For this performance nerf, IDK, seems fine to me. Software companies do this all the time. Same piece of software but you have to pay to unlock features. I don't see why hardware should be any different.
Granted, even for the CAD nerf, it's a gray area. You pay for features, not for silicon, and NVidia is clear about what you have to pay for what features, so. But I'm a bit more biased on that one because my 10-person HW company had to spring for several of those workstation cards.
we're lucky they still do gaming by limiting the datacenter chips
it's like getting a ferrari speed limited for usd20,000 and then I complain I don't get the acceleration of a usd100,000 model. they sold the product cheaper, they cared, they adapted. I'm happy they are still improving year after year for the same dollar value
Just because Ferrari might be capable of making that car for $20k, I don't have a fundamental right to demand it from them any more than I have a fundamental right to demand that you make me a sandwich right now for $5.
> they can afford
Before using the word "they" in a prescriptive sentence, think about whether you could substitute "I" and you would still be happy with it.
I have no issue selling into a competitive market, that’s just how things work for individuals. It’s only at the scale of countries and giant companies that the ability for anti competitive behavior really shows up.
What about all other stuff? i.e. maybe you or somebody else can "afford" to sell their labour at 10-80% of what they are paid?
That a competitive market drives prices to zero economic profit is a fairly basic result; no active measures besides the existence of competition are necessary for this.
> What about all other stuff?
Yes, this applies in all competitive markets. If it doesn't apply in a market, there is a constraint on competition causing it.
Yes and that's not necessarily a good thing in all markets. Very low profit margins can result in less innovations and would certainly discourage companies from taking risks (basically by definition)
No, they don't.
That they are able to price discriminate this way is a sign that they are functionally a monopoly exercising pricing power, otherwise, they would be easily undercut in the market where they charge premium prices by a competitor.
Had AI and Crypto not been a thing. These so called price discrimination was what kept the company afloat and continue to spend stupid money ( according to many ) on CUDA rather than making gaming better.
And when often people say "X" needs competition. What they really want is just cheaper price for the same thing. Would it be great if Nvidia had more competition? Absolutely, but is Nvidia not making progress and milking everything they have? Absolutely not. They invested even more in CUDA, Large Die Size Correction Tooling, Assisted EDA Design and many more to their arsenal to built their moat.
I also often found when a successful founder is still working at a company, that company is often pushed far harder by its founder than whatever market force is driving them. So we need competition for Intel 2009 - 2021, Microsoft in 2000, Any company who just sit there and no longer improves or failed to execute.
Nvidia? They are doing fine if not better than I could imagine. ( I just wished they spend a little more money to compete in the Mobile and Desktop Consumer SoC space. I guess that is coming soon. )
They'd probably be happy with competitive market pricing, which is unlikely to happen without a competitive market.
Nvidia's gross margins are extraordinary vs. AMD or intel margins (or even "overpriced" Apple.)
There is competition of a sort - for example at the low end with intel ARC and at the high end with AMD Instinct based supercomputers. However, competitors don't seem to be able to match the CUDA software platform, particularly for AI/ML. The deepening CUDA moat is hard for competitors to cross and for customers to escape.
In the cloud space it seems that Nvidia may face more competition with platforms like GCP/Cloud TPU and AWS/Trainium.
Different markets, same techniques. It's in the company DNA. That and their aversion to open source drivers and various other bad decisions around open source support that make maintaining a working Linux GPU setup way harder than it should be even to this day.