Does anyone know what a typical number of acquired frames is for a space telescope?
It might be compressed for transmission, but raw data (warts and all) is king .. once it's "processed" and raw data is discarded .. there's no recovering the raw.
Years later raw data can be reprocessed with new algorithms, faster processes and combined with other sources to create "better" processed images.
Onboard hardware errors (eg: the historic Hubble Telescope erros) can be "corrected" later on the ground with an elaborate backpropagated trandfer function that optimally "fixes" the error, etc.
Data errors (spikes in cell values, glitches from cosmic rays, etc) can be combed out of the raw in post .. if smart people have access to the raw.
Baking processing into on board instrument processing prior to transmission isn't a good procedure.
The launch mass of a petabyte of SSD is under 10 kg. I don't know if it would survive 17 years of space radiation though.
I don't think I'd do that.
Ignoring the failure modes of a petabyte of SSD spending decades in deep space, what kinds of things are difficult and|or impossible if you were to
> store all the data on the satellite, upload new code to process it differently, and download the resulting image
?
Probably worse than sending up well-shielded flash, but I don't think the Seagate/WD warranty expressly forbids this usage.
My understanding is that some newer instruments do both compress and select data to be downloaded (i.e. prioritizing signal over noise), and that there is more and more consideration of on-board processing for future missions, as well as possibly introducing the capability within DSN itself to prioritize which instruments get bandwidth based on scientific value of their data.
Source: A presentation from people at NASA Heliophysics last week, where this very topic came up.
[1]: < https://www.nasa.gov/communicating-with-missions/dsn/> [2]: < https://science.nasa.gov/mission/soho/>
Instead, we would use lasers with a far superior gain to what radio communication is capable of. The divergence on even a decent pocket laser pointer diode is less than 0.1 degree. This is a gain of 10*log10(41,253/(0.1*0.1)) = 66 degrees. Launch telescopes of modest size can increase this further. Then receiver telescopes fitted with narrowband filters can hone in on that laser signal.
> "First, transmitted beams from optical telescopes are far more slender than their radio counterparts owing to the high gain of optical telescopes (150 dB for the Keck Telescope versus 70 dB for Arecibo)." - https://www.princeton.edu/~willman/observatory/oseti/bioast9...
With no way to send commands to the decices?
Would it be possible that Mr. Turyshev uses that name as his preferred name (at least when writing in English) and that we should just respect his decision?
I'm from a slavic country myself and my name is almost impossible to pronounce correctly in English - but I continue to use it anyway. If he wanted to do that, he could have done it.
Apologies to all the other Pavels out there; I've been training everyone I've met to pronounce it wrong. But it's the way I prefer to be addressed.
The reason is that you won't bother to pronounce Vyacheslav so Russians have to use a short version of their name.
Going by an easy-to-pronounce name is much less aggravating.
Did you mean that English speakers don't pronounce Russian names the way Russians do?
Ask your local Russian to pronounce rural Worcestershire the way that English speakers do.
Your typical Russian speaker cannot. Is it that they aren't "bothering"? The idea is absurd. Let people approximate foreign names in their own tongue. Or, if the way that they naturally pronounce something is truly atrocious, give them a name that is easier to pronounce.
Or watch this fellow give foreign pronunciation his best shot: https://youtu.be/fKGoVefhtMQ Absurd, right?
But the point is that most people won't bother to google the pronunciation, listen to it and make an effort to repeat close enough. By the way, Dr. Turyshev's name is the easy part, the surname is the real challenge)
I don't think people have that obligation when the name has foreign sounds in it whatever language they're speaking.
Which is understandable as it is a very esoteric topic. But if you don't feel comfortable talking about a subject that doesn't mean that you should change the subject to one that you do feel comfortable with.
People come to Hacker News to see experts talk about these esoteric ideas and you ruin that when you derail the conversation into something relatable out of discomfort.
What you were betting? You farm, hopefully?
Put a relay at the Lagrange point.
Stick a relay at the midpoint between earth / Voyager 1 so it gets a signal that’s 4x as strong. Unfortunately that’s still really weak so it needs a huge dish, and orbital mechanics means it can’s stay in that position.
We’re better off sending out probes that send stronger signals and just build huge ground based systems. At least until space based manufacturing becomes practical.
PS: Where relays make sense is for probes on the surface of a planet etc communicating with something in orbit which then sends signals to earth.
I learned this doing engineering trades on the Aldrin cycler idea; Ultimately it doesn't add much to a mission because getting there and getting back into the transfer sacrifices more than you could really hope to gain. You're likely better off just launching what you need attached to everything else at the Earth escape burn.
Life support for a manned Mars missions runs maybe ten tons per person on the low end. That's mostly in shelf-stable packaged food; I used 6 tons in my estimate. Metabolizing food generates excess CO2 + H2O; elaborate ECLSS systems can crack this for extra oxygen and filter the water for further consumption and sanitation. This food dominates mission payload mass. It's heavier than the rest of the habitat put together. You have to put it to good use - line the interior of the hull with it and it serves as radiation shielding for the journey. You could try getting the CO2 + H2O back into hydrocarbon-lox fuel if you like, but that's going to make a fragile critical path for getting home.
The base hardware for Mars and the people for Mars are going on basically the same Hohmann transfer, and they're using it because it's the cheapest way. There are faster ways involving the help of Venus' gravity well, but they're only SLIGHTLY faster, they burn a lot more fuel, and more importantly they only occur briefly every few years. A more rapid direct transfer is possible at the cost of enormous amounts of fuel, but the purpose of that transfer is a 'flags and footprints' mission where you save about a third of your 3-year mission time at the cost of reducing your exploration and ISRU time window from a year to weeks. "Opposition class mission" vs "Conjunction class mission".
> In 2020, Turyshev presented his idea of Direct Multi-pixel Imaging and Spectroscopy of an Exoplanet with a Solar Gravitational Lens Mission. The lens could reconstruct the exoplanet image with ~25 km-scale surface resolution in 6 months of integration time, enough to see surface features and signs of habitability. His proposal was selected for the Phase III of the NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts. Turyshev proposes to use realistic-sized solar sails (~16 vanes of 10^3 m^2) to achieve the needed high velocity at perihelion (~150 km/sec), reaching 547 AU in 17 years.
> In 2023, a team of scientists led by Turychev proposed the Sundiver concept, whereby a solar sail craft can serve as a modular platform for various instruments and missions, including rendezvous with other Sundivers for resupply, in a variety of different self-sustaining orbits reaching velocities of ~5-10 AU/yr.
Here is an interview with him laying out the entire plan.[1] It is the most interesting interview that I have seen in years, possibly ever.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slava_Turyshev#Work
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lqzJewjZUkk