News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by mediaman on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:04PM (#42446825)
I don't understand why people even think about selling $10/mo licenses.

Just go sell $2-4k/mo SaaS to a medium sized traditional industry that has ancient, crummy software with a target customer employee size of 50 - 1,000 people.

Customer problem discovery is easier, you get reputation network effects within the vertical, you gain trust because you learn the industry lingo, you can actually solve peoples' problems because you're not balancing needs against unrelated industries, they're willing to pay, and once you get 20 customers you're doing pretty OK.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by TechDebtDevin on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:48PM (#42447091)
Cool, says everyone... Have you done it?
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by x0x0 on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:09PM (#42447212)
Done that with $25k saas.

The one point where gp is wrong is you really can't sell $4k things; $10k min and $25k is better. eg a good to great salesperson closes 25% of deals, so you have the cost of 4 mqls per one close, and then the salesperson gets 20%ish of the deal.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by mediaman on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @10:30PM (#42447889)
Yes. But it's not for everyone, especially not for a lot of engineers.

Many of these buyers feel more comfortable meeting you in-person, so going to trade shows, writing articles for niche trade publications, and sometimes doing site visits are all very helpful. So is cold calling.

Sales cycles are often slow. You have to get used to customers taking months to decide, having lots of meetings with different stakeholders, and to get good at telling the difference between those who need a lot of meetings but will likely close versus those who will never do anything. It's a very different game than selling subs online, which I know little about.

The product does need to be decent but I disagree with others that it has to be amazing. Most enterprise software is horrible. They will be delighted if you actually solve their problems (rather than the problems horizontally-oriented software vendors want their customers to have), even if it has some rough edges, as long as you're very customer-focused, responsive, and available.

But it also tends to be durable revenue, because you get tightly integrated into their operations if you do it right.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by NetOpWibby on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:27PM (#42446942)
This is a solid plan, thanks.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by cj on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:23PM (#42447277)
> Just go sell $2-4k/mo SaaS to a medium sized traditional industry that has ancient, crummy software with a target customer employee size of 50 - 1,000 people.

I’ve successfully done exactly this.

Except in order to get there, we had to spend 3-4 years selling cheap $29/mo self-serve plans at volume to iron out all of the kinks in the product and UX. Only after that were we able to go upmarket selling $40-90k/yr contracts.

It all boils down to the fact that customers paying $20k/yr or more have extremely high expectations across the board. It’s extremely difficult to just pop into a completely new market with a brand new product untested by anyone, and expect large companies to trust and buy from you.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by giraffe_lady on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:05PM (#42447484)
Yeah exactly. You can't just roll out of bed one morning and grustle out a stable enterprise application. Also:

> customers paying $20k/yr or more have extremely high expectations across the board.

They definitely do, in certain ways. But also a lot of the software companies use sucks shit. But this part of the other comment cracked me up.

> a medium sized traditional industry that has ancient, crummy software

This is actually how to do it but the thing they're leaving out is that you have to already have knowledge of the specific industry and its players, their niches, and the software they use within them. You have to know where standards are high, and where the current options are bad, and how to market that improvement to the companies that are juuuust flexible enough to switch to your product while being conservative enough not to dump you if exactly one VP leaves.

Once you have all that in place, sure, you can "just" sell your software to them lol.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by palmfacehn on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:59PM (#42447740)
>This is actually how to do it but the thing they're leaving out is that you have to already have knowledge of the specific industry and its players, their niches, and the software they use within them.

In most cases, this requires at least one former employee who used the crummy software. Most likely this person would be the one to identify the problem and propose an alternative solution.

Information like this is extremely valuable. It forms the core of the biz opportunity. Casual comments often overlook this.

Builders doing their own thing may not overlap with employees using office horror software 9-5.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by cj on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @10:24PM (#42447850)
Boiled down into 1 sentence: Create a company that solves a problem you’ve personally experienced.

(If you feel like you haven’t experienced any problems worth creating a company to fix, consider putting yourself in situations where you’ll be exposed to different/new problem sets)

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by sourcepluck on Sunday December 29, 2024 @03:34PM (#42542827)
Lol @ "office horror software". So apt.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by foxglacier on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:46AM (#42448392)
Yes, get industry experience! You have to be pretty special to be just a software developer with no domain knowledge who can somehow make something more valuable than the bazillion other just-a-software-developers out there. I sell fairly high priced software to companies and I'm doing fine. Though I'm kind of lucky in how I got into it and by now most of my domain knowledge has come from my previous customers asking for things.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by fsndz on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @05:07AM (#42449338)
True and what I find funny is that the same companies are often willing to pay a lot of money to consultants that will deliver a shitty streamlit POC. Like they will literally pay consultants the equivalent of 4 years of new SaaS cost to get a POC instead of using a product with rough edges and grow with it. Expectations can be really dumb and confusing.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by giva on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @08:45AM (#42450357)
I'd pay to buy a bad house and then spend money to improve it, rather than paying a full rent for the same bad house and hoping that the landlord uses that money to improve it.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by fsndz on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:34PM (#42452701)
I don't get the comparison. are you comparing a SaaS that is doing 70% of the job and a shitty streamlit POC that no more than 3 people can use in parallel ??
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by cj on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @07:48PM (#42457174)
They’re saying that they would rather pay a consultant because they would have control over fixing things that don’t work the way they want. Compared to the alternative of buying a SaaS product that is “rough around the edges” where you’re not able to directly control whether and how the product is improved over time.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by fsndz on Thursday December 19, 2024 @04:22AM (#42459818)
that's a false choice because the SaaS startup will often be willing to modify the product to improve it for customers
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by giva on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:18AM (#42469774)
It can but it's up to its good will.

To be clear: It usually makes no sense to develop an internal solution when there is an estabilished offering on the market. If there isn't, embracing an rough and incomplete Saas solution from a startup may work, but:

- You have no control on how the solution will evolve

- You don't own the solution (an internal solution can became a product on itself)

- You don't have any competitive advange (the money you pay are used to develop a product that benefit your competitors as well as you).

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by htrp on Thursday December 19, 2024 @09:41AM (#42461787)
Exactly this!
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by abe94 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @10:01AM (#42450959)
We experienced something similar - we were able to wrangle a $30k/year contract as one of our first contracts, but the expectations around the software were and continue to be incredibly high - we sort of wish he had had a few $100/mo customers first to iron out the UX, and just learn more about how to work with a midmarket/enterprise buyer.

Anyway we survived but we understand why companies move upmarket over time now haha.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by Tostino on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:29AM (#42448340)
Hell, I went straight for 20k/mo (average) with my SaaS.

The key is providing a good value proposition. My software would save my customers more than they would spend on it yearly, while outsourcing $50-300k/year in salary worth of work that previously had to be done in internally (usually incorrectly).

You always need to solve an actual business problem that people are willing to pay to fix.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by rkuodys on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @05:44AM (#42449474)
Would you be willing to share insights and help with mentoring in private. I'm going this path (building SaaS) and would appreciate someone with experience to share to discuss topic.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by j45 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @03:02AM (#42448828)
Using B2C pricing for B2B SaaS is a big headwind.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by siva7 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @08:40AM (#42450333)
Recipe for your SaaS always being a hobby
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by morkalork on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @10:52AM (#42451467)
Just gotta find that price point within discretionary spending where a manager can OK the cost without having to get a VP to sign off on it. It's definitely way higher than $10/mo.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by j45 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @01:35PM (#42453388)
Most businesses won’t have issue with $20-50/mo if it saves them time or money elsewhere
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by sfjailbird on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @05:46AM (#42449480)
There's gotta be a name for this fallacy. "This enterprise software sucks and is extremely expensive, so we will build something that is actually good and become billionaires!"

This is the graveyard of engineer driven startups in the enterprise space, who make the mistake of thinking that software quality matters. The fact is it is not a top priority, if it is even a priority at all.

In the enterprise space, if you're not a Fortune 500 company, all that matters is 'relationships', by which I mean sleazy sales processes (or actual nepotistic friends-and-family relationships).

Joel Spolsky wrote a great essay once about why there is no software priced between $1000 and $100,000. Because above $1000 you need a sales team that takes purchasing managers to strip clubs and play golf with CEOs, and that shit adds up. On the plus side, your software can be dogshit, like the stuff you work with every day.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by gizmo on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @07:26AM (#42449922)
The world has changed. Today you can sell software for $5000 or $10000 without any sales process. Not always of course, you have to find the right niche.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by geo88 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @04:27PM (#42455474)
Curious to learn more about this, re pricing limits in today's corporate world.

What do most managers have access to on their corp card in terms of spend limits, without needing to get VP/finance approval for their purchase?

In my mind, I had the limit as $500/month (potentially from some old readings on the subject).

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by gizmo on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @06:59PM (#42456834)
There is a whole non-corporate world of SMBs that employ 30 or 100 people total. Those businesses have no VPs or corporate cards, but they still have problems and are willing to pay good money for solutions. Family businesses in any industry, law offices, marketing agencies, boutique hedge funds/pe, etc.

Corporate approval for a 10k purchase doesn't need to be complicated either. As a software vendor it helps to have a web page/email with all the relevant info intended to be forwarded to accounts payable.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by samiv on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @11:08AM (#42451679)
Exactly.

Only engineer and product oriented types think that quality has any actual value. Unfortunately it does not, even less so if your only USP is "quality". If your products only differentiator is that it's technically better than the competitor it really needs to be 100x better in order to sway anyone's interest.

If your maximum work/effort you can put into any project is 100% which you have to allocate into fragments, the product person will put 80% into product development and 20% to marketing but a sales person will put 80% into marketing and 20% into development and unfortunately the latter will product much better results. All it needs to be is "good enough" but reaching to your target market with the right product really is the key.

The unfortunate side effect is that quality is best achieved by having the PR team write it out and put it into a snappy slogan on your product website. Done. Quality achieved.

Edit: And the above applies to your typical non-safety critical Saas, Enterprise, B2B, B2C software. And thinking back to for example the Boeing crashes it likely also applies to the the "safety critical" software/systems as well...

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by geo88 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @04:25PM (#42455436)
Isn't that going into the other extreme though?

You can get very far with just sales and marketing, but if the quality isn't there, reputationally, that's going to catch up with you over time, same if you have dodgy business practices (i.e.: predatory pricing practices for existing customers, impossible cancellations etc.).

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by acuozzo on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @11:29AM (#42451933)
> there is no software priced between $1000 and $100,000

Nitpick, but this is the price range for most professional film restoration software.

The target is often small restoration houses with workstations at 10 or so seats.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by throwaway2037 on Thursday December 19, 2024 @04:50AM (#42459985)
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by jf22 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @06:16AM (#42449614)
>Just go sell $2-4k/mo SaaS to a medium sized traditional industry that has ancient, crummy software with a target customer employee size of 50 - 1,000 people.

As if that is easy.

Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by brabel on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @06:46AM (#42449736)
The guy is so out of touch it's like a cartoon. Like, right, why did they think of that?! Just create something that's worth several thousands a month instead of a small value product!!! And get all the big companies who can actually afford that kind of thing to buy your product!!! How hard can that be?
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by morkalork on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @10:45AM (#42451382)
The only times I've seen anything remotely like that work, it's a situation like this: Two engineers work together at company A, become friends and gain experience in the domain. Both move on, progress in their careers and work other companies in the same domain. They meet for coffee and person 1 says: "hey remember that problem we had at A? I see it again at B", person 2: "me too and I've been working on a side project to fix it, you should totally buy the solution from me". And voilà. Could a kid right out of school build the same thing? Sure. Would it have ever succeeded? No. They lack the domain experience and the social connections to do it.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by jf22 on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @11:47AM (#42452181)
I've heard this story dozens of times now.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by brabel on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:08PM (#42452398)
And that's almost exactly how the company I work for started.
Re:After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code by mediaman on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:18PM (#42452499)
I didn't say it's easy, and it's probably not the right fit for you. But it's at least a plan with a good end-game, which a lot of $10/mo online only business models simply cannot turn into something viable.

50-1,000 person companies aren't actually that big. You can get to know the decision makers and it's not like navigating 20,000 person corporate mazes (also possible if you have the stomach for it).

It does seriously benefit from industry knowledge though. The reason so many people think it's a ridiculous pipedream is because they have no industry experience outside of tech, and that's a big problem -- a solvable one, but most people will never do what it takes to solve it and instead say that it's not possible.

It takes a lot of willingness to do non-tech things though. You can't just set up an online marketing funnel and watch the cash come in. It's relationship driven. The advantage of going after a vertical is that the relationships start feeding each other -- you get social proof within the niche industry. And you don't compete with VC-backed software companies as much because they much prefer horizontal solutions (which can get bigger and achieve bigger exits) versus vertical solutions.