Edited to remove Sweden because it's obliged to eventually adopt the euro.
Also, yeah, the Danish Krona is pegged to the euro at ~7.45 so there is little incentive to switch over.
Although it doesn’t make sense, because the influx of cheap money would make joining the EU an obvious boon for that class, wouldn’t it?
Can you elaborate?
A shock therapy Euro adoption is not in the interest of anyone.
The case of Sweden is interesting though, they don't have an opt-out clause so they are obligated to adopt the Euro eventually, but they exploited a loophole by not joining the newest version of European Exchange Rate Mechanism after the 1999, which prevents their entry in the Euro.
Of course, the EU often ignores its own treaties. So that's not a hard guarantee. But the first rule of the EU is that everyone has to pretend it follows its own rules even when it doesn't, so it's not like Icelandic leaders can just announce they'll join the EU but won't adopt the Euro.
> Denmark has a treaty opt-out from the obligation to join the eurozone even if it complies with all criteria.
They are required to say they will at some unspecified future date, but that's another matter.
All EU countries have to publicly commit to joining the Euro and doing the work to do so. They are therefore required to join it, under any reasonable interpretation of the treaty language. The fact that some countries realized they could just not do what they agreed to and/or hack their economy to avoid the entry criteria, without any consequences, is good evidence that the treaties are indeed meaningless. But lax enforcement isn't the same as no requirement. The EU Commission could change their stance at any time.
It has been a while since I last looked at this, but from memory a pre-condition for Euro adoption is spending a certain amount of time within some formal "convergence mechanism", however there is no obligation to join that convergence mechanism.
This could well be ERM-II which I have in mind.
Nobody cares about inflation. They just need the right "democratic leaders". See Georgia. /s
The inflation absolutely matters.
It would not, simply because joining the Euro Area isn't a one time thing, but a series of steps, and they wouldn't move forward as long as the inflation is higher than in the rest of the EU.
> If Iceland adopted the EU's interest rate which is mainly set for France and Germany, that would be a 5% interest rate cut which is a massive stimulus.
Interests rate is only one of the factors involved in controlling inflation, and the fact that Italy has been able to adjust its economic policy in order to align its inflation figures to Maastricht requirements and join the Euro Area is a good proof of that.
> People should also look into Optimal Currency Area theory popularized by Paul Krugman
It has been popularized by Robert Mundell in the 60s, for which he got the Sveriges Riksank prize (the "Nobel") in 1999, not by Paul Krugman.
> For all the above reasons, Iceland joining the EU would be the stupidest and most economically illiterate decision in it's history.
The creation of the Euro is IMHO the "most economically illiterate decision in […] history" but moat of your arguments above miss the mark.
By "popularized" I mean brought to a modern audience in Krugman's New York Times column. It's Mundell's theory of course.
Interest rates are the main way to fight inflation. Glad we agree that the Euro is a silly currency union!
They cannot join Euro until inflation stops being higher, because that's simply how it works: countries must achieve “convergence criterias” before they can enter the single currency.
Startups?
I wonder in the coming years if we'll see the US actually become more like the EU. I expect there to be significant competition between Texas and California, in terms of industry, polity and philosophy. As the US continues to be internally fragmented politically, we're bound to see states compete actively, sometimes even to the detriment of other states. While we won't see a significant fragmentation like the EU, we will see a country that's so internally divided, there would be saboteurs and collaborators with enemies. We're kind of already seeing this, for example Texas and Florida shipping their illegals into Massachusetts and NY, states being firmly in the control of one party, with no room for switching governments, and the ever present question of states' rights.
Which is a game-theoretically sound choice given the lack of legal authority to prevent unlawful entry to begin with.
In the EU, you don't see countries arguing about which bathrooms people should use, or what model of creation they should teach children in schools. Yes, there is linguistic separation, but there is very little political and even cultural distinction between European countries, save for some hot button issues like immigration (which is also seeing alignment now).
Ask any European what European culture is, and you'll get a fair melange of what make Europe European (they might mention elements such as architecture, classical music, heck Roman Empire even). Ask an American about American culture and you'll get definitely different answers between Americans from even two red states.
Let's imagine for a second you want to create a startup making cell phones, or cars, or TVs etc. You base in say Texas for the taxes, but workforce can freely move to the Texas from California. They have zero language barrier, they have zero legal barrier. Legal, highly skilled immigrants in California can freely move to Texas for work. The product you make has to conform with both Cali and Texas laws, bud federal ones are unified. It needs to be localized for 1 single language. And it can be immediately sold to the 350mil market with minimal changes. Now if you do the same in France, you are limited with French workforce, because of the language barrier and legal barriers. Then to sell to the whole EU you need to comply with 24 laws and localize to 21 language. And support all that. EU company is less competitive on this basis alone, plus USA doing brain drain (which they foolishly want to limit now) is not helping.
And in fact, I think you have it exactly backwards in this case.
Many countries have dollarized their economies - replacing a local currency supported by high interest rates with the US dollar which has even lower interest rate than EUR - as a tool to tame inflation or kill hyper-inflation. Other - small non-EU countries have adopted the Euro for the same reason.
And with the same result - a massive fall in inflation.
This isn't just theory, this has been observed to work over and over again.
Iceland doesn't suffer from hyperinflation and it's already got an established central bank and trusted institutions. Lowering the interest rate in this environment would 100% lead to more inflation.
Plus Iceland relies on currency devaluation to cope with shocks. It would be crazy to give this up.
Considering its remoteness and population size, where Iceland sits today as country is an absolute success story. Don’t give up your sovereignty.
That's because of how US politics work. Less populous states have disproportionately higher political power. It's not a monetary policy thing. It's a core difference between US and European politics.
> The US also allows whole areas to deindustrialize
That's because Americans are free to live and work where they choose.
There's a lot more nuance here, if you look at Obama's memoir, he writes quite frankly about the dilemma of propping up the US auto industry with government dollars. When they (US automakers) asked for bailouts, he found them quite mismanaged, but if they went under a large portion of the US economy would find itself unemployed.
Why?
Iceland's interest rate is 8.5% https://www.cb.is/other/key-interest-rate/
EU's interest rate is 3% https://www.ecb.europa.eu/stats/policy_and_exchange_rates/ke...
The higher Icelandic rate is set for Icelanders by Icelanders in order to bring their 4.8% inflation rate down to the 2.5% target.
If Iceland adopted the EU's interest rate which is mainly set for France and Germany, that would be a 5% interest rate cut which is a massive stimulus. Icelandic inflation would skyrocket and there would be no chance of hitting the 2.5% target.
People should also look into Optimal Currency Area theory popularized by Paul Krugman eg https://archive.nytimes.com/krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/0...
The US Dollar works because of massive fiscal transfers from states on the coasts to states in the interior. The US also allows whole areas to deindustrialize like Detroit in order to solve the unavailability of currency adjustments between states.
Are Icelanders willing to subsidize Greece? Are they willing to forgo their ability to devalue their currency like in 2008? Without devaluation that means deindustrialization.
For all the above reasons, Iceland joining the EU would be the stupidest and most economically illiterate decision in it's history.