News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by droideqa on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:05PM (#43303521)
Anybody reading this might appreciate ‘Astounding’[0]:

“Astounding is the landmark account of the extraordinary partnership between four controversial writers—John W. Campbell, Isaac Asimov, Robert A. Heinlein, and L. Ron Hubbard—who set off a revolution in science fiction and forever changed our world. ”

[0]: https://www.amazon.com/Astounding-Campbell-Heinlein-Hubbard-...

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by righthand on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:51PM (#43303864)
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by Henchman21 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:17PM (#43304873)
I appreciate the non-Amazon links, thank you!
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by dcminter on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:18PM (#43304506)
Be warned, I found it a bit depressing though. Never meet your heroes they say...
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by ethbr1 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:46PM (#43304671)
I'm hazarding that a lot of the early scifi luminaries weren't the most well-adjusted humans?
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by pfdietz on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:49PM (#43304685)
Some were even worse. I threw out (not sold) all my Marion Zimmer Bradley books when I found out.

https://www.reddit.com/r/books/comments/aklqck/breendoggle_a...

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by mcswell on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:45PM (#43305995)
Campbell was a racist, and I believe bought into the theory that smokers smoked because their bodies were trying to prevent or fight off lung cancer. He also appeared to be a believer in psi. He attracted (and doubtless encouraged) authors who shared those beliefs. If you go back and read the stories from the 50s and 60s, the heroes were invariably heavy smokers, and many of the stories involved telepathy, telekinesis, etc. The role of women in the stories was usually secondary (and the boy got the girl in the end), although that was probably true of most scifi back then. I don't recall any stories in Analog where the hero was other than a white man.
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by sbierwagen on Sunday March 09, 2025 @12:01AM (#43306413)
>although that was probably true of most scifi back then

In 1950? That was true of all media, including novels written by women. Is Dagny Taggart the protagonist of Atlas Shrugged?

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by r0uv3n on Saturday March 08, 2025 @11:51PM (#43306353)
Arguably Bayta is the lead in The Mule maybe? But of course the basic plot was very much influenced by Campbell still
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by pdimitar on Sunday March 09, 2025 @04:30PM (#43313426)
One of the most refreshing things about this part of the Foundation books was that I couldn't quite figure out who was in fact the main character.

I too eventually concluded it was Bayta since she was the one who figured out who The Mule was but the other characters contributed quite a lot.

Plus it's my belief that it was the intent of Asimov that nobody is actually a main character -- not for long anyway; I mean, people just die at the very least -- because Seldon's plan is just that big.

But yeah, Bayta was a very likeable character. One of the very few female characters that I liked from Asimov.

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by fractallyte on Sunday March 09, 2025 @06:32AM (#43307843)
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by fractallyte on Sunday March 09, 2025 @06:40AM (#43307869)
Regarding „psi“: inexplicable stuff happens, and Campbell was one of the few who sought answers, rather than simply dismissing it.

I suspect almost everyone has their own experience of „It happened to me!“: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33295560

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by dmurray on Sunday March 09, 2025 @10:03AM (#43309129)
Asimov's Susan Calvin stories first appeared in Analog (when it was called Astounding, but already under Campbell).
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by swombat on Sunday March 09, 2025 @10:23AM (#43309239)
Granted, he did. At the same time, Asimov was well known to be a groper, and even wrote a satire book called "The sensuous dirty old man" which would probably have landed better as satire had he not been fairly well known in scifi circles to be in fact a dirty old man.

There were some decent scifi authors at the time - not least, Ursula K LeGuin.

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by dmurray on Sunday March 09, 2025 @02:47PM (#43312318)
Ok, but "had some authors who wouldn't pass a 2025 purity test" is moving the goalposts quite a lot from "never published anything that wasn't by a White man, about a White man".

Le Guin, while a great author, was 12 when the first Susan Calvin story was published, and wouldn't be published herself until 18 years later. So she wasn't exactly being overlooked at the time.

And if you really insist on some identity politics in your science fiction, you'd do well to remember that in 1941 Asimov wasn't a White man. He was Jewish, which while not as bad as being Black had some very real consequences in 1940s America, not least being subject to a university admissions quota.

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by southernplaces7 on Sunday March 09, 2025 @10:36AM (#43309347)
>Campbell was a racist

Back in the 50s? Most people of all kinds were, either implicitly or explicitly, even those who could have known and embraced better with a bit of context improvement.

Judging the people of the past by all the biases and ingrained assumptions of their time is myopic at best and a dumb path to disregarding a lot of wonderful knowledge too.

No human is free of at least some absurd ideas, it doesn't necessarily make the rest of what they create or say worth denigrating.

I'd hate to imagine all of us in the early 21st century only being mocked because of certain absurd things we surely take for granted as truths today.

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by mcswell on Sunday March 09, 2025 @01:50PM (#43311713)
No disagreement, and I was probably racist back then. I'm just agreeing with an earlier comment that some of the 1950s authors were not "well adjusted", because I now think of racism as a sin.
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by rectang on Sunday March 09, 2025 @07:52PM (#43315212)
I think we'll only reach an equilibrium on racism if and when we reach consensus that it's innate human nature to be prejudiced, and that what distinguishes us is whether we make an effort to counter our base impulses.

Let me join you in acknowledging that I have been racist before. (And I might be again, if I slip up.)

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by bigstrat2003 on Sunday March 09, 2025 @02:10PM (#43311936)
I definitely agree - it's better to focus on the good in people, rather than the flaws. People 75 years from now will think just as poorly of our values as people today do of the values in 1950. And the people of 1950 would no doubt have thought just as poorly of our values today!

The change of values throughout the years is not one of monotonically increasing moral rightness. Every age gets some things right, and some things wrong. So we should focus on the positive and not the negative, because that's what we would want done for us.

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by KerrAvon on Saturday March 08, 2025 @08:43PM (#43305370)
I found the the Hubbard sections most unpleasant, but I also knew the least about him.
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by dcminter on Sunday March 09, 2025 @08:17AM (#43308443)
I knew he was behind scientology, so I wasn't too surprised there. Heinlein wasn't completely unexpected (although his gullibility with Hubbard was). I was more thinking of Asimov turning out to be a serial groper.

I read a bio of John Wyndham shortly afterwards and I was so relieved that he seems to have been one of the good ones.

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by pdimitar on Sunday March 09, 2025 @04:40PM (#43313533)
Let me be crystal clear that I am NOT defending Asimov here; he used his fame and was aware that many of the women will not be believed if they spoke out -- and shamelessly took advantage of that.

Combine that with my strictly personal opinion that he could have taken much better care of his looks at least; a good barber and a dentist alone would have gone a long way so he looked a bit less unpleasant, not to mention he could have jogged once a month and still could have been in a better shape...

...but after reading stories about many other authors, well, Asimov looks like a saint in comparison.

Again, not defending the guy. And Heinlein's gullibility also starkly contrasts with his intelligent aura and writing style. Goes to show we all have blind spots, I suppose. A bro club and all that in their case, probably.

[sighs deeply]

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by rendaw on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:49PM (#43304688)
Asimov was controversial?
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by mperham on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:16PM (#43304870)
He was a known harasser at cons.
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by jimbob45 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @08:24PM (#43305289)
Nobody was saying this prior to the Foundation TV series coming out. It seems like marketing wanted to drum up some controversy for their series because the allegations would have required evidence from 40 years prior. Maybe it happened, maybe it didn’t, but definitively saying so either way makes it seem like you have an agenda.
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by Finnucane on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:19PM (#43305854)
Lol, Asimov's reputation for being, shall we say, physically inappropriate with women at SF conventions goes back, well, for literally as long as there have been conventions.
Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by zimpenfish on Sunday March 09, 2025 @05:28AM (#43307595)
> Nobody was saying this prior to the Foundation TV series coming out.

I knew about this back in the 90s. It's always been out there whenever Asimov is mentioned.

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by xhkkffbf on Sunday March 09, 2025 @11:13AM (#43309734)
It's written into the story line of some stories like the mystery solving ones.

But in the story lines, the affections seem very mutual. So I'm not sure it's fair to call him a "harasser". Dirty? Perhaps. Old man? Yes, that's chronological and it can't be denied.

Re:"Big 3" science fiction magazines including Asimov's and ... by KerrAvon on Saturday March 08, 2025 @08:41PM (#43305362)
His writings weren’t controversial, though, except to anti-science nuts.