News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by ryandv on Thursday October 03, 2024 @05:53PM (#41735449)
This is just the practice of invasive data harvesting taken to its natural conclusion, which any tech savvy user or computer geek brought up in the pre-postmodern social media era of the Internet (before Facebook) could have seen coming decades in advance. The only winning move here is not to play, accepting the unfortunate consequence that you will need to "limit the reach of your profile just to avoid participating in the new technology" - because nothing on the Internet is ever forgotten, and can (and will) be used for any purpose.

Adding a few magic words to bewitch the AI into not scraping your profile is the new superstition of the digital era, a cousin to the pseudolegal "no copyright intended" incantation often seen on pirated YouTube videos of yesteryear. You cannot have your cake and eat it too, for there is a fundamental tradeoff between privacy and convenience as popularized by Schneier, 11 years ago. [0] You must stop using the platform and do something other than continue to consume vapid social media nonsense; yet no one ever listens or cares, for the revealed preference of the masses is to continue to not be users of the system but to be used in exchange for "free" access to these platforms.

[0] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/06/trading_priva...

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by joe_the_user on Thursday October 03, 2024 @06:08PM (#41735593)
I'm not sure why having an LLM use my output in particular is problematic - I'm pretty sure OpenAI trained GPT-3+ on every single bit of data they could find, so they probably included a bunch of stuff I've written here already (though it is minuscule fraction of their vast corpus of course). Losing anonymity is something I'd be much more worried about overall (not that it's entirely separate I don't think it's the same).
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by rpgwaiter on Thursday October 03, 2024 @06:30PM (#41735774)
There’s many good reasons, but for me it’s that I don’t want companies profiting off of my posts that have no intention of profit sharing.

When I make a Youtube video and companies run ads on it, I get a piece of that pie (assuming I meet the requirements, etc.).

That same video fed into Gemini so google can charge for AI video generation? I get nothing, Google makes bank. As a user I can pay for YouTube premium and not see ads, but as a creator there’s no amount I can pay to not feed Gemini.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by recursive on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:56PM (#41736357)
> for me it’s that I don’t want companies profiting off of my posts that have no intention of profit sharing

I won't argue with your position, but most people would be hurting themselves more than they would hurt the companies, even in absolute terms.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by gruez on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:35PM (#41736195)
>That same video fed into Gemini so google can charge for AI video generation? I get nothing, Google makes bank.

How do you feel about commenting on this site for free, which probably provides some benefit to ycombinator?

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by rpgwaiter on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:58PM (#41736372)
I would happily pay a reasonable monthly subscription to this site or similar. No problem paying for a service that treats users with respect. Also using this site has taught me all sorts of things that likely made me some money indirectly. It seems mutually beneficial without selling my data or paying for HN.

That said, if YC made a deal with some tech company to give them the firehose of data to train AI, I’d probably stop using HN. I stopped using reddit for a similar reason despite being a very frequent redditor with like 60k karma. I know it’s all pretty open and getting fed into many different LLMs anyways, but thats not necessarily YC’s fault.

My ideal would be strong government regulations regarding AI training, requiring explicit opt-in that isn’t buried in a ToS or EULA. Ideally companies would require a “non-AI feeding” version of their website to legally run in my country.

I can’t imagine a scenario where this happens in the current system, but I sure can fantasize.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by gruez on Thursday October 03, 2024 @08:03PM (#41736406)
Right, but are you objecting to AI training because companies are benefiting while you're being uncompensated, or think AI training is fundamentally bad? Your previous comment suggests it's the former, but by the same logic you shouldn't comment online either, because that also benefits the company and is uncompensated.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by afiori on Friday October 04, 2024 @04:33AM (#41739164)
They already said that they believe commenting here has been mutually beneficial but anyway this is a false dichothomy, one could be neutral on AI in general but feel negative towards training proprietary privacy-invasive AI models that will for sure be used to make their content creation less relevant.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by shprd on Friday October 04, 2024 @09:25AM (#41741146)
Users are here because they want to, they chose to participate in this community. You can stop using HN at any minute and Ycombinator will not chase you.

But AI companies on the other hand took the internet hostage. They stole any creative work, code, art, and literally any data they could their hands on with no regard to license or consent from users. No one actively opted-in to let AI companies have their personal data, they just silently grapped everything they could. Maybe there's some obscure website where you shared something private and lost access to the account or the website even went down? Congrats, it's now revived in OpenAI dataset where you've absolutely no control or details about how it's being used, not even a way to request and pursue legal action because the training data is a "secret".

It's not about compensation, it's that fact you have no option or say even if you don't use their services.

You can't escape or opt-out, unless you go off the grid, and even then they still retain your old data and use it as they see fit.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by 01HNNWZ0MV43FF on Thursday October 03, 2024 @08:48PM (#41736684)
I get the satisfaction of telling off strangers
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by csallen on Thursday October 03, 2024 @09:06PM (#41736789)
> I don’t want companies profiting off of my posts

I despise this attitude. It's so entitled.

Our history of forever extending copyrights and protecting "intellectual property" has run amok, to the point where the average person thinks their scribbles, utterings, and ideas are valuable enough on their own to be worthy of a pay day. It's the culture of "My cut, my cut, my cut!"

Someone else profiting is not a tragedy to get up in arms about. The fact that you were somehow, tangentially, kinda sorta in the vicinity of that profit does not and should not mean you are owed money.

If you want to talk about privacy, sure, that's an issue worth bringing up. But, "I'm only mad because someone else made money and I didn't get paid," has nothing to do with privacy. It's pure greed, entitlement, and envy.

You know what? If you want to profit, do something to create value. Write a book. Start a paid newsletter. Create a startup. Put on a show and charge admission. Nobody is stopping you.

But if someone else figured out how to use a snippet of a comment you made 10 years ago as one-quadrillionth of the training data for a powerful LLM… if someone else figured out how to use your publicly-shared social media posts to attract advertisers to a platform they built… if someone else used 6 notes from a song you once sang to create a smash hit… kudos to them. They created something of value. You should've and could've done it yourself. Hell, you still can.

But nobody should owe you money. We should not have a society where people who actually create stuff are subject to endless friction and threats from do-nothings and patent trolls demanding "my cut" if the metadata from their words or actions contributes to 0.0001% of someone else's idea that they turned into profit with hard work.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by _heimdall on Thursday October 03, 2024 @11:00PM (#41737375)
> You know what? If you want to profit, do something to create value. Write a book. Start a paid newsletter. Create a startup. Put on a show and charge admission. Nobody is stopping you.

I believe that the GP's complaint is that their content online is actually being scraped and turned into value for companies, they would want compensation for it.

I'm personally of two minds on this, posting public content online includes no guard rails for how its used. I also disagree strongly with LLM companies throwing mountains of resources at scraping the web though, if nothing else it feels very much like a monopolistic play leveraging massive power in those resources to create a competitive edge that other players couldn't compete with.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by Dylan16807 on Friday October 04, 2024 @04:45AM (#41739243)
> I believe that the GP's complaint is that their content online is actually being scraped and turned into value for companies, they would want compensation for it.

And the comment directly addresses that. If someone creates a valuable thing and it has a minuscule pinch of your content inside it, you shouldn't be complaining or demanding payment. That's how participating in culture is supposed to work. When someone copies you orders of magnitude more directly, that's when you should be compensated or have control over it.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by _heimdall on Friday October 04, 2024 @11:05AM (#41742170)
That's a totally reasonable take, though it is just one opinion. I wouldn't tell someone they can't complain or feel entitled to payment for the value they created, though I bet we both agree that posting publicly online offers no expectation of payment by anyone coming across your content.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by JohnFen on Friday October 04, 2024 @11:51AM (#41742656)
Since the web was widely scraped to train LLMs, I have to assume that the entirety of what I had up on the web was included. That's more than a "miniscule pinch". I consider it to be wholesale abuse. For me, money doesn't enter into it at all.

However, there's literally nothing I can do about it aside from withdrawing from the public web -- which is what I've done, aside from writing comments here. Until/unless there is some sort of effective way of defending against the crawlers, the open web is no longer a suitable place to publish anything.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by Dylan16807 on Friday October 04, 2024 @01:22PM (#41743518)
The complaints I see are almost always aimed at the output of an LLM, and that only contains a significant amount of a work when it breaks.

Going after the LLM itself, not the output, is a lot trickier. Anyone can make a big database of public website contents. And if they use it to make a search engine for example, that gets classified as entirely legitimate. If we're excluding the output of the LLM, what's the difference?

Also if you scrunch down into a small model, it mathematically can't contain very much of the input text.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by JohnFen on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:13AM (#41766211)
> Going after the LLM itself, not the output, is a lot trickier.

Exactly so, and this is why withdrawing from the open web is the only realistic solution at this time.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by _heimdall on Friday October 04, 2024 @02:07PM (#41743991)
There's never going to be a way to defend against crawlers and still have an open web. Good actors may respect conventions like a robots.txt file but that's ultimately just a polite request.

You could get further trying to block by user agent headers, known crawler IPs, etc but then you're just taking up the same fight advertisers have with ad blockers.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by JohnFen on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:11AM (#41766199)
> You could get further trying to block by user agent headers

That's a game of what-a-mole, though, and when the scraped data is being used to train LLMs, then a single miss is a really huge problem. That's why I gave up on that approach and took my sites off of the open web until some effective defense becomes possible.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by johngladtj on Friday October 04, 2024 @03:04AM (#41738609)
I couldn't have put it better myself.

If you don't want others to use what you say to make money... Shut up.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by OvbiousError on Friday October 04, 2024 @09:25AM (#41741144)
OP is not saying they want money. They say they don't want companies profiting from their work. The two are unrelated here.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by csallen on Saturday October 05, 2024 @02:04PM (#41751704)
Even worse. It's not that they want to make things better for themselves, but that they want to make things worse for others. Why?
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by seanhunter on Friday October 04, 2024 @12:20PM (#41742922)
I'm pretty sure for antitrust reasons Google is (ironically) about the only AI company who is not training generative AI on youtube content. So when you make a youtube video and people train AI on your video and generate stuff using it you only get 1 click of benefit out of it from their first download.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by quantified on Thursday October 03, 2024 @08:18PM (#41736495)
I was served a youtube ad for a service that will let you pick a topic to write an ebook on, write the book for you, give it a layout design and a cover, then you can market it. A bunch of topics available. I find this to be gross. Look for an explosion of crap on Amazon bookshelves.

Do you want me to publish 12-15 different ebooks containing the content you actually worked to create, and it just found permutations for?

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by _huayra_ on Thursday October 03, 2024 @09:35PM (#41736956)
> Do you want me to publish 12-15 different ebooks

Just make sure you spread it out over a few days and you're all good: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2023/09/ai-ge...

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by JohnFen on Friday October 04, 2024 @10:14AM (#41741657)
> I'm not sure why having an LLM use my output in particular is problematic

For me, the problem is almost entirely that doing so requires me to have a great deal of trust in entities that I consider untrustworthy.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by moron4hire on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:12PM (#41736049)
It's not possible to not play. Even if I chose to avoid social media, my kids' school insists everyone interest with their teachers through some crappy branded app.

Read the TOS. Didn't like what I saw. Told them I didn't want to install an app on my phone. Asked nicely if there was some way I could participate without it. They acted like I beat my kids.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by masfuerte on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:42PM (#41736238)
Organisations insist that I interact with them using an app. I show them my Nokia feature phone and they find an alternative.

Really, this is more damning. They could accommodate you but they don't because you could submit to their bullshit and choose not to.

Maybe the answer is to carry a dead feature phone to show to them. Like a talisman to ward off their evil.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by _heimdall on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:18PM (#41736080)
How do schools actually manage requiring this? Is it required that all students have access to smartphones, tablets, the internet in general, etc? If a student doesn't have a device to install the crappy branded app on, what does the school do?

I don't have kids yet though that time is likely coming, this goes firmly on the growing list of reasons why we'd choose to homeschool.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by theGnuMe on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:45PM (#41736269)
When you homeschool you will likely buy said crappy app (or another one) to help you actually school your kids...
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by from-nibly on Saturday October 05, 2024 @10:59PM (#41754415)
Why would you need an app to homeschool your kids?
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by SoftTalker on Thursday October 03, 2024 @09:13PM (#41736820)
Schools that do this typically provide a Chromebook or iPad to each student.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by hyggetrold on Friday October 04, 2024 @05:47PM (#41745861)
Notice how there's a very consistent winner in all this :)
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by SirMaster on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:53PM (#41736331)
Sure it is, you can homeschool for example.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by moron4hire on Thursday October 03, 2024 @10:18PM (#41737179)
No thanks, don't want to put my kids through my childhood
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by _heimdall on Thursday October 03, 2024 @11:02PM (#41737389)
Assuming you were homeschooled and it went poorly for you, was your takeaway that it could never be done well? What did you find that makes homeschooling always worse than trusting the local, likely poorly paid and appreciated, state educators?
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by em-bee on Friday October 04, 2024 @07:36AM (#41740317)
What did you find that makes homeschooling always worse

we all live by the experience of our childhood. it is pervasive, and influences us in ways that we can't escape. i don't know what the parent commented experienced. but most likely they have not experienced bad regular schools, nor seen well working homeschooling. so their own homeschooling experience probably is all they have to go on.

i struggle as a parent because i missed a lot of important experiences from my childhood. as a result i am unable to replicate them. even if i get told by others what i should be doing, it feels unnatural and uncomfortable because i have not experienced that myself. for all i can tell, my kids childhood is better than my own, but i am repeating many of the mistakes of my parents because i simply don't know any better.

homeschooling may go the same way. if the parent had a bad experience homeschooling, they may just be unable to translate that into a better experience for their kids even if they believe or know that a better experience is possible.

trusting the local, likely poorly paid and appreciated, state educators?

my experience in a US highschool led me to conclude that the poor pay self selects for more motivated teachers. all the teachers i had there were excellent and i had the best time there out of all my schooling. that's an anecdote of course, and there are many counter examples, but equally you could ask the reverse question. what did you find that you believe that government schooling is necessarily a bad experience?

homeschooling is not for everyone. during covid, my ability to engage the kids into learning activities was an abysmal failure. so despite believing that great homeschooling is possible and not having experienced bad homeschooling myself, i'll never be doing it with my kids.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by _heimdall on Friday October 04, 2024 @11:03AM (#41742152)
Thanks for sharing here, its always interesting to hear a different person's experience/story. With regards to public schooling I'll share my anecdotal experience, as you mentioned I can't compare directly to homeschooling since I only ever went to public school.

I grew up in a pretty well off area, by no means was it a rich area but solidly middle to upper middle class. My public schools were pretty well funded and maintained, the teachers I had were very hit or miss though.

I had a handful of really good teachers in high school, maybe 3 out of the 25 or so different teachers I had. I had at least as many that were down right awful and had no business teaching. The rest were somewhere in the middle, they did seem to care about their job but weren't very good teachers and were mostly just teaching to the test.

That is my biggest issue with how public schools are run. Public education is made into such a specific process of how students are taught, what they are taught, and how they are tested and evaluated that the education seems better suited to developing robots rather than adults. The remnants of an educational system designed to produce factory workers are still very noticeable in my opinion.

I saw plenty of my peers struggle in school because they weren't interested in the topics they were forced to learn and weren't offered the chance to engage with what they actually enjoyed. Others struggled because the teachers we did have didn't understand the materials very well and weren't able to teach lessons in different ways for different students (I always noticed this most in math classes).

Homeschooling is interesting to me, if and when we have kids, because (a) I experienced way too many bad teachers in what was comparatively a pretty good school system and (b) I don't prefer the idea of the state taking such direct control over what, how, and when kids are taught. It definitely isn't for everyone though, totally agree there and I've seen friends and relatives bounce between public schools and homeschooling as they struggled with making homeschooling work for them.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by em-bee on Friday October 04, 2024 @06:26PM (#41746086)
i agree that traditional schooling leaves a lot to be desired. it's not just public schools but private schools as well. it's the whole structure of lectures and boring homework and the inflexibility of the teaching material. but most of all, and i believe studies confirmed that (i vaguely remember there was a discussion about this here on HN) the primary factor for a good school experience is the quality of the teachers. that goes for homeschooling as well as public or private schools. and the solution here is not the funding for schools, but the funding of education of teachers. no amount of school funding is going to make schools better if we don't give teachers better training.

besides that though, i think schooling really needs to be revamped. and we already have proven alternative options, if only our governments had the courage to try them.

i am mainly thinking of the montessori education model. it has proven itself. and teacher training is not expensive. it only takes one year if done fulltime.

i really do not know what it takes to change that though. there is so much resistance to change in the education sector that it is really painful to watch.

btw, it is interesting to note that in germany where i am from, homeschooling is strictly illegal. the reason today is that homeschooling allows families to avoid integration into the wider society. it enables insular thinking and allows families to avoid contact with others who think differently. the goal of public schooling in germany is to let children of different backgrounds, cultures, opinions and worldviews interact and learn from each other, to accept and tolerate them and to create an integrated society. school is the only place where different cultures are forced to interact with each other.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by _heimdall on Saturday October 05, 2024 @08:24AM (#41749396)
> i am mainly thinking of the montessori education model. it has proven itself. and teacher training is not expensive. it only takes one year if done fulltime.

My wife is a big fan of the Waldorf schools and has said she'd went to replicate a lot of their approach if we homeschooled. We actually lived a few blocks away from one in the Netherlands and had planned on sending kids there, but have since moved back to the US and are nowhere near a Waldorf.

That's really interesting to hear why homeschooling is banned in Germany. I was pretty sure it is either banned or extremely limited in the Netherlands as well, but never dug into why when we lived there. Integration and socialization is definitely a challenge for homeschooling. The friends and family I have that either are homeschooling or did in the past had good luck with getting their kids into the same sports leagues that public school students do, though that still doesn't replace 7+ hours a day of interacting with a school full of kids your own age.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by em-bee on Sunday October 06, 2024 @10:21AM (#41757355)
Integration and socialization is definitely a challenge for homeschooling

it is possible to manage that. the problem is people intentionally avoiding socializing to prevent their children from learning alternative ideas.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by 3np on Friday October 04, 2024 @09:58PM (#41747154)
I don't see them saying anything of the sort and just talking about their own choices for their own children.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by SirMaster on Saturday October 05, 2024 @04:10PM (#41752537)
My point was simply it's a valid option. You can't just reject some valid options and then say that what's left is inescapable... Or at least I don't think that's a very strong argument.
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by moron4hire on Sunday October 06, 2024 @05:47PM (#41760614)
I'm not on a good mentalspace to discuss this, I will admit. By most accounts, I'm consider a "success" of homeschooling. And in that, I have some resentment. A child shouldn't be a social experiment. A child should be prepared to live in the society in which they live. And that's where I think homeschooling failed me.

I don't blame my parents for this. At the time, 35+ years ago, it was "different". I guess. I don't know. I know my parents did what they thought was best. I just don't think they knew what was best. They were barely in their 20s when they had me. I was well into my 30s when we had our kids. So now, I'm here with them, and I don't want them to experience the pervasive loneliness that I did.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by 7bit on Friday October 04, 2024 @04:24AM (#41739104)
Americans and their home schooling
Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by pessimizer on Thursday October 03, 2024 @07:30PM (#41736159)
> Asked nicely if there was some way I could participate without it.

You've done your duty with them. Now write a letter to the school board. Give them a little while to respond, and if they don't, start handing copies of the letter to other parents outside of the school gates.

If you can't get other parents to care, then you're in trouble. Try to claim a religious exception.

Re:You Can't Opt-Out of A.I. Online by em-bee on Friday October 04, 2024 @07:47AM (#41740396)
exactly this. i have written about this before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41529783

some people just do not understand that there are interactions that are forced on us and that refusing to participate is only to our own disadvantage.

even if they allow you to participate without installing that app, you will always be second class. people will forget to copy you on messages, or not see messages you sent. and they will have a grudge because you make them do extra work. they will leave you out on things that are optional, or not vote for you when electing a parent representative. they will reject you for not being a team player.

the irony is that as a software developer i would not hesitate to create such an app. surely my app is better than the alternatives. and the TOS of my app is fine. oh wait, my boss changed the TOS without asking me. ooops.