News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by manquer on Friday December 13, 2024 @04:36PM (#42412594)
> The product market fit is fantastic. This isn't the first time I've heard random strangers discussing it in public.

Hardly the evidence of PMF. There is always something new in the zeitgeist, that every one is talking about, some more so than others .

2 years before it was VR, few years before that NFTs and blockchain everything, before that it was self driving cars before that personal voice assistants like Siri and so on .

- self driving has not transformed us into minority report and despite how far it has come it cannot in next 30 years be ubiquitous, even if the l5 magic tech exists today in every new car sold it will take 15 years for current cars to lifecycle.

- Crypto has not replaced fiat currency , even in most generous reading you can see it as store of value like gold or whatever useless baubles people assign arbitrary value to, but has no traction for 3 out of other 4 key functions of money .

- VR is not transformative to every day life and is 5 fundamental breakthroughs away.

- Voice assistants are useless setting alarms and selecting music 10 years in.

There has been meaningful and measurable in each of these fields, but none of them have met the high bar of world transforming .

AI is aiming for much higher bar of singularity and consciousness. Just in every hype cycles we are in peak of inflated expectations, we will reach a plateau of productivity where it is will be useful in specific areas (as it already is) and people will move on to the next fad.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:22PM (#42412883)
> 2 years before it was VR, few years before that NFTs and blockchain everything, before that it was self driving cars before that personal voice assistants like Siri and so on .

I never saw people talking about VR in public, nor NFTs, and the closest I got to seeing blockchain in public were adverts, not hearing random people around me chatting about it. The only people I ever saw in real life talking about self-driving cars were the ones I was talking to myself, and everyone else was dismissive of them. Voice assistants were mainly mocked from day 1, with the Alex advert being re-dubbed as a dystopian nightmare.

> AI is aiming for much higher bar of singularity and consciousness.

No, it's aiming to be economically useful.

"The singularity" is what a lot of people think is an automatic consequence of being able to solve tasks related to AI; me, I think that's how we sustained Moore's Law so long (computers designing computers, you can't place a billion transistors by hand, but even if you could the scale is now well into the zone where quantum tunnelling has to be accounted for in the design), and that "singularities" are a sign something is wrong with the model.

"Consciousness" has 40 definitions, and is therefore not even a meaningful target.

> Just in every hype cycles we are in peak of inflated expectations, we will reach a plateau of productivity where it is will be useful in specific areas (as it already is) and people will move on to the next fad.

In that at least, we agree.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by behnamoh on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:26PM (#42413295)
> ... and that "singularities" are a sign something is wrong with the model.

Einstein thought that way too because his model predicted singularities in space-time fabric. Turns out he was wrong. Nowadays we call them blackholes and have images of them too.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Friday December 13, 2024 @07:09PM (#42413506)
Black holes have had two different singularities in general relativity:

(1) the event horizon was the first singularity, but that turned out to be a free choice of the coordinate system, i.e. a mistake in the maths — and we can't see past the event horizons anyway, so we don't know what happens on the other side of them even though they're not "real" singularities

(2) the point in the centre where the geodesics stop, which everyone in the field knows is incompatible with (a) the assumption in the maths of relativity that spacetime is smooth and can be differentiated everywhere, and (b) quantum mechanics

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by zeroonetwothree on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:36PM (#42413338)
He wasn’t exactly wrong in that the model still breaks down for black holes. Even though we know they exist we don’t know what goes inside them.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by mnky9800n on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:09AM (#42415453)
The image is not of the singularity itself but the accretion disc.

This is not to discount that amazing accomplishment but to point out that, in addition to misrepresenting what the singularity is in a black hole, you also misrepresented what the image of a black hole is.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by swatcoder on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:59PM (#42413099)
> never saw people talking about VR in public, nor NFTs, and the closest I got to seeing blockchain in public were adverts, not hearing random people around me chatting about it. The only people I ever saw in real life talking about self-driving cars were the ones I was talking to myself, and everyone else was dismissive of them. Voice assistants were mainly mocked from day 1, with the Alex advert being re-dubbed as a dystopian nightmare.

Isn't that funny? It speaks exactly to the GP's point about how frothing and uninformative the "zeitgeist" can be, as my experience happens to have been the opposite of yours. The people I happened to be casually brushing around during those earlier fads happened to be hip to them, or maybe my ears were more attentive, and so I heard them mentioned more often and with more enthusiasm.

In contrast, most of what I happen to hear about generative AI, outside of HN, tends to be idly laughing at its foibles and misrepresentation if it's mentioned at all.

I don't expect you to have the same experience as me, but I'm careful not to assume too much based on either of ours.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by og_kalu on Friday December 13, 2024 @07:25PM (#42413570)
I mean nobody needs to bother with anecdotes here. chatgpt.com hit 3.7B visits in October and was #8 in worldwide internet traffic. Open AI say they have 300M weekly active users and 1B messages per day.

The idea that it's some fad with no utility or that the general public knows little about it is at this point laughable. It's the software product with by far the fastest adoption any software product has ever seen.

And if people want to lump that in with bitcoin or VR or whatever, shrug, i just don't know what to say.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by parineum on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:08AM (#42414821)
> I mean nobody needs to bother with anecdotes here. chatgpt.com hit 3.7B visits in October and was #8 in worldwide internet traffic. Open AI say they have 300M weekly active users and 1B messages per day.

As far as the "zeitgeist" conversation goes, though, there's one story in the non-tech news about AI right now and it isn't how it's making everyone's life easier. It's, yet again, a story about how someone trusted it and got burned because the markov chain landed on something not true.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by chipsrafferty on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:08AM (#42415451)
That actual isn't evidence at all that the general public knows a lot about it, or even uses it much. It can be a small group of very active users.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by og_kalu on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:53PM (#42419720)
To put it frankly, not at this scale.

I don't know what you think nearly 4B visits per month is (and top ten in worldwide traffic) that "a small group of active users" can generate. 300M active users a week is not a small group and you do not get there without general public awareness.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by darkwater on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:10AM (#42415461)
Yes, because it is free.

How many paid users? Is a paid user generating profit right now? Google had to inject advertising in its search results to start earning real money. What will OpenAI do? That's the PMF.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by chgs on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:58AM (#42415907)
90% of my use of OpenAI is to avoid the crap of internet search (Google or ddg, even when I find the right page finding the specific part of a pain)

At some point chatgpt will become crap and the cycle will repeat

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by og_kalu on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:15PM (#42419846)
There are millions of free apps.

They had some estimated 10M paid users a few months ago.

>Is a paid user generating profit right now?

For themselves ? I don't know and neither does the person saying they have no PMF.

There is nothing stopping Open AI from inserting ads into GPT's responses, either explicitly with the search tool or weaved into predicted responses.

Their revenue nearly quadrupled year on year and model training and inference costs have reduced by several orders of magnitude in the last few years.

I'm not saying that Open AI are foolproof. But the money being pumped to them is more or less expected.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by DennisP on Friday December 13, 2024 @07:42PM (#42413649)
Self-driving won't take over by just being available in the new cars people are buying anyway.

It'll take over when people find it cheaper to ride robotaxis than to own a vehicle at all. That's potentially a much quicker transition, requiring significantly fewer new vehicles.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by manquer on Friday December 13, 2024 @07:52PM (#42413688)
Assuming we get to your level of value prop. It will still only be a choice for new first time buyers

If I already own a car, for which am paying an emi and no hope of selling for good value (because market is dropping as newest buyers disappear) it won’t make economic sense for me till I generate LTV from the car to switch over .

Either way it till take 1-2 decades after ubiquitous L5 availability, even if that was possible at all and soon

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by bdangubic on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:02PM (#42413745)
there are already cheaper ways to ride from point A to point B without owning a car (especially in urban areas) and yet car ownership has never been higher… ideal robotaxis will take at least one full generation to actually materialize.

just as a silly personal example, I took a car to the shop and got Uber credits. my wife was heading into the city for an event (had to deal with both traffic and parking) and I was like “take a free Uber” and she was like “no way, driving my own car…” my daughter on the other hand…

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by mnky9800n on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:13AM (#42415471)
Nobody is going to sit and wait for a robo uber in the suburbs for ten minutes to go to the grocery store ten miles down the road. This is the main problem, America has suburbanised itself to hell and no amount of robo taxis will create the world you are suggesting. And elsewhere in the world there’s no need because most places have adequate public transit which solves the problem way more efficiently than robo taxis ever will.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by cinntaile on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:14AM (#42415716)
[delayed]
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by mnky9800n on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:33AM (#42415794)
I can catch a bus every five minutes a one minute walk from my house in Utrecht. Those buses go anywhere. In Oslo I could ride the T-bane to the forest or to downtown. In Tokyo it was obvious public transit is the only way to go. All the places I lived outside the USA I would never take a taxi much less a robot one in lieu of Public transit.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by cinntaile on Saturday December 14, 2024 @04:40AM (#42415817)
Because taxis are not cheap enough. Once they become cheap enough, by not having a driver, the equation changes. Travel becomes more convenient.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by chgs on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:00AM (#42415923)
In a city I don’t take public transport over uber due to the cost but due to the convenience and speed.

The only exception is the US, and even then that doesn’t apply in Manhattan.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by cinntaile on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:58AM (#42416218)
That's what I'm saying. When price goes down, robotaxis become a more viable option due to convenience and speed. You're shopping? Just put it in the trunk. Have fun with 4 grocery bags on public transport.

Public transport can be faster for going from A to B, but most people live a couple of kms from A and they're not going to exactly B but somewhere in the vicinity. The "last mile" will more likely be by robotaxi.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:54AM (#42416803)
> When price goes down, robotaxis become a more viable option due to convenience and speed.

Lower prices don't make things more convenient or fast.

> You're shopping? Just put it in the trunk. Have fun with 4 grocery bags on public transport.

Here is "The Shops at South Town" mall in Salt Lake City: https://www.google.com/maps/@40.5617162,-111.8944801,171m/da...

Note that some parts of that car park are 300m from some of the shops in that building. (There are choices of shops and parking spaces larger than that, but it looks like I can easily justify 300m without resorting to maxima).

Here is my old apartment: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Prenzlauer+Promenade+1,+13...

Note that within 300m of that address — i.e. the bounds of the example American shopping mall car park — there are 6 [super]markets, a pharmacy, five cafe/bakeries, two cinemas, several takeaways, two restaurants, a dentist, a car repair shop, a car dealership, a kitchenware shop, a newsagent/post office, and I'm not counting any corner shops ("Späti" in the local language).

Carrying a few bags of groceries around inside well-planned cities is pretty trivial.

Even in my current place, still in Berlin but close to the outskirts without the advantages of density, a mere four grocery bags is easier to get through public transport than it is from one end of an American car park to the other.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by cinntaile on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:35AM (#42417385)
> Lower prices don't make things more convenient or fast.

You are replying to a straw man, I never said anything like that. It makes for dull discussions.

> Even in my current place, still in Berlin but close to the outskirts without the advantages of density, a mere four grocery bags is easier to get through public transport than it is from one end of an American car park to the other.

It's unclear to me why you compare it to a geographically unrelated area. You should compare the public transport with a robotaxi alternative. At similar pricing, how is convenience and speed impacted.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:25AM (#42417656)
>> Lower prices don't make things more convenient or fast.

> You are replying to a straw man, I never said anything like that. It makes for dull discussions.

If you didn't mean that, why did you say "When price goes down, robotaxis become a more viable option due to convenience and speed"?

> You should compare the public transport with a robotaxi alternative.

The alternative being "do I put these four bags in a trunk, or on the seat next to me?"

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ickelbawd on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:57AM (#42417829)
Not the op. If you reread what he wrote I think he’s trying to say the price going down changes the viability of the option—not the convenience and speed which he treats as inherent to the car.

Said another way: When price goes down, robotaxis (which are convenient and speedy) become a more viable option.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:11PM (#42418220)
Thanks, that reading looks plausible :)
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by cinntaile on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:40PM (#42419294)
Yes, that is what I meant.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by thrw42A8N on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:32AM (#42416104)
That's because people are behind the wheel. Once car ownership drops, the computerized traffic control can get much more efficient.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by chgs on Saturday December 14, 2024 @01:09PM (#42418535)
Computerised public transport is even more efficient

Your public transport with robo taxis takes up far more space in the surface than there is available in a normal city, as shown in this photo.

https://danielbowen.com/2012/09/19/road-space-photo/

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by thrw42A8N on Sunday December 15, 2024 @10:48AM (#42424036)
Not sure what you think is my public transport. My ideal computerized public transport combines vehicles of all sizes and types, and an uber-like app let's me choose what I prefer based on cost and other attributes.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by inertiatic on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:29AM (#42416088)
People wait for things all the time and if it can take away the hassle or driving your kids somewhere, maintaining multiple vehicles for multiple family members etc. I'd bet that it does take off. Public transport doesn't solve groceries or other types of shopping though even in highly connected cities, especially for people with health problems or just aging ones.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by happyraul on Sunday December 15, 2024 @10:05AM (#42423787)
Imagine a parent today driving to work and dropping off their two kids at school on the way. Instead of one car making three stops, you're suggesting three robo taxis would accomplish the same thing. What do you think already clogged roads would look like in this future? The only scalable solution is public transit, walking, and cycling.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by DennisP on Sunday December 15, 2024 @01:10PM (#42424895)
I used to live in Germany, which had lots of excellent public transit, walking, and cycling. There was still quite a bit of car traffic. If even Germany's public transport isn't enough to eliminate cars, then we should put some effort into improving car transport, in addition to whatever we do with buses and bike lanes.

To that end, I'm not convinced automation will make things worse.

If the kid's school is near the parent's route to work, there's nothing stopping the parent from saving money by taking the kid in the same taxi.

If the kid's school is in the opposite direction, then a separate robotaxi can be more efficient. What matters is total system mileage. If a robotaxi takes the kid, then picks up a commuter starting near the school, then we save the parent's trip from the school back to their starting point.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by thrw42A8N on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:31AM (#42416098)
Why would you wait for 10 minutes? Robo taxis would be driving all around to be optimally available to the market.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:06AM (#42417220)
The optimal route means picking up multiple people on the same route, and dropping them off elsewhere on the route, and then making the vehicle large enough so that they can do this comfortably, i.e. a bus.

It ends up being another form of public transport — perhaps one with no predictable timetable, or perhaps timetables are themselves a useful Schelling point, I wouldn't want to guess.

But as fixed bus routes make it possible to plan things like bus shelters, I think I'd prefer a bus over the logical progression of self-driving "taxis" that constantly move rather than finding parking spots.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by DennisP on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:09AM (#42417562)
That's optimal for the vehicles, but less optimal for the people, who have to walk to stops. I used to live in Germany which had fantastic public transport, but walking a mile to the nearest stop was something we took in stride. That's great for health, but didn't prevent Germans from being quite fond of their personal automobiles, and there didn't seem to be noticeably less traffic than in the US.

Meanwhile I think plenty of people find Uber perfectly convenient, just a bit expensive.

As far as physical efficiency goes, Tesla's plan is more efficient than their competitors'. Their dedicated robotaxis are either small two-seaters, or decent-size buses.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by DennisP on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:46AM (#42417450)
So people are not willing to wait for a robotaxi, but they are willing to wait for buses and trains?
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by EliRivers on Sunday December 15, 2024 @05:43AM (#42422741)
Nobody is going to sit and wait for a robo uber in the suburbs for ten minutes to go to the grocery store ten miles down the road.

I absolutely would do that. Sometimes I already do wait that kind of time for a taxi or bus. Having the robo taxi turn up in ten minutes from when I decided I wanted to go to the shop would be fantastic.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by tim333 on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:49PM (#42413045)
>people will move on to the next fad

AI isn't really a fad. It's going to something more like electricity, say.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by swatcoder on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:02PM (#42413127)
My favorite comparison right now is to the microwave oven.

It's a novel thing. It's not going anywhere. It makes some things easier, sometimes, in both personal and professional settings. But you're not at a big loss without it and in many cases your choice to do without is a choice that favors quality, control, nuance, and skill refinement.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by tim333 on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:14PM (#42413191)
AI probably has more capacity to be incorporated into many things than microwaves.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by manquer on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:42PM (#42413369)
I will bite, going with your analogy comparing to electricity on the other end of the spectrum.

electricity is not ubiquitous in many parts of the global south full 130 years.

The common definition is- access to electricity source that can provide very basic lighting, and charge a phone or power a radio for 4 hours per day. Not even grid connected.

Even with this basic definition there is still full 660 million people who don’t have access to even that. It only dropped below a billion in 2015.

https://ourworldindata.org/energy-access

You need beyond the basic to be meaningfully transformative, clean cooking fuel access is one proxy used that is still 2Billion people without access for example.

Nobody is denying the transformative nature of electricity or say internet , but even these things take a long long time, more than one life time to propagate and be world changing, and not because of their choice of lifestyle to live disconnected.

If electricity, clean water, sanitation and nutrition and basic healthcare is not available to half the population, what is AI going to do in next 3- 5 years or whatever ridiculous timeframe Sam Altman keeps talking about .

And this is a not productivity problem, there is more than enough food production capacity to feed the world, yet starvation and malnutrition is not solved.

AI may rock your world, it is not going to rock the world anytime soon even if was like electricity.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by bruce511 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @01:13AM (#42415031)
Something can be transformative long (long) before its "completely available to everyone ". Clearly electricity is transformative despite 660 million people not giving it.

So I guess it all depends on your definition of "transformative".

If a billion people are affected? 2 billion? One continent? All of them?

If something is big in Australia, Asia, Europe and North America, is that enough to describe it is "rock the world"?

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by parineum on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:10AM (#42414830)
People have been saying that for a few years now. I've been using it as a very advanced autocomplete while coding for that time and not much else.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:42AM (#42416150)
I use it for cooking, proofreading, learning German, skimming long documents, shopping advice (by uploading photos), and asking dumb questions about physics that get me [closed] if I were to post on physics stack exchange, in addition to being a coding assistant.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by Sateeshm on Saturday December 14, 2024 @01:50PM (#42418719)
Most of those existed before llms. Also still like a microwave, not very essential.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:31PM (#42419243)
Farming existed before the combine harvester, and like the combine harvester LLMs are very useful tools in these tasks.

You can't get a useful response from German for Dummies if you ask it to rate the email you're writing in German and let you know what needs improvement, human teachers who can are expensive, and friends may not wish to be constantly bothered by a 40 year old asking the kinds of questions a native speaker might have asked their teacher when they were 13.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by Nullabillity on Sunday December 15, 2024 @04:44AM (#42422565)
As a new language learner you're, by definition, not going to be in a place to judge the quality of the "feedback" you get from it.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Sunday December 15, 2024 @01:31PM (#42425034)
Course not. I can make the judgement call "this is good at German" by virtue of all the Germans around me using it.

(Conversely, I'm told it's quite bad at, say, Chinese — though mainly by people online, as there aren't many native Chinese speakers in my life right now).

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by tim333 on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:26AM (#42417662)
Electricity probably had niche uses for the first few years but as electrical stuff got better it got used in all sorts of things. I imagine AI will go a bit like that if quicker.

Looking back at the history of electricity, there is early stuff from the Greeks and then:

Faraday's homopolar disc generator 1831

Light bulb 1870

Transistor 1947

etc. So quite leisurely.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by parineum on Sunday December 15, 2024 @04:50PM (#42426227)
Considering the exponential increases in invention and adoption of new technologies for the past 200 years, I'm not sure that timeline is very close to what I'd expect from a new technology in this era.

I'd argue that we've already passed peak LLM as I think, after been having burned by it a few times, it's usage as a professional or reliable technology has seceded, rather than accelerated, over the past 6 months. Gone are the days of doom sayers talking about AGI taking over the world and LLMs replacing every single job at the call center and in software teams. Now everyone's scaled back to the things you can actually let it do, which is assist with a lot of coddling/verifying.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by bee_rider on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:20PM (#42412868)
Consciousness is a stupid and unreasonable goal, it is basically impossible to confirm that a machine isn’t just faking it really well.

Singularity is at least definable…Although I think it is not really the bar required to be really impactful. If we get an AI system that can do the work of like 60% of hardcore knowledge workers, 80% of office workers, and 95% of CEOs/politicians and other pablumists, it could be really change how the economy works without actually being a singularity.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by lupire on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:44PM (#42414237)
Those numbers are approximately zero, because demand will immediately 10x as soon as AI makes that affordable, as computers have always done. So, profitable (if the AI can cost less than a human for the work), but not changing how the economy works
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by tsimionescu on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:57AM (#42414971)
If white collar jobs get automated away to the extent that blue collar jobs were in the industrial revolution, that will be, by definition, a massive upheaval of the economy.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by result2vino on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:19PM (#42413244)
> 2 years before it was VR, few years before that NFTs and blockchain everything

Are you so deep in the SV tech echo chamber that you can’t distinguish between tech bro / snake oil salesman hype and something that actual normal people are engaged by?

The only people talking about NFTs in a non-disparaging way were delusional in large part because they themselves bought into it wanted to egg others on. NFTs were just a stupid faddish speculative ‘commodity’ market. It’s a completely different thing.

Ditto with “blockchain”. That well was positioned by people trying to make money from cryptocurrencies. The mechanics allowed for that. Again, it’s a completely different thing. Civilians with no vested interest weren’t sitting in restaurants singing the praises of decentralised ledgers or monkey pictures on someone’s Google Drive. I assure you. I also assure you that this IS however happening with ChatGPT. Out here in the real world, we see it.

This doesn’t mean that there aren’t issues with LLMs, both philosophically and in therms of their actual output. This doesn’t mean there aren’t the same old SV snake oil salespeople and YouTube wannabes trying to push some BS products and courses. But let’s not pretend for a second like this is usefully comparable to “blockchain” and “NFTs”.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by lupire on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:45PM (#42414243)
Blockchain and NFT took over the Super Bowl. That's pretty mainstream. There are Bitcoin ATMs.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by manquer on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:31AM (#42414898)
I am sorry, every A-List celebrity was shilling a NFT project, from superbowl to other public spheres of discourse seemed all crypto. The future president of the country has a crypto project to sell, I don’t see how much mainstream it can get.

Yes, There is close connection to SV hype cycle and what happens in mainstream, most mainstream ones originate in SV but the ones I mentioned specifically impacted the larger public not just SV tech sphere

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by lodovic on Saturday December 14, 2024 @02:35AM (#42415345)
I think that underestimates public engagements in these hypes. Billions were wasted by "normal" people worldwide on VR headsets, in-game nfts, and shitcoins. Real world money, not some inflated VC capital projections. And while the current LLMs still are an "advanced Eliza", regular people are quite happy to pay for its services.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by eastbound on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:44PM (#42412998)
Common, VR, NFTs and blockchain were always abysses of void looking for a usecase. Driving cars maybe, but development has been stalling for 15 years.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by manquer on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:14PM (#42413198)
Not to their proponents particularly at the time.

For the rest of us in HN it was easier to judge on much mileage will get, but a long time in each cycle we were in the minority, just like the AI skeptics including me and many here are today on how much we will value get.

Don’t get are wrong, AI is more real and more useful than the things before it, but everything is on a spectrum of success - some more and some less, but none of it has been or will be world changing or truly global.

The true breakthroughs rarely get public or even tech community attention until late in the cycle although their progress is public and can be tracked, like with EUV or mRNA or GLP-1 etc . Others which are incremental changes like 5G or cheaper smartphones do not get as much attention as their impact should warrant especially compared to the fads

Hype cycles don’t correlate well with real tech cycles

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by ben_w on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:30PM (#42413315)
I'd say VR is just another form factor for games rather than being a void looking for a use-case, but I agree about NFTs and cryptocurrency*.

* technically not all blockchains because git and BitTorrent are both also hash trees and therefore non-currency block-chains, but definitely the cryptocurrency uses of them.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by manquer on Friday December 13, 2024 @07:56PM (#42413705)
The point is not that they are snakeoil and have zero value . Every one of these things have some value in some area of applications.

However the hype cycle just as now in AI claimed it will change everything, not hey here is interesting new thing and it is going be used in select applications . Nobody is investing billions and billions on that pitch

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by sneak on Friday December 13, 2024 @07:03PM (#42413482)
Did you really just compare the thing that makes me able to code and ship 5x faster to... NFTs?
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by Terr_ on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:17PM (#42413815)
> code and ship

I notice that doesn't say what happened to the throughput of "diagnose, fix, and reduce technical debt." :p

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by manquer on Friday December 13, 2024 @07:45PM (#42413661)
Matter of perspective, Ai tools value depends on your existing skill level and whether it only doing what you already can do and you can correct it very well.

However that kind of user in my experience is rare , vast majority are junior developers who do not understand the output well enough and now generate 5x of it that I have to review and they no longer make the effort to understand any foundational concept .

This is not new, the rise in popularity of StackOverflow created a class of developers who didn’t want to spend the time to learn properly reading the manual.

In itself reducing the skill level needed to be productive is not inherently bad, it was PhD in CS could only program in 70s and 80s. Each generation of tech and abstraction opened up software development to newer class of employees.

However the difference is the industry desperately needed expansion each time because PCs became popular or the desktop or mobile devices etc . There was enormous demand for new applications both personal and professional which couldn’t be satisfied with kind of volume CS research programs could fulfill.

There is no such transformation currently , there aren’t a new class of users or major applications coming up in a such high volume, that quality drop is compensated by quantity .

There is lot more need for higher quality products as software market is plateauing from the highs mobile adoption gave.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by johnnyanmac on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:13PM (#42414100)
really depends on the kind of AI. If I said I shipped a AI-genned game 5x faster , then people would indeed compare it to NFTs.
Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by mlyle on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:47PM (#42413965)
> despite how far it has come it cannot in next 30 years be ubiquitous, even if the l5 magic tech exists today in every new car sold it will take 15 years for current cars to lifecycle.

We must have a different meaning of ubiquitous. Ubiquitous means "found everywhere" not "has eliminated everything else."

You don't even need to cycle the fleet once to meet the definition of ubiquitous. If you can get a self driving car in any city and many towns, you see them all over the place, and a third of trips are done with them, that'd be ubiquitous in my book.

I don't see why you couldn't get there in 3 decades. I don't think it's likely in 12 years but it seems possible in that timeframe.

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by manquer on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:20AM (#42414872)
I considered fleet change as the transformation that eliminates driving as a needed skill .

Getting a slightly better version of Waymo in SF is just augmenting for a poor public transit with a very American car solution .

It scales pretty poorly and cannot replace good public transit, at best can augment them as last mile connectivity .

There is value to those of course and is disruptive to a sector, it is still a specific use case and not world changing. You are only disrupting the taxi industry not driving itself .

The claims at the time was not we are going replace taxis with robotaxis , but driving itself will be a thing of the past. That is the nature of hype cycles .

Re:Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit by og_kalu on Saturday December 14, 2024 @05:20PM (#42419875)
Comparing the site that was #8 in Internet worldwide traffic last month, has 300M weekly active users, 1B messages a day and is basically the fastest adopted software product in history to NFTs, VR and Blockchain does not make any sense.