Re:Partnering with the Shawnee Tribe for Civilization VII
by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2025 @05:49PM
(#43165885)
> That might be an interesting mechanic. Allow unlimited stacking but make artillery pieces hit every unit in the tile. C
Congratulations, you have basically invented Civ 4's collateral damage mechanic.
> Thinking about this some more it might be possible to make "doomstacks" that actually have some tactics.
Yes, it is. For one more fully developed example, see
https://civilization.fandom.com/wiki/Combat_(Civ4)
(They have a different solution to modeling ranged capability -- in addition to the collateral damage effect of artillery, it includes the First Strike ability of archery and certain other units.)
Thinking about this some more it might be possible to make "doomstacks" that actually have some tactics.
Idea:
Unlimited stacking is allowed. Units are ordered in the stack based on melee attack power * current health. When stacks attack one another only one melee type unit and one ranged unit may attack any particular single unit on the other side. Both attackers and defenders work from the top down. If an attacker or defender destroys their unit then leftover attack power will be used against the next available unit, after all initial attacks have been completed, but that melee unit will take return damage based on the percentage of the attack they have remaining.
For example, side 1 has a stack with 3 warriors and 2 archers. Side 2 has 1 warrior and 4 archers.
The idea with the followup attacks is that it prevents someone from building an "army" out of a lot of cheap units just to roadblock strong units. By limiting battlefront size you still need to split your stacks to flank enemies or even attack on multiple fronts. Ranged units would be very vulnerable to melee, and artillery would be mostly strong against cities but would do damage to everything in the stack. Units inside of cities or fortresses would be protected against artillery and take very little damage.I think this could be an interesting way to do combat, but it is relatively complicated and the AI would probably be even worse at managing it.