News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by matsemann on Sunday February 02, 2025 @09:02AM (#42908687)
Ref 2: if you buy from Amazon, you never know if you get a genuine card. Even if you shop from an official seller, as inventory is commingled so you might as well get a fake one from another seller with the same SKU.

Big problem in action cam related circles, where lots of people have broken recordings due to fake cards.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by jqpabc123 on Sunday February 02, 2025 @09:52AM (#42908982)
if you buy from Amazon, you never know if you get a genuine card.

Yes, but there is a significant difference --- I can always return it to Amazon postage free if the capacity is fake and it won't format properly. Presumably, Amazon extracts the appropriate weight in flesh from the seller.

The way retail typically works in the USA, the vendor assumes all the risk --- any problems get unrolled backwards. You can sell a fake product on Amazon --- but it will likely cost you --- not Amazon (who controls the money) nor the end consumer if he is astute.

Basically, Amazon acts like an escrow service.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by Palomides on Sunday February 02, 2025 @09:59AM (#42909035)
you're still feeding the machine, and assuming you can catch cases where something is merely lower quality rather than completely fake
Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by jqpabc123 on Sunday February 02, 2025 @10:09AM (#42909093)
If there are too many returns, the machine doesn't get fed; it gets punished.

Amazon and other retailers have played this game for a very long time and they aren't in it to lose money.

In my experience, the thing most commonly faked with memory cards is the capacity --- for example, an 8Gb card altered to appear 64Gb, until it is formatted.

If you want extra assurance, buy Amazon branded cards. In this case, Amazon assumes almost all the risk so there is little incentive for fakery.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by reboot81 on Sunday February 02, 2025 @11:30AM (#42909646)
Validrive[1] can validate actual vs advertised storage area. Maybe works on SD-cards aswell?

1 https://www.grc.com/validrive.htm

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by BolexNOLA on Sunday February 02, 2025 @10:22AM (#42909187)
> If there are too many returns, the machine doesn't get fed; it gets punished.

On Amazon? I highly doubt it. The threshold for “too many returns” is probably rarely hit. MicroSD’s are super cheap - people don’t return things that are cheap because they don’t consider it worth their time. Then these companies go and pay people for good reviews and just keep flipping inconsistent/garbage products.

If punishment were a real thing that companies had to deal with then this wouldn’t continue to be a problem. It’s been this way for many, many years. Amazon has no equal competitor, there’s nowhere else for folks to go and people rarely look at the specific vendor they’re buying from. As far as they’re concerned it’s all Amazon.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by nothrabannosir on Sunday February 02, 2025 @11:00AM (#42909444)
> Amazon has no equal competitor, there’s nowhere else for folks to go and people rarely look at the specific vendor they’re buying from.

I’ve bought more off target.com than Amazon and I read at least one other commenter here who does the same. Walmart.com also has a wide range of products.

Even sd cards. Which are still going strong.

https://www.target.com/s/microsd

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by Retric on Sunday February 02, 2025 @11:24AM (#42909603)
Personally I’ve given up on Amazon years ago but I definitely understand why people don’t feel like there’s competition. Here’s a 40% price difference on seemingly the same product.

Target: “20% off sale” 32.99$ https://www.target.com/p/sandisk-ultra-plus-256gb-microsd/-/...

Amazon: 23.69$ https://www.amazon.com/Sandisk-Ultra-256GB-MicroSDXC-Adapter...

If it’s just fraud then maybe that explains it, but Target seems to have significant overhead.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by jqpabc123 on Sunday February 02, 2025 @10:49AM (#42909370)
Amazon back charges the vendor for every return --- which likely includes return shipping and handling. I can assure you, Amazon doesn't just "eat" these costs.

Remember, Amazon holds the cash for all sales. The cost of returns is extracted from vendor disbursements. A fake card sold for $10 may cost the vendor $20 if it gets returned.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by BolexNOLA on Sunday February 02, 2025 @10:53AM (#42909394)
If enough people return the item which again, with microsd cards, is likely not nearly often enough on Amazon.

If “the system worked” i.e. companies get appropriately punished for selling bad products, then this issue wouldn’t still be so widespread. It’s basically a feature of Amazon now. People just assume they’re going to randomly get junk. It’s baked into our expectations at this point.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by jqpabc123 on Sunday February 02, 2025 @11:24AM (#42909601)
Amazon returns are very easy --- maybe even too easy.

I suspect the real issue with memory cards is that most people probably don't check them. The solution is --- don't be like most people.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by BolexNOLA on Sunday February 02, 2025 @11:58AM (#42909853)
It is significantly more work to return an item than to buy one, it’s very asymmetric.
Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by circuit10 on Sunday February 02, 2025 @12:57PM (#42910325)
Just formatting it isn't enough, you need to use a tool that does a test that writes to all the storage and reads it back
Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by jqpabc123 on Sunday February 02, 2025 @06:09PM (#42912838)
Formatting is a base level test that doesn't require any additional software.

A lot of cheap cards from China can't even pass this basic test.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by everybodyknows on Sunday February 02, 2025 @09:24AM (#42908801)
Are you saying that the counterfeiting of name brand packaging is so skillful that even careful inspection by us the consumers cannot reasonably hope to detect it?
Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by cwillu on Sunday February 02, 2025 @11:19AM (#42909566)
https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/on-microsd-problems/

“One vendor in particular interested me; it was literally a mom, pop and one young child sitting in a small stall of the mobile phone market, and they were busily slapping dozens of non-Kingston marked cards into Kingston retail packaging. They had no desire to sell to me, but I was persistent; this card interested me in particular because it also had the broken “D” logo but no Kingston marking.”

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by AlexandrB on Sunday February 02, 2025 @09:49AM (#42908966)
Unless you have the real and the fake side by side it can be really hard.
Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by dboreham on Sunday February 02, 2025 @09:54AM (#42908997)
Even then it's hard because the legit vendors change their packaging frequently.
Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by BolexNOLA on Sunday February 02, 2025 @05:57PM (#42912744)
Yes it’s a very big problem until you run speed tests and the like which most people have no clue how to do.
Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by lazide on Sunday February 02, 2025 @10:37AM (#42909302)
Personally I found an easy way to tell - write a script which fills the drive fully with random data (computing a check sum as it writes), then read it all back and verify you get the right checksum.

Oh and compute read/write times while doing so.

If the read back data doesn’t validate, or you can’t write the amount expected, or the read/write rates don’t match expected? faaaaaaake

Pretty accurate too. I personally never had an actual fake Sandisk SD card from Amazon. I bought probably 50 of them in the space of 6 months at one point. Other brands were not great.

USB flash drives though? Literally all trash. I tried at least 5 different ones before I just gave up.

No idea what the market looks like now however.

Re:Reverse-engineering and analysis of SanDisk High Enduranc... by mikae1 on Sunday February 02, 2025 @09:55AM (#42909007)
First rule: never buy flash storage from Amazon.