revenue - expenses == profit
Maybe Apple can not calculate the profit up to the last decimal but no matter how they claim this to be impossible they are capable of calculating it up to a percent or two. It won't matter if they get it a few percent too low since actual profits will be far up in the double digits region if they're anywhere smart about it and if Apple is anything it is keen on getting more money.In other words this is what can be called bulshytt [1] in technical terms.
[1] Bulshytt: (1) In Fluccish of the late Praxic Age and early Reconstitution, a derogatory term for false speech in general, esp. knowing and deliberate falsehood or obfuscation. (2) In Orth, a more technical and clinical term denoting speech (typically but not necessarily commercial or political) that employs euphemism, convenient vagueness, numbing repetition, and other such rhetorical subterfuges to create the impression that something has been said. (3) According to the Knights of Saunt Halikaarn, a radical order of the 2nd Millennium A.R., all speech and writings of the ancient Sphenics; the Mystagogues of the Old Mathic Age; Praxic Age commercial and political institutions; and, since the Reconstitution, anyone they deemed to have been infected by Procian thinking. … (Neal Stephenson, “Anathem” (2008))
If you think of it like a hick farmer would
OK, let's do that. But we need to use an example where there are two or more outputs under 'joint supply'. Otherwise it's not analogous to the situation with Apple's ecosystem.Let's figure out the profit margin on wool from your sheep farm. Each month:
- Your wool revenue is $1000
- Your mutton revenue is $1000
- Your total costs (feed, labor, etc.) are $1000
What's your profit margin on wool?Most people will try to split the costs 50/50 since revenues are equal, making wool's margin (1000 - 500)/1000 = 50%.
But then ask them: What if wool prices double, so now:
- Wool revenue is $2000
- Mutton revenue is still $1000
- Total costs still $1000
Should wool's costs still be $500? Or should they now be $667 since wool is 2/3 of revenue? The margin would be either: A) (2000 - 500)/2000 = 75%
B) (2000 - 667)/2000 = 67%
Which is right? There's no correct answer, because any cost allocation between wool and mutton is arbitrary. We can calculate the total profit margin for the farm, but not for individual products.I have to assume this pattern holds true for the areas I’m less knowledgeable in. It’s probably safe to assume that the further a topic strays from tech, the less faith you should put in the popular HN take.
But that's only because the example is over-simplified, and assumes that the labor & feed benefit both wool & mutton equally.
They don't. For example, a lot of the labor cost will be in the shearing. That should be allocated completely to wool, right? Not so fast, if you don't shear your sheep your meat production will be affected so even farmers that raise sheep for mutton will still shear their sheep. So there is no correct answer in a real-world situation. rahimnathwani is correct.
Besides, why the analogy? We’re talking app stores. It's not apparent why we need a joint supply analogy.
It's not apparent why we need a joint supply analogy.
The ecosystem wouldn't work without the hardware, the SDKs and the app store. They are designed and maintained in tandem. They are in joint supply. Why does Apple create Xcode and the various SDKs? Is it to support hardware sales, or to support app store sales?I could reasonably argue that 100% of costs should be allocated to wool (after all, I'm a wool farmer, and mutton is just a byproduct!), or that 100% of costs should be allocated to mutton.
Since the question was written to pose by percentage of revenue contribution as wrong, by production units is another way you could do it. But importantly, as a public company, you pick a method and go with that so that the numbers can be compared from year to year, and quarter to quarter, and is more important than the absolute number, though that's still important.
Importantly, it's not this big crazy unknown question that's never been answered before in the history of the business of sheep. Or hardware and software sales. Apple, whos legal and accounting department used an aggressive tax minimization strategy similar to the Dutch Sandwich to book revenue in Europe until they got called out for it, isn't comprised of "hick farmers" who don't know what they're doing and can't figure out a method on how to book revenue. It's a ploy yet again to avoid paying taxes or developers and isn't some off-the-cuff answer.
Apple, as a public company, is required to break out material revenue, and thus the App store revenue is listed in their quarterly 10-K with the SEC. Cost of sales and operating expenses are also listed. Importantly though, the lawyers fighting Apple just need to establish that the percentage is quite high, even if a specific number came be agreed upon, and thus Apple is can sustainability pay out whatever they're being asked for.
Though, the SEC is a US institution and has limited reach outside of the US, and the linked case is coming from the UK, so I'm not sure if the existence of the 10-K comes into play.
Perception of value can be more important than the actual value. Like Trump famously said:
> My net worth fluctuates, and it goes up and down with attitudes and feelings, even my own feelings
He was right! The numbers on paper (and the convictions in court) don't matter when you ride the feelings into the White House.
You can argue that all Apple R&D and marketing are expenses for the App Store, or at least are so intertwined that they can't be separated. People pay a premium for the brand, and (the perception of) quality and safety. That can't be dissected into pieces.
But that being said, if the AppStore were somehow spun off into a separate company, I think their costs would be less than 10% or even 5% of the cut that Apple takes from the AppStore sales. I'm sure I could run it at those costs.
Still, it's fair for Apple to want the cut they take from the App store revenues. I totally get their position. They built a great product and platform. They deserve to reap the rewards.
Are you counting the surely enormous amount you would have to pay Apple for the privilege of being the App Store?
But that being said, if the AppStore were somehow spun off into a separate company
The 'somehow' assumes we have some way of deciding which costs should be borne by this separate entity. But we've already agreed that's not possible!They know all the labor costs and revenue for each of their products. Every single one.
Zero chance Apple doesn’t categorize server allocation and assign those to budgets. Small companies do it.
So, the obvious answer is they’re lying. They’ve done it before, too. They’re doing it now.
Your rebuttal is simply “of course they know the answer”.
Is there any reason someone reading this thread should prefer your take over theirs?
1. The first $1 trillion, $3 trillion and (soon to be) $4 trillion company. 2. Cancels or stops production of products that don't make money (VisionPro being the latest). 3. Spent over half a trillion dollars in stock buybacks.
No company gets to the height Apple is currently without knowing every dollar coming in and going out.
I'm reminded of "if it don't make dollars, it don't make sense" chorus from DJ Quik's "Dollaz + Sense".
When I apply that to Apple (let alone any successful company for that matter), the claim that they don't know if the AppStore is profitable or not *defies belief*.
Schiller might not know exactly how much profit is generated, but to suggest that he's clueless whether or not on the WHOLE if the AppStore is profitable... If people believe that, I got a bunch of bridges up for sale.
Yeah, like Schiller isn't ever told about revenue and expenses at Apple. Please. What a joke.
If they were losing money, what would they do? They probably can't raise their rates, since people are already very unhappy with their current rates, so it would be a hard sell given how much the company as a whole makes. They can't close the App Store, since it would flush their entire iPhone line down the toilet. Could they lower costs? Probably—cut back on reviewers, get rid of the promotional pages they create. I dunno.
But seriously, this ignores too many simple truths. Companies with even under $100 million in revenue categorize labor and other general expenses. Even full-time employees who don’t log their hours have them tracked by entry-level management all over the U.S.
Why would one do this? To capitalize on software costs, apart from even hardware costs. Something Apple does regularly, and they have a history of sharing that information with shareholders.
So, the GP is talking out of his rear end. The obvious reason Apple doesn't want to share their margins is because every closed software ecosystem is absolutely screwing their developers. That’s why.
There isn’t a single company I’ve worked for in nearly 20 years that doesn’t assign department and project costs to employees, contractors, and ancillary workers. Each department and project also has its own materials expenditure reports.
All of them. Even the smallest companies do this. It’s such a naive claim to think otherwise. I have no idea why people here think the “integrated” argument holds up at Apple, either. Staff there absolutely have "App Store and related work" assigned to their employee profiles. Without a doubt. Even their hiring roles don’t hire general software engineers; each role is preassigned to a specific department or project.
I am no expert, but that seems like a 74% margin on services, which would seem to include their "app store".
It is difficult for me to imagine that apple is somehow incapable of breaking those numbers down into smaller component categories.
Am I missing something here?
You are assuming Apple is a reseller (whose revenue is the full price paid by the end buyer) rather than an agent (whose revenue is only their commission).You are also ignoring the app store's advertising revenue.
And you're assuming that it costs zero to run the app store.
This isn't an unreasonable assumption, especially considering the invoice for my last App Store purchase has an Apple address and tax identifier (VAT number). Apple is the merchant of record.
As someone who qualified as an accountant over 15 years ago, it's not obvious to me how you would develop a meaningful allocation of costs.
I suspect this misunderstanding stems from the same thinking that leads people to believe the myth that Costco makes no profit on its physical products, only on memberships.