, so we don't know that.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:36AM (#43351633)
"if they want" and "lazy" are the load-bearing phrases in your response. If we take them at face value, then it follows that:

1) There are no idiots who want to do better than AI, and/or

2) All idiots are lazy idiots.

The reason we're even discussing LLMs so much in the first place, is AI can and does things better than "idiots"; hell, it does things better than most people, period. Not everything in every context, but a lot of things in a lot of contexts.

Like run-of-the-mill short-form writing, for example. Letters, notices, copywriting, etc. And yes, it even codes better than general population.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by zekica on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:58AM (#43351438)
By using your brain and a web search engine / searchable book index in your library / time or even asking a question somewhere public?
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by roygbiv2 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:12AM (#43351512)
If it's been indexed by a Web search engine surely it's in a training dataset. The most popular Web search engines are the least efficient way of finding answers these days.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by wongarsu on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:46AM (#43351680)
But just because it's in the training set doesn't mean the model retains the knowledge. It acquires information that is frequently mentioned and random tidbits of everything else. The rest can be compensated with the 20 web searches models more get. That's great when you want a react dropdown, but for that detail that's mentioned in one Russian-speaking forum and can otherwise only be reduced by analysing the leaked Windows XP source code AI will continue to struggle for a bit.

Of course AI is incredibly useful both for reading foreign language forums and for analysing complex code bases for original research. AI is great for supercharging traditional research

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by buckyfuller on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:08AM (#43351492)
How does this make sense when you can put any book inside of an LLM?
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by ljm on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:29AM (#43351902)
Learning isn't just about rote memorisation of information but the continuous process of building your inquisitive skills.

An LLM isn't a mind reader so if you never learn how to seek the answers you're looking for, never curious enough to dig deeper, how would you ever break through the first wall you hit?

In that way the LLM is no different than searching Google back when it was good, or even going to a library.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by dagw on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:41AM (#43351969)
Just because you can put information into an LLM, doesn't mean you can get it out again.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by buckyfuller on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:07AM (#43388766)
retarded
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by Beretta_Vexee on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:14AM (#43351523)
I recently interviewed a candidate with a degree in computer science. He was unable to explain to me how he would have implemented the Fibonacci sequence without chatGPT.

We never got to the question of recursive or iterative methods.

The most worrying thing is that the LLM were not very useful three years ago when he started university. So the situation is not going to improve.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by IanCal on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:26AM (#43351594)
This is just the world of interviewing though, it was the same a decade ago.

The reason we ask people to do fizzbuzz is often just to weed out the shocking number of people who cannot code at all.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by brulard on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:22AM (#43351873)
Yep, I still can not understand how programmers unable to do fizzbuzz still have a sw engineer career. I have never worked with one like that, but I have seen so many of them on interviews.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by Beretta_Vexee on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:55AM (#43352049)
I have seen IT consulting and service companies employ ‘developers’ who are barely capable of using software to generate views in a banking software package and unable to write a line of Java (which was the language used on the project).

When the client knows absolutely nothing about it and is not supported by someone competent, they end up employing just anyone.

This applies to both construction, IT and probably everthing.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:59AM (#43352401)
Unless you're also a programmer, it's very difficult to judge someone else's programming ability. I've worked places where I was the only remotely-technical person there, and it would have been easy to fake it with enough confidence and few enough morals.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by jstummbillig on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:21AM (#43351566)
But it is. Some knowledge and questions are simply increasingly outdated. If the (correct) answer on how to implement Fibonacci is one LLM query away, then why bother knowing? Why should a modern day web developer be able to write assembly code, when that is simply abstracted away?

I think it will be a hot minute before nothing has to be known and all human knowledge is irrelevant, but, specially in CS, there is going to be a tremendous amount of rethinking to do, of what is actually important to know.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by Shorel on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:49AM (#43351692)
The answer on how to implement Fibonacci is so simple that it is used for coding interviews.

Any difficult problem will take the focus out of coding and into the problem itself.

See also fizz-buzz, which it is even simpler, and people still fail those interview questions.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by Beretta_Vexee on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:58AM (#43351731)
Not everyone does web dev. There are many jobs where it is necessary to have a vague idea of memory architecture.

LLM are very poor in areas such as real time and industrial automation, as there is very little data available for training.

Even if the LLM were good, we will always need someone to carry out tests, formal validation, etc.

Nobody want to get on a plane or in a car whose critical firmware has been written by an LLM and proofread by someone incapable of writing code (don't give ideas to Boeing ).

The question about Fibonacci is just a way of gently bringing up other topic.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by jstummbillig on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:32AM (#43352252)
My answer and example does not really care about the specifics.

I see nothing you mention here as something that a human inherently needs to concern themselves with, because none of these things are things that humans inherently care about. CS as a discipline is a layer between what humans want and how to make computers work to do these things. If todays devs are so far detached from dealing with 1s and 0s (which is not at all how it obviously had to develop) why would any of the other parts you mention be forever necessary given enough artificial intelligence?

Sure, it's fun (as a discipline) for some of us, but humans inherently do not care about computer memory or testing. A good enough AI will abstract it away, to the degree that it is possible. And, I believe, it will also do a better job than any human ever did, because we are actually really, really bad at these things.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by ghssds on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:39AM (#43351643)
Not outdated. If you know the answer on how to implement Fibonacci, you are doing it wrong. Inferring the answer from being told (or remembering) what is a Fibonacci number should be faster than asking an LLM or remembering it.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:50AM (#43351699)
> Inferring the answer from being told (or remembering) what is a Fibonacci number should be faster than asking an LLM or remembering it.

Really?

If I were to rank the knowledge relevant to this task in terms of importance, or relevance to programming in general, I'd rank "remembering what a Fibonacci number is" at the very bottom.

Sure, it's probably important in some areas of math I'm not that familiar with. But between the fields of math and hard sciences I am familiar with, and programming as a profession, by far the biggest (if not the only) importance of Fibonacci sequence is in its recursive definition, particularly as the default introductory example of recursive computation. That's all - unless you believe in the mystic magic of the Golden Ratio nonsense, but that's another discussion entirely.

Myself, I remember what the definition is, because I involuntarily memorize trivia like this, and obviously because of Fibonacci's salad joke. But I wouldn't begrudge anyone in tech for not having that definition on speed-dial for immediate recall.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by frotaur on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:06AM (#43351777)
I assume in an interview you can just ask for the definition. I don't think the interview is (should be) testing for your knowledge of the Fibonacci numbers, but rather your ability to recognize precisely the recursive definition and exploit it.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by lupusreal on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:16AM (#43351833)
Already knowing the Fibonacci sequence isn't relevant:

> He was unable to explain to me how he would have implemented the Fibonacci sequence without chatGPT.

An appropriate answer could have been "First, I look up what the Fibonacci sequence is on Wikipedia..." The interviewee failed to come up with anything other than the chatbot, e.g. failed to even ask the interviewer for the definition of the sequence, or come up with an explaination for how they could look it up themselves.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by asddubs on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:27AM (#43351603)
the point is that it's an easy problem that basically demonstrates you know how to write a loop (or recursion), not the sequence itself
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by immibis on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:49AM (#43352346)
Why should my data science team know what 1+1 is, when they can use a calculator? It's unfair to disqualify a data scientist just for not knowing what 1+1 is, right?
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by dherikb on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:17AM (#43351536)
Well, I found these candidates long before ChatGPT
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by iddan on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:18AM (#43351546)
I’m 10 years in software and was never bothered to remember how to implement it the efficient way and I know many programmers who don’t know even the inefficient way but kick ass.

I once got that question in an interview for a small startup and told the interviewer: with all due respect what does that have to do with the job I’m going to do and we moved on to the next question (still passed).

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by sarchertech on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:50AM (#43351698)
You don’t need to memorize how to compute a Fibonacci number. If you are a barely competent programmer, you should be capable of figuring it out once someone tells you the definition.

If someone tells you not to do it recursively, you should be able to figure that out too.

Interview nerves might get in your way, but it’s not a trick question you need to memorize.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by JaumeGreen on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:14AM (#43351824)
But I'm sure there would be some people that given the following question would not be able to produce any code by themselves:

"Let's implement a function to return us the Nth fibonnaci number.To get a fib (fibonacci) number you add the two previous numbers, so fib(N)=fib(N-1)+fib(N+2). The starting points are fib(0)=1 and fib(1)=1. Let's assume the N is never too big (no bigger than 20)."

And that's a problem if they can't solve it.

OTOH about 15 years ago I heard from a friend that interviewed candidates that some people couldn't even count all the instances of 'a' in a string. So in fact not much has changed, except that it's harder to spot these kind of people.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by dijksterhuis on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:51AM (#43351700)
i’m around 10 years as well and i can’t even remember how the fibonacci sequence progress off hand. I’d have to wikipedia it to even get started.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by lupusreal on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:22AM (#43351872)
There's nothing wrong with that. But once the interviewer tells you that the next number is the sum of the previous two, starting with 0 and 1, any programmer with a pulse should be good to go.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by protocolture on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:54AM (#43351715)
I interviewed a guy with a CCIE who couldnt detail what a port forward was. 3 years ago.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by genewitch on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:43AM (#43351664)
If some interviewer asked me what recursion was or how to implement it, I'd answer, and then ask them if they can think of a good use case for a duff's device.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday March 13, 2025 @08:03AM (#43352421)
That's a great question because there are 3 levels of answer: 1) I don't know what recursion is 2) This is what recursion is 3) This is what iteration is
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by dagw on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:51AM (#43352023)
Duff's device hasn't relevant for over 25+ years and there is no reason why anybody who learnt to program within the past 20 years should even know what it is, while recursion is still often the right answer.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by brulard on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:34AM (#43351933)
Why? It looks like a reasonable interview question.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by swat535 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @08:25AM (#43352575)
I suppose it depends on the position, but if your company is building CRUD apps with Postgres and you're asking candidates about Fibonacci, you're wasting both your time and, more importantly, the candidate's time.

Instead, you're better off focusing on relevant topics like SQL, testing, refactoring, and soft skills.

These "clever" questions are pointless. They either serve to stroke the interviewer’s ego: "Look, I know this CS 101 problem because I just looked it up!", or to create a false image of brilliance: "Everyone here can invert binary trees!"

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by brulard on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:00PM (#43356728)
I don't think the point of the question is "do you even know wha fibonacci sequence is?". If candidate didn't know what exactly it is, I have no problem with that. If I explained to him simply the nature of the sequence and he couldn't code it, I wouldn't expect him to be a worthy addition to the team. Recursion is everywhere, SQL, UI, refactoring, data processing, etc.

But I agree you can hire a shitty programmer, because his soft skills are amazing. I worked with people that wouldn't contribute much to the code, but created a culture and improved processes in the company. But you should be aware that you are not hiring for a coding position then.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by genewitch on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:21PM (#43356903)
> They either serve to stroke the interviewer’s ego

that's why i'd ask about duff's device. I often admit i am no programmer or developer, here on HN, and that's true. I've only ever implemented recursion when it's part of the pattern or when "learning" a language.

my understanding is that recursion is great for tight, small loops, where you need to do say 0<n<10 loops. But if you can't guarantee the tight loop every time, i.e., if it is a dynamic part of business logic or whatever, then you run the risk of blowing up the stack, or heap, or whatever it is. I don't remember which, and i could look it up; but my point is most developers don't need to know if the stack is at risk rather than the heap if your recursive call ends up being called a lot of times.

But i really would ask about duff's; me and a friend came up with a use for duff's device maybe 2005 or 2006, and tested it, and published it as part of a forum argument; but i am curious if anyone else could "come up with one" or "remember one" that isn't the "de-facto duff's device demonstration".

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by RGamma on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:45AM (#43351372)
Becoming the single point of failure for every societal function is the goal of VC. It's working brilliantly thus far.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by 946789987649 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:27AM (#43352223)
You could say the same about Google, where there's an entire generation who no longer needed to trawl through encyclopedias to find relevant information. I think we're doing just fine.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by cm2187 on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:38AM (#43352287)
Actually I did. Saw some kids just googling an exercise question instead of googling the topic. Trying to find the answer to the question while avoiding to understand the underlying topic.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by escapecharacter on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:29AM (#43351612)
They’ll just mumble something about the context window needing to be larger.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by arrowsmith on Thursday March 13, 2025 @04:56AM (#43351427)
Should we call them the “AI generation generation”?
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by adammacleod on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:00AM (#43351444)
I vote for GenAI
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by mcny on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:15AM (#43351529)
Is GenAI after gen alpha? I think it depends on whether agents become a thing. Assuming agents become a thing before the end of this decade, we could see a divide between people born before we had ai agents and after.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by globular-toast on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:18AM (#43351547)
I already consider reading to be a superpower. So few people seem capable these days. And we're talking about people born decades before ChatGPT.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by aa-jv on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:42AM (#43351657)
I think we already saw this manifestation a few decades ago, with kids who can't program without an IDE.

IDE's are fantastic tools - don't get me wrong - but if you can't navigate a file system, work to understand the harness involved in your build system, or discern the nature of your artefacts and how they are loaded and interact in your target system, you're not doing yourself any favours by having the IDE do all that work for you.

And now what we see is people who not only can't program without an IDE, but can't be productive without a plugin in that IDE, doing all the grep'ing and grok'ing for them.

There has been a concerted effort to make computers stupider for stupid users - this has had a chilling effect in the development world, as well. Folks, if you can't navigate a filesystem with confidence and discern the contents therein, you shouldn't be touching the IDE until you can.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by kasey_junk on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:21AM (#43351867)
I worked early in my career with a developer who printed out every part of the codebase to review and learn it. He viewed text search tools, file delineations, and folder structures as crutches best avoided.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by aa-jv on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:26AM (#43351892)
Yes indeed, that is a perfectly reasonable approach to take, especially in the world of computing where rigorous attention to detail is often rewarded with extraordinary results.

I have very early (and somewhat fond) memories of reviewing every single index card, every single hole in the punch-tape, every single mnemonic, to ensure there were no undiscovered side-effects.

However, there is a point where the directory structure is your friend, you have to trust your colleagues ability to understand the intent behind the structure, and you can leverage the structure to gain great results.

Always remember: software is a social construct, and is of no value until it is in the hands of someone else - who may, or may not, respect the value of understanding it...

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by silver_silver on Thursday March 13, 2025 @09:05AM (#43352896)
I have (older, but that generation) colleagues who simply stop working if there’s something wrong with the build process because they don’t understand it and can’t be bothered to learn. To be fair to them, the systems in question are massively over complicated and the project definitions themselves are the result of copy-paste engineering.

Unfortunately they also project their ignorance, so there’s massive pushback from more senior employees when anyone who does understand tries to untangle the mess and make it more robust.

The same thing will happen with these ML tools in the future, mark my words: writing code will come to be seen as “too complex and error prone” and barely working, massively inefficient and fragile generated code bases will be revered and protected with “don’t fix what isn’t broken”

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by HPsquared on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:48AM (#43351689)
Conversely, it's easier than ever to read said source material.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by belter on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:40AM (#43351650)
It is truly astonishing how bad things have become, so quickly. Just the other day, I found myself debating someone about a completely fabricated AWS API call.

His justification was that some AI had endorsed it as the correct method. There are already out there salaried professionals supporting such flawed logic.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by sam_goody on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:41AM (#43351971)
Kinda like the kids who only learned to drive with Waze.

When they are stuck without it, they get hopelessly lost. They feel strangled, distracted, and find it hard to focus on the road. For about 3 days. Then they pretty quickly get up to speed, and kinda remember where they used to make the left turns when they had GPS, and everything is dandy.

But it happens so infrequently, that it's really not worth the time thinking about it.

And the truth is, I am just guessing what happens after 3 days - since anyone who grew up with GPS will never be that long without it.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by mihaaly on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:35AM (#43351631)
Sounds like 'Daddyy! Do this for mee!' level.

Otherwise I recall an old saying: 'Robots will take the job of engineers as soon as being able to figure out and make what the client needs, not what the client asks. I think we are safe'. Along this, I hope AI becomes a good tool, subordinate, or maximum a colleague. But not a father figure for big infants.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by solumunus on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:06AM (#43351480)
Please elaborate on what you think the issues will be? Why read documentation when you can simply ask questions and get better contextualised answers faster? Whatever edge issues manifest they will be eclipsed by greater productivity.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by indeyets on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:58AM (#43351732)
Because learning improves your internal LLM which allows you to creatively solve tasks without using external ones. Additionally it is possible to fine tune your internal LLM for the tasks useful for your specific interests, the fun stuff. And external llms are too generalised
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by solumunus on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:45PM (#43373617)
I ask questions to AI and learn exactly what I need to learn. Perplexity gives me sources to verify or expand upon the answers. I’m getting better information and I’m getting it faster, what am I losing? I’ve experienced it both ways and I’m telling you without doubt that AI is enhancing my productivity significantly. It’s hard for me to believe that I’m an edge case.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by stavros on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:26AM (#43351588)
Because back in my day, we convinced ourselves that the effort was the goal, not the result.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 13, 2025 @07:36AM (#43352271)
It was also fun, though. Unfortunately, taking up programming as a career is a quick way to become disillusioned about what matters (or at least what you're being paid for).
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by aa-jv on Thursday March 13, 2025 @06:23AM (#43351881)
The issue is, glib understanding replaces actual application.

Its one thing to have the AI work through the materials and explain it.

Its another thing to have lost a lot of the background information required to sustain that explanation.

Greater productivity, is of course, a subjective measure. If that's all that matters, then being glib is perfectly acceptable. But, the value of that productivity may change in a different context - for example, I find it very difficult to go back to AI-generated code some months later, and understand it - unless I already took the time earlier to discern the details.

Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by solumunus on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:49PM (#43373648)
I guess context matters. I rarely use AI to generate code outside of the automatic suggestions my IDE gives me in my own coding style (my full time work is a code base almost entirely my own). What I use it for heavily is anything I previously used Google and documentation before, and in that context the AI solution is significantly better and it’s not even close.
Re:Cursor told me I should learn coding instead of asking it... by guardian5x on Thursday March 13, 2025 @05:15AM (#43351530)
People said that about the internet as well. These kids don't even find the right books in a library!