News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by Leary on Friday December 06, 2024 @01:35PM (#42342667)
The court must not have looked very hard.

"Let us be very clear: TikTok does not remove content based on sensitivities related to China. We have never been asked by the Chinese government to remove any content and we would not do so if asked. Period. Our US moderation team, which is led out of California, reviews content for adherence to our US policies – just like other US companies in our space. We are not influenced by any foreign government, including the Chinese government; TikTok does not operate in China, nor do we have any intention of doing so in the future."

https://newsroom.tiktok.com/en-us/statement-on-tiktoks-conte...

"58. Have members of the Chinese Communist Party, or other members of the Chinese government, asked ByteDance or TikTok employees to heat content?

TikTok does not heat content in the U.S. at the request of any government, including the Chinese Communist Party. TikTok may promote or "heat" specific content (including, e.g., promoting the video of an artist who will be hosting a concert on TikTok Live) in line with company content policies to support the inclusion of diverse and high-quality content on the platform. A content operations team will review heating requests submitted by a limited number of cross-functional partners with access to the heating request, and the Content Operations team will either approve or reject the request based on their assessment of whether it follows the platform's best practices in support of content diversity and quality (including, e.g., being engaging and meaningful and focusing on timely/relevant content) and business objectives. An audit function, that is in the process of being refined, will regularly review the heating request process to ensure internal compliance with company policies. Even if the request is approved, increasing visibility or video views ("VV") is not guaranteed as the recommendation system will not heat low quality content (e.g, reposted or irrelevant content). Heating impacts less than 1% of VV in the US."

https://docs.house.gov/meetings/IF/IF00/20230323/115519/HHRG...

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by WillPostForFood on Friday December 06, 2024 @01:48PM (#42342845)
The court must not have looked very hard.

The court isn't an investigative body, they take the evidence submitted. Perhaps TikTok was more careful to be truthful in court submissions than press releases.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday December 06, 2024 @02:33PM (#42343378)
Especially since what they said in the press doesn't even matter.

The models come from China.

You don't need to ask the US team to silence and amplify certain topics when your models do it for you.

If you know this is happening, you tell the US gov it isn't happening, and they find out it is - you're in for a bad time.

I'm not sure it's physically possible for a CEO to bury their head in the sand deep enough to plead ignorance in this situation.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by sanderjd on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:41PM (#42344187)
Yeah I'm pretty flabbergasted that the commenter who posted this press language thinks it's a disproof of the issue rather than a transparently carefully worded statement that you could drive a truck of algorithmic manipulation through.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by HaZeust on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:39PM (#42344773)
I mean, it's a lie by omission - which fundamentally needs familiarity (and oftentimes intermediate+ knowledge on a matter) to spot and scrutinize. The people who write these press releases are led by smart people that often talk to smart lawyers - it's easy to get lost in the sneaky language sauce.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by lukan on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:06PM (#42345048)
Would this really work? Hardcoded models? When you want to influence a certain topic in a new way, on recent events - this means a new model needs to be created and adjusted all the time. I assume they rather use a complex traditional algorithm that can be tweaked - and if it is in use in US - it can be verified. If it is run through china, then things are clear as well. Do we have technical insights how it works?
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by floatingtorch on Friday December 06, 2024 @11:52PM (#42347370)
You can simply use specific training examples that teach the model what you please. Eg. a set of examples which lead ranking/retreival/filtering models. The models are already online training and weights likely updated every ~1 hour ( or even less).

It’d be easy to go from a set of “moderators” who find examples and use it to query related content and use it as negative training samples. Just a guess.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by alwa on Friday December 06, 2024 @02:02PM (#42342992)
I think those kind of answers might be exactly what the court is talking about. You don’t have to “remove” something to influence its reach.

They’re denying stuff that doesn’t matter while leaving plenty of room for the kind of behavior that does.

To the question that you quoted: asked a question in the past tense, they responded in the present. Asked whether individual people had made requests, they answered whether they currently act on government requests.

It reads as such a non-denial denial.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by MisterKent on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:56PM (#42344955)
Search tiananmen on any app and then on TikTok. Regardless of their testimony, it doesn't take much to show that it isn't 100% of the truth.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by beastcoast on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:34PM (#42346472)
I just did though - got lots of results about the massacre. Not sure what you’re alluding to.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by fluidcruft on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:22PM (#42345199)
Things can be manipulated without being removed. This sort of word substitution is the type of misdirection "never squarely denies" could be referencing. They're asked about manipulation and they reply about removal. Removal is merely one type of manipulation. For example something like permanently hiding content while keeping it in the database isn't a removal.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by jsyang00 on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:41PM (#42345357)
"We are not influenced by any foreign government, including the Chinese government."

It is laughable to suggest that the basis for this ruling is anything less than fear and paranoia about Chinese government softpower. Nothing they could have said, and no fact they could bring to bear, would change the outcome of the court, which has been predetermined, for better or worse, by the current American political climate.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by UltraSane on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:15PM (#42345625)
Search tiananmen on any app and then on TikTok. It is ridiculous that China can block all these sites but the US can't block TikTok

    Facebook (and Messenger)
    Instagram
    Pinterest
    Twitter
    Blogger
    Tumblr
    Tinder
    Blogspot    
    New York Times
    The Financial Times
    The Economist
    The Wall Street Journal
    Bloomberg
    Google News
    Wikipedia
    YouTube
    Netflix
    Vimeo
    Google Search
    Bing
    Yahoo
    DuckDuckGo
    Messenger (and Facebook)
    WeChat
    SnapChat
    Telegram
    Signal
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by llamaimperative on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:24PM (#42345694)
I'm no fan of TikTok but this is a really shitty argument.

China can do it because China doesn't have the First Amendment, which is, you know, sort of the whole point...

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by Wowfunhappy on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:42PM (#42346185)
But in practice, that means the only global social network—one that is accessible in both the US and in China—is one that agrees to Chinese censorship laws. IMO, this is a massive backfire to the purpose of freedom of speech.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by corimaith on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:18PM (#42346378)
paradox of intolerance rears it's head up again.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by brookst on Saturday December 07, 2024 @01:25AM (#42347687)
Yes? That’s how it works. Because as soon as you act like the enemy, you’re no different from them.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by votepaunchy on Saturday December 07, 2024 @02:48PM (#42352329)
An America without TikTok is still vastly more free than China. Our constitution is not a suicide pact.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by oskarkk on Saturday December 07, 2024 @05:51AM (#42348871)
Isn't there a totally separate TikTok for China?

>TikTok, whose mainland Chinese and Hong Kong[3] counterpart is Douyin,[a][4] is a short-form video hosting service (...)

>While TikTok and Douyin share a similar user interface, the platforms operate separately.[28][4][29] Douyin includes an in-video search feature that can search by people's faces for more videos of them, along with other features such as buying, booking hotels, and making geo-tagged reviews.[30]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TikTok

So I think even TikTok (app for non-China markets) isn't available in China.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by llamaimperative on Saturday December 07, 2024 @08:26AM (#42349688)
Yep, liberalism is hard. More breaking news at 10.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by SllX on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:08PM (#42346926)
Plenty of countries don't have the First Amendment that are still liberal democracies that adhere to more or less free trade principles. The PRC does it because they are totalitarian State subject to the control of the Communist Party of China and their censorship regime does not stop at the border:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_censorship_abroad

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by pelagicAustral on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:20PM (#42346974)
Do Americans really have a 1st amendment anymore?
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by bdangubic on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:39PM (#42347057)
If social media sites had identity proofing (e.g. IAL2) and you can definitely say who is saying what - then you can talk

A) About “Americans”

B) Freedom of Speech

If TikTok bans a post from user846859347 which American’s freedom of speech are we talking about. 98.65% of shit on TT is bot-generated propaganda and removing it isn’t violating anyone’s freedom of speech

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by llamaimperative on Saturday December 07, 2024 @08:25AM (#42349683)
Yes, which is why you hear them unabashedly complaining about their government nonstop.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by UltraSane on Sunday December 08, 2024 @06:39PM (#42361729)
Compared to China? Absolutely. Ask Gedhun Choekyi Nyima
[dead]
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by proxynoproxy on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:19PM (#42346057)
What TikTok offered was abhorrent to American sensibilities:

America: we don’t want ccp censorship of people’s content ByteDance: no problem, here are the knobs for US gov censorship, should be ok! America: you have missed the point entirely, pls go away

Have a think why this might be, thinking about…

rule of law, acceptability to the public, democracy, freedom of speech, freedom of association, authoritarian states and arbitrary rules.

There is a reason why one place must carefully plan policy, and another place can arbitrarily restrictions on anyone or anything. State violence can be used in both cases, but typically the later will use friends and family for leverage with such state violence.

I just wish for a world without bytedance and its patrons stamping on the worlds faces forever.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by maxglute on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:34PM (#42346133)
What TikTok offers is compliant with American sensibilities considering it follows US laws and is massively popular with US audiences. You know rule of law... acceptability to the public etc etc. If anything PRC restrictions are less arbiturary since it applies to all platform operators, while US is arbiturary since it doesn't.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by proxynoproxy on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:42PM (#42346187)
You are making the same mistake as bytedance. It’s not about applying the law equally, it’s about the abhorrence of such laws.

When you have no say in the law, all you can demand is that it is applied equally. When you have a say in the law, you can question its existence.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by maxglute on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:15PM (#42346356)
One can point out the existence of the law is designed to be not about equal application, and highlight that is reflection on quality of law and the interests behind it. Ultimately, it's applier's perogative to push unequal application. Highlighting this scenario is one where US is more rule by law vs PRC rule of law is certainly going to seem like a mistake to those who want to interpret it as the opposite.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by proxynoproxy on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:33PM (#42346468)
Again, you are missing the point, which may be a product of your environment. It’s not about systemic differences, or who is doing rule of law “properly”.

One side is pointing at knobs with the word China crossed out and replaced with USA.

The other side is shocked that someone would make such knobs in the first place, regardless of their label.

The issue is not the shape of the knob, or the color, or its size. The issue is the knobs existence.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by maxglute on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:57PM (#42346600)
Who is shocked? It's extremely not surprising the knob exists, it's surprising so many people think the knob is one shape when it's another. The original chain is about discussing the shape, not the existence.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by proxynoproxy on Friday December 06, 2024 @09:08PM (#42346663)
Getting closer!! You are not shocked, and can’t see why anyone would be surprised the knob exists. This is closer to the root issue.

I want you to think about people that might be shocked, Not for the shape, but the existence. Or why one might even desire such knobs. Think about why this might be.

It’s all very abstract now. You are not trying to convince me of anything, and all I am trying to do is expand your perspective. Peace to all.

[dead]
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by 10000truths on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:49PM (#42346236)
This site isn't the place for Reddit-quality mudslinging. From the guidelines:

> Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents, and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by UltraSane on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:42PM (#42346523)
I fixed it.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by maxglute on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:18PM (#42346051)
When did I suggest US didn't have sovereign right to ban tiktok? I'm merely pointing out the reality that PRC didn't specifically craft legislation to ban US platforms - they block platforms that doesn't comply with PRC laws. Whereas US has to specifically single out TikTok because TikTok complying with the same US laws as other US platforms still undermines US interests. It's fine to accept US can do what it wants, but let's not pretend they're the same thing.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by UltraSane on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:27PM (#42346101)
"I'm merely pointing out the reality that PRC didn't specifically craft legislation to ban US platforms - they block platforms that doesn't comply with PRC laws"

This says a lot about how restrictive Chinese laws are vs US laws.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by maxglute on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:49PM (#42346231)
And? It's restrictive but equal - hire 100ks of local moderators at extraordinary cost vs cheap out on human moderation and wrecklessly cause anti-social events. If anything PRC laws are prescient considering the reason they existed was lax US platform enforcement causing 2009 minority riots in PRC after which western platforms (twitter/fb) were blocked for literally refusing to censor calls for violence. Wouldn't be until NZ shooting and Rohingya genocide years later that western platforms took a page from PRC model and increased human moderation - incidentally after which when both FB and Google had internal programs to build PRC compliant services - after they learned unlimited speech is stupid, and human moderation was neccesary cost. After realizing scaling up human moderation made complying with PRC laws possible. And the only reason those initiatives failed was corporate internal drama, i.e. it wasn't PRC that stopped them from reentering market. At the end of the day - western plaforms are converging towards PRC model, not vice versa because restrictions fine. They just can't square PRC platforms operating on same local restrictions which says a lot about US laws.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by fluidcruft on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:58PM (#42346269)
Yes, everyone waring a bootprint on their face is the mark of equality. It's not the mark of freedom, but it is the mark of equality.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by maxglute on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:01PM (#42346287)
It's Uncle Sam's bootprint... it's as free as any other boot western platforms wears. Except as we learn the boot doesn't matter if it's a Chinese foot.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by fluidcruft on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:32PM (#42346464)
I already live with that one, don't need another.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by proxynoproxy on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:39PM (#42346505)
Who cares who owns the foot. It’s the action, and the boot, that is the problem. Don’t make this about the owner, make it about the action. And maybe get rid of the boots?
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by UltraSane on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:45PM (#42346541)
Where is Gedhun Choekyi Nyima?
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by UltraSane on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:43PM (#42346530)
The majestic equality of a boot stomping equally on everyone's faces.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by kaishiro on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:35PM (#42346141)
I’ll start by saying that I’m honestly largely ambivalent about this entire situation (potentially more than I should be - but I find it more difficult to care about things outside of my immediate control as I get older), but I’m really finding it difficult to understand what point it is you’re trying to make. Is your only issue that the US has far less restrictive commercial laws and so has specifically targeted TikTok in this case?
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by maxglute on Friday December 06, 2024 @07:58PM (#42346271)
I don't have issue with US specifically targetting TikTok - it's USsovereign right, I have issue with people who forwards the argument that this is the same as PRC not specifically targetting US platforms who chose not to comply with PRC laws that also apply to domestic plaforms, which btw FB and Google both had initives to comply with (i.e. project dragonfly for Google) but was killed due to internal dissent, i.e. it's US companies that doesn't want to deal with PRC laws. At the end of the day, at least PRC requirements are "fair", they don't have to resort to wild requirements like divestment. At most they required local JV/warehousing, i.e. what TikTok offered with Oracle.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by kaishiro on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:09PM (#42346329)
So it sounds like if the US had a far more restrictive system, like China currently has, that was applied across the board you would be OK with this? (That’s an actual question, I’m not trying to be combative). I’m also still unsure why targeting TikTok specifically is “wild”, unless again you think the US should simply never be targeting corporations directly - foreign or otherwise - and instead should always be legislating more broadly?

In case it’s not clear, even though I think I disagree with you I want to again say that I’m trying to understand your opinion, not tear you down.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by maxglute on Friday December 06, 2024 @08:25PM (#42346413)
I'm OK with US banning TikTok on whatever legal lawfare/loophole it chooses to conjure, the goal is afterall to ban TikTok, realstically not just from US but from world via US control of app stores. The "wildness" is not targetting TikTok per say, but the specific tactic of requiring divestment, i.e. literally trying to nationalize (or rather de-nationalize) another countries company (and let's be real ByteDance is PRC even if incorporated in Singapore). Even PRC doesn't go further than a 51/49 JV. They'll have sectoral black/white lists, but that includes/precludes everyone, not country specific. It's just comes off as extra fragile rule-by-law behaviour on platforms even relative to PRC, but as I reiterate elsewhere, that's US perogative, I don't find it "wrong", just highlighting how it's extreme even by PRC standards.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by datavirtue on Saturday December 07, 2024 @12:02PM (#42351030)
That's a hell of a lot of milieu control. Seems they are just trying to prevent an understanding and ultimately a blending of cultures and are effectively controlling language and therefore the people's world view.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by llamaimperative on Saturday December 07, 2024 @12:48PM (#42351374)
... yes...
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by nambamutta on Saturday December 07, 2024 @05:38PM (#42353397)
Do you even use the app? I literally found it on Tiktok within seconds
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by llamaimperative on Friday December 06, 2024 @06:23PM (#42345679)
Oh no, fear and paranoia about a dictatorial regime with extrajudicial police stations in the US to hunt down family members of domestic political dissidents putting media in front of our children's eyes 24/7 while walking around our streets with space age sensor arrays! Oh no! So unjustifiably fearful!

Who could possibly take issue with such a technology!

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by CPLX on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:48PM (#42345420)
If a court of appeals says a party to a case "has not denied" something they are speaking specifically about the record of the trial being presented to them.
Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by epolanski on Saturday December 07, 2024 @08:48AM (#42349814)
Not sure why are you getting down voted to express an informative take.

It feels like I'm on Reddit and not in a place that should be more intellectually active and open.

Re:TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court by nullc on Saturday December 07, 2024 @12:54PM (#42351415)
Public comments not made in court are worthless as a defense. They didn't make those same remarks in court where they could be forced to answer questions about their meaning and where the speaker could be sent to prison for knowingly lying about them.