News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:39AM (#42642264)
This entire song-and-dance from executives, media, platforms, and the general "status quo preservationists" over the last month in response to Luigi is priceless.

They seem to have a high desire to place any disrespect they can on what seems to be an otherwise revered political activist in recent times; and it's only further fueling the discussion, and in all likelihood - probability for successors.

They would have been smart to play a leveling field, to treat Luigi's act with an element of absurdity, which would cause everyday people to question if their relatability towards Luigi was warranted or even made sense. Instead, they played a hand that the fearful would - because they are, and only validated the vigilante's narrative - because it is.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by anigbrowl on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:01AM (#42642403)
Administrators reflexively lie. They are committed to preserving whatever institution employs them, not to any objective standard of truth or behavior. I have lost count of how many times I have highlighted such behavior over the alst decade.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by beefnugs on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:21AM (#42642604)
I find it hilarious that they can't even keep their power in check to save it for when it would REALLY matter... but they just cant help themselves, they love to execute the control as quickly as it is available even though this leaves a trail of erosion.

An obvious worldwide trend of complete speech control, right in the open for all of us to follow and see. Instead of just waiting a bit longer... until there was no way to stop it (maybe its already too late?) But i feel like this is too soon to pull this trigger, we still have time to stop using all these large platforms that aren't even vital to our lives, to make open and peer to peer alternatives

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:06AM (#42642459)
Me as well, but instead highlighting their lack of commitment to morals and integrity; rather than standard of truth or behavior - equally valid take, mind you!
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by chongli on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:08AM (#42642935)
Lying to preserve an institution is like playing Jenga: eroding the foundation in order to scale up the tower.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by anigbrowl on Friday January 10, 2025 @12:00AM (#42652652)
Fantastic metaphor - I'll definitely be using that.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ch33zer on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:24AM (#42643055)
Hypothetical - is it possible for someone to set up an ethical health insurance company that just takes in premiums and pays out for care? If people despise the current companies so much why can't we just start a new company, maybe as a public benefits corporation that by charter has to act ethically?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ars on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:02AM (#42643304)
So the fun thing is that's already what happens! It's part of a law passed with the ACA called the Medical Loss Ratio rule.

I've come to discover that most people really do not understand healthcare insurance at all.

The true driver of increased costs is Dr's and Hospitals. Not insurance.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by DangitBobby on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:46AM (#42647416)
This rule magically solved all incentive misalignment in healthcare and everyone clapped.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by DangitBobby on Thursday January 09, 2025 @07:22PM (#42651240)
The rule might have made things even worse, since now total costs have to go up for their profit to go up.

Contrast this with a non-profit which has no incentive to increase profits and thus no incentive to increase costs.

I agree that these conversations mainly reveal to me that many people don't understand the economics driving costs in US healthcare, since they are so willing to carry water for private insurers.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ars on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:11PM (#42652357)
> since now total costs have to go up for their profit to go up.

And yet, they deny claims, despite that denying a claim reduces their profits.

> to carry water for private insurers.

Because insurance it utterly irrelevant to the issue. The problems in the US lie at the Dr/Hospital level, not the insurance. Procedures simply cost too much, having the government pay for them will just makes things worse because government always overpays for things.

You want to solve things? Make medical tuition free, and remove ALL caps on number of doctors (especially difficult with residency, but it can be done). Then reduce rates for services.

Someone should start a fully integrated company: They educate you, find you a residency, and hire you. In exchange for free tuition you agree to work for lower rates. (There will need to be some details to work out obviously, since you can't force people to work.)

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by DangitBobby on Friday January 10, 2025 @09:52AM (#42656060)
Whatever their reasons for denying claims, capricious denials is the main complaint people have about insurance, so it doesn't really feel any better if it doesn't actually increase their profits. Out of curiosity, why do you think they deny claims of it has nothing to do with profitability? Is denying claims just fun?

It's actually comical to claim insurance is irrelevant.

Billions of dollars of middlemen creating makework inserted into the process surely adds no costs, and is completely irrelevant to how much it costs. The waste generated in hospital billing departments is free, since people famously love working for billing departments and will do it for free. Commercial real estate for healthcare company buildings is also free, and so are the salaries of all the people that work for them. Not to mention their role in creating price opacity, allowing prices to rise unchecked and having different prices for different payers, also has no effect on prices. The stress that patient dissatisfaction (or outright getting fucked) causes providers is also completely free and causes no waste.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:02AM (#42642414)
> They seem to have a high desire to place any disrespect they can on what seems to be an otherwise revered political activist in recent times

Perhaps because he is a murderer?

As several others have pointed out, Magione's support is extremely limited, to a very liberal, very online few.

See: https://today.yougov.com/politics/articles/51189-presidentia...

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by pfannkuchen on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:37AM (#42642723)
I suspect the interest in the case comes mainly from the fact that Mangione doesn’t fit the typical “nothing left to lose” profile of most killers, especially outside of the crime-of-passion genre. A man with prospects doing such things may signal a turning of the tides in a way that makes some discontents hopeful. I personally don’t think it’s a good sign, but I can understand where people are coming from.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by michaelsshaw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:06AM (#42642460)
The images of the most effective human rights leaders have been so whitewashed.

Many of the greats were definitely killers. Nelson Mandela famously founded a "terrorist" organization and for years refused to condemn any partisan violence.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:18AM (#42642574)
Yes, but simple as -- Nelson Mandela is not Luigi Mangione.

This isn't apartheid. Get a hold on your horses and grow up. You live in a republic. You need to convince other people single payer health care is the right policy.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by llmthrow102 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:58AM (#42642870)
The average American citizen has less influence on politics in their "republic" than a citizen of a dictatorship. Only the will of the financial elite actually has influence. See Gilens and Page 2014.

It really doesn't matter if people are convinced to want single payer or not, it isn't going to happen. There are many, many systems in place to prevent the will of the people from happening if the elite don't want it.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:09AM (#42642945)
> The average American citizen has less influence on politics in their "republic" than a citizen of a dictatorship.

You can't be serious.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by danlitt on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:29AM (#42643091)
"you need to" - apparently we don't. Apparently we can do this, too, and it works.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:32AM (#42643114)
> Apparently we can do this, too, and it works.

Works how?

What if the right began killing left wing figures in retribution? How would that work?

Just let this play out in your mind, and ask how much of this sounds like some right wing militia fantasia set in 1995.

BTW I was in OKC in 1995. Thank God it didn't and doesn't work.

"It's not Halloween. Grow up, Peter Pan. Count Chocula."

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by danlitt on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:35AM (#42643133)
Began?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by chongli on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:12AM (#42642965)
Be careful what you wish for. I live in Canada. We have single payer health care here. The system is collapsing. Practitioners are getting burned out and extremely unhappy. Waiting lists for many common procedures just keep getting longer and longer. Many people don’t have access to a family physician and ER waiting rooms are overcrowded.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by danlitt on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:33AM (#42643124)
I guarantee you whatever problems with Canada's single payer healthcare, it kills far fewer people than the US's monstrous system.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by deanCommie on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:47AM (#42642797)
There is a now infamous tweet:

"People on twitter will really be like "you believe in voting? that pales in effectiveness to my strategy, firebombing a Walmart" and then not firebomb a Walmart" [0]

Well, Luigi firebombed a Walmart.

Is that a valid strategy for enacting societal change? Perhaps not. But this republic accepts and engages in war. And as Clusewitz says, ""War is the continuation of policy with other means." [1]

Perhaps Luigi is also pursuing policy change through other means. I have to say that watching American politicians and law enforcement agencies treat the man who at worst committed one murder (alleged; innocent until proven guilty) with the wrath and civil rights abuses previously only reserved for terrorists associated with 9/11 makes me believe that his actions genuinely shocked the system.

I'll be shocked if he makes it to trial alive.

[0] https://x.com/LinkofSunshine/status/1720538218628558969?lang...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_von_Clausewitz

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by michaelsshaw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:53AM (#42642830)
>the wrath and civil rights abuses previously only reserved for terrorists associated with 9/11 makes me believe that his actions genuinely shocked the system.

When people responded positively or indifferently to the killing of Thompson, the ruling class took notice. That's REAL power, a new sensation to most Americans. I can hope only good things can come of this realization.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:56AM (#42643260)
> Perhaps Luigi is also pursuing policy change through other means.

Luigi, a person with zero history of political activism, with no record of organizing for anything, decides his only open political alternative is to kill the CEO of an insurance company, not registering new voters or organizing his workplace for better health coverage or driving old folks to the polls.

I don't know? That sounds less like rational political activism than a mentally disturbed lone gunman to me.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by throwaway48476 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:10AM (#42643717)
Jim Bell
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:39AM (#42646689)
It sounds like someone who has analyzed the situation and decided that this is the only thing that works, and that it's better if someone without a record does it.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:02AM (#42642896)
Regardless of whether or not you think it's valid, it's clearly very effective. No major social change for the better has EVER happened in history without such actions.

It seems to go like this:

1. One group calmly demands some sensible thing. They might do some protests.

2. The powers that be say no, because they like the status quo. They might arrest some people for peaceful protesting.

3. A different group does some violence.

4. The powers that be acquiesce to the first group because the alternative is continued violence. The second group has no basis to continue the violence once the first group is acquiesced to.

5. History paints the first group as the ones who caused change and the second group as bad people who shouldn't have done what they did.

It's got to be one of those psychological sales tricks. Door in the face technique?

Anyway, this is the ONLY way that regular people have EVER caused things to change for the better, so take that into consideration. (Whatever counter-example you're thinking of is probably not actually a counter-example)

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by deanCommie on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:44PM (#42650617)
Correct. Most recently, peace in Northern Ireland and the end of Apartheid in South Africa.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:58AM (#42642868)
Why don't you think it's apartheid?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by michaelsshaw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:23AM (#42642615)
>You need to convince other people single payer health care is the right policy.

I think we've effectively already done that. What people actually want does not impact the way in which our government functions, despite popular belief.

The people in this country have absolutely no power and are tired of it. You can't vote out a parasitic system that exists only to extract as much from you as possible. The people who "represent" us only focus on culture war bullshit INTENTIONALLY, to distract from the fact that the one of two preselected candidates we have basically represent the same despicable capitalists and their same interests of stripping us of everything you have so they can have more shit they don't need, while the rest of us are fighting over their droppings.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by imgabe on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:34AM (#42642699)
> What people actually want does not impact the way in which our government functions, despite popular belief.

The US just elected a president despite a years-long coordinated media and legal effort to make him disappear, along with multiple assassination attempts. So, yes, what the people want does actually matter. They just don't happen to want what you think they should want.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by dqv on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:48AM (#42642807)
> So, yes, what the people want does actually matter.

No, it doesn't. Unless what they want aligns with what the ruling class and interest groups want. [0] The propaganda arm of the ruling class, of course, endeavors to get the public on their side precisely because violence ensues when they push too far without public buy-in.

[0]: https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/c...

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by imgabe on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:44AM (#42643188)
Do you think the ruling class wanted Trump elected?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by dqv on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:10AM (#42643716)
The ruling class isn't a monolith (see the linked study), but the consensus is yes:

https://www.opensecrets.org/elections-overview/biggest-donor...

https://americansfortaxfairness.org/billionaire-clans-spend-...

The ruling class used its propaganda arm to manufacture consent for "I don't like him as a person, but he's good for the economy". I imagine this also represents many of their own views on Trump: what they appear to support is not necessarily what they support. That is, they might very publicly and loudly say they don't like him, but they love to see their decreased tax payment come tax season.

None of this is ideologically binary though. The ruling class is going to support whatever it thinks will allow it to continue to be the ruling class. They're not always in 100% agreement on what that is (or, at least, they want to have that appearance). If they aren't careful (and they haven't been as of late) and continue to whittle away at the populace's material conditions, it will lead to more violence, and possibly violent revolution.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by bagels on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:46AM (#42642789)
How do you try to make someone disappear by talking about and showing video of them every day?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by imgabe on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:54AM (#42642842)
You talk about them as a "threat to democracy" in hopes some homicidal lunatic will take it to heart.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by michaelsshaw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:38AM (#42642731)
And four years before that they elected a literal corpse because they were so sick of Donald Trump. And yet, somehow, the 2024 election was borderline the same.

Did literally anyone want Trump v Biden v 2.0? No. Literally nobody wanted that.

Did anyone actually want Kamala? No. Literally nobody wanted that.

>coordinated media and legal effort to make him disappear

Donald Trump is the most reported-on person of the past 10 years. This sentence does not make sense.

>along with multiple assassination attempts

You put this in the same sentence to make it seem like his "assassins" were on the same page as the media. They were not. Both of them were highly ineffective and downright cringey with their plans.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by throwaway48476 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:12AM (#42643729)
Yet one very nearly succeeded.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by xerox13ster on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:35AM (#42643869)
I contend that The People don't know what they want
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by bigstrat2003 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:27AM (#42642654)
> I think we've effectively already done that.

You definitely haven't. Lots of Americans would be deeply unhappy if single payer healthcare were implemented tomorrow. Say what you will about whether they should be convinced, but they haven't been.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mw1 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:51AM (#42643226)
The majority is convinced. Nearly 70% support Medicare for All across multiple polls and that’s with the leadership of both major parties, corporate interests, and news media aligned against.

https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/494602-pol...

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by bagels on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:47AM (#42642796)
Who? Insurance employees?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ZeroGravitas on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:57AM (#42642862)
There's research that supports this. The laws that get passed depend on corporate, not public support.

It's why academics have been referring to the US as an oligarchy for a while now.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by 0xDEAFBEAD on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:57AM (#42642864)
>The people in this country have absolutely no power and are tired of it. You can't vote out a parasitic system that exists only to extract as much from you as possible. The people who "represent" us only focus on culture war bullshit INTENTIONALLY, to distract from the fact that the one of two preselected candidates we have basically represent the same despicable capitalists and their same interests of stripping us of everything you have so they can have more shit they don't need, while the rest of us are fighting over their droppings.

I miss old-school conspiracy theorists like Ron Unz who actually have sophisticated arguments for what they believe.

The internet is now full of handwavey conspiratorial BS that's "not even wrong". Who is writing all of this stuff?

At least the 9/11 truthers made specific false claims.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by michaelsshaw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:09AM (#42642941)
me: "The rich steal from the poor and use politics to divide and distract them"

this guy: "You're literally a 9/11 level conspiracy theorist!!!!!"

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by 0xDEAFBEAD on Thursday January 09, 2025 @07:31PM (#42651296)
Again, the distinction I'm drawing is: 9/11 conspiracy theorists at least tried to present factual arguments for their claims. You haven't done so, and I don't think you ever will. (Insofar as your "claims" can even be hammered down -- they're incredibly vague.)

It's not a point in your favor that your flavor of conspiratorial thinking is so widespread despite its thin evidence base.

https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/america-doesnt-really-have-a-w...

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by hulitu on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:43AM (#42642767)
> Nelson Mandela is not Luigi Mangione.

> This isn't apartheid

You're right. It is just segregation, a thing at which US (still) excels.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by aoanevdus on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:08AM (#42642934)
Nelson Mandela didn’t kill anyone! “Murder is ok” is a really weird message to take home from the knowledge that Nelson Mandela was slandered.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by michaelsshaw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:18AM (#42643005)
I didn't mean to imply he did. But his group, uMkhonto weSizwe, definitely did.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by danlitt on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:29AM (#42643098)
Oh, grow up. Nobody is saying "Murder is ok". They are saying that some killing, sometimes, can be worth it to further a certain political aim, which is obvious to anyone who knows any history.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by aoanevdus on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:35AM (#42643136)
Are you saying the murder of Brian Thompson is ok, or not?

If it’s ok to murder the CEO of a health insurance company, how about the CTO? How about a director? How about a manager of claims adjusters? How about an adjuster?

How about the CEO of Exxon? How about Twitter? What about a engineering manager of the team who actually implements the parts of these companies you think are evil?

Don’t tell me it can’t happen - if lots of people are on Luigi’s side, there will surely be a lot of diversity among the opinions of his followers. Somebody shot 3 people at the YouTube HQ because the company was biased against veganism.

What’s the limiting principle here? Are you sure you aren’t on the “ok to murder” list?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ZYbCRq22HbJ2y7 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:07AM (#42642470)
> He is a murderer?

Assassin, might be the more correct term, not that it isn't inclusive of the other.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_assassinations#:~:text...

> Magione's support is extremely limited, to a very liberal, very online few.

I would imagine asking people if they support an assassin is subject to extreme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social-desirability_bias

I think this is especially likely, given that YouGov pays its panelists.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:15AM (#42642547)
Relying on any form of polls for a political subject after their performance for November 5th is something else, that's all I can say to your edit.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:21AM (#42642598)
I mean the polls weren't really wrong re: 2024? But even if they were, wouldn't such polls, if biased re: Trump and law and order Rs, be worse for Mangione?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:25AM (#42642635)
2024 election polls were wrong. Every single one had it either at a coin-flip odd between the two, or Kamala leading 1 point. It was 2 months ago, this isn't hard to remember.

How it came out, in fact, was Trump winning popular vote with 2 million more votes than kamala, and almost 90 more electoral votes. That's FAR from coin-flip odds, and don't even get me started on the swing state polls, with Trump winning every single one.

-----

Yeah, the biased nature of most people not wanting to publicly sympathize with an early political vigilante WOULD make polls regarding him worse, despite the fact they do. I completely agree with you.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by aoanevdus on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:14AM (#42642979)
Trump won the popular vote by 1.5%, which is a few percent off from the polling average. If the polling on Mangione is similarly off by a few percent (within the margin of error), it hardly affects our interpretation of the results.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:47AM (#42643204)
Give me a break. The polls weren't based on who will get the popular vote. They were based on electoral votes, with swing states polls being that exact toss-up (you can check them again).

He ended up winning every single swing state, muuuch farther than the projections of ANY polls that was getting time-of-day.

Even if you want to die on that purposely misinterpreting hill, it still shows they were inaccurate and unreliable.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by aoanevdus on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:51AM (#42643225)
Let’s take PA since it’s the tipping point state. Polling average had Harris at a 0.2% lead. Actual result was Trump with 1.7% lead. That’s a 1.9% error.

AtlasIntel released a poll which predicted the actual lead: https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/20241102_SwingSta...

So, “muuuch farther than the projections of ANY polls” is wrong.

Correlated error between states is expected, and not relevant (ie. if you think Mangione poll is affected by this few % correlated error, again it doesn’t change the interpretation).

Overall, election results tend to come pretty close to the polls. They are often wrong by a little bit, occasionally by a lot, which is what you’d expect based on the theory of polling and statistics. The conclusion is asking a large random sample of people what they think, using the best methodologies the polling industry has developed, is a pretty good way of finding out what most people think (within a few % margin of error), certainly more objective than a vibe check of your personal echo chamber. If your argument depends on completely dismissing polling results, you’re probably wrong.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:02AM (#42643299)
I thought you were someone else, but now that I know you're not - I want to make something clear: I think that social desirability bias affected the answers of respondents much more [1].

To be clear, that's not the MARGIN of error in those statistics, but rather the difference between predicted and actual. In a five-tier scale, separated between groups, there is already statistical manipulation by having fewer respondents per-category, and therefore a higher margin of error between each. A margin of error even in low single-digit percentages can completely compromise the outcomes of data presented in this fashion.

1 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42643027

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by aoanevdus on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:06AM (#42643328)
How wrong do you believe this poll is? Can you use some methodology to come up with a modified margin of error that encompasses what you believe to be more realistic?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:15AM (#42643360)
"How wrong" is something I can't quantify. It’s tough to pin down a single “modified margin of error,” but I’d say it’s bigger than what the poll shows. Multi-tier questions automatically have smaller sample sizes per option, which inflates the margin of error. Throw in social desirability bias (people not wanting to admit an unpopular opinion) and you get systematic skews on top of random error.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by 0xDEAFBEAD on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:43AM (#42642772)
>2024 election polls were wrong. Every single one had it either at a coin-flip odd between the two, or Kamala leading 1 point. It was 2 months ago, this isn't hard to remember.

>How it came out, in fact, was Trump winning popular vote with 2 million more votes than kamala, and almost 90 more electoral votes. That's FAR from coin-flip odds, and don't even get me started on the swing state polls, with Trump winning every single one.

It sounds like the polls were off about the popular vote by a few percentage points at most.

That meant a lot in the US election context, because the candidates were neck-and-neck.

It wouldn't change the basic picture of Mangione's support in the YouGov poll.

Why do I see so many basic reasoning errors like this on Hacker News? I thought this was supposed to be an intelligent forum with intelligent posters.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:53AM (#42642832)
>"It wouldn't change the basic picture of Mangione's support in the YouGov poll."

My single sentence underneath the horizontal divider in a sub-thread that primarily diverted to discussing the 2024 Election polls, and their accuracy, addresses that. Why didn't you quote that anywhere in your reply?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by 0xDEAFBEAD on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:05AM (#42642912)
See if you can critique your own reasoning first, before asking me to do it more.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:20AM (#42643027)
Tourangeau, R., & Yan, T. (2007). Sensitive questions in surveys. Psychological Bulletin, 133(5), 859–883. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/6117379_Sensitive_Q...

>"Social desirability concerns can be seen as a special case of the threat of disclosure, involving a specific type of interpersonal consequence of revealing information in a survey—social disapproval. The literature on social desirability is voluminous, and it features divergent conceptualizations and operationalizations of the notion of socially desirable responding (DeMaio, 1984). One fundamental difference among the different approaches lies in whether they treat socially desirable responding as a stable personality characteristic or a temporary social strategy (DeMaio, 1984). The view that socially desirable responding is, at least in part, a personality trait underlies psychologists’ early attempts to develop various social desirability scales. Though some of these efforts (e.g., Edwards, 1957; Philips & Clancy, 1970, 1972) recognize the possibility that social desirability is a property of the items rather than (or as well as) of the respondents, many of them treat socially desirable responding as a stable personality characteristic (e.g., Crowne & Marlowe, 1964; Schuessler, Hittle, & Cardascia, 1978). By contrast, survey researchers have tended to view socially desirable responding as a response strategy reflecting the sensitivity of specific items for specific individuals; thus, Sudman and Bradburn (1974) had interviewers rate the social desirability of potential answers to specific survey questions. > >Paulhus’s (2002) work encompasses both viewpoints, making a distinction between socially desirable responding as a response style (a bias that is “consistent across time and questionnaires”; Paulhus, 2002, p. 49) and as a response set (a short-lived bias “attributable to some temporary distraction or motivation”; Paulhus, 2002, p. 49). > >A general weakness with scales designed to measure socially desirable responding is that they lack “true” scores, making it difficult or impossible to distinguish among (a) respondents who are actually highly compliant with social norms, (b) those who have a sincere but inflated view of themselves, and (c) those who are deliberately trying to make a favorable impression by falsely reporting positive things about themselves"

Looking forward to your response.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by 0xDEAFBEAD on Thursday January 09, 2025 @07:25PM (#42651266)
Why is it that so much online discussion of Mangione's actions is supportive?

Wouldn't social desirability bias predict that people would be reluctant to support Mangione's actions in any way which might be traced back to them personally?

Hypothetical evil plutocrats would be far more likely to dig up your social media history to get your take on Mangione than somehow obtain your response to a telephone poll.

The supportive online climate suggests that supporting Mangione could even be more socially desirable. There is social pressure to support him.

In any case, your Harris/Trump example suggests that social desirability effects should be on the order of perhaps 2-3 percentage points in a poll. So it wouldn't represent a drastic change to the overall picture.

My theory: Mangione cleaves society along an "extremely online" vs "touch grass" axis.

The passionate social media addicts, who see conspiracies and exploitation everywhere, support Mangione.

The "touch grass" people understand that healthcare is a systemic problem which requires systemic solutions. Political murders undermine the social contract, increase the likelihood of subsequent political murders, and contribute to the unraveling of society.

The "touch grass" people are underrepresented in online arguments, but well-represented in a randomized poll.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Friday January 10, 2025 @12:26AM (#42652813)
>"Wouldn't social desirability bias predict that people would be reluctant to support Mangione's actions in any way which might be traced back to them personally?"

I think you inadvertently answered your question with the preceding question to this one. Because it's harder to trace back a lot (not all) of individuals from their online identities to personal identities, they're probably more willing to show support for Mangione there, than in places that trace back to them directly.

Who are "touch grass" people? What are you talking about?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by computerfriend on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:04AM (#42642436)
It's not mutually exclusive.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:10AM (#42642505)
Sure -- the two ends of the political horseshoe do seem to admire political violence more and more. But I'd take issue with "revered". Perhaps "revered" among the very liberal and very online, all of whom must certainly be mentally ill to revere political violence in the US in this climate.

And to think what will rise from the ashes of lefty political violence will be a lefty utopia? Of course it will be fascism. Of course.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by y_MAxY on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:48AM (#42642802)
Be careful with this horseshoe theory, as it's been around for more than a century without any real traction in academic research and in fact been very much contradicted by recent studies. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:00AM (#42642884)
This has to be one of the goofiest nitpicks because remove the "horseshoe theory" language from above the point and the above point is the still the same.

"Sure -- the two ends of the political spectrum do seem to admire political violence..."

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gazunklenut on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:14AM (#42642535)
Yeah exatly, like when they murdererd poor old innocent Louis XVI
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:19AM (#42642585)
eye roll Please.

Health care policy isn't war, isn't apartheid, isn't civil rights.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by pm90 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:32AM (#42642686)
People die when they’re denied affordable healthcare. They see their loved ones be treated like shit by insurance companies. Its another form of extreme injustice to those who experience it, similar to war and civil rights.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gazunklenut on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:53AM (#42642831)
Health care policy isn't a civil rights issues?

Don't you think thats jsut so ironic? It's not a civil rights issue in the USA and that is the exact problem.

The healthcare system in America is completely dysfunctional. Countless people's lives are being ruined and lost. Corporations like UnitedHealthcare are intentionally perpetuating this. The leaders of these companies are conciously complicit in all of this.

There are reforms being proposed constantly because of these incredibly predatory and exploitative Corporations, again conciously lead by these leaders.

These Corporations and the people leading them are evil, they're exploiting innocent sick people for profit and they've managed to convince people like you that it's not a civil rights issue. That is the exact problem here.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by amatecha on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:27AM (#42642653)
Oh yeah, speaking of rights...

"Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control."

- https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma...

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by imgabe on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:02AM (#42642898)
The UN isn't going to build you a house or grow you any food or really do anything. It doesn't matter what they say. I can write lots of pretty words about how everyone should have a pony and never be sad when I'm not responsible for making it happen.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by amatecha on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:13AM (#42642977)
It's a set of guidelines, not a set of promises from the UN. Countries/societies/communities are who implement policies and systems that support and correlate with these extremely-broadly-agreed-upon guidelines.

My point is that health care is absolutely an element of rights (though perhaps categorized separately from _civil_ rights, though that's getting quite nitpicky).

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by imgabe on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:48AM (#42643209)
I don't think the UN is the ultimate arbiter of what is or is not a right. Not that something being a "right" really means anything unless you have a way to enforce it.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by amatecha on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:15AM (#42643366)
At the time of this Universal Declaration of Human Rights being published, the UN had 54 member countries[0]. Not sure what organization in human history is better positioned to author such a declaration.

Further, nitpicking around the definition of "rights", or who is worthy of declaring them has zero relevance to the point I'm making - that health care is traditionally an element of human rights policies and/or has a deep connection to the subject of human rights.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Member_states_of_the_United_Na...

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by hulitu on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:50AM (#42642816)
> Oh yeah, speaking of rights...

> "Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family ...

This is only valid for Rusia, China and North Korea. Not for US. /s

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @08:03AM (#42644912)
Why do you think that?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by hilux on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:32AM (#42642689)
I don't think you read the data in article you quoted.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by presentation on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:18AM (#42642575)
Seriously, I get that the US healthcare system is brutal and terrible, but this is not how you handle it (and I don't think insurance companies are even the root of the problem).
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by fuzzfactor on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:44AM (#42642778)
>this is not how you handle it

Correct, it's just how one person handled it.

If it gets worse it'll likely be more than one.

Edit: not my downvote, corrective upvote actually.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by colechristensen on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:51AM (#42642821)
With dysfunctional government and people in power abusing the population, the first step response is unhinged folks doing unhinged things.

> but this is not how you handle it

The problem being that the mechanisms for handling it aren't working (judicial, executive, legislative, regulatory, stockholders, public pressure). The next steps of handling it are unhinged folks doing unhinged things. Several more steps down the road handling it means ordinary folks doing revolutionary things.

This is what long term dysfunctional government not representing the people looks like. This is a result of the politics of fear.

The end of this path looks like a bloodthirsty mob with a guillotine. After the French got disgusted with themselves having executed 30,000 to 50,000 people they overthrew the revolutionaries and were promptly taken over by Napoleon.

The structural problems that lead to this kind of popular support for an unhinged dude assassinating a CEO need to be addressed, and the fix doesn't focus on unhinged dudes or public opinion of them.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by Nullabillity on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:47AM (#42643202)
When citing YouGov, it's worth keeping in mind that they were founded by two conservative politicians. Not exactly the most neutral of sources.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mrtesthah on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:15AM (#42642550)
His “extremely limited support” constitutes 41% of everyone under 30.

https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/5044269-poll-finds-41-...

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:25AM (#42642636)
People under the age of 30, who have never experienced a day of their lives in a broken or failed state which includes political violence as an everyday occurrence, think political violence is a good idea. Because... they like LARPing as downwardly mobile lefties?

Seriously, ask a few asylum seekers from Honduras or El Salvador what they think about political violence. I guarantee you not a one will tell you about how romantic it all is.

Because political violence is obviously something to be scared of, not something to "revere". Like -- we can see it happen elsewhere. We can watch it on the tube every night.

It's not "edgy", Daria. Put down the hair dye and the kitchen sheers. You're too old to play act revolutionary.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by otherme123 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:32AM (#42642690)
You can't go like that: "he doesn't have support", "here's evidence of support", "that doesn't count".

Claiming someone has support is the ad populum falacy, you can argue that. But don't dismiss data because it doesn't support you.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by hilux on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:34AM (#42642695)
Sure, if you diminish and demean absolutely everyone who disagrees with you, then you're left in a bubble where your truth is the only obvious correct one.

I know old white guys who are the same way. The craziest thing is how "open-minded" they imagine themselves to be!

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ZYbCRq22HbJ2y7 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:32AM (#42642688)
> I don't think children who can't solve their disagreements without violence should be listened to

Have you ever heard of these things?

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duel

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War

Seems like the victor in the later gets a lot of people to listen to them.

> It's not "edgy", Daria.

Clearly they should rely on the very mature practice of name calling instead.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ookblah on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:38AM (#42642733)
the irony of this entire post ranting about the views of "children" (classified as people under...30?) when presented with evidence contrary to your beliefs.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by hulitu on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:56AM (#42642858)
> Seriously, ask a few asylum seekers from Honduras or El Salvador what they think about political violence.

Why not ask some US citizens ? Or does assasination attempts at a running candidate does not count as political violence ? Or assasination of a president FWIW ?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by lmm on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:18AM (#42643006)
Can't call him a murderer when he hasn't been convicted yet. (Well, you can, but at that point you can do the same for the guy he shot)
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:55AM (#42642847)
If someone had murdered Hitler I'd support that person. Wouldn't you? Could have saved 11 million lives. But Germany would still have sent him to prison for life because he broke the rules.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gre on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:07AM (#42642927)
Upwards of 75M people assuming ww2 was not inevitable.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by chongli on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:17AM (#42643000)
If Hitler has been assassinated before he came to power then we wouldn’t have any idea of the significance of that. It’d be hard to say anyone would have supported the assassin besides the most ardent of the Nazi party’s political opponents.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:22AM (#42643045)
> If someone had murdered Hitler I'd support that person. Wouldn't you?

You: The UH CEO is another Hitler?

Me: No, that's really stupid.

Mangione is also not MLK Jr. or Mandela.

Stop. You don't understand enough about history to do this here.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:06PM (#42648826)
Would you like to enlighten us on the RELEVANT differences?

I guess he hasn't killed enough people yet? If so, what's the threshold number of people?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by cess11 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:34AM (#42642697)
I'm going to quote it right here so it is clear what you're describing.

"Americans are twice as likely to view Luigi Mangione — who was charged with the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson — very or somewhat unfavorably (43%) than favorably (23%).

    But adults under 30 are more likely to view Mangione favorably than unfavorably (39% to 30%). Those between the ages of 30 and 44 are evenly divided (28% to 29%)
    Liberals are much more likely to view Mangione favorably than are conservatives"
One in four is not "extremely limited". The age group where unfavourable wins clearly is 44+.

This poll report also suffers from the US brain worm that calls everything but the far right "liberal". It's likely most of those that see Mangione's direct action favourably are actually leftists, and some fascists of the kind that follow Ben Shapiro and commented negatively about his coverage.

The US healthcare profiteers have killed many more people than Mangione, likely thousands, since he killed Thompson.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by mustache_kimono on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:39AM (#42642743)
> One in four is not "extremely limited". The age group where unfavourable wins clearly is 44+.

Some age groups, which on the whole don't vote, view Mangione more favorably than others, but still view him unfavourably.

Okay.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by lazide on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:51AM (#42642819)
Also the age group that tends to make up the vast majority of rebels, revolutionaries, criminals, soldiers, etc….
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:54AM (#42642837)
It's not the first time they've done this. They've consistently done it with Gaza. When they do cover it at all, it's only to paint protestors as terrorists. (Yet the France vs Israel sportsball match was played to a three quarters empty stadium because that many people hate Israe now)
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gorororog on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:49AM (#42643216)
How does an empty stadium equate hate?

Seems more like not caring to me.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by llm_trw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:08AM (#42642478)
It's a shame that these people don't read, because if they did they see just how often the rich and powerful were murdered during the gilded age. From Wallstreet to St. Petersburg everyone from Emperors to titans of industry was assassinated by those with nothing left to lose. It's almost like income equality is there to keep them alive and to keep another world war from breaking out.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by martin-t on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:43AM (#42642775)
But that _have_ learned. They are systematically making violence a taboo the way sex was in the past.

If all people think violence is wrong and immoral instead of just against the rules they have written ("laws"), then they can keep writing rules that suit them even more and more without any pressure against it.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by raincole on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:49AM (#42642814)
Except almost every blockbuster movie, rap song and mainstream video game romanticizes and heroizes violence.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by martin-t on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:56AM (#42642859)
Yes but try to apply the same rules to real life and people will laugh at you.

How many times do you see the hero having to choose between killing the villain and leaving him to the legal system (not justice system) to give him a lesser punishment?

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by chongli on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:06AM (#42642922)
This whole story was started by the fact that countless people have begun to revere Luigi Mangione as a Robin Hood-like folk hero. Whatever taboo put in place against violence seems to have failed in this case.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by martin-t on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:18AM (#42643007)
Yep, if you boil the frog too fast, it will notice.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by hackable_sand on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:10PM (#42648286)
When people say "staring daggers", do you think they are actually trying to stab someone?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by tokinonagare on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:02AM (#42642897)
I have a theory for a long time that "democracy" as a concept is pushed so strongly in the West not because it really favors people nor for its effectiveness but because it nulls political assassinations and delegitimates them. Thus it is an extremely good system for the rulers.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by immibis on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:04AM (#42642911)
A system with fewer assassinations is a better system, if all else is equal. Unfortunately, all else is not equal.

Democracy should be an alternative to violence: Instead of murdering the next Hitler, you can just vote him out. Unfortunately, this only applies as long as it works. American democracy has not worked for a very long time.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by martin-t on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:06AM (#42642921)
Not just vote him out, that solves all his future murders. Depending on when he was votes out, he still needs to be punished for all his past murders.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ZYbCRq22HbJ2y7 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:04AM (#42642907)
Resorting to violence over other non-violent means to resolve disputes is often a symptom of weak institutional capacity, and one could argue that this instance of violence is such a symptom.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by martin-t on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:20AM (#42643029)
It's a tug of war between institutional capacity (people's inability to act) and injustice (people's willingness to act even if they will face negative consequences).
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by manquer on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:01AM (#42642891)
> taboo the way sex was

Was it? the puritanical views in some western social groups is hardly how the whole world saw sex, even in those western societies sex was seen differently as long as it was within the same class.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by HaZeust on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:28AM (#42643087)
>"even in those western societies sex was seen differently as long as it was within the same class."

Same with violence! Not too much institutional change made for gang violence between 13-21 year olds in Chicago - as long as they're in the same class.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by lazide on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:45AM (#42642785)
Do you think assassinating arch-dukes was being sold as virtuous back then either? Especially by the churches which were the moral arbiters of the time?

Plenty of people were still in favor, clearly.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by martin-t on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:54AM (#42642843)
The difference is in the past most discourse was by mouth - impossible to censor and eavesdropping was costly because you needed a person to do it.

These days more and more discourse is online

- heavily censored by platform rules which are much more strict than laws, partially because it makes the moderator's job easier to err on the side of caution, partially because it teaches people to self censor which then extends into real life

- censorship can be automated and even invisible (shadowbanning, fake degradation of QoL, ...)

- eavesdropping is also automated and omnipresent

The real danger of AI or LLMs these days is not they machines will want to kill us but that powerful people will use them to mass-profile everyone and stop any dissent from spreading.

Do you think China will have a revolution and restore democracy? How? How will people organize?

And every currently democratic state will be the same - democracy only needs to fail once and it will be almost impossible to restore.

---

EDIT: Even word of mouth is in danger, sufficiently powerful organizations are or will be able to access microphones near you. Or cameras for lip reading. Again, en-masse, automated by AI.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by llm_trw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:26AM (#42643067)
By the Serbian orthodox Church?

https://images.app.goo.gl/dqHBEnQvy2hc6RHD8

This is them blessing the troops to go kill the Austrians a month later.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by lazide on Thursday January 09, 2025 @04:03AM (#42643306)
Sure, after the declaration of war by the state. The Church (depending on which definition you use) sponsored plenty of Crusades too. None of these actions are ‘rebel against the machine’.

Though that does sometimes happen, usually leading to/in the middle of a civil war.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by grujicd on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:54PM (#42648719)
It was a blessing for a defensive war. Serbians didn't "go" anywhere to attack Austrians. It was the other way around. But I guess you already know that. Why did you choose to write "to go kill" when they didn't go anywhere?
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by llm_trw on Thursday January 09, 2025 @07:18PM (#42651217)
Any society that stigmatizes violence is soon overtaken by one that doesn't.

The west is in terminal decline and will be replaced by a cult from the middle east. This is the third time this has happened.

The only annoying thing is that I'll need to learn Arabic. English was bad enough.

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by lyu07282 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:14AM (#42642980)
True but I think it just shows that this isn't malicious on their part, like journalists and politicians aren't all uniformly intentionally creating and maintaining a broken healthcare system that murders¹ thousands of people and bankrupts an estimated 650k people a year. It's rather the very natural result of their ideology, if the same people had to rebuilt the healthcare system the end result would be identical.

There is a reason why Bernie is universally despised by all of them, this is the shared ideology, its this unspoken thing that every CNN and FOX news anchor, every nypost and nyt journalist, Obama, Bush, Biden and Trump all have in common. That's why this Luigi situation was so eye-opening to many people, it showed the cracks in the system. None of those people will ever be part of the solution, it's all of them collectively we need to overcome.

¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_murder

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by ActorNightly on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:26AM (#42642642)
Honestly, they are just playing the rulebook of "lets not get into regulartory waters". The reality is that no one on either side really gives a shit that much, as proven by recent elections.
Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by gorgoiler on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:42AM (#42642761)
An aspect worth considering: everyone with a large investment in civil society is opposed to murderous vigilantism, and while that includes the economic 1%, the fellow CEOs, the Media Industrial Complex*, et al., it also includes a much more boring demographic: simple, decent folk who are opposed to violence and law-breaking.

The status quo behaviour of Stack Exchange and others is pandering, but it’s just as likely to be pandering to mom and pop as it is to Musk and Murdoch.

* tongue-in-cheek

Re:Luigi Mangione's account has been renamed on Stack Overflow by maeil on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:54AM (#42642839)
This doesn't take away from your point, but what defines violence? I recently asked this to someone here but unfortunately did not get an answer [1].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42566862