News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by dijit on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @06:57PM (#42570329)
There’s a bunch of evidence that this isn't true.

People seem to choose quality when they have an option. The rise of Apple is not because people are “sheep”, it’s because there is a quality level that apple products never go beneath- even if the design is stupid.

People can forgive poor quality with innovation, or in the pursuit of pure art- but the more crappy things get the more you notice people gravitating towards higher quality items/content.

The “issue” is when there’s a total monopoly or an oligopoly that is racing to the bottom, which seems to happen quite often, because building high margin things tends to be more risky, and MBAs are risk averse.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by steveBK123 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:00PM (#42570341)
I think given enough time and experience where people can discover rock bottom dollars isn’t working, they will gravitate towards higher perceived value per dollar.

Apple won only after windows gave average home users a horrific bsod/virus/reboot hell of an existence for about 20 years.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by ronsor on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:16PM (#42570425)
It's also good to remember that Macs weren't exactly that stable until Mac OS X.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by Nevermark on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:29PM (#42570501)
Even so, the more Windows machines I had back in the day, the less real work I got done. Something was always not working, with no obvious pattern. Most problems took work to fix.

I learned not to install and uninstall things. Even if I needed to.

The more Mac’s I had, the more likely I ran into a problem as well. But it was usually just some glitch.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by steveBK123 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:35PM (#42570539)
Some of us remember the 90s-00s era of debugging non-tech family & friends windows machines for various critical ailments with great frequency until they all switched to Macs.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by Clubber on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:12PM (#42571001)
>Some of us remember the 90s-00s era of debugging non-tech family & friends windows machines for various critical ailments with great frequency until they all switched to Macs.

I second this. My mom switched to a iMac G4 and never needed me again, except that time she plugged the power strip into itself.

It got to the point where I didn't want to tell people I worked with computers.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by detourdog on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:22PM (#42570460)
They were stable enough and the plug and play actually worked.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by steveBK123 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:24PM (#42570470)
And yet people kept buying windows and whining about it many versions of OS X later.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by tonyedgecombe on Saturday January 04, 2025 @02:47AM (#42593226)
Nor was Windows in the 95/98/Me era, it was a Hobson's choice back then.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by leptons on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @08:09PM (#42570718)
How did Apple "win"? They have always been a fraction of the market share of desktop/laptop computers, and they are only popular on mobile in the US, worldwide Android is dominant with 72% of the market. If you mean money===success, then sure, they have money, but do you compare their money to all the companies making PCs and all the companies making Android phones in the world combined? Apple fans have 1 single company to choose from, but PC/Android fans have hundreds of options - I can get a PC or Android in hundreds of form factors, whatever I need but Apple only sells what Apple makes. Sounds to me like PC/Android fans are the real "winners".

>Apple won only after windows gave average home users a horrific bsod/virus/reboot hell of an existence for about 20 years.

This hasn't been a thing for a very long time. I hear about as much about the spinning beach ball of death as I do BSOD. Apple is by no means perfect, or did you forget "you're holding it wrong".

Re:Most people don't care about quality by steveBK123 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:57PM (#42571182)
Everyone is a winner of their own story
Re:Most people don't care about quality by CamJN on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:19PM (#42571298)
AAPL 3.785T > MSFT 3.134T. In the only measure that matters for American companies, Apple won.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by brightlancer on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:21AM (#42572185)
That's a silly comparison: by that metric, Apple "won" against Saudi Aramco and Berkshire Hathaway, and Microsoft also "won" against them.

Except that they aren't in the same business.

On the desktop, Microsoft is still kicking Apple's ass. Even moreso for servers. The only place Apple "won" is on mobile, where Microsoft lost to _everybody_.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by steveBK123 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @08:31AM (#42574236)
I can't find the exact stat right now with some light google, but I recall there was a stat that while Apple doesn't have majority of user base, they essentially have an outsized share of the profit due to the average sales price & associated profit margins.

In Windows space, MSFT gets their license money, and then its a commodity race to the bottom by the hardware makers who need to pay AMD/Intel for chips, MSFT for a license, and compete with 100 no-names OEMs for every penny.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by iamacyborg on Thursday January 02, 2025 @11:53AM (#42576093)
> The only place Apple "won" is on mobile

They won on MP3 players.

They won on music stores.

They won on mobile.

They won on laptops.

They won on headphones.

Etc.

I'm not an Apple fanboy by any stretch of the imagination but it's immediately obvious that they've "won" more than just the mobile market.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by leptons on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:33PM (#42577245)
>They won on MP3 players.

Sure I guess if you're still living in 2010. Nobody uses an "mp3 player" anymore. Get with the times grampa. Everyone has a cellphone that plays MP3s today.

> They won on music stores.

Spotify is at 36% market share compared to Apple's 30% of the music streaming market.

>They won on mobile.

And Apple did not "win on mobile" - only in the US are they popular, but globally Android has 72% market share. Apple lost the mobile market to Android a long time ago.

>They won on laptops.

No, Apple did not "win on laptops", they are still at about 9% market share.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_share_of_personal_compu...

"As of the third quarter of 2020, HP was cited as the leading vendor for notebook computers closely followed by Lenovo, both with a share of 23.6% each. They were followed by Dell (13.7%), Apple (9.7%) and Acer (7.9%)."

Nothing has really changed since 2020. Apple will always be a tiny portion of the personal computer and laptop market.

>They won on headphones.

huh? There are far better headphones than anything Apple makes. Are you talking about earbuds? There's a difference.

No, Apple has not "won" on anything but having overpriced hardware. $3600 for a VR headset? Yeah, I guess they "won" most ridiculously overpriced hardware ever.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by tonyedgecombe on Saturday January 04, 2025 @02:45AM (#42593217)
>On the desktop, Microsoft is still kicking Apple's ass.

Microsoft won in the enterprise. They are steadily loosing market share outside of it.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by steveBK123 on Saturday January 04, 2025 @09:55AM (#42595034)
Arguably in the long run, Amazon is winning enterprise in ways Google never did. MSFT owns enterprise desktop / desktop collab use cases (and any virtualization / server side stuff to support it) only.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by Gigachad on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:54PM (#42571489)
Apple has won for people who can afford quality. If a student has $400 for a laptop, it doesn’t matter how much they appreciate quality, they can’t afford the MacBook and will buy something cheaper.

Anecdotally, I work in a coworking space with lots of businesses in Australia, and I’d say about 85% of people in the office space have MacBooks.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by leptons on Thursday January 02, 2025 @03:07AM (#42572661)
What quality? We had to sue Apple in a class action because the motherboard in our MBP (and many other people's) died 7 times and the 8th time it happened Apple wanted to charge us $1200 to replace it again. We had to sue them, but we won.

> I’d say about 85% of people in the office space have MacBooks.

That doesn't prove quality. All it proves is you are in an echo chamber. I've worked in lots of corporate environments that were all PC and some that were all Apple, and a few that were mixed. All it really depends on is if the company values appearances or functionality, and appearances are one of Apple's main value propositions.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by detourdog on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:21PM (#42570450)
During that 20 years experts dismissed Apple as dying and too risky windows was the smart investment just like VHS.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by steveBK123 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:26PM (#42570483)
Mostly windows machines of comparable spec could be had for 10% less, but most importantly there were many OEMs willing to sell objectively bad underspecced machines that were 50-75% cheaper than the cheapest Mac. Remember the era when people had overheating laptops etc.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by detourdog on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:38PM (#42570554)
Price comparing Macs and PCs has rarely been accurate. The experts I remember would hammer the price difference and say Apple was dying so the investment isn’t worth it.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by devmor on Thursday January 02, 2025 @10:24AM (#42575212)
This is happening again now, with a new addition (well, resurgent) of insidious price cutting strategy: adware.

Ed Zitron goes into it in a recent article rant here[1] (skip to the "direct example" section if you're not interested in the rest of the read) where he reviews the best selling laptop on Amazon, which is ridiculously cheap... at a devil's bargain.

1. https://www.wheresyoured.at/never-forgive-them/

Re:Most people don't care about quality by steveBK123 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @10:52AM (#42575471)
At this point it’s like the old story about boots - too poor to afford cheap ones.

Most people would be better served with a $600 Mac mini that will literally still be working & better in 5 years than in buying a $300 Amazon deal with 4GB ram which will run awful and die right outside warranty period. Maybe in a couple years apple will have prior year minis a little cheaper / refurbs available at $450-500ish too.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by Dylan16807 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @04:49PM (#42579318)
$240 for that, huh.

I just bought a $280 Acer laptop, still limited storage but better class, twice the ram, and with a CPU that actually has performance cores so it runs 2.5x-5x faster.

It came with chromeOS, which is a limiting factor, but in this particular comparison it sounds like it's more of an upside than a downside.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by dehrmann on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:52PM (#42571727)
> Apple won only after windows...

Apple won after Sony dropped the ball on HDD Walkmans and Nokia, Motorola, Palm, and Blackberry failed to reject carrier bloatware.

Macs are a side hustle for Apple, and MS is still the dominant player for desktop computing.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by SoftTalker on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:21PM (#42576370)
Apple has never "won" in the sense that Windows has always had by far more installed desktops.

Android also by far runs more phones than iOS.

Apple "won" the wealthy Western market, which is all that has ever mattered to them.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by scarface_74 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:25PM (#42570474)
The iPhone especially in America is a unique case.

Sure the average selling price of an iPhone is $500 more than an Android. But all of the major and even minor carriers either subsidize the phone or have no interest payment plans between 24-36 months. The price difference is negligible over 3 years.

No other product is like that. Even today in the US, the Mac only has around 15% market share.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by tokinonagare on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:34PM (#42570527)
> The iPhone especially in America is a unique case.

iPhones have a >50% market share in Japan, Canada, and in a few European countries (Danmark, Sweden). The common point I see between all those is that they are high-income countries.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by tredre3 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:15PM (#42571019)
> Sure the average selling price of an iPhone is $500 more than an Android.

The only honest way of comparing Android to iPhone pricing, in my opinion, is to compare flagships.

The S24 and the Pixel 9 are the exact same price as the iPhone 16. The S24+ is more expensive than the iPhone 16 Pro.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by scarface_74 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:33PM (#42571100)
And if you only talk about market share in the premium market, it’s even more skewed to iOS.

Google Pixel phones only make up 4% of the US market.

https://chromeunboxed.com/google-pixel-phone-sales-see-their...

And Samsung sells around 31 million S24 phones

https://www.phonearena.com/news/samsung-2024-goal-sell-more-...

Android users aren’t buying high end phones for the most part

Re:Most people don't care about quality by dagmx on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:18PM (#42571033)
While I agree with your larger point, I just wanted to point out some inaccuracies

> Sure the average selling price of an iPhone is $500 more than an Android

FWIW this is only true if you’re not comparing within market segments.

If you stick to the same market segment, then they’re about on par with equivalent Android phones for price. They just don’t have anything in the real budget categories.

> The iPhone especially in America is a unique case

The iPhone market share is relative to the premium phone market share of most locations. Which in turn is relative to the spending power of the populations.

iPhones dominate the premium market share compared to Android. I’m actually curious what the Mac market share is when framed to just “premium devices, and non-gaming”.

I suspect, but cannot backup, that Macs do relatively well if constrained to that market. But most people who have premium computers do so for gaming, and the ones who want budget don’t have a Mac to cater to them.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by x0x0 on Thursday January 02, 2025 @05:57PM (#42579939)
> They just don’t have anything in the real budget categories

Not sure what you define as budget categories, but apple sell the iphone se for $429 new on their site now. And you can get one through eg Tmobile for $250 or $50 + $10 a month for 24 months. Or the 64gb version for just that $10 a month. So I think they do compete in the budget category?

Re:Most people don't care about quality by dagmx on Thursday January 02, 2025 @07:37PM (#42580751)
A lot of the world doesn’t have subsidized phones so I exclude carrier deals.

The SE is considered a mid range device imho in a lot of classifications. Budget is usually <300, mid range goes from 300-600 and premium is upwards from there. Of course with some deviation, but it’s how a lot of sales figures tend to split it up.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by cableshaft on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:48PM (#42571462)
The phones also last a long time, being very durable and getting updates for a quite a while, so you can buy an older refurbished iPhone and save quite a bit of money.

I only just upgraded a year ago from an iPhone 7 I had owned for about 4 years and bought refurbished for under $300 (that still worked fine, I just wanted to start developing mobile apps again and needed something with the newest iOS) to a refurbished iPhone 12 for $250, and it feels plenty modern to me. It still has the latest iOS version on it as well.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by kube-system on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:31PM (#42570520)
I think most people choose value, which might mean that sometimes quality plays a factor, but rarely means it is the sole factor.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by dijit on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:47PM (#42570599)
It feels like a cheap shot to bring up the mechanical keyboard situation that is close to the hearts of most techies - but sometimes "value" can mean... quality.

Sometimes it's not just about longevity, it's about how the product feels. This is especially true when it comes to our online content and- as adults- we have less time as we have children. Meaning quality is more important than quantity.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by kube-system on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @08:50PM (#42570912)
Quality is almost always a component of "value", but competing with other priorities, e.g. cost.

I think mechanical keyboards are a good example here, but maybe not in the way you were expecting. You may note that most PC sales are laptops these days, and nearly all of them eschew mechanical keyboards in favor of other priorities. And also, most desktops still ship with membrane keyboards, and only a tiny fraction of users replace them with a mechanical keyboard -- as you say, "techies". It's a niche preference that "most people" (from the title) do not find value in.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by brightlancer on Thursday January 02, 2025 @01:34AM (#42572247)
> Meaning quality is more important than quantity.

It's not a binary choice.

Price is a non-linear factor here: "quality" may be prohibitively expensive as a single purchase, even if it is less expensive over X years than re-buying a cheaper item every year.

In the US, shopping trends are clear that many people (perhaps most) value quantity very highly, to the point that they will sacrifice "quality" which is loosely defined and more subjective. IME this also ties into Americans being very price conscious.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by AndrewDucker on Thursday January 02, 2025 @07:54AM (#42574004)
I've tried mechanical keyboards a few times. Wasn't a fan. Didn't like how they felt or the noise they made The idea that they're automatically better seems very odd to me.
Re:Most people don't care about quality by dijit on Thursday January 02, 2025 @10:13AM (#42575095)
They cost a lot, and the main reason is the quality of the components.

They definitely are "better", as in they're a pure luxury good that serves no purpose outside of being a higher quality product.

There's really no value that a mechanical keyboard that can give you that a standard chiclet keyboard doesn't give you, yet, it's a quite large industry with many disparate manufacturers and standards and so-forth.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by devmor on Thursday January 02, 2025 @10:31AM (#42575284)
> There's really no value that a mechanical keyboard that can give you that a standard chiclet keyboard doesn't give you

There absolutely is, if you spend all day typing. Chiclet keyboards give poor tactile feedback that for many, leads to more typing mistakes. There is also value in the "pleasantness" of the experience - it's hard to quantify, but if it feels better to use something then you are certainly getting value from it (for another example, a cheap and uncomfortable vs expensive and comfortable chair).

I don't know what percentage of mechanical keyboard users this is, since there are certainly many that view it as a hobby or collector's interest, but I am one of the other side that use them exclusively because they make typing easier and more comfortable.

Re:Most people don't care about quality by mixdup on Thursday January 02, 2025 @12:29AM (#42571934)
Apple doesn't have 100% market share and the title is "most people"

The fact that Android has a larger market share, and Apple has a larger share of revenue and profit actually goes to show that the larger mass market doesn't care about quality as much as price

Re:Most people don't care about quality by AndrewDucker on Thursday January 02, 2025 @07:51AM (#42573985)
I absolutely care about quality and I choose Android.

The fact that different people choose different qualities should surprise nobody.

(Some people are obviously price constrained out of the Apple price bracket, but there are also plenty of people who actively prefer Android)

Re:Most people don't care about quality by kbelder on Friday January 03, 2025 @03:04PM (#42588994)
It still kind of low-key boggles my mind that so many developers choose iPhones and buy into that ecosystem. Not criticizing them... everybody makes their own choices and gets to decide what's good for themselves. But I just don't get it.

(And it's not because I haven't heard the stated reasons. They just don't resonate with me.)

Re:Most people don't care about quality by croes on Thursday January 02, 2025 @10:30AM (#42575278)
>it’s because there is a quality level that apple products never go beneath- even if the design is stupid.

There’s a bunch of evidence that this is also not true.