Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by bauta-steen on Saturday November 02, 2024 @07:08PM
(#42029905)
To get started with Fenics you can maybe use the FEATool GUI, which makes it easier to set up FEA models, and also export Python simulation scripts to learn or modify the Fenics syntax [1].
[1]: https://www.featool.com/tutorial/2017/06/16/Python-Multiphys...
Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by fn-mote on Saturday November 02, 2024 @06:53PM
(#42029822)
> For hobbyists, I assume we need this stack.
Just curious what kind of hobby leads to a finite element analysis?
Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by kragen on Saturday November 02, 2024 @08:39PM
(#42030350)
Electronics (when you start to care about EMI or antenna design), model airplanes (for aerodynamics), rocketry, machining (especially if you want to get into SPIF), robotics, 3-D printing (especially for topology optimization), basically anything that deals with designing solid structures in the physical world. Also, computer graphics, including video games.
Unfortunately the barrier to entry is too high for most hobbyists in these fields to use FEM right now.
Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by nativeit on Saturday November 02, 2024 @10:03PM
(#42030698)
There are some obvious downsides and exceptions to this sentiment, but on balance, I really appreciate how the expansive access to information via the internet has fostered this phenomenon: where an unremarkable fella with a dusty media studies degree, a well-equipped garage, and probably too much free time can engineer and construct robotic machines, implement/tweak machine vision mechanisms, microwave radio transceivers, nanometer-scale measurements using laser diodes and optical interferometry, deep-sky astrophotography, etc., etc..
Of course, with burgeoning curiosity and expanding access to surplus university science lab equipment, comes armchair experts and the potential for insufferability[0]. It’s crucial to maintain perspective and be mindful of just how little any one person (especially a person with a media studies degree) can possibly know.
[0] I’m pretty sure “insufferability” isn’t a real word. [Edit: don’t use an asterisk for footnotes.]
Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by kragen on Sunday November 03, 2024 @04:13AM
(#42031974)
> comes armchair experts and the potential for insufferability
Hey, I resemble that remark! I'd be a little less armchair with maybe more surplus equipment access, but maybe no less insufferable.
Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by jasomill on Saturday November 02, 2024 @08:49PM
(#42030385)
IMO, the mathematics underlying finite element methods and related subjects — finite element exterior calculus comes immediately to mind — are interesting enough to constitute a hobby in their own right.
Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by magicalhippo on Saturday November 02, 2024 @06:28PM
(#42029675)
Yeah not my domain so wouldn't really know. For FEniCS I know Gmsh[1] was used. There's some work[2][3] been done to integrate FEniCS with FreeCAD. It seems FreeCAD also supports[4] other FEM solvers.
But, I guess you get what you pay for in this space still.
[1]: https://gmsh.info/
[2]: https://github.com/qingfengxia/Cfd
Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by physicsguy on Sunday November 03, 2024 @05:47AM
(#42032327)
You can export other CAD meshes for use in it
Re:Eighty Years of the Finite Element Method (2022)
by physicsguy on Sunday November 03, 2024 @05:48AM
(#42032332)
FEniCs is mostly used by academic researchers, I used it for FEM modelling in magnetic for e.g. where the sorts of problems we wanted to solve you can’t do in a commercial package.
So to have anything useful, you need that entire pipeline? For hobbyists, I assume we need this stack. What are the popular modelling tools?