News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by illumen on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:49AM (#4198427)
Facebook.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by tikhonj on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:03AM (#4198476)
Yes. And now Facebook is spending a ton of resource and man-hours programming around this. They had to write their own compiler!

Also, I think they are trying to move away from PHP as quickly as possible without rewriting the entire site. The new projects and tools are not in PHP; moreover, I think most of the new people they hire never have to use PHP at all.

Finally, just because they managed to use PHP to run a bit site does not mean it is the best web language, or even a good web language. It just means it's adequate.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by InclinedPlane on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:21AM (#4198747)
You get the same issues almost no matter what you write a website in, whether it's PHP, C#, Rails, or node.js. When you get to the level of scale that Facebook is at you are in a realm that conventional web application tooling and frameworks don't cover. If anything the "best" and most trusted platform for what facebook is doing today would be java. Does that mean java is the "best" web platform? Not in the least.

The central fallacy here is imagining that one size could or should fit all, whether it's php or rails or anything.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by rimantas on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:22AM (#4198749)

  > Yes. And now Facebook is spending a ton of resource and
  > man-hours programming around this. They had to write
  > their own compiler!
Is there a project of Facebook scale which does not have "their own" at the very core, no matter initial choice of technology? My understanding is that by solving problems no one had to solve before you are bound to create "your own" stuff. Even for desktop — didn't Excel have it's own compiler?
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by notinfinland on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:20AM (#4198540)
Do you have inside info on this? I've seen several people from Facebook comment that they are in fact using PHP.

The fact that they're compiling to C++ is a consequence of the slowness of the programming language implementations of those languages that are used traditionally for web development. AFAIK Ruby was and still is the slowest of the bunch.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by tikhonj on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:27AM (#4198573)
A couple people I know well spent the summer there (I actually visited one at the old headquarters; it was pretty cool). One now works there full time (the other hasn't graduated yet). I also talked to some fulltime engineers who were not using PHP.

Now, it's reasonable that I did not get the full picture, but the people I did talk did not use PHP themselves and claimed that new projects didn't either. Perhaps this varies per team. My impression was that existing code bases using PHP were still under active development (that is, getting new features) but new projects and new developers did not use PHP.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by notinfinland on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:44AM (#4198953)
Interesting. What were they using, C++? I've heard about D...
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by tikhonj on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @03:12PM (#4200537)
The particular people I talked to were using C++. But I think there is even a team using Haskell for some internal tools :).
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by charliesome on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:17AM (#4198739)
MRI Ruby is actually significantly faster than CPython these days.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by irahul on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:02AM (#4198829)
Citation needed. Both CPython and MRI are slow - if you need computational speed, use something else. But when your are comparing them to each other, CPython is faster. I don't know where you are getting that significantly faster bit from.

Since most benchmarks are unscientific, this one is as good as any. So here goes:

http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/u64q/benchmark.php?test=al...

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by chrisrhoden on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:05AM (#4199241)
I suspect that parent was referring to the python 2.x branch, which has been catching up with ruby 1.9, but on most benchmarks started at ~ 3x slower and are now ~ 2x slower.

Since benchmarks are completely worthless, let's just stop this pissing match right now.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by irahul on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:19AM (#4199287)
> I suspect that parent was referring to the python 2.x branch, which has been catching up with ruby 1.9, but on most benchmarks started at ~ 3x slower and are now ~ 2x slower.

Citation needed again. Ruby 1.9 is slower than Python 3, and Python 3 is slower or as fast as Python 2 on Python official benchmarks.

http://docs.python.org/release/3.0.1/whatsnew/3.0.html#perfo...

> Since benchmarks are completely worthless, let's just stop this pissing match right now.

Benchmarks are far from worthless. And pissing match? Asking for citations amounts to pissing match? The parent claimed something that isn't true(ruby 1.9 significantly faster than CPython - that has never been the case). And you are adding python 2.x was slower than 1.9, when 2.x is generally faster than 3.

I love ruby as much as the next guy. But when it comes to execution speed, ruby has always been the slowest among ruby, python, and perl.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by chrisrhoden on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:59AM (#4199425)
Fib(36)

Python 2.7.2

    def fib(n):
        if n == 0 or n == 1:
           return n
        else:
           return fib(n-1) + fib(n-2)
     
     for i in range(36):
         print "n=%d => %d" % (i, fib(i))'
python -c 20.69s user 0.06s system 99% cpu 20.807 total

Ruby 1.9.3 def fib(n) if n == 0 || n == 1 n else fib(n-1) + fib(n-2) end end

    36.times do |i|
      puts "n=#{i} => #{fib(i)}"
    end
ruby 11.44s user 0.03s system 99% cpu 11.507 total

I guess since benchmarks are not completely worthless, we should conclude that ubuntu doesn't keep up on ruby and uses 2-3 year old versions.

I wasn't accusing you of starting the pissing match.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by irahul on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:13AM (#4199694)
> I guess since benchmarks are not completely worthless,

The original keeps getting re-iterated: http://programmingzen.com/2007/11/28/holy-shmoly-ruby-19-smo...

The original author, on a basis of a fib benchmark, concludes ruby 1.9 is faster - that is as flawed as it gets.

Did you try running with Python 3? You will get around the same time as you get with Python 2.7. Pick anything from here http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/u64q/benchmark.php?test=al... and run it with Python 2.7 and ruby 1.9. The programs which are faster with Python 3 will be mostly faster with Python 2.7. 2.7 isn't slower than ruby 1.9; it is faster in most of the cases.

Regarding the fib example, when the original was doing the rounds, I didn't find any explanations from python or ruby implementors. I can't say why, but most likely python has a higher overhead with growing call stacks, and ruby does some optimizations.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by slurgfest on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @10:49AM (#4199597)
Data is not dishonest and benchmarks are not dishonest. What is dishonest is this tendency to cherry-pick only the case which is convenient to you, as you have done here. If you want to talk about Ruby performance vs. Python then you will have to dig into something like the site linked previously, which has many different benchmarks run on a uniform testbed rather than a single cherry-picked case run in whatever way you felt like.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by igouy on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @12:18PM (#4199916)
>>ubuntu doesn't keep up on ruby and uses 2-3 year old versions<<

Huh? Since 21 Apr 2012, the benchmarks game has shown - ruby 1.9.3p194 (2012-04-20 revision 35410).

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by igouy on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @01:06PM (#4200107)
If you're looking at measurements made on the quad core machine, then remember to check the "≈ CPU Load" column to see whether some programs are using multiple cores and some programs are only using one core.

When the comparison would be better without that complication, look at single core measurements -- http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/u64/benchmark.php?test=all...

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by igouy on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @12:58PM (#4200071)
>>Since most benchmarks are unscientific, this one is as good as any.<<

1) You seem to be using "unscientific" as a nothing more than an insult.

2) Your conclusion "this one is as good as any" doesn't follow from your premise that "most benchmarks are unscientific" -- "this one" might well be different from "most benchmarks".

3) If your conclusion was correct then that wouldn't mean that the benchmark was good, just that it was also bad.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by irahul on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:45AM (#4201882)
>>Since most benchmarks are unscientific, this one is as good as any.<<

>1) You seem to be using "unscientific" as a nothing more than an insult.

More like preemptively declaring I don't want to deal with HN crowd replying with "but benchmarks are worthless".

> 2) Your conclusion "this one is as good as any" doesn't follow from your premise that "most benchmarks are unscientific" -- "this one" might well be different from "most benchmarks".

IMO shootout benchmarks are better than random benchmarks on the web as they detail the testing environment, provide the source code and can be re-created

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by igouy on Thursday July 05, 2012 @01:37PM (#4203985)
>>More like preemptively declaring I don't want to deal with HN crowd replying with "but benchmarks are worthless"<<

It's a dirty job but it still has to be done ;-)

Let them reply and then answer them.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by nbm on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @02:30PM (#4200367)
I have only a year and a bit of context since starting at Facebook, but here's my viewpoint.

Facebook isn't trying to move away from PHP as quickly as possible. For years, there have been PHP components (primarily web front-end rendering, aggregation/ranking of data from various sources) and C++ components (primarily high-performance back-end services) and other languages like Python (primarily non-production-path/operations back-end services) and Java (primarily Hadoop-related technologies like Hive and HBase, and services that are heavy users of such), and nothing groundbreaking has changed in this.

New hires use PHP or C++ or whatever language (and often multiple languages) necessary to work on the team and projects they choose to work on. New projects use the languages that make the most sense.

Almost all web front-end work involves PHP - the frameworks and libraries and runtime environment are well-developed, well-tested, well-documented, and well-known.

In terms of HipHop for PHP, the question to ask is: What language could have allowed quick low-barrier-to-entry web-app-centric development in the early days while still delivering the sort of runtime efficiency demanded by the environment? Languages like Python and Ruby may arguably allow the first (but remember we're talking about early 2004 here, so Ruby on Rails was not out, and neither were Django, Flask, and so forth and WSGI had just come out), but would have required a "HipHop for PHP"-style solution as well. Languages like C, C++, and Java may have the runtime efficiency, but it would be a hard argument to say they're as developer-time-efficient as PHP (especially back then).

That's a slightly different question to what one should do today if starting a new venture. And _that_ is also a different question to what Facebook should do today - HipHop for PHP exists, and is delivering performance/runtime efficiency that most languages people mention as an alternative do not. And, the PHP frameworks and libraries and runtime environment exist and allow rapid development of production code. It's actually reasonably pleasant to develop for with those in place.

The HipHop for PHP team is small, but have huge leverage - this small team of reasonably hardcore low-level C++ programmers are making a whole bunch (hundreds?) of PHP developers way more productive (since they don't have to use a relatively slower-to-develop-in language/runtime like C++), and also makes the cost of operating the site go down by making that code more efficient and reducing the number of servers needed.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by Kudos on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:12AM (#4198500)
The same argument could be made of Ruby on Rails, just look at Twitter moving core infrastructure to the JVM.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by tikhonj on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:14AM (#4198506)
It could, and I think it should. I am no fan of Rails. But that is a different story for a different time.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by illumen on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:24AM (#4198561)
The Face Book.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by davidlumley on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:56AM (#4198451)
I keep hearing people mention Facebook as a reason why PHP is a great development language but they compile it down to C++ using their HipHop compiler, and from what I understand they develop Facebook _in spite of_ PHP ( http://www.quora.com/Do-Facebook-engineers-enjoy-programming... )
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by nicholassmith on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:55AM (#4198679)
I got downvoted on another PHP related thread here for bringing that up. Can you truly say they use PHP when they've invested a hell of a lot of money into HipHop to essentially allow devs to write additional PHP code and transform it into C++ binaries? It's a strange way of using it for sure, but it seems to be effective for them.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by memla on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:32AM (#4198768)
Right, but Facebook supposedly receives 1 billion new comments + a couple billion likes + a couple hundred million status updates daily, and is probably the largest photo sharing site on the net. Twitter gets about 200 million tweets daily and Reddit has 250 million comments total. Disqus is not much larger than Reddit.

So, since most people here are suggesting Python or Ruby, what real world example can we provide that compares to Facebook in order to make sure that these languages would perform better than PHP?

Neither Twitter, nor Reddit or Disqus are exactly the most stable and performant sites out there. So?

I would say that quick and dirty comparisons like this are meaningless.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by lars512 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:12AM (#4199263)
Google is the real-world example of Python deployment you're looking for, although we don't have the full details of where it begins and ends in their no doubt complex stack. So again, the comparison isn't that useful.

Talking about what languages programmers find enjoyable and productive is perhaps more meaningful. This is where Python and Ruby shine, and PHP falters.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by Kudos on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @06:23AM (#4198752)
Yes, you can truly say they use PHP. You are confusing the language and the interpreter. I've seen Facebook engineers comment on threads like this and say the same thing I just have.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by tijs on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:55AM (#4198448)
And just because a big site uses it the language does not become good either, see the availability argument. I think most PHP programmers would not recognize what's running at Facebook as PHP with all the customization they have done.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by drivebyacct2 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:52AM (#4198434)
I very specifically didn't say that PHP couldn't be used to build real products, but that still doesn't (at least on it's own) make it good or make it the best.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by illumen on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:53AM (#4198441)
I guess the worlds most popular websites, and the vast millions of PHP programmers must all not really exist. They can't exist, and can't be making good stuff, because PHP is just doesn't work.

Here is a list of template languages people on 'real' platforms use:

Python.

Airspeed, Castalian, Chameleon, Cheetah, CubicTemp, Django template system, Elements, EmPy, Evoque, HRL Powerful macro preprocessor for HTML, Genshi, Jinja 2, Mako, moody-templates, Myghty, Qpy, PML, pyratemp, Spyce, SUIT, Tempita, Tenjin, Template Toolkit, Templite+, thrases, ClearSilver, HTMLTemplate, JonsPythonModules, meld3, PyMeld, Pyxer, pso, Sprite, teng, webstring, XSLTools, PyPa, Genshi, kajiki, htmltmpl, Kid, SimpleTAL, CherryTemplate, AsciiDoc, Markdown, PyTextile, ReStructuredText, txt2tags, PottyMouth, Creole,

Ruby.

Radius. HAML. cs/Template. ERB, eRuby, Erubis, Galena, Tenjin, Liquid Markup. Ruty, PageTemplate, Amrita, Amrita2, Kwartz, Markaby. Maline. Builder::XmlMarkup, RedCloth, BlueCloth, RSmarty, Tempura, TAL, Curtis / Punk, Erby, RBML, RTALS, Tie, RVelocity, RailTags,

Java.

FreeMarker, SiteMesh, StringTemplate, Tea, Better Templates for Everybody, jxp, LSP, JCopist, Dynamator, RTFTemplate, Velocity, JByte, Jamon, JDynamiTe, WebMacro, Viento, IKAT, Bluprints, Transformica, Hapax, MiniTemplator, Xtempore,

_Not a complete list._

PHP is a pretty good template language, with pretty amazing documentation.

To deploy, you just upload a file.

You could walk outside now, and start yelling "I NEED A PHP PROGRAMMER!" and you'd probably find someone pretty quickly.

There are millions of hosts to choose from at tiny prices, who can provide support because they know the platform.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by talkingquickly on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:00AM (#4198469)
Saying PHP is good because Facebook use it is kind of like saying phone hacking is good because it was utilised but some of the UK's most popular newspapers...

I'd be interested to know if there's any commentary from people high up in Facebook on whether they'd use PHP again if they were starting now?

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by jfarmer on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:14AM (#4198511)
Look at Quora, Path, and Asana, the three most successful consumer startups started by former Facebookers.

None use PHP.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by illumen on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:44AM (#4198638)
Never heard of them.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by irahul on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @07:07AM (#4198842)
You are deliberately trying to miss the point. But in the off chance that you don't really get it, the point is quora, asana were started by early facebook programmers, and they didn't use PHP. If they liked PHP so much, they would have used it.

I can't find a citation, but there was a thread where a fb engineer claimed fb's internal PHP wiki starts with "There are two kind of people. People who hate PHP, and people who don't use PHP."

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by maratd on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @10:32AM (#4199545)
> If they liked PHP so much, they would have used it.

Or they got tired of being bullied by people like you.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by irahul on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:18AM (#4199712)
>> If they liked PHP so much, they would have used it.

> Or they got tired of being bullied by people like you.

Or they really aren't a fan of PHP?

http://www.quora.com/Quora-Infrastructure/Why-did-Quora-choo...

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by jfarmer on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:59AM (#4198690)
And that's relevant how?
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by nivla on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:24AM (#4198563)
What kind of an analogy is that? It is not only flawed but does not relate to your argument. I guess the point that illumen was trying to make is that PHP can be used in popular real world applications and is "proven" to scale. Just like Facebook, you can look at Wikipedia, Wordpress, Tumbler or earlier days of Youtube all of which was/is written in PHP!

Be comfortable with the language you prefer and quit whining about the rest!!!

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by talkingquickly on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:41AM (#4198623)
In no way whining about PHP, I still maintain various projects which use it and for which I think it's well suited.

The analogy was only meant to demonstrate an objection to arguments along the lines of "it's used by something popular therefore it's good" or "lots of people use it therefore it's good" which seem to be common points put forward in favour of PHP.

Popularity/ use by someone popular may be an indicator of quality but it very often isn't, the analogy isn't intended to go any further than that!

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by tomelders on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:14AM (#4198507)
No, it's nothing like that.
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by papsosouid on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:29AM (#4199328)
There is such commentary from people who left facebook to do their own thing. They did not use PHP. http://www.quora.com/Quora-Infrastructure/Why-did-Quora-choo...
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by slurgfest on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @09:14AM (#4199273)
I guess your point is that there are too many options. But you have artificially inflated the count as you have made this point. Most of the things you have listed are not applicable (either not used any more, or are not general and were never used to compose full HTML pages). Cut out the ones which are not actively developed and you only have a handful for each language.

Since the problem seems to be that you need someone to choose for you: use Django on Python, use Rails on Ruby, and for each one use the templating that comes with it. If you switch to another framework, use its templating language. If you are advanced enough to use a microframework then you are advanced enough to plug in Jinja2 or whatever it is you really want.

Django, Rails, and Jinja2 have excellent documentation. I can't understand why you would think that PHP's documentation is significantly better.

You get what you pay for on super-cheap hosts who are somehow incompetent to understand Python or Ruby.

And choice is not a bug.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by ceejayoz on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @01:28PM (#4200173)
> Cut out the ones which are not actively developed and you only have a handful for each language.

"The template language you pick has a good chance of becoming an abandoned project" hardly seems a great selling point.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by greyfade on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @11:49PM (#4201669)
> You could walk outside now, and start yelling "I NEED A PHP PROGRAMMER!" and you'd probably find someone pretty quickly.

This is something that I point out as a negative. Yes, you can get a PHP programmer just about anywhere. But being that there are so many, it's harder to find those few truly talented programmers.

My own complaint about this is that if you bring in cheap PHP programmers, you end up with cheaply-written PHP. And the result is inevitably an unmaintainable mess. If you want well-written, maintainable code, you have to be willing to hire talented and experienced programmers. And in doing so, you give up that so vaunted "advantage" of PHP's mindshare.

Moreover, it seems to me that the truly talented programmers that would produce good software have a tendency to distance themselves from PHP.

So it seems to me: Choose PHP for cheap, quick projects on a budget for which quality is irrelevant; or choose a "harder" language for solid applications that will stand the test of customer interaction.

Re:PHP is much better than what you think by OyoKooN on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @05:15AM (#4198518)
Yeah. That's why they completety rewritten it...
Re:PHP is much better than what you think by drivebyacct2 on Wednesday July 04, 2012 @04:18PM (#4200740)
You literally just repeated all of the things that I just got done addressing. You also continue to ignore that I said NOTHING about PHP not being usable for "real sites".

I also, still, don't get your point. There are other templating languages for PHP too.

Again, your deployment argument is just as silly as your availability argument. It's trivial to deploy to Azure (sites) or Heroku, or Ironio or gondor, or any Go project, or etc, etc.

>There are millions of hosts to choose from at tiny prices, who can provide support because they know the platform.

Are you even reading what I write? Please show me a real webapp with actual users hosted on el cheapo shared hosting.