News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by the_mitsuhiko on Monday November 11, 2024 @06:43AM (#42106452)
Vienna to me is a fascinating case of a city that found itself again after having lost its place in history more than once.

If you look at the geography, if you look at the political climate, just at the fundamentals it's not clear why Vienna is a large city. There really is not a lot of reason for this city to matter today yet somehow it is a wonderful place to live in, despite all that.

The city somehow managed to find an identity on its own that somehow makes it work.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:19AM (#42106634)
> If you look at the geography, if you look at the political climate, just at the fundamentals it's not clear why Vienna is a large city.

Could you elaborate on this a bit please? Vienna has culturally always been considered the front door to eastern Europe (from a central European POV).

Vienna is one of the best cities in central Europe to go for an academic degree: Renting is capped and still affordable (and wants to be kept that way btw, see the ban of AirBnB). There are almost no education fees, even non-austrians can apply for benefits from the government. With 200k students it's the largest german-speaking university city on par with Berlin[0]. The employment law is exemplary good. For me personally it isn't surprsing that almost 1/4th of whole Austria lives in Vienna.

[0]: https://www.wien.gv.at/statistik/pdf/viennainfigures-2023.pd...

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:44AM (#42106727)
>The employment law is exemplary good.

Taht's not true at all. Employers can lay off workers for no reason at all at any time without paying any severance (unless you have a unio that can negotiate a better deal). Just hand them the notice and you're done.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:51AM (#42106760)
The notice period is 6 weeks at minimum by law and often negotiated to be 3 months on unlimited contracts - limited contacts can't be terminated unilateral. And, depending on social situation, you can still sue immediately through the Arbeiterkammer[0] without any costs.

[0]: https://www.arbeiterkammer.at/beratung/arbeitundrecht/beendi...

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by jahnu on Monday November 11, 2024 @08:56AM (#42107117)
Right there are some restrictions but people seem to have the weird idea that you can't get fired without cause or redundancy. If the employer does it correctly they can essentially get rid of anyone, those restrictions notwithstanding.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:05AM (#42107169)
You can get fired immediately without cause, but that's against the law, and the law is pretty clear on lawful causes:

  § 27.

  Als ein wichtiger Grund, der den Dienstgeber zur vorzeitigen Entlassung berechtigt, ist insbesondere anzusehen:

    1. Wenn der Angestellte im Dienste untreu ist, sich in seiner Tätigkeit ohne Wissen oder Willen des Dienstgebers von dritten Personen unberechtigte Vorteile zuwenden läßt, insbesondere entgegen der Bestimmung des § 13 eine Provision oder eine sonstige Belohnung annimmt, oder wenn er sich einer Handlung schuldig macht, die ihn des Vertrauens des Dienstgebers unwürdig erscheinen läßt;
    2. wenn der Angestellte unfähig ist, die versprochenen oder die den Umständen nach angemessenen Dienste (§ 6) zu leisten;
    3. wenn einer der im § 1 bezeichneten Angestellten ohne Einwilligung des Dienstgebers ein selbständiges kaufmännisches Unternehmen betreibt oder im Geschäftszweige des Dienstgebers für eigene oder fremde Rechnung Handelsgeschäfte macht oder wenn ein Angestellter den in § 7, Absatz 4, bezeichneten Verboten zuwiderhandelt;
    4. wenn der Angestellte ohne einen rechtmäßigen Hinderungsgrund während einer den Umständen nach erheblichen Zeit die Dienstleistung unterläßt oder sich beharrlich weigert, seine Dienste zu leisten oder sich den durch den Gegenstand der Dienstleistung gerechtfertigten Anordnungen des Dienstgebers zu fügen, oder wenn er andere Bedienstete zum Ungehorsam gegen den Dienstgeber zu verleiten sucht;
    5. wenn der Angestellte durch eine längere Freiheitsstrafe oder durch Abwesenheit während einer den Umständen nach erheblichen Zeit, ausgenommen wegen Krankheit oder Unglücksfalls, an der Verrichtung seiner Dienste gehindert ist;
    6. wenn der Angestellte sich Tätlichkeiten, Verletzungen der Sittlichkeit oder erhebliche Ehrverletzungen gegen den Dienstgeber, dessen Stellvertreter, deren Angehörige oder gegen Mitbedienstete zuschulden kommen läßt.
The employee can also "fire their employer", see § 26[0] for lawful causes.

The proof of guilt is up to the one who fires in the end.

I know of one person who got fired unlawful, and their ex-employer is now EUR 80k+ poorer.

[0]: https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=Bundes...

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:29AM (#42107353)
I think you're mixing up firing and dismissing. You need a reason to fire someone but firing means no notice period and no unemployment benefits, but you don't need a reason to dismiss someone with notice, which is relatively unique nerf in terms of EU workers rights by comparison.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:41AM (#42107463)
GP was talking about firing and you were talking about the usual termination of an employment contract with a notice period.

You don't need a reason to terminate an employment contract with a notice period, correct, but that doesn't mean it wasn't socially discriminating in origin - that depends on the social situation (eg. older employees can sue for discrimination on age) and the Arbeiterkammer will fight for it.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:57AM (#42108051)
If they don't need to provide a reason for terminating you then you also can't have a case for discrimination even if that were to happen since no employer is gonna tell you "yeah, we're firing you behause you're too black/woman", they'll just say "you're fired". AK was never of any use with despicable employers since the employee protection laws are very lax and employers very good at skirting the law so they can abuse you without being legally liable. Just read Kununu reviews of several Austrian companies.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:17AM (#42108230)
> Just read Kununu reviews of several Austrian companies.

I'd rather suggest to go to the Arbeits- und Sozialgericht[0] and listen to some real cases, they are public anyway.

[0]: https://www.justiz.gv.at/asg-wien/arbeits-und-sozialgericht-...

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:35PM (#42108856)
How does looking at "real cases" help me? They don't make my own cases any less real?

Just because cases don't go through the court system, doesn't mean employer abuse doesn't happen.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by em-bee on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:28AM (#42108317)
you can still suspect discrimination, and if you sue they have to prove that it wasn't.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:10PM (#42108678)
This isn't America. AK won't help you sue based on suspicions of discriminations if you don't bring written evidence that makes it a slam dunk case. And the court isn't biased towards the employee like the US jury.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:54PM (#42109014)
Austrian law isn't US law, correct. I still don't understand your persistent pessimism though...

What I once saw when I went to the Arbeits- und Sozialgericht was a man, in the beginning of his 40s, suing for unlawful termination of his employment contract, after notice period and 7 months of employment. He sued with the help of the Arbeiterkammer. The judge asked the employer for their reasons, and tried to figure out if the termination has been made through thoughtful reasoning and after consideration of any other options. It is the responsibility of the employer too(!), and frankly in their best interest, to bring their employees up to speed and make them succeed in their work.

"We don't need to state any reason" won't fly in front of the judge in Austria, as the judge wants to make an informed decision.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by em-bee on Monday November 11, 2024 @01:22PM (#42109277)
exactly, this isn't america. despite not needing to have a specific reason for letting someone go you are not allowed to use morally questionable reasons (which goes beyond outright discrimination), and you must evaluate how the loss of employment affects the employee. that means, for example, the likelihood of that employee finding a new job with similar pay, (so you can't easily let go of older people), their family situation, or if they have another income. so you basically have to choose the employee who would be least affected. as far as i understand these kinds questions are not considered at all in the US. only discrimination againt protected classes, as defined by the law.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @08:57AM (#42107128)
>The notice period is 6 weeks at minimum by law and often negotiated to be 3 months

The issue is being able to let go of workers for no reason, not the notice period itself, which BTW, every EU country has, Austria is nothing special here, quite the opposite. Do you feel this imbalance of power that you can be let go at any time for any reason is a fair to the workers in a so called socialist country?

Wouldn't be such a big issue if unemployment wouldn't be a pitiful 60% of your salary for ~3 months (yes it can be longer but you're then at the mercy of the system handler if they agree with the job search you're doing, otherwise they can also cut you off if you don't want to take hard jobs like warehouse work) .

>you can still sue immediately through the Arbeiterkammer

AK will only help you sue only in case of unfair dismissal which rarely happens because employers don't need to provide a reason for terminating you as long as they give you the 6-week-3-month notice. So long hours, burnout and hire-and-fire mentality is rampant among Austrian companies, but rarely talked about because it contradicts the "most livable country" narrative paid for by Austria to the Economist who runs that yearly campaign-ad.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:58AM (#42107588)
> The issue is being able to let go of workers for no reason, not the notice period itself, which BTW, every EU country has, Austria is nothing special here, quite the opposite. Do you feel this imbalance of power that you can be let go at any time for any reason is a fair to the workers in a so called socialist country?

I don't think of Austria as a socialist country and I think it's fair to be able to let people go without reason, but with a notice period (and unemployment benefits and social healthcare).

In practice, it won't be much different than with the requirement of a reason anyway: If you'll want to fight it, then you'll need to go through legal ways and contest the employers decision anyway. In Austria there's a 2-week time limit to bring in a lawsuit on unlawful termination of an employment contract if you still want to work there.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by rettetdemdativ on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:08AM (#42107663)
Where did you get the idea that Austria is a socialist country? It used to be to a certain degree, but those times are long gone, except for strong unionization, the social safety net and worker protections. Austria is a deeply conservative country and has been for much of its history. Vienna is a bit of an exception, as it has actually been ruled by social democrats for ~100 years (with a violent break during the 30s and 40s).
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by the_mitsuhiko on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:11AM (#42107220)
I would argue that's what makes it good employment law.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:50AM (#42107992)
How so? Wages are still lower than in Germany, Belgium, Sweden or Netherlands where it's difficult to dismiss someone without proper cause and a long process.

Where are the benefits for Austrian workers for this lack of protection against firing versus countries that have protections?

And where is this HN simping for ruthless capitalist that lay you off you the moment you get sick coming from? What am I not seeing here?

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:43AM (#42108437)
> And where is this HN simping for ruthless capitalist that lay you off you the moment you get sick coming from?

Sounds like you made some experiences with the wrong people.

The process is faster than in other european countries, true, but we're still far away from a short process... unemployment benefits, social healthcare, sick leave, holidays etc. A shorter process can open up good opportunities, but demands some security to enjoy the risks. I think we're mostly balancing this act and it's a good thing when it makes Austria more attractive to employers. Competition against Germany, Belgium, Sweden, or the Netherlands is in my own interest.

Especially in the case of software engineering it can be beneficial to join unstable employments and be ready to change frequently. I'm mostly seeing it as grateful (depending on market), as you can only see so many system designs fail in your lifetime. :D

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:58AM (#42108576)
>Sounds like you made some experiences with the wrong people.

A lot of Austrian employers behave like this: Hire and fire. Got sick? So long. This shouldn't be acceptable in an EU country. AK is also useless here because the laws are toothless.

>unemployment benefits, social healthcare, sick leave, holidays etc

Those exist in every other EU company where you can't lay off people just because you don't like their face anymore.

>Competition against Germany, Belgium, Sweden, or the Netherlands is in my own interest.

Yet those countries score better at innovation, entrepreneurship while having better worker rights and higher wages. How do you explain that? I'm not sure working yourself to death in a race to the bottom on lowering workers rights is a good strategy.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by sehansen on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:52AM (#42115447)
Without any personal experience with the Austrian labour market, it seems like firing people is around as easy in Austria as it is here in Denmark. And wages are higher in Denmark than in Germany, Belgium, Sweden and Netherlands. So the low wages and bad conditions for employees in Austria probably have some other, common cause.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by FredPret on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:34AM (#42107399)
The easier it is to fire or retrench someone, the easier it is to hire them.

And if it's easy for me to hire... then it's easier for the next entrepreneur to hire... paradoxically driving wages up and forcing businesses to keep hiring high so as to keep their competitive edge.

The only people suffering under such a system are freeloaders - who get hired and then proceed to lean on labour laws to stick around for a long time after their welcome has worn out.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by the_mitsuhiko on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:14AM (#42107242)
> Could you elaborate on this a bit please?

Austria has no sea access, no navy, few natural resources. Vienna is strategically not in a particularly amazing position compared to most other cities around. It's not clear to me what the fundamental reasons are why Vienna should be a large city other than that it historically was one, declined a bit and somehow regrew.

I think it's great here, but I also cannot really understand why.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by paulgerhardt on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:31AM (#42107834)
Coffee.

While Vienna is located at the crossroads between the planes and the Alps along the Danube making it modestly fortifiable from previous Ottoman incursions in 1529 and essential hub for quarterly markets. As the easternmost capital not to fall to the Ottomans, merchants that went to the Viennese markets would have valuable first arbitrage opportunities on eastern spices, textiles, medicines, gems, and ceramics coming from the east (the taxes on which solidified the Hapsburg position). However, it wasn’t until the siege of 1683 [1] that resulted in the Ottomans crushing defeat and withdrawal much like a port city by a sea only to see the sea recede.

In that withdrawal the Ottomans left behind enough coffee in their abandoned provisions that the Viennese were able to open Europe’s first coffee house and cement Vienna as Europes premier nexus for academia :-)

[1] https://youtu.be/ukyquQkQAYo

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by em-bee on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:54AM (#42108029)
Austria has no sea access

austria had sea access right up to WW1. and vienna only started to decline after that. vienna is also on the danube, a river that is connected to the main and rhine and allows ships to travel all the way from the north sea to the black sea. that makes it better positioned than paris, berlin or munich in this aspect. although i doubt that the river had much to do with its regrowth in the last few decades. it is more likely that its closeness to eastern europe made it an attractive destination once the eastern bloc fell apart, which was just before the time vienna started growing again.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by the_mitsuhiko on Monday November 11, 2024 @01:00PM (#42109065)
Sure, but Austria lost a lot of this many, many years ago. Yet Vienna continues to be an important city :)
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:33AM (#42107390)
Austria was mostly about mathematics, engineering and human sciences. There was an Austro-Hungarian Navy, and Josef Ressel gave the Royal Navy the world's most powerful navy with his invention of the propeller. :D
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by inglor_cz on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:25PM (#42110568)
Maths was stronger in Germany, especially in Heidelberg. Riemann, Hilbert et al. were all Germans.

There was also a fairly strong Polish school of maths and formal logic, but it can only be called Austrian with some stretching of the word; while Galicia was part of the empire, it was about as far (ethnically, culturally and physically) from Vienna as possible.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by empath75 on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:24AM (#42107309)
> Austria has no sea access, no navy, few natural resources.

Austria used to have all of those things. Vienna itself is not particularly different from any other imperial capital in terms of its location.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by kingkawn on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:07AM (#42107654)
Even a cursory look at its history would resolve these questions
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by numewhodis on Monday November 11, 2024 @02:34PM (#42109818)
> I also cannot really understand why.

That's exactly why. Some wonderfully peculiar people were born from that gene pool. But that's history. They don't build em like that anymore.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by akgerber on Monday November 11, 2024 @05:02PM (#42110823)
Nearly all large cities today are large cities because they historically were one, leading to economies of scale in infrastructure and agglomeration economies in the production and exchange of goods and services. Ease of sea access is not a major determinant of a city's growth & prosperity today.

Many cities historically grew around ports due to the labor intensity of break-bulk shipping and the difficulty and expense of overland goods transport but modern container ports require relatively few employees and can easily move freight intermodally. The old piers in London and Hamburg and New York and San Francisco and their adjacent factories have all been redeveloped, and the working container ports have all relocated away from the city center to places where rail & highway access is easier, to places like Newark, Oakland, and Felixstowe.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by wintermutestwin on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:20AM (#42107282)
>see the ban of AirBnB

Huh? I was there this summer with my daughter and there were plenty of Airbnbs. They were dramatically more affordable (especially given my need for two separate rooms).

I get the AirBnB hate from local renters, but as a frequent traveler, hotels suck so bad that they deserve disruption.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by cg5280 on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:33AM (#42107387)
I actually feel the opposite, I quite like the convenience that hotels offer (such as housekeeping, clean sheets) and I've found that unless you are doing longterm stays (1 month+) the prices between hotels and Airbnbs are usually comparable.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by ghaff on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:33AM (#42107855)
I've done very little renting from AirBnBs and they can be cheaper and there are certainly certain types of properties (like whole house rentals) that aren't really available from traditional hotels vs. AirBnB/VRBO/etc.

That said, especially for visiting a city, I'll pretty much go with traditional hotels, often chains, for the predictability. I've very rarely had a truly bad experience and it's usually been something like a badly situated luck-of-the-draw room and even that isn't usually a big deal in a city where I'm not spending a lot of time in a room.

I can reliably checkin whenever, there's staff on-call, I don't usually care if I have a kitchen other than a small fridge (which many hotels have these days), and so forth. I've stayed in many B&Bs--some of which are also listed these days on AirBnB. Most have been good, some less so. Usually less of a good option in urban centers.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by isaacremuant on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:13PM (#42110476)
Airbnb is just a scapegoat for the people who want quick solutions for the damage governments have done for ages.

Competition is good and empowering people to make money off their assets (just like Uber) even better. Regulate it and hotels to protect consumers but don't pretend Airbnb's are the cause for housing being unaffordable to rent or buy. Specially not when you're taxing renters like mad and offering little in return.

It's always funny reading takes in HN about places where you have first hand knowledge of, whether it be a geographic location or a company.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by rettetdemdativ on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:03AM (#42107626)
Renting is not capped, unless I'm reading your comment wrong and you mean that the city's government influences it. Vienna does not have an explicit cap. Newer flats and houses are index-bound and rents are raised depending on a certain inflation threshold. Older buildings are usually cheaper and there are strict rules on how much rent can be raised. What Vienna does to make renting an apartment affordable is build social housing. Lots of it. 500.000 people in Vienna live in social housing and the Gemeindebauten are actually nice to live in, priority is given to young Viennese still living with their parents, and you can stay in your apartment even if your income increases. The city can therefore bring down rents in the market as not only the poorest can live in these apartments, but they are a valid choice for many.

There also isn't a ban on Airbnb. As someone else already commented, you can still stay at Airbnbs in Vienna. You cannot rent out apartments in social housing as Airbnbs anymore and there are areas in the city where you would have to get a special permit and other inhabitants of the building would have to agree.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:33AM (#42107856)
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by rettetdemdativ on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:43AM (#42107942)
As I commented further down, that's true. Although category III is about buildings built before 1953/1945. I just didn't want to give people the impression that Vienna has relatively affordable rents because it has a hard cap on all rents. Newer buildings (not as old as 1953 seems to count as new) with index-bound rents have raised rents quite a bit in the past 5 years and have made Altbau very sought-after.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:52AM (#42108013)
Fair point.

It's not only buildings built before 1953/1945 though, social housings (Wohnungen in gefördert errichteten Mietwohnungshäusern mit mehr als 2 Mietgegenständen) are capped as well.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by em-bee on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:24AM (#42108293)
add to that that in any new building 2/3rd of the apartments must be social housing.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by rettetdemdativ on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:56AM (#42108035)
This I didn't know. TIL. Also, thanks for the sources.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by spacechild1 on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:14AM (#42107711)
Rent in old buildings (Altbau) is capped. The problem is that many landlords don't care and there are no penalties. You can charge back the extra rent but then your landlord will probably not extend your contract...
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by rettetdemdativ on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:31AM (#42107839)
That is true, but it only affects buildings built before 1953/1945. I just didn't want to give people a wrong impression of why rents in Vienna are relatively low compared to other European cities of a similar size. It's not a "Mietpreisbremse" of hard cap on all rents.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by whilenot-dev on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:25AM (#42107782)
That's why:

  1. make an unlimited contract
  2. sue when you'll leave anyway
The statute of limitations is 30 years.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by spacechild1 on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:20AM (#42108260)
> 1. make an unlimited contract

That's a good one :-D

> The statute of limitations is 30 years.

It's actually 10 years. I thought it was less...

> 2. sue when you'll leave anyway

So that's actually a good strategy! Just note that there are certain deadlines, see https://wien.arbeiterkammer.at/beratung/Wohnen/altbaumietenc....

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:50AM (#42106752)
>The city somehow managed to find an identity on its own that somehow makes it work.

It's not "somehow" by magic. The explanation is that as a neutral country between NATO and the former Iron Curtain, it was a middle-man for business, politics and trade between the two blocks in the cold war era, profiting from both parties without having to pay obligations to any of them. Basically it won the geopolitical lottery, similar to a Switzerland Light. Today with the Iron Curtain gone and the EU-Schengen borders extended east beyond Austria, it's a lot less relevant than it used to be and therefore a lot less profitable.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by jahnu on Monday November 11, 2024 @08:59AM (#42107135)
> it's a lot less relevant than it used to be and therefore a lot less profitable

which metrics are you using for this assertion?

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Rinzler89 on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:07AM (#42107192)
My 2 cents.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by holri on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:20AM (#42107285)
Since the end of the Iron Curtain Vienna population grew dramatically by the size of the second largest city in Austria (Graz). During the time of the Iron Curtain Vienna was the only big city in Europe that lost population. It was a grey, old, slowly dying city. The city and the quality of live evolved dramatically since then. I would call it a completely different and in my opinion in almost any regard much better, lively, young, modern city. But it managed to keep its very distinguished identity.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by namaria on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:14AM (#42107707)
Austrian legislation largely encourages clandestine ops and this brings a lot of offices, officials, fancy equipment and money to Vienna to this day.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by jahnu on Monday November 11, 2024 @09:20AM (#42107286)
One big reason why it's large is because it was once the capital of an empire.

Why it grew back from being small due to WW2 up to the 90s is, my educated guess, the geography combined with the standard of living. Right up against the poorer east and rich west. Easy for young people to move from the poorer neighbours, for a short while or even stay. Abundant labour and low corruption [ignoring political ;)] then trades easily with its richer western neighbours.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by kingkawn on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:05AM (#42107636)
Vienna was also the primary neutral ground meeting point during the Cold War between soviet and western interests
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by dewey on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:28AM (#42108320)
It still is considered the "city of spies" because of some special cases in Austrian law: https://apnews.com/article/austria-spying-government-legisla...
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by shadowtree on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:36AM (#42107876)
It sits on a major European waterway, the Danube, which after Vienna exists into the plain lands - Hungary, Romania.

Started as a Roman settlement, Vindobona, it has been strategically important for a very long time.

Paris without the Seine would equally be irrelevant. London too.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by insane_dreamer on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:23AM (#42108276)
> If you look at the geography, if you look at the political climate, just at the fundamentals it's not clear why Vienna is a large city

Sits on the Danube and was the capital of the Austrian Empire, so very important all throughout the 1800s. I'd say strategically located in Central Europe.

Then in the second half of the 20th C it was the gateway to the "East Bloc", the place where east meets west in terms of diplomacy, economic and cultural exchange, and of course espionage.

It has played a neutral role similar to Switzerland, which is why OPEC is headquartered there. It's also one of the UN's four major sites worldwide (along with NY, Geneva, Nairobi).

I spent a couple of years there; nice place to live; would happily return.

Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by Loudergood on Monday November 11, 2024 @01:10PM (#42109158)
Austria avoiding being split like Germany after WWII is a masterclass in geopolitics.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by insane_dreamer on Monday November 11, 2024 @01:14PM (#42109207)
Casting itself as the victim of Germany was a smart move.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by numewhodis on Monday November 11, 2024 @02:30PM (#42109790)
they are the control group "that doesn't 'have to' feel guilty" ...
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by fakedang on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:27AM (#42114048)
I mean they were the victim of Nazi infiltration. Dolfuss was assassinated, the Anschluss vote was practically a rigged vote and I'm sure Kurt Schussnigg was not pleased with the outcome.
Re:Review of Vienna: How the City of Ideas Created the Moder... by aprilthird2021 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:57AM (#42116584)
And they also stole tons of land and businesses from the Jews who they helped expel into concentration camps they helped staff.

Many of the famous cafes in Vienna itself, which show up in almost every writing about the city, were stolen from expelled Jews