News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by sixQuarks on Thursday December 05, 2024 @12:32PM (#42330355)
Wow, I can’t believe you think Tesla needs a miracle to beat not only Waymo, but Zoox. This is laughable.

Are you not aware of FSD version 13 that just came out in beta?

An early tester did the exact same pickup and drop off at the same time of day between Tesla and Waymo yesterday. Tesla took 15 minutes while Waymo took 40 minutes.

Watch for yourself. Tesla is going to destroy Waymo, they can’t compete

https://youtu.be/CfX8Lu9MHa0?si=cOYWNXjPiYP9R6L_

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by teractiveodular on Thursday December 05, 2024 @01:57PM (#42331302)
And what makes you believe 13 will finally have decent FSD when the previous 12 attempts using the same hardware did not?
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by rsanek on Thursday December 05, 2024 @12:40PM (#42330424)
in what markets is tesla able to drive autonomously without any driver in the seat? from what I've read, none.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by kernal on Thursday December 05, 2024 @02:14PM (#42331523)
Until you can hop into the back seat of your Tesla and tell it to drive you somewhere with complete confidence then don't even compare the capabilities of Waymo and Tesla FSD.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by JumpCrisscross on Thursday December 05, 2024 @04:42PM (#42333120)
> Tesla is going to destroy Waymo, they can’t compete

You're both wrong. This remains an open question.

Tesla has promised a Level 5 product but hasn't delivered; FSD is Level 3. Waymo has a Level 4 product, but it requires an expensive sensor suite.

If Tesla can get Level 4 with cameras only, you're right. They win. We currently have no indication they've cracked that. We also have no evidence it's not doable with current technology.

Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by ra7 on Thursday December 05, 2024 @10:35PM (#42336051)
Slight correction: FSD is Level 2, not Level 3.
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by thrownv7032g on Thursday December 05, 2024 @07:58PM (#42334807)
Did the Tesla take the highway and the Waymo not?
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by cozzyd on Thursday December 05, 2024 @10:30PM (#42336011)
That's what it looks like... also looks like the Tesla was speeding on the highway. Probably should get an automatic speeding ticket...
Re:Waymo announces Miami as its next ride hailing city by bbor on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:32PM (#42341946)
I really didn't expect such a response from HN! I guess the Elon energy is still going strong. Thanks for staying polite though :) probably the only place on the internet where polite convos about such a divisive topic/figure/company are still taking place.

Suffice to say, I really don't think drive time comparisons by biased unpaid beta testers is a good way to measure viability in this market. Safety, regulatory cooperation, and ethics branding are going to be paramount, all of which Tesla is known to struggle with, to say the least.

Again though, the biggest problem is technical. I think the evidence is objective and clear that LiDAR guarantees a level of safety unattainable with cameras alone. Not only will this slow down development, it also highlights the issues above; how many more "Tesla swerves into a white semi-truck because the sun was reflecting off of it in a weird way" stories could they survive before backlash? Especially when the passengers are random people instead of invested enthusiasts, many of which have their retirement investments tied up in the company's worth.

You can laugh at Zoox, but A) based on what...? it's still in the R&D phase, there's no consumer product to laugh at, and B) there's certainly a lot of smart people still working on it, and money pouring in. Again, (AFAICT as an outsider-) it's night-and-day compared to orgs Amazon has abandoned, like Alexa.