News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by brookst on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:37PM (#42891658)
I despise Facebook, but given a choice of US youth being indoctrinated by Facebook, by TikTok/CCP, or both… the choice is pretty clear. Sure, I’d like a “none of the above” option but that is not on the table. Wake me when it is.
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by spencerflem on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:59PM (#42891897)
I'd like neither too, but at least it's nice to be able to pick instead of having the govt decide for me
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by kerkeslager on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:04PM (#42891970)
Honestly, the choice is clear: the CCP is clearly not doing as much damage to our youth as our own companies are. Which is more important for U.S. youth to know about, Tienanmen Square or abortion, Winnie the Pooh or jury nullification? And that's just the censorship aspect of this; surveillance remains a bigger factor IMO. Which organization is more likely to be used by an American cop to track the ex-girlfriend they domestically abused: TikTok or Facebook?

It seems like your entire argument here is just vague sinophobic hand-waving. Do you have even a single example of TickTock/CCP harming American youth that hasn't been done worse by US social media and government?

To be clear, I'm not arguing that China is better than the US in any general way, I'm specifically making the claim that American government and social media harms Americans more than any other government or social media harms Americans.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by onetokeoverthe on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:44PM (#42891753)
none of the above is easy.

craigslist used to have free personals, and escort ads.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by add-sub-mul-div on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:31PM (#42892338)
Why is it clear that your life won't suffer more under domestic control than foreign control, other than reflexive jingoism? Domestic control has more direct levers and the gloves are off right now.
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by tivert on Friday January 31, 2025 @05:22PM (#42892978)
> Why is it clear that your life won't suffer more under domestic control than foreign control, other than reflexive jingoism? Domestic control has more direct levers and the gloves are off right now.

Because foreigners are even less accountable to Americans and even less interested in their well being than any domestic group? It just stands to reason, there's not even the weak ties of being members of the same group.

I mean, to be a little outlandish: if there was a conflict, and some foreign adversary could transmit a mind virus to Americans that would cause them to go on murderous rampages and kill everyone, they'd probably do it. It'd be an instant win, and there'd be some sweet, sweet land to colonize afterwards.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by ceejayoz on Friday January 31, 2025 @05:52PM (#42893309)
> Because foreigners are even less accountable to Americans and even less interested in their well being than any domestic group?

That is not necessarily true. The Hitlers and Putins of the world will happily sacrifice their own citizenry and their country's future for more power in the moment. It's entirely possible for some foreigners to hold more goodwill towards a country than its own leadership.

> I mean, to be a little outlandish: if there was a conflict, and some foreign adversary could transmit a mind virus to Americans that would cause them to go on murderous rampages and kill everyone, they'd probably do it. It'd be an instant win, and there'd be some sweet, sweet land to colonize afterwards.

Several countries are entirely capable of doing this with nukes.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by tivert on Friday January 31, 2025 @05:59PM (#42893379)
> That is not necessarily true. The Hitlers and Putins of the world will happily sacrifice their own citizenry and their country's future for more power in the moment.

Don't you think they'd be even more willing to sacrifice Americans or other foreigners?

> Several countries are entirely capable of doing this with nukes.

No, and you're kind of missing the point, which was the adversarial leader cares less about foreigners. Also: nukes are somewhat controlled with MAD, and they'd spoil that sweet, sweet land with fallout.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by ceejayoz on Friday January 31, 2025 @06:01PM (#42893406)
> Don't you think they'd be even more willing to sacrifice Americans or other foreigners?

I'm saying I'd rather, say, France's Macron calling the shots here than an American-born version of Hitler.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by brookst on Friday January 31, 2025 @09:10PM (#42894963)
Sure. But that’s not the choice on the table.
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by ceejayoz on Saturday February 01, 2025 @09:56AM (#42898766)
Again:

> Because foreigners are even less accountable to Americans and even less interested in their well being than any domestic group?

In my example, the foreign group probably has my well being as a higher priority than the domestic one.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by add-sub-mul-div on Friday January 31, 2025 @09:04PM (#42894928)
The rich who are currently raiding the country are effectively unaccountable and care as little for the bottom 99% of the US as the Chinese government does.

If we ignore murder mind viruses and look at what's actually going on.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by brookst on Friday January 31, 2025 @09:10PM (#42894958)
You see it as “jingoistic” to prefer more local corruption that sucks, but largely zero sum among the country you live in, to foreign corruption that is zero sum with adversaries?

I’ll be charitable and assume your point is “any corruption is so unbelievably awful that we might as well have the worst possible form of it if we have any at all.”

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by spencerflem on Friday January 31, 2025 @09:59PM (#42895230)
No its more - if the Chinese find out I support Occupy Wall St. , what are they going to do about it?

Vs the local govt that has a monopoly on violence

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by olyjohn on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:45PM (#42892517)
That's not a choice. I can choose CenturyLink or Comcast, but neither actually gets me good internet at a reasonable price.
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by brookst on Friday January 31, 2025 @08:45PM (#42894806)
We’re not playing “in an ideal world”, we’re playing “in the world we have, do you want a foreign adversary controlling content”.
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by spencerflem on Friday January 31, 2025 @09:58PM (#42895222)
I trust them about as much as the domestic adversary controlling the content. And the Chinese have a harder time sending in the cops if they don't like what they see
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by agnosticmantis on Friday January 31, 2025 @05:24PM (#42893007)
False dichotomy, when you could have both, and they can have non-overlapping censorship criteria.

What one censors the other doesn't, and you get less censorship when there are more options available.

Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by brookst on Friday January 31, 2025 @08:47PM (#42894818)
Great! So some US kids grow up with Chinese propaganda, and some with more milquetoast and fragmented corporate propaganda, and that’s a better world?
Re:Instagram and Facebook Blocked and Hid Abortion Pill Prov... by spencerflem on Friday January 31, 2025 @10:01PM (#42895240)
Yes- they can talk to each other and swap notes. It sounds like you're arguing for a great firewall type thing to make sure there's only approved non-propaganda content