News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 29athrowaway on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:36PM (#43154673)
Civ was completely changed after Civ 4.

The Normandy invasion in World war 2 was a "death stack".

Blitzkrieg style operations were death stacks too (e.g.: schwerpunkt)

And almost every major conflict involved a decisive battle with two death stacks on each side.

The game designers of Civ 5 decided to restrict forming death stacks and the new versions of the game still have this mechanic. This is the moment Civ became a completely different game. The last true Civ game was Civ 4.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jltsiren on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:17PM (#43154917)
Normandy was not a death stack. The actual landings involved 156k troops facing 50k troops over 80 km of coastline. That's maybe 2x as many troops as in a major ancient battle, stretched over a frontline 20x as long.

WW2 battles were physically large, often spread over hundreds of kilometers. When the main threat was artillery, dense concentrations of force made no sense.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by coryrc on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:41PM (#43155327)
How big do you think a single square in civ takes up? It's about 80 km wide[0].

And Normandy was multiple units moving against multiple defensive units occupying the same space. This is far better approximated by the original of many units in one spot moving into a singular space occupied by many other units, than the new method of singular units spread hundreds to thousands of miles apart.

[0] Post in thread 'How much area does a single tile cover in Civ?' https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/how-much-area-does-a-...

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jltsiren on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:03PM (#43155424)
It depends on the map. In the Civ 6 Europe map, the area where the Normandy landings took place was 3 tiles. You could have three units attacking in the initial wave against 1 defending unit, with various ranged units on both sides. At that point in the game, the units could be corps or armies, which would make the overall scale of fighting about right.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2025 @01:11AM (#43156293)
> How big do you think a single square in civ takes up?

On the largest map size in the last game to have squares at all (Civ 4), about 278km east-west if you assume that the cylindrical map has the same circumference as earth does at the equator. Smaller if you assume that the the map has the same surface area as the Earth instead of the same circumference. (The answer you linked is based on the hexes of a later civ game, but based on Earth’s land area.)

Later Civ games the answers are larger, since, as well as switching to hexes, the largest map size is smaller in each subsequent Civ iteration (5 is smaller than 4, 6 smaller than 5, and 7 uses the same sizes as 6 but cuts off the two largest.)

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by robbie-c on Monday February 24, 2025 @02:31AM (#43156744)
That’s one way to measure it, sure. Another way is that archers can shoot 2 tiles away.

Part of the abstraction of the game is that the map for cities and the map for units are at different scales (despite being the same map), and scales change depending on what year you’re in

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2025 @02:01PM (#43163434)
> That’s one way to measure it, sure. Another way is that archers can shoot 2 tiles away.

Well, if we are talking about games where the size of a square is a coherent question, they can only do that in Civ III; Civ 1/2 units have only attack/defense, units with weapons "better range" just goes into the attack/defense abstraction, whereas in Civ IV archery units get first strike, and artillery units damage city defenses, but, like all other units that can attack at all, they can attack only adjacent units. (Even the single use missile units in Civ 4 are just units with a lot of movement that are destroyed when they attack, not ones that have a "range" capability distinct from movement.)

Range units came back with Civ V, along with the introduction of hexes and the elimination of stacks.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by thaumasiotes on Monday February 24, 2025 @03:42AM (#43157158)
> Smaller if you assume that the the map has the same surface area as the Earth instead of the same circumference.

This would make no sense; the top and bottom of the map are always land that blocks you from going that way. If you assume that you're on a spherical Earth, you also need to assume that the regions around the north and south pole don't appear on the ingame map.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2025 @02:02PM (#43163455)
I agree that the assumption makes no sense, but the calculation offering an 80mi diameter elsewhere in the thread is, in fact, based on distributing the Earth's land area across the number of tiles in a (Civ 6 huge, IIRC) map, calculating the area of each tile based on that, and then calculating the distance across the tile based on the area.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jandrese on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:44AM (#43160153)
That might be an interesting mechanic. Allow unlimited stacking but make artillery pieces hit every unit in the tile. Civ kind of has that mechanic with nukes, but they have all sorts of other implications that make them impractical in most games.

Thinking about this some more it might be possible to make "doomstacks" that actually have some tactics.

Idea:

Unlimited stacking is allowed. Units are ordered in the stack based on melee attack power * current health. When stacks attack one another only one melee type unit and one ranged unit may attack any particular single unit on the other side. Both attackers and defenders work from the top down. If an attacker or defender destroys their unit then leftover attack power will be used against the next available unit, after all initial attacks have been completed, but that melee unit will take return damage based on the percentage of the attack they have remaining.

For example, side 1 has a stack with 3 warriors and 2 archers. Side 2 has 1 warrior and 4 archers.

    Initial attack:
    side 1 archer 1 vs. side 2 warrior 1: 40% damage to warrior
    side 2 archer 1 vs. side 1 warrior 1: 40% damage to warrior
    side 1 warrior 1 vs. side 2 warrior 1: 50% damage to warrior
    side 2 warrior 1 vs. side 1 warrior 1: 50% damage to warrior
    side 1 archer 2 vs. side 2 archer 2: 60% damage to archer
    side 2 archer 2 vs. side 1 warrior 1: 40% damage to warrior
    side 1 warrior 2 vs. side 2 archer 2: 40% damage to archer, 60% attack remaining
    side 2 archer 3 vs. side 1 warrior 3: 40% damage to warrior
    side 1 warrior 3 vs. side 2 archer 3: 100% damage to archer, 0% attack remaining
    side 2 archer 4 can not make it to the battle lines and does not take an action

    Followup attacks:
    side 1 warrior 2 vs. side 2 warrior 1: 3% damage to warrior (10% health, 60% attack), takes 3% damage in return
The idea with the followup attacks is that it prevents someone from building an "army" out of a lot of cheap units just to roadblock strong units. By limiting battlefront size you still need to split your stacks to flank enemies or even attack on multiple fronts. Ranged units would be very vulnerable to melee, and artillery would be mostly strong against cities but would do damage to everything in the stack. Units inside of cities or fortresses would be protected against artillery and take very little damage.

I think this could be an interesting way to do combat, but it is relatively complicated and the AI would probably be even worse at managing it.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2025 @05:49PM (#43165885)
> That might be an interesting mechanic. Allow unlimited stacking but make artillery pieces hit every unit in the tile. C

Congratulations, you have basically invented Civ 4's collateral damage mechanic.

> Thinking about this some more it might be possible to make "doomstacks" that actually have some tactics.

Yes, it is. For one more fully developed example, see

https://civilization.fandom.com/wiki/Combat_(Civ4)

(They have a different solution to modeling ranged capability -- in addition to the collateral damage effect of artillery, it includes the First Strike ability of archery and certain other units.)

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jldugger on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:56PM (#43154794)
> The Normandy invasion in World war 2 was a "death stack".

It's clear to me that the designers wanted to include flanking as a mechanic, and other positioning elements of warfare (ranged attacks, zone of control, etc) thus stacks of doom had to go.

If you want to be pedantic about it, Normandy was 5 separate beaches in a 50 mile stretch, and involved paratroopers behind the beachfront ahead of time. And the game does model concentration of power to some degree, in the form of armies and corps.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jncfhnb on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:49PM (#43154748)
The problem isn’t really the existence of death stacks so much as the fact that the map is too zoomed out for _any_ tactical nuance. This creates extremely unrealistic game-y mechanics when you have two opposing stacks of 50 guys and one guy moves right while the other guy jukes and runs into a city that’s not defended.

I actually love Humankind’s approach where you have a fairly chunky stack and the stack gets spread out over the map into individual units during combat where you do some short term tactics that pulls in all surrounding units as reinforcements with temporary combat only movements.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 29athrowaway on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:50PM (#43154758)
You can pick the world size.

Knowing how to concentrate your forces is a tactical element. Once you get railroad you can move your units across your territory easier.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jncfhnb on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:54PM (#43154786)
“Put everyone in a single stack” is not an interesting tactic or knowledge check imo.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by dmoy on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:45PM (#43155347)
There was a year-ish period of sc2 which was death stacks, I think at that point I went back to watching sc1 lol

I agree, it's not fun or interesting

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by bigger_cheese on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:01PM (#43155143)
I played a lot of the original Civ but it was in the early 90's so my memories are a little hazy now. Units on the world map had a "zone of control", you couldn't move units through tiles adjacent to an enemy unit, so the behavior you mention where you could juke past a stack of units wasn't possible, you could put units around cities and similar to create blockades, cut off reinforcements etc (including with naval units).

There was even a tile improvement you could build "fortress" which was useful to build in chokepoint areas as it gave defenders a big advantage. It made this blockading tactic more effective.

The big difference I feel going from old school civ games vs newer games is map tile improvements in old games you had to dedicate a unit to upgrading the tiles around cities (you would have units dedicated to permanently building irrigation, mines, roads and in late game they'd be on pollution cleanup duty to avoid global warming occurring). In modern civ they've abandoned this.

Alpha Centauri was the peak civ game for me had so many cool things you could do like nerve stapling (removed the cities unhappy population permanently but also removed specialists), population booms - where you could grow cities extremely fast by funneling a massive amount of growth resources into them, Supply crawlers (could ferry resources from any tile on the map to crawlers home city), multi tiered social civics (for example rather than just playing a constitutional republic, you could be a combination of Democratic/Planned Economy or Fundamentalist + Free Market, Police State + Green Economy etc.)

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by toast0 on Monday February 24, 2025 @12:41AM (#43156142)
> The big difference I feel going from old school civ games vs newer games is map tile improvements in old games you had to dedicate a unit to upgrading the tiles around cities (you would have units dedicated to permanently building irrigation, mines, roads and in late game they'd be on pollution cleanup duty to avoid global warming occurring). In modern civ they've abandoned this.

I haven't played Civ VII, and I don't think I played much of Civ II or III, but tile improvements is still a thing in Civ IV, V, and VI. In Civ I, the settler unit would do tile improvements and found cities, and at some point they switched to a settler that only founds cities and a worker unit that does tile improvements. In Civ VI, the worker only has a certain number of charges and then disbands, and they separated out road construction to happen with trade routes, but you still need workers to irrigate and add mines and whatever you need for special resources (in Civ I, there was one special resource and it was called resources; later games there's like spices and bananas and coffee and gold and what have you)

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by bigger_cheese on Monday February 24, 2025 @04:52PM (#43165379)
In Civ I there were resources, for example jungle tiles could have "gems", hills had "coal", grasslands had "game" etc. There was also another resource "luxuries" which is what I think you are talking about, you obtained these via establishing trade routes between cities, or by creating specialized citizens (entertainers).
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by bee_rider on Monday February 24, 2025 @12:46AM (#43156158)
I think the issue is that people actually want to do tactical fighting with flanking and concentrating attacks, but the scale is quite odd. Zone of control is a good game mechanic but it’s very game-y; I can’t pass this guy who’s standing a city’s distance away from me?

Maybe a better mechanic could be for units to be able to pass by each other, but it could cause attrition for the moving unit (representing the fact that the moving unit will have trouble foraging with all the entrenched defenders hanging around).

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by distances on Monday February 24, 2025 @05:21AM (#43157901)
Civ 5&6 apply zone of control well, I think: you are able to move past enemies, but it takes all of the unit's move points. So the advancing is slow and dangerous.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2025 @05:36PM (#43165765)
> The big difference I feel going from old school civ games vs newer games is map tile improvements in old games you had to dedicate a unit to upgrading the tiles around cities (you would have units dedicated to permanently building irrigation, mines, roads and in late game they'd be on pollution cleanup duty to avoid global warming occurring). In modern civ they've abandoned this.

Tile improvements have used units (settlers in Civ 1, settlers/engineers in Civ 2, workers in Civ 3-5, builders and military engineers in Civ 6) in all version of Civ in the main franchise line until Civ 7, in Civ 7 non-road improvementsare created automatically by working a tile (and you can't change which tiles are worked once selected, while road and railroad are created by creating cities close enough [roads] or close enough and with rail station buildings [railroads].)

Civ 6 made roadbuilding automatic with trade route creation, but still required units for other tile improvements, including railroads.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jncfhnb on Thursday February 27, 2025 @12:03AM (#43191520)
Ok sure but let’s zoom out a bit.

Both sides have 10 guys. Let’s say one of them puts 10 in a stack. The other splits into 5/5 to tackle two nearby objectives.

In death stack civ games the 10 stack can just instantly swallow the 5’s without suffering much in the way of losses.

Alternatively you have two cities to defend. You have 9 units vs. their 10 and would win if defending from walls or lose if they fight in the field. Does it really make sense that you have no option but to let them take a city for free because you can’t split your defenses to any effect? Nah.

Humankind’s combat is simply far more elegant. If you attack the 5, the nearby 5 can reinforce them. The combat also takes time. So if a small force can hold off a large force at a defensible choke point or maybe a walled city you can buy time for your other troops to arrive at the battle. The focus on gamey movement points and timing of inputs is gone.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by Aerroon on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:45PM (#43155344)
I have to agree: Humankind has a much better base for combat.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by ethbr1 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @11:28PM (#43155847)
The problem is that Civ has never modeled military logistics.

That gap means death stacks are magically logistically-supported.

But fair, as that's not the kind of game it wants to be.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by krige on Monday February 24, 2025 @01:48AM (#43156497)
That's kind of the niche Age of Wonders occupied, a civ-lite strategic layer and xcom-like tactical layer. Too bad 4 is hideously bland (I'll blame paradox and focus group testing for that)
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by int_19h on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:11PM (#43154882)
One thing that bugs me the most in Civ7 is that there's no option to continue playing after the victory condition is achieved, anymore. Nor can you disable some victory conditions if you don't want them.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jmb99 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @11:25PM (#43155835)
This seems to be the biggest (gameplay) complaint across the web, so I would be shocked if it’s not addressed in an update fairly soon.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by npinsker on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:39PM (#43154693)
I haven’t played much Civ — is there some reason that preserving that particular mechanic is important? It doesn’t seem obviously desirable (or undesirable).
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 29athrowaway on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:40PM (#43154702)
Civ 1, 2, 3, 4 all played the roughly the same.

Civ 5 onwards plays completely different because how tile movements are restricted.

In real life those silly restrictions they added do not exist and get in the way of simulating a war.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jncfhnb on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:52PM (#43154772)
A single giant blob of every unit you have moving as one is about as unrealistic as you can get with respect to war logistics and strategy.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by morgante on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:20PM (#43155241)
All of those battles involve battlefield tactics, and in several of them the numerically inferior force won — exactly the opposite of "death stacks."
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 29athrowaway on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:43PM (#43155642)
The Civ series is not the Total War series.

The level of detail of battles is meant to be low because it's focused in wars not battles. You are not a war general you are a head of government.

There are still plenty of tactics in Civ 4. Units have different bonuses depending on terrain and other factors. You have to plan where the combat takes place and what types units you want to use.

Some unit types have collateral damage (catapult, trebuchet, cannon, artillery, mobile artillery, etc.), and there are similar mechanics with air units, cavalry, etc.

The game is not short of battle tactics just not the board game inspired mechanic of Civ 5+.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by focusgroup0 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:34PM (#43155289)
At random, I picked and read Battle of Pharsalus. The Deployment section explains in detail how, through meticulous troop positioning and clever tactics, Caesar was able to defeat the overwhelming force of Pompey.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by HideousKojima on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:11PM (#43155469)
Stalingrad was won because the Soviets flanked and cut off the supply lines supplying the German 6th Army, not because of one death stack defeating another.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 29athrowaway on Monday February 24, 2025 @12:33AM (#43156103)
And in Civ 4:

- you can destroy roads (needed for some resources)

- you can also occupy the tile or destroy the improvement (mine/plantation/camp/quarry/etc) needed to harvest a resource

- you can use diplomacy to deny a resource

- you can use a spy to destroy an improvement

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by Apocryphon on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:18PM (#43155228)
On the other hand the “solution” has to be create a carpet of units creating traffic jams, just a different set of annoying and unrealistic logistical problems.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jncfhnb on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @11:46PM (#43191451)
That’s what I thought. But Humankind’s solution of moving stacks around that get spread out for combat solved this very elegantly imo.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by bee_rider on Monday February 24, 2025 @12:57AM (#43156214)
Moving to one unit per tile didn’t add a logistics or strategic component. It jumped all the way down to a tactical one, you suddenly care about individual units flanking each other.

IMO it was sort of more “honest” from a realism point of view to just admit that the simulation is not that accurate at the unit level, you smash the stacks into each other and assume the officer corps of each army is handling flanking.

It is hard to say which way is more fun really. Seems like a matter of preference. I like tactical games better anyway, so IMO the new way is an improvement. But, realism? Not really.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by jncfhnb on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @11:47PM (#43191457)
That’s why Humankind’s approach is great. Stacks are fine for macro movement. And then actual battles take place with one unit per tile and tactics considerations.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by senkora on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:07PM (#43155171)
I preferred it because I considered the point of Civ to be building up your economy/tech such that you were superior to your opponents, and then using that economic/technological advantage to out-produce them in military and defeat them that way.

The shift from death-stacks to one-unit-per-tile made economic advantage relatively less important and battlefield tactics relatively more important. Tech is still important, though.

Some players like the old feel where battlefield tactics were abstracted away, and some players like the new feel where battlefield tactics are a big part of the game. But they are two very different feels from the same franchise, so we get into this debate.

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by recursivecaveat on Monday February 24, 2025 @12:27AM (#43156078)
Imo one way it was desirable was it was much easier for the AI to play (most people only play against the AI). It has never reeeally gotten the hang of routing and positioning units around in a 1-unit-per-tile model. Consequently they struggle to pro-actively fight each-other even.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by drawkward on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:17AM (#43159795)
You've got it right: it comes down to personal preference.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by throwawaymaths on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:44PM (#43154726)
even unit stacks were janky. for me the last true civ game was CTP 2
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 29athrowaway on Sunday February 23, 2025 @07:47PM (#43154739)
Ironically Call to Power 2 is not a Civ game because their Civilization license was lost so they had to remove Civilization from the name.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by throwawaymaths on Monday February 24, 2025 @03:40AM (#43157137)
yep, that was the joke!
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by ProjectArcturis on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:36PM (#43155020)
And the AI was totally incompetent at maneuvering tactically. They had to massively outnumber you to even have a chance at taking your city. And they really haven't learned anything since!
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by sien on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:58PM (#43155127)
Civ 1 and Civ 4 got highest ratings on Metacritic .

https://www.metacritic.com/pictures/every-sid-meiers-civiliz...

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by JojoFatsani on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:57PM (#43155393)
Civ 4 is cheap on steam. I decided to buy that and go back and run a campaign on there while I wait for VII to mature a bit.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 01100011 on Monday February 24, 2025 @03:29AM (#43157066)
Yeah but it's mac and windows only, no?
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by Delk on Monday February 24, 2025 @04:37AM (#43157558)
Natively, yes. I seem to remember it ran fine on Wine years ago, though. ProtonDB gives it a gold rating.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 29athrowaway on Monday February 24, 2025 @05:15PM (#43165567)
It works on Proton just from Steam with no modification.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by sien on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @09:58PM (#43180116)
It doesn't run on macOS either these days.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by 29athrowaway on Monday February 24, 2025 @12:55AM (#43156202)
Civ 4 Colonization is a lot of fun.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by bigstrat2003 on Monday February 24, 2025 @01:11AM (#43156291)
Fair argument, but death stacks (however realistic) were boring. There was no gameplay there, it was just "mash your stack into the other stack". Perhaps the 1UPT system wasn't the right answer, but they needed to do something to make warfare be an actually interesting part of the game.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by frakrx on Monday February 24, 2025 @04:10AM (#43157374)
They were never boring for me at all and there was lot of strategy and planning involved in troop composition of such stacks. Civ4 was a game about research, development and relationships between civilizations and not an turn based strategy game like latter iterations try to be.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by smallstepforman on Monday February 24, 2025 @01:15AM (#43156322)
I only play Beyond the Sword, the new Civs are not for me. Civ4 is a logistics game, as is real life.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by frakrx on Monday February 24, 2025 @04:03AM (#43157318)
Why do people hate 'doomstacks' I dont get it. It is a 4X game about civilizations after all not a turn based military strategy. There is also startegy involved in doom stack composition and you can beat a much larger doomstack with better troop composition. But like in real life of course, with all things being equal bigger doomstack will defeat smaller one. How realistic are armies of a few thousands man spread across half a continent like in latter Civ series.
Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by muzani on Monday February 24, 2025 @05:09AM (#43157809)
I actually loved Fall From Heaven II[0] as a Civ mod because of the latter civ style handling of archers and such. Somehow Civ 5 onwards utilized that style, but didn't really bring over all the tactical complexity of FFH2. Sadly there has been no other mods that caught my attention the same way FFH did.

[0] https://civilization.fandom.com/wiki/Fall_from_Heaven_(Civ4)

Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2025 @05:13PM (#43165554)
> Civ was completely changed after Civ 4.

This is true, but it was also completely changed after Civ 1, Civ 2, and Civ 3 (and, for that matter, Civ 5 and Civ 6.)

> The game designers of Civ 5 decided to restrict forming death stacks and the new versions of the game still have this mechanic.

Civ III radically changed stack mechanics by eliminating "defeating the strongest defender destroys the stack" (it also added ranged units), Civ IV radically changed stack mechanics by adding in collateral damage from certain attackers (it also got rid of ranged units, replacing them with first strike or archery, and collateral damage for artillery.) Each of these changed the game as radically as Civ 5s one-unit-per-tile (which also so substantial changes with Civ 6's Corps/Army and Fleet/Armada mechanics, and Civ 7's different Army/Fleet/Squadron mechanic.)

The idea that Civ 4 was the single point that changed everything is silly.