Ha. Same here but reporting a job ad that targets the dublin area, but it's really for bangkok. I hate it.
For every account I create on the internet I create a new mail inbox, this way I can just compare the email title with the inbox it was sent to. So, when I receive a notice from my bank on my github email I know what happened. This genuinely saved me a few times already.
I've just explained the problem with the gmail tagging in another comment.
I've caught a couple of hacked or sold email lists, but nothing that drastic yet.
One organization posted the email address I gave them on a public contact list webpage, so I get spam/phishing at that one.
Using a catch-all is the easiest way to do this, and I highly recommend it for other people.
Most providers let you run a catch-all adress on your own domain. You usually set it up with just a check-box "catch-all" and where to send all mail, or you write the username as "*" in an alias.
The problem is that [email protected] and [email protected] are delivered to the same inbox, so if you are trying to scam someone it is safe to remove anything after the + in a gmail address.
And having a custom domain on gmail doesn't improve your situation, because with just a simple 'dig mx' you can know if the domain is hosted on gmail and apply the same regex to remove all labels.
So, to be less inflammatory the feature works as expected. But it only protects you if the bad actor is really dumb/lazy or if he is honest.
And the 'fuck them, I won't do business with them' attitude doesn't really work if the system that wont accept your email is the local gas company.
And there is another problem, some systems will just remove any label without informing you. I've had this problem logging in some random websites. My account was created with [email protected] but to log I had to use [email protected].
For those sites, you can add a dot in your username. Then you can ignore any emails sent to an address without the presence of a dot or a plus.
I'm sure there are sites that don't accept dots either, but I've never run into one. So you have to make an exception? Oh well.
I agree that it's easiest to do with [email protected], like the grandparent suggested.
+ sign is part of the standard (`atext` token, RFC 5322), so sites, which disallow it in address are doing it wrong. The fact, that industry adopted a practice of using everything after + sign as a "tag" is not captured anywhere so this creates even more mess in already messy space (e.g MS followed GSuite in this too and added subaddressing - https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/exchange/recipients-in-exc...)
The problem, however, is that most companies still rely on crappy Enterprise services like Microsoft Office. For most people managing identities like this is impossible to do - due to either lack of user-friendly options or due to too high thresholds of necessary IT knowledge.
I mean, we are speaking about having to configure Dovecot and Postfix and similar tools, and I fuck that up regularly. And we are also assuming that they have to be unguessable (you have github@? maybe I should target linkedin@, too, then!) which implies that they have to be random-looking which means they will likely be blocked by registration filters.
Newer projects like Maddy [1] kind of go towards that direction, but are still targeted at developers or sysadmins.
'Creating a new inbox' was an exaggeration on my part. What I have is a catchall on my fastmail account. But when I talk about creating creating inboxes it seems to make it easier for normal people to understand what I'm doing and the benefits it brings.
> we are also assuming that they have to be unguessable
That would be nice, but I don't have a nice way of doing it. I've tried to use something like rot13 to make it less obvious, but it is a pain to manage it. It would be nice it existed a cypher that was pretty easy to do in my head, but I never found anything like this.
> you have github@? maybe I should target linkedin@, too, then!
Yes, this is a problem. For a targeted attack this may become a weakpoint in my defense. But this is a calculated risk I'm willing to accept for now.
Since many sites can't believe that an email address can have a "+", I can also use "[email protected]" at most sites instead of [email protected]. ("anytext" typically, for me, being the name of the company or organization that I'm dealing with. Also, my Panix account is not really "dcoder".)
If you have 'domain.com' you can receive emails either on '[email protected]' or '[email protected]' without problems.
You can even get an api key for it and plug that into bitwarden, so that when you sign up for whatever, you click bitwarden, generate password, generate email, sign in and it's all set. So smooth. (I sound like an ad, but internet pinky promise no affiliation)
I always give out myname+tag@... to places that ask for email, and have an incoming message rule that puts bare myname@ straight into spam folder.
So far, the only messages to bare address were service updates from my email provider itself.
I don't know what they are thinking. Isn't it a real family name in Korea?
That said, are you sure it wasn't the + that caused the problem? I've run into that a few times, presumably when someone tried to roll their own email validation.
[email protected] worked just fine..
I'll make these intentional letter swaps every time just to avoid regexes and automatic filters.
It's especially hard now that many legitimate companies use a lot of generic sounding AI-generated content, which seems to be same approach the spam/phish/malware teams are using.
IMO we need some kind of zero-knowledge proof system that can be checked to verify if a message sender is a US citizen, employed by who they say they are employed by etc.
I don't see how we can trust anything in a post-generative AI world any other way.
I think this could be a great opportunity for Google. Lots of organizations already make use of Google Workspace/Gmail. Imagine if Google Workspace offered the equivalent of a "Twitter blue check", where you pay extra, and anyone who views your email in Gmail sees a little check mark next to it, that shows Google verified you are who you say you are, and Google thinks you're not malicious. Salespeople sending cold emails would love it.
I don't think you can solve this problem purely cryptographically. An attacker could always bribe a US citizen to set up a shell corp or whatever. Most objectively verifiable indicators can be gamed. There has to be an organization that's good at security, like Google, which is in the business of continuously keeping up with adversaries. Actually Google might not be the best because they kinda suck at tailored customer service, but anyway.
Turns out there's a lot of fake shell companies that act either as hosting companies specifically for malware campaigns from Russia and China or specifically as a company that tries to fraud people, e.g. their CEO being on the FBI most wanted list or the company being sanctioned by the UN.
I'm currently creating some sort of cyber map of these spam/phish/malware campaign overlaps, as part of my antispam [1] effort.
I got tired of LLM based targeted spam where they have a system in place that is trained on my social media profiles, because they are very hard to identify as being spam.
Blocking specific domains is a useless effort because they keep on spawning new fake company domains that are either copies of legit ones or are generated fake profiles. They are so automated that they also create staff members and fake profiles on LinkedIn, specifically for that spam effort. Nobody at LinkedIn gives a shit about those fake avatars, I reported hundreds by now and they did absolutely nothing.
Anyways, long story short, here's the blocklist of those ASNs and companies. I'm working on the map at the moment and don't wanna publish it until I can prove its correctness:
[1] https://github.com/cookiengineer/antispam