News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by bsaul on Monday December 16, 2024 @02:29AM (#42428785)
i'm looking forward to the day calculus gets rewritten using more intuitive notations.

Everytime i manipulate dx i feel like walking on a minefield.

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by pif on Monday December 16, 2024 @04:06AM (#42429281)
> Everytime i manipulate dx i feel like walking on a minefield.

Embrace the minefield, love the minefield!

  Signed
  a physicist
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by hyperbrainer on Monday December 16, 2024 @03:51AM (#42429196)
Newtonian notation certainly feels more elegant to me. But kind of painful to work with in LaTeX. Langrangian notation is almost the same, and much eaiser to type too.
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by pseudostem on Monday December 16, 2024 @08:10AM (#42430648)
It has been argued before [0] that Leibniz notation being embraced in mainland Europe and not adopted in England/UK was the reason England fell about a century behind. First heard of this in MIT Calc undergrad course on YouTube, but would be too tedious to find which video, hence ran a search on the Internet.

[0] https://hsm.stackexchange.com/questions/7704/was-english-mat...

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by seanhunter on Monday December 16, 2024 @11:50AM (#42432771)
Newtonian notation is just doing time derivatives with a dot above them, so in Latex that is just \dot{x} = v . Which means dx/dt = v, or \ddot{x} = a.

Did you mean "Leibniz's" notation[1]? If so, if you use the right packages it's just \pdiff{y}{x} for partials or \diff{x}{y} for regular derivatives.

Lagrange's notation is when people do x' = v or x'' = a and Like the Newton's notation you kinda have to know from context that you are differentiating with respect to time in those cases.

Sometimes people call the partial derivative notation where you use subscripts "Lagrange's notation" also[2]. So like f_x(x,y) = blah is the partial derivative of f with respect to x.

[1] Actually invented by Euler

[2] Even though that was also actually invented by Euler apparently.

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by hyperbrainer on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @12:49PM (#42452908)
\dot {} is not convenient to write everytime, and I suck at remembering to use macros. On the other hand, just writeing f' is far faster.
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by xeonmc on Monday December 16, 2024 @05:33AM (#42429786)
SICM?
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by Y_Y on Monday December 16, 2024 @09:23AM (#42431197)
If you liked the "functional" style of calculus in SICM, or want a calculus only book in this vein I recommend Baby Spivak: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calculus_on_Manifolds_(book)

(And obviously Functional Differential Geometry by the authors of SICM)

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by leoc on Monday December 16, 2024 @03:55PM (#42435321)
Certainly Gerry Sussman's frustrations with ambiguous notation were a big reason for his decision to create SICM! https://youtu.be/arMH5GjBwUQ?t=236
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by bsaul on Thursday December 19, 2024 @05:03AM (#42460055)
never seen this talk before, thanks ! i feel less lonely.
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by TachyonicBytes on Monday December 16, 2024 @06:18AM (#42430043)
You can always try infinitesimal analysis[1]

[1] https://people.math.wisc.edu/~hkeisler/calc.html

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by Chris2048 on Monday December 16, 2024 @08:47AM (#42430892)
I honestly don't know why infitesimals aren't widespread. It can basically have the same basis/justification can't it? But with the bonus of being more intuitive.

You don't even need to use "infinity", it starts out as just a variable representing some unknown quantity, then you "round to zero" on output.

I actually collected a bunch of old Infinitesimal calculus math books.

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by Qem on Monday December 16, 2024 @10:26AM (#42431908)
> I honestly don't know why infitesimals aren't widespread. It can basically have the same basis/justification can't it? But with the bonus of being more intuitive.

Indeed they are more intuitive, people like Newton and Leibniz invented/discovered calculus by thinking in terms of infinitesimals, but it took time to be made rigorous, in the XX century. By then network effects got we stuck with epsilons and deltas, given that was the approach made rigorous earlier, and broadly adopted, despite being more cumbersome.

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by TachyonicBytes on Monday December 16, 2024 @10:36AM (#42432000)
Would you mind giving us the titles of those books?
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by Chris2048 on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:05PM (#42432928)
They are in the attic at the moment, but they are all fairly old books (and terse, dry, basic formatting/illustration), seemingly from a period in time when infitesimals were apparently more popular.

There are a few similar ones on IA, e.g.

https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.148501/page/n8...

On that page the 'h' term is the infitesimal, as in

  d(x^2) / dx = 2x + h
Though I prefer something like 'Δx' to make the link to x more explicit. Would love to see a more modern book on the topic.
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by azalemeth on Monday December 16, 2024 @09:02AM (#42431012)
Or, for the Knuth-included, surreal numbers: https://people.math.harvard.edu/~knill/teaching/mathe320_201...

(Seriously though, learn to love the minefield. ~~~~Another physicist)

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by Qem on Monday December 16, 2024 @10:30AM (#42431946)
Keisler book is excellent.
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by BobaFloutist on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:04PM (#42432916)
The XKCD about unifying standards under a new standard is how I feel every single time I learn anew piece of math notation.

"This is ridiculous! We need a better, more intuitive notation that's also easier to do math at."

Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by fragmede on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:10PM (#42432969)
That's xkcd 927,a mnemonic for that is 3^2 * 100 + 3^3
Re:Derivatives don't always act like fractions (2021) by BobbyTables2 on Monday December 16, 2024 @10:24PM (#42438042)
I’d be thrilled if mathematicians would just use multicharacter variable names instead of getting overly fancy with diacritics and italic/bold/capital/Greek variations.