News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by simonbw on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:47PM (#42639891)
I went to UW a decade ago, and back then it was pretty common knowledge that you don't fuck with software and the class registration system. Registering for classes was really competitive and they were really strict about making sure that no one had an edge over anyone else by being able to write code. There were plenty of rumors of people being expelled for using scripts to try to get the classes they wanted right when they opened. I also believe they forbid or at least frowned on students "trading" registrations, because they didn't want even more people trying to sign up for high value classes and trading them as a commodity.

So at least back when I went there, basically any CS student could have told you that this website was a horrible idea that is sure to get you in trouble.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by isotypic on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:51PM (#42640357)
I am somewhat surprised issues of scripting and trading even exist in the registration system. Staggering enrollment times over a few days, with new waves every 20 minutes or so, mostly solves scripting issues since you are only competing with a fraction of the student body now. Giving courses waitlists once they are full, instead of allowing people to just directly register once a spot frees up, makes trading impossible since if you could trade you could have just registered for the course anyways.

I understand that the registration system is probably old and tied up in tons of just as old management software, but if the university really cared the solutions should be there.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by loeg on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:28PM (#42640967)
So, for context, UW's registration system runs on, like, a single 1980s VAX.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by lupire on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:44AM (#42646099)
I didn't know VAX had web APIs.

Do you know that software can be used to build a wrapper layer around other software?

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by twodave on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:51AM (#42646189)
It's much easier to build a gateway API for a legacy system than to extend it. Not disagreeing with you. Honestly, though, software systems for academic institutions are ridiculously complicated, because they are essentially a student portal, a school, a sales organization, a rules engine, etc. etc. all wrapped up into one and interconnected in ways that aren't obvious on the surface.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by confidentlyinc on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:11PM (#42648294)
That is confidently incorrect
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by dpedu on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:16PM (#42649452)
The school I attended in 2010 had a system like this as well. Awful backend with a simple, but still awful, web interface to talk to it. There was rumor you could telnet in and use an actual text interface, but I never saw it.

The system was replaced a few years later with an Oracle PeopleSoft implementation. Everybody hated it more.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by campbel on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:40AM (#42641988)
I went to school about 20 years ago and we had staggered online registrations. Surprised the best solutions haven't propagated further.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by wil421 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:59AM (#42647562)
Pretty much every schools uses staggered registrations to allow upper class men or even athletes the ability to get classes they need.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by buildbot on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:47AM (#42647426)
When I went there it was staggered, which causes this desire for spot trading - seniors register first, so if you are an freshman/sophomore/junior, you beg a senior to register a spot in a class you want then coordinate them deregistering just before you register for the class. This automated that and at scale could be a big issue.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by potato3732842 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:26PM (#42650487)
Punishing people is easy. Changing process is hard, especially when you're a dysfunctional bureaucracy.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by uwthrowaway on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:06PM (#42640035)
UW cs student - most current cs students would still know that this would get you in trouble.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by hirvi74 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:46PM (#42640708)
> they were really strict about making sure that no one had an edge over anyone else by being able to write code.

Or you know, they could have just improved their registration system so this wouldn't be an issue... But hey, I'm sure UW raises their tuition every year for good reasons and the money is well spent.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by scotty79 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:00PM (#42640802)
This is so bizarre to me that I'm not sure if I understand it correctly. They soft lock him out of UW system which will get him expelled for having an idea for an app for trading spots in classes and implementing a demo with fake data and using the token they provided him with to download data that is public already? And then they try to blackmail him with a promise of restoring system access to do unpaid compelled work for them?
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by loeg on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:29PM (#42640970)
I'd heard of people writing these kinds of scripts but never heard of anyone getting expelled for it (ca. 2010).
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by DaSHacka on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:20AM (#42641885)
At my University, scripts like these are pretty much universal.

We even have an alumni-run site that scrapes the registration platform's API for the details of every course to provide a better UI interface.

It even has a tool to generate an AutoHotkey script so students can insta-register for all their classes seconds after registration opens up for them (it's usually a mad rush at midnight when course registration opens for freshman/sophomores as they all compete for the remaining course slots left after seniors and juniors have already registered).

Seems inane an institution would crack down on it.

We even have another alumni-run site that does nothing but FOIA the average GPA of all courses from every professor; While I can't imagine the university is thrilled about it, as it's completely legal they haven't tried to pressure the creators to shut it down afaik.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by macNchz on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:04AM (#42645613)
> Seems inane an institution would crack down on it.

Mad rushes to register requiring people to use automations like that sounds like a bad system to me, and something the university should be trying to address. That said, rather than a crackdown on tools, it’d make more sense to implement a harder-to-game system like spreading registration across a long period and assigning students to have their access unlock at a random time during the period. My college had time-slot (in person!) appointments like that 20 years ago.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by mmcwilliams on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:19PM (#42648367)
If the university offers an API then it's not a "scrape". If you're describing unauthorized use of an API then you've disclosed a possible CFAA violation, not web scraping.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by DaSHacka on Thursday January 09, 2025 @05:09PM (#42650324)
I have no idea how they do it, and I don't care if they're breaking the CFAA; Neither are my problem.

Though they do claim to obtain at least some of their information using an API, so if it's the word "scrape" you take issue with in the post, perhaps "queries" is a better fit.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by mmcwilliams on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:05PM (#42652037)
It's no skin off my back if they're violating it, just clarifying that was what you could be describing. Considering this post is about a student facing expulsion, what you were saying could lead the developers to worse outcomes.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by asdffdasy on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @10:09PM (#42641205)
it's almost like universities are about controlling an artificial limited access to knowledge than about knowledge uh.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by gonzobonzo on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:02PM (#42641489)
That's what bothers me the most about this. The reason this is even an issue in the first place is because universities are aren't adequately providing what the students want.

So you want to study, say, engineering.

First you have to apply and get admitted to the university, and many people aren't admitted. The acceptance rate I can find for UW is 54% in-state, 46% out of state.

Then the university tells you that if you want to study engineering, you have to study a lot of other non-engineering things it feels like you should study. All of which are pretty costly and time consuming.

You might have to take courses in things you already know, because there are few courses you can test out of and the universities limit how many credits it can bring over.

Then on top of this, the universities don't provide anywhere near enough adequate quality classes for students, which is the whole reason why there's this level of demand in the first place.

Not only do they not provide enough, they know they don't provide enough, so their response is since it's "really competitive" they need to be "really strict about making sure that no one had an edge over anyone else." It's not about making sure students needs are being met, even for classes that the university is forcing on them. It's about restricting students, so that they suffer a roughly equal amount from the university's failures.

The attitude of the universities seems to be that since they're the only game in town, students have to suffer through all of this. Imagine a system where students could take classes from anywhere they want, and then could get a degree just by passing assessments at the university. I imagine the number of people paying huge amounts of money for inadequate classes would plummet.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by lupire on Thursday January 09, 2025 @09:46AM (#42646117)
It's not the university's fault that the taxpayers refuse to fund a larger school.

Edit per reply: $1M/yr for the President is less than $50/student/year. Not funding more classes for students.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by pc86 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:24AM (#42646543)
The president of UW makes $912,000 a year. They have plenty of money, they're just not allocating it on the things they should be.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by pc86 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:24AM (#42646538)
Having admissions is an objective good though. Yes there's some gatekeeping aspects to it. But smart people want to be around smart people. I went to a school that I got into easily and if I could change one thing that I did in HS I would apply to more schools and try to go to the one that I barely got into.

Study other things is good too. I went to a liberal arts school for this. I studied politics, chemistry, computer science, Chinese language, South African history, Russian literature. Of course me knowing how to count to ten in Mandarin or being able to talk about the influences of Dostoevsky never helped me get a job but being well-rounded is an objectively Good Thing. I don't think you should have 60 credits of gen eds but a semester or two worth of non-STEM classes over 2-3 years is not going to hurt anyone.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by tiborsaas on Saturday January 11, 2025 @02:15AM (#42663979)
> Imagine a system where students could take classes from anywhere they want...

Udemy and friends are exactly like that. The only thing the platform can't replicate is the community feeling. Sitting at home isolated is not for everyone.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by yard2010 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:01AM (#42642889)
It's funny how a perfectly organized crime is not crime at all
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by gorgoiler on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:32PM (#42641660)
Non-transferable class registrations decided by lottery would solve this. Publicly visible, physical random number generation is important of course.

With pre-registration you can also get an idea of demand in advance, instead of having to post-hoc schedule additional classes (or concert tour dates, or airline flights, or PS5 units, or… etc.)

Non-transferability means the lottery is continuous. As soon as anyone relinquishes their class, the lottery will have to run again to reallocate. You could do this daily.

This is a technical solution that works but it overlooks the cultural side of a resource allocator wanting their resource to generate hype and demand, build up to the Big Event, and then sell out in “record time”. I can understand that a big part of University marketing is to try to seem as popular and oversubscribed as possible, even if I don’t agree with it.

Finally of course, the public RNG bit feels like the most interesting. A giant continuous dice tumbler in the middle of UW’s Red Square? The tumbler feels easy, but how would you make a physical ledger to record the dice rolls automatically?

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by pc86 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:07AM (#42646351)
The idea of transferring registration from one student to another without input from the university is bananas to me. But only slightly more stupid than not having waitlists which is the only reason that exists in the first place.

My alma mater let people register in descending order of number of completed credits with a C or better (e.g. 2.0), and then GPA, in waves. Same with dorm sign ups which were required for everyone but seniors. It worked out great and professors always had enough slack to let special cases in if they felt compelled to.

Making it random seems like a bad idea to me. It's "fair" only insofar as randomness is fair. For high-demand classes isn't it more "fair" that people who will graduate sooner and/or have done better in their classes thus far should have the first opportunity to get those classes?

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by gorgoiler on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:26PM (#42649011)
I really like the point you make about randomness being bad as well, albeit in different ways. I’m not sure if I agree on the prior-grade route, not for freshmen at least but that does make a lot of sense for the later years.

Overall, randomness, like democracy, might be the least worst option.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by pc86 on Friday January 10, 2025 @09:11AM (#42655693)
IMO randomness removes accountability. Imagine needing a class to graduate and the gods of the PRNG don't allow you to register in time.

Better to have at least one aspect within your control (e.g. completed credits or GPA). I'd much rather have to go to school for another semester because I'm lazy and drank too much than just getting cursed by bad luck.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by IshKebab on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:46AM (#42642790)
If they didn't want people trading registrations why not just... not allow them to trade reservations? I can't trade plane tickets, and that isn't because of some implied threat.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by nlawalker on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:04AM (#42646323)
The "trading" is all out of band, the system only sees one person drop their registration and another person fill the slot.

When someone drops a class, the opening becomes available immediately, so you coordinate a time well after the registration rush has died down for one person to click "drop" and the other to refresh the page and click "register". At least that's how it worked when I did it 20 years ago. It was relatively common in the Greek system not to "trade" a class for a class but rather a class for a few beers or the like: prior to registration, if you were an underclassman who really needed to get into a class next quarter that you knew filled up quickly, you'd find an upperclassman (who get access to the system earlier) who was eligible for the class you needed and wasn't full on credits to grab a slot, then a couple days before classes started, you'd have them drop and then grab it for yourself.

At that time (early 2000s), polling bots weren't common, but there were rumors, so people doing this got more careful and actually sat next to each other with their laptops to coordinate the drop and add instead of just picking a time or date.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by gms7777 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:32AM (#42647272)
I feel like if the university has an issue with it, this could all be fixed by just adding course waitlists. Which is how it was handled at both my undergrad and grad university
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by gowld on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:31PM (#42649046)
polling bots were absolutely common by 2000
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by IshKebab on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:28PM (#42649549)
So have a queue?
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by 93po on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:06AM (#42646337)
or you know, offer more of the desirably classes, or charge extra for them, or give people "fun bucks" to register for classes and the more desirable ones cost more fun bucks
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by pc86 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:20AM (#42646498)
High-demand classes are bi-modal. The left side of the distribution is the low-level intro and survey courses. I went to a very heavily pre-med undergrad with a total enrollment of about 1,500 where the intro Chemistry course had two 100-150-person survey courses with multiple TAs. Charging more for these is pretty stupid. The answer is to offer more of them if you have the physical space, the professor(s), and the TA(s) to do it, which you don't always have.

The right side is the 5- or 6-person high level classes offered every other year or something. Usually, but not always, these are in demand because professors are not fungible at this level and they're probably taught by a popular or famous professor. I took one of these at my school taught by a former cabinet secretary, just four of us seniors and him talking about politics for 4 hours every week. You can't just offer more of these; if you're teaching one class every other Spring you're unlikely to seriously consider changing that to two Fall and two Spring classes every year.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by 93po on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:45AM (#42647406)
god forbid schools get more desirable instructors when, in a class of 100 students, they're getting paid close to $200k in revenue if they're charging $600 per credit hour, which is on the low side, and making hundreds of millions per year off of endowment investments
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by pc86 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:00PM (#42647569)
You'll get no argument from me on higher ed misspending the majority of their funds. You could remove 80% of all US higher ed administration from the workforce forever and I'm convinced there would be no noticeable negative impact on the economy. IMO it's one of the careers with the largest gap between how important the people in it think they are vs. how much of a real impact they actually have.

I was just pointing out that there are two competing reasons why classes end up with long waitlists or people who graduate having never had the chance to take them so it's not a simple "Do _________" and it's fixed.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by pc86 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:13AM (#42646418)
It's an unintended consequence of the system being so laughably out of date and so poorly designed it doesn't support waitlists.

Allowing infinitely large waitlists for a given class - which even in the most convoluted legacy system imaginable is not that big of a challenge - and trading disappears overnight.

It's not a problem for the university directly, and fixing it would cost money, so there's no incentive to do it. Gotta make sure there's enough money to keep paying the president $76,000 every month, after all.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by ikrenji on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:41PM (#42648590)
it's a disgrace that a university administrator makes over a million a year... in a public school to boot
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by themaninthedark on Friday January 10, 2025 @04:49PM (#42660668)
Look up how much other(k-12) school administrators make, then look at how many administrators there are now(middle and high schools now have multiple principles and vice principals). Education spending is at an all time high, teacher pay is still low and the results haven't gotten better.

People complain about Teacher Unions all the time but I would hazard that the problem is the creeping middle management.