Remember Monica? She was a Stack moderator who got in trouble over Stack's new Code of Conduct a few years back.
The Code required using people's pronouns if they listed them. Monica always used gender-neutral pronouns and wanted to keep doing so, but Stack took issue with this.
Pronouns are a pretty standard part of interacting with someone in English -- and so is the "thank you" in GP's Stack post. So why is one social convention mandatory while one is forbidden?
Because it's not about what's on topic and what isn't. It's about archetypes. And the highest archetype for a certain kind of programmer is the Vulcan. Be respectful, be noble, but don't "waste time" on pleasantries that are just there to convey warmth and friendliness.
The problem is that not all programmers are Vulcans, and more and more non-Vulcans have become programmers as coding has become more and more mainstream. But Stack essentially set up test cases for how Vulcan its users are. That tends to be an alienating culture for those who aren't.
Reddit has similar problems in some expertise subs and when it boils over a new one will be formed. You can’t do that with Stack sites. Stackexchange has had the advantage of content but when that is available through friendlier and more user friendly methods it’ll really hurt their numbers.
Editing other people's questions to remove parts that are not necessary can seem hostile, but that is not the intent behind this rule.
It does speak to the culture of editing/moderation on SO, though. For many people, myself included, it simply does not work.
That said I haven't logged in to StackOverflow for years.
As a user just searching for an answer to my technical question I don't want to see flame wars, cultural exchanges, needlessly verbose text, bad grammar, political discussions and anything else that makes it longer and more difficult to get from point A to B. Similar to how I don't go on Wikipedia to experience the article writer's language skills or culture. There are plenty of other forums (ahem Reddit) for all that.
It was nice to be able to find answers on the internet while it lasted.
If there is a disease of modern social media, it's that.
> This is incredibly toxic and stupid, contributes nothing
It's almost like the toxic people who whined about toxic social media became mods everywhere. The most toxic people tend to be the mods in my experience.
> The site years ago was an amazing resource of like minded people helping each other.
Then a few years ago, SO along with many/all social media sites became trash. Almost in tandem. Wonder why and how.
And that's before we even get to the hair-trigger question closing and downvoting. It's always the early votes that are negative too - from the weirdo power users that trawl new questions. They don't understand the question (it's not for them) so they downvote. Then later you get people who have the same question coming from Google who understand it upvoting.
This is incredibly toxic and stupid, contributes nothing, and as such, it's not worth providing your expertise for free. The site years ago was an amazing resource of like minded people helping each other. The only cure would be to stop community moderation and do professional only, as well as guide the noobs to resources like chatgpt first for "how to I write a hello world", while sorting the quality questions onto the front page.