For the more low-level stuff there's the FEniCS project[1], for solving PDEs using fairly straight forward Python code like this[2]. When I say fairly straight forward, I mean it follows the math pretty closely, it's not exactly high-school level stuff.
[1]: https://fenicsproject.org/
[2]: https://jsdokken.com/dolfinx-tutorial/chapter2/linearelastic...
So to have anything useful, you need that entire pipeline? For hobbyists, I assume we need this stack. What are the popular modelling tools?
[1]: https://www.featool.com/tutorial/2017/06/16/Python-Multiphys...
Just curious what kind of hobby leads to a finite element analysis?
Unfortunately the barrier to entry is too high for most hobbyists in these fields to use FEM right now.
[0] I’m pretty sure “insufferability” isn’t a real word. [Edit: don’t use an asterisk for footnotes.]
Hey, I resemble that remark! I'd be a little less armchair with maybe more surplus equipment access, but maybe no less insufferable.
But, I guess you get what you pay for in this space still.
[1]: https://gmsh.info/
[2]: https://github.com/qingfengxia/Cfd
They buy "vertical aligned" software, integrate it, then slowly let it die. They just announced they're killing off one of these next year, that they bought ten years ago, because they want to push a competitive product with 20% of the features.
I've been using nastran for half as long but it isn't much better. It's all sales.
I dabbed a bit in abaqus, that seems nice. Probably cause I just dabbed in it.
But here I'm just trying to do my work, and all these companies do is move capabilities around their license tiers and boil the frog as fast as they get away with.
Abaqus is more difficult to get up to speed in, but its really nice from an advanced usability standpoint. They struggle due to cost though, it is hugely expensive and we've had to fight hard to keep it time and time again.
LS-Dyna is similar to Abaqus (though I'm not fully up in it yet), but we're all just waiting to see how Ansys ruins it, especially now that they got bought out by Synopsys.
Each individual physics regime is not particularly good on its own - there are far better mechanical, CFD, electromagnetism, etc solvers out there - but they're all made by different vendors and don't play nicely with each other.
Ouch. I kind of know Comsol because it was already taught in my engineering school 15 years ago, so that it still counts as a “new entrant” really gives an idea of how slow the field evolves.
But they changed to COMSOL because they didn't have the trademark in Japan and FEM also gave associations to the feminine gender.
Wait? What? NASTRAN was originally developed by NASA and open sourced over two decades ago. Is this commercial software built on top that is closed source?
I’m astonished ANSYS and NASTRAN are still the only players in town. I remember using NASTRAN 20 years ago for FE of structures while doing aero engineering. And even then NASTRAN was almost 40 years old and ancient.
There might be better programs for some problems, but COMSOL is quite nice.
Happy to hear if people have good resources!
It's written in C++, makes heavy use of templates and been in development since 2000. It's not meant for solid mechanics or fluid mechanics specifically, but for FEM solutions of general PDEs.
The documentation is vast, the examples are numerous and the library interfaces with other libraries like Petsc, Trilinos etc. You can output results to a variety of formats.
I believe support for triangle and tetrahedral elements has been added only recently. In spite of this, one quirk of the library is that meshes are called "triangulations".
Much to my surprise, it seems there hasn't been much movement there. ANSYS still seems to be the leader for general simulation and multi-physics. NASTRAN still popular. Still no viable open-source solution.
The only new player seems to be COMSOL. Has anyone experience with it? Would it be worth a try for someone who knows ANSYS and NASTRAN well?