News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by mg on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:03AM (#42329409)

    our service – which already provides over 150,000
    trips per week across Phoenix, Los Angeles, San
    Francisco, and Austin
Interesting. That's about 8 million rides per year.

I wonder how close they are to being profitable? As soon as they are getting close to being profitable, they will probably scale this up super fast.

I don't know how much Google invested into Waymo so far. Something like $10B?

If they at some point make $10 per ride, they would only need something like 50 million rides per year to justify that investment with a p/e ratio of 20.

To go from 8M rides to 50M in 5 years they would have to increase their capacity by 50% per year. Might be possible?

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by avrionov on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:44AM (#42329814)
The number of trips increased 10x from Sep 2023 to August 2024. https://www.sfchronicle.com/california/article/waymo-robotax...
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by ezfe on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:11AM (#42329482)
Profitable from an operations perspective? Surely close since they charge the same order of magnitude as an Uber/Lyft and have fewer than one driver per vehicle (monitoring the vehicles).
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by mg on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:12AM (#42329491)
We have to add the deprecation and maintenance of the car.

Plus I guess they need high resolution maps? Not sure if that is a significant cost factor.

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by bbor on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:25AM (#42329616)
I mean, they're Google -- I'm guessing they're pulling out their "pointcloud of the entire world" for this one. The first point is a great one, tho; rideshare companies exist by offloading as much cost as possible onto their employees, and even then barely make it work.

Plus, at least some of the Waymos are super-fancy Jaguars -- tho it looks like roughly 20K Jaguars to 65K Chrysler minivans, according to Wikipedia. Still, they're all brand new vehicles; even with bulk discount, that can't be cheap.

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by jeffbee on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:33AM (#42329704)
Waymo does not have 85k cars lol. In their latest CPUC report they only have 480 cars in California and that is their biggest market by far. If they had 85k cars and only 175k rides per week that would be the worst business in the history of businessing.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by yellowstuff on Thursday December 05, 2024 @12:25PM (#42330290)
It looks like they contracted to buy "up to" 20,000 Jaguars: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/mar/27/waymo-sel...

Pretty effective press release! Nothing in it is untrue, but it's obviously misleading even to careful readers.

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by cozzyd on Thursday December 05, 2024 @10:24PM (#42335966)
Yes, and I have up to 20,000 jaguars in my garage. (ok, I don't even have a garage...)
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by marcosdumay on Thursday December 05, 2024 @12:51PM (#42330539)
On the other hand, they certainly have a much better vehicle utilization than the other ride-app companies. They cars are cooperating in covering an area, not competing for the rides there.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by ezfe on Monday December 09, 2024 @11:06AM (#42367458)
Since they're using entirely electric cars that they will likely never sell so depreciation and maintenance will be favorable. There is the up-front cost of equipping the cars with equipment though, which I imagine is substantial.

For the high resolution maps, that cost is fixed per market area. It could limit a rollout to new markets by driving area.

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by jeffbee on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:24AM (#42329611)
Just a few hours ago Sundar Pichai said it's 175k/wk https://youtu.be/kZzeWLOzc_4?t=926
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by bbor on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:22AM (#42329585)
I imagine it's hard to quantify "profit" with such a research-driven org. It's like penciling out the profitability of the metaverse after years of $XX billion dollar losses. In general I get the sense that Waymo is more of a diverse investment than a pure ride-hailing play; for example, as of 2020 they were working for Volvo, Chrysler, Jaguar, and Nissan[1], presumably for $$$.

It's also worth remembering that Zoox exists (Amazon's more futuristic self-driving car play, no steering wheel at all), and has not at all gone the way of Alexa/the Dodo bird (yet). I expect them to make a big splash sometime in the coming decade, personally.

That is, of course, assuming they survive regulatory capture by Tesla, which would need a miracle or an unfair advantage to beat these two at this point, even if they finally follow the science on the need for LiDAR. Another big unknown is how the electorate will react to self-driving cars becoming more than a novelty; Elon Musk is absolutely correct that a backlash of some kind is inevitable even if the safety stats pencil out, IMHO. Trusting a machine is kind of inherently creepy - see Prof. Weinersmith's lectures on the topic:

- https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/decisions

- https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/fsd

- https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/self-driving-car-ethics

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidsilver/2020/06/29/waymo-an...

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by sixQuarks on Thursday December 05, 2024 @12:32PM (#42330355)
Wow, I can’t believe you think Tesla needs a miracle to beat not only Waymo, but Zoox. This is laughable.

Are you not aware of FSD version 13 that just came out in beta?

An early tester did the exact same pickup and drop off at the same time of day between Tesla and Waymo yesterday. Tesla took 15 minutes while Waymo took 40 minutes.

Watch for yourself. Tesla is going to destroy Waymo, they can’t compete

https://youtu.be/CfX8Lu9MHa0?si=cOYWNXjPiYP9R6L_

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by teractiveodular on Thursday December 05, 2024 @01:57PM (#42331302)
And what makes you believe 13 will finally have decent FSD when the previous 12 attempts using the same hardware did not?
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by rsanek on Thursday December 05, 2024 @12:40PM (#42330424)
in what markets is tesla able to drive autonomously without any driver in the seat? from what I've read, none.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by kernal on Thursday December 05, 2024 @02:14PM (#42331523)
Until you can hop into the back seat of your Tesla and tell it to drive you somewhere with complete confidence then don't even compare the capabilities of Waymo and Tesla FSD.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by JumpCrisscross on Thursday December 05, 2024 @04:42PM (#42333120)
> Tesla is going to destroy Waymo, they can’t compete

You're both wrong. This remains an open question.

Tesla has promised a Level 5 product but hasn't delivered; FSD is Level 3. Waymo has a Level 4 product, but it requires an expensive sensor suite.

If Tesla can get Level 4 with cameras only, you're right. They win. We currently have no indication they've cracked that. We also have no evidence it's not doable with current technology.

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by ra7 on Thursday December 05, 2024 @10:35PM (#42336051)
Slight correction: FSD is Level 2, not Level 3.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by thrownv7032g on Thursday December 05, 2024 @07:58PM (#42334807)
Did the Tesla take the highway and the Waymo not?
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by cozzyd on Thursday December 05, 2024 @10:30PM (#42336011)
That's what it looks like... also looks like the Tesla was speeding on the highway. Probably should get an automatic speeding ticket...
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by bbor on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:32PM (#42341946)
I really didn't expect such a response from HN! I guess the Elon energy is still going strong. Thanks for staying polite though :) probably the only place on the internet where polite convos about such a divisive topic/figure/company are still taking place.

Suffice to say, I really don't think drive time comparisons by biased unpaid beta testers is a good way to measure viability in this market. Safety, regulatory cooperation, and ethics branding are going to be paramount, all of which Tesla is known to struggle with, to say the least.

Again though, the biggest problem is technical. I think the evidence is objective and clear that LiDAR guarantees a level of safety unattainable with cameras alone. Not only will this slow down development, it also highlights the issues above; how many more "Tesla swerves into a white semi-truck because the sun was reflecting off of it in a weird way" stories could they survive before backlash? Especially when the passengers are random people instead of invested enthusiasts, many of which have their retirement investments tied up in the company's worth.

You can laugh at Zoox, but A) based on what...? it's still in the R&D phase, there's no consumer product to laugh at, and B) there's certainly a lot of smart people still working on it, and money pouring in. Again, (AFAICT as an outsider-) it's night-and-day compared to orgs Amazon has abandoned, like Alexa.

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by oblio on Thursday December 05, 2024 @12:26PM (#42330302)
Google has invested and also drawn external funding. From what I've seen in the last 15 years since founding the lower bound for their cost seems to be higher than $12bn and I can only imagine expenses will only accelerate.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by fragmede on Thursday December 05, 2024 @06:18PM (#42333961)
Assuming they don't license the technology to everybody else and keep running their own cars. How much is this technology worth to every taxi company, every car manufacturer, every fleet operator in the world?
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by marketerinland on Thursday December 05, 2024 @10:54PM (#42336182)
How many rides are there every day in developed countries?

Their internal business case probably has them targeting not 50 million rides per year, but per week… at an absolute minimum

Regardless; at some point specialised vehicles will be developed which are ultra small and lightweight - less than $1,000 to produce - to take care of short downtown rides, for example.

It’s going to be a wild world.