News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by SamPatt on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:04AM (#43342781)
>“Twenty or thirty years ago, the shipping industry made a major shift to natural gas, believing it was the fuel of the future. Now, we know it wasn’t the right step,” says Prousalidis.

This sentence confuses me. The shipping industry runs on natural gas? If so, why is there regret? My impression is that most systems using natural gas right now are in a good position.

What am I missing here?

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by iamthemonster on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:10AM (#43342851)
Liquefied Natural Gas was expected to be a lower-emission alternative fuel compared to bunker fuel.

The proportion of LNG fuelled cargo tankers out there right now is about 2% but for new orders, about 30% of them are LNG fuelled so that small percentage will grow rapidly.

However, for United States LNG in particular, the LNG production chain actually has very high emissions of methane. The industry has been fighting to keep that as unclear and unquantified as absolutely possible, and there's a good reason for that - when you take into account the methane emissions along the whole value chain from drilling through liquefaction, LNG's climate impact (in terms of global warming) is no better than coal. I'm sure it's beneficial compared to bunker fuel, but the climate benefit is much much slimmer than first believed.

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by dylan604 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:30AM (#43343049)
NASA has been showing methane leaks from satellites built for purpose.[0] I'll give you three guesses as to where the location of the leaks are located, but you'll only need one.

Better read the data now before it gets stricken from the record.

[0] https://www.nasa.gov/centers-and-facilities/jpl/methane-supe...

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by _aavaa_ on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @11:01AM (#43343999)
Except most emissions are not leaks. A leak implies an unintended or unwanted behaviour. But most emissions are from indented behaviour of the system. The equipment is. designed to vent to atmosphere as part of normal operation, and it’s not worth it for them to burn it until they have to pay for this pollution.
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by dylan604 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @11:13AM (#43344137)
I see you and I have a difference of what we consider a leak. You seem to only consider it a leak in the equipment being used. I consider it when humans punch a hole in the ground and the gas is released by that human activity.
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by lurk2 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @12:27PM (#43344904)
[flagged]
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by dylan604 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @12:37PM (#43345027)
I'm not being obtuse at all. That methane would not be leaking in these locations if humans did not attempt to extract it. Regardless if the leaks from faulty plumbing or just not making the hole the right way so the methane in the air is a direct result of that human activity, it is still methane leaking into the air
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by lurk2 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @01:20PM (#43345492)
No ordinary person would interpret your original comment this way. _aavaa_ was correct: "A leak implies an unintended or unwanted behaviour."

If producers are intentionally venting off the methane, it isn't leaking, it's being released.

> A leak is a way (usually an opening) for fluid to escape a container or fluid-containing system, such as a tank or a ship's hull, through which the contents of the container can escape or outside matter can enter the container. Leaks are usually unintended and therefore undesired.

https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leak

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by p1mrx on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @01:36PM (#43345691)
> I'll give you three guesses as to where the location of the leaks are located, but you'll only need one.

Were we supposed to guess New Mexico, Turkmenistan, and Iran, or am I missing something?

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by dredmorbius on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @02:11PM (#43346067)
Firstly, drilling / wellhead operations.

2nd 'graph of the linked article:

In the data EMIT has collected since being installed on the International Space Station in July, the science team has identified more than 50 “super-emitters” in Central Asia, the Middle East, and the Southwestern United States. Super-emitters are facilities, equipment, and other infrastructure, typically in the fossil-fuel, waste, or agriculture sectors, that emit methane at high rates.

<https://www.nasa.gov/centers-and-facilities/jpl/methane-supe...>

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by Telemakhos on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:17AM (#43342925)
> However, for United States LNG in particular, the LNG production chain actually has very high emissions of methane.

I thought LNG was methane. What am I missing here?

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by gwbas1c on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @10:21AM (#43343560)
Methane leaks. Unburnt methane has a global warming potential 28 times higher than CO2. (This is why landfills will burn methane buildup, even if they aren't using it to generate electricity or capturing it to resell.)
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by ethangk on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:18AM (#43342942)
I’d assume they’re talking about methane leaks throughout the supply chain
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by XorNot on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:20AM (#43342955)
No you've got the gist of it: the point is that numbers for CO2 emissions of LNG assume a leak-free supply chain.

That's not possible in practice: LNG leaks at almost every single step, and monitoring of it has been inconsistent and poorly implemented. Add in the significantly higher greenhouse effect of methane in the atmosphere, and you lose essentially all the potential benefits (not to mention the ultimate issue of continuing to add sequestered CO2 back into the atmosphere - it's still a fossil fuel).

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by Dylan16807 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @12:20PM (#43344836)
> LNG's climate impact (in terms of global warming) is no better than coal. I'm sure it's beneficial compared to bunker fuel,

Why are you sure of that?

Oils release an amount of CO2 that's midway between natural gas and coal. So unless bunker fuel is causing some other big release of greenhouse gasses, if natural gas is near coal then it's worse than bunker fuel.

On top of that, doesn't the sulfur pollution from bunker fuel have a cooling effect?

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by iamthemonster on Thursday March 13, 2025 @03:20AM (#43350997)
Hmm maybe I shouldn't be so sure of myself then. The comparison between LNG and coal that I was referencing was the comparison between coal and LNG's lifecycle emissions on the basis of like-for-like electricity generation (so it was slightly apples&oranges for me to say that).

I'd assumed that a main engine's efficiency with bunker fuel was awful and with LNG was much better, meaning LNG had emissions as a shipping fuel.

But I think taking into account the methane emissions of upstream production (which varies incredibly wildly depending on the production environment) LNG from most of the world (particularly the USA) will be a worse shipping fuel on a global warming basis than bunker fuel.

Thanks for picking that up.

The cooling effect of sulphur dioxide emissions (which make sulphates in the atmosphere) is a whole Pandora's box that I'm unqualified to open but yes, there's a significant cooling effect from the SO2 emissions of bunker fuel and the 2020 rules change on VLSFO dramatically slashed the shipping industry's SO2 emissions (noting that SO2 emissions have also been falling across the board, and shipping is only one component of that). https://ourworldindata.org/data-insights/sulfur-dioxide-emis...

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by sidewndr46 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:07AM (#43342815)
Almost all shipping by weight is done by burning bunker. By ship quantity, most ships probably actually just burn some variant of diesel. Some do run off natural gas.

If you read through industry journals, you can find some point in the late 80s where the industry journals were all reporting about how all ships would need to go back to burning coal soon. I'm pretty sure this was just a fantasy that shipbuilders paid the journals to push as it would mean the opportunity to sell lots of new ships.

I doubt the statement you quoted is grounded in any reality.

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by dredmorbius on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @11:59AM (#43344605)
I'd thought that several notable ships had been refitted to burn petrol, though I can't find the references I'd had in mind.

(I'd think that petrol itself would be a less desirable fuel for some of the same reasons as ammonia: it's heavier-than air, sinks, and burns rapidly or explodes when vapours combine with air.)

Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by xandrius on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @11:19AM (#43344193)
Natural gas, aka methane, has a big impact on climate change. Don't listen what the gas industry is trying to get everyone to believe, natural gas is as natural as petroil.
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by pjc50 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:11AM (#43342861)
The shipping industry only ever dipped slightly into natural gas. There are some CNG/LNG ferries around, but all the long haul stuff in international waters (which is basically lawless) uses bunker fuel.
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by looofooo0 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:09AM (#43342829)
Batteries are most likely the most feasible option for many applications soon.
Re:First Ammonia-Fueled Ship Hits a Snag by hannob on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:14AM (#43342902)
> What am I missing here?

Climate change. Maybe you've heard of it?

(And it turns out things with LNG ships are much worse than previously believed. They not only emit CO2 - a bit less than traditional bunker fuel, but not much - they also emit methane, and in no small quantities. The LNG industry likes to pretend that these emissions are small and neglegible, but whenever someone goes out and actually measures them, they are substantial.)