News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by e-clinton on Sunday September 29, 2024 @04:54PM (#41690418)
I hate the term “woke”… and pretty much any other term that takes a heavily nuanced subject and condenses into one word for lazy minds to use and misuse. I hated the term when the left introduced it 10+ years ago, and I hate it now that the right has taken it over.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by dredmorbius on Sunday September 29, 2024 @04:57PM (#41690464)
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by TeaBrain on Sunday September 29, 2024 @07:08PM (#41691684)
Both of those articles reference only a single historical quote using the term, that being the 1938 song "Scottsboro Boys". The way the term is used in the song also isn't the way that is used today, but as a way to communicate to stay vigilant.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by jjaacckk on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:14PM (#41690648)
Making it easier to name makes it easier to criticise. I think this is your real concern.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by Lerc on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:37PM (#41690895)
It makes it easier to characterise. The way it does so is by eliminating nuance and making a word that doesn't express the opinions that people actually have.

Making it easier to characterise makes the characterisation easier to criticise, but that's not a meaningful target.

Use of unnuanced terminology creates battlefields far away from the positions that people actually care about.

Defund the police is used as a phrase by people who want a well regulated well funded police system. Only a very few extreme people want to eliminate police correctly

Microaggression is used in academia with a degree of specificity but there are those who will use it to mean "Thing I don't like". Dunning Kruger is a non partisan term that is misused similarly.

I don't particularly like the term woke myself but I also tend to agree with Godwin's second law.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by lostmsu on Sunday September 29, 2024 @10:52PM (#41693057)
At some point you need to ask yourself if the policies need that much nuance.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:00PM (#41690494)
At least woke had a real meaning when it started, now the right just uses it as “anything the the other guys do that I don’t like”
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by standardUser on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:07PM (#41690562)
It's hard to argue this is inaccurate. The origin of the term isn't really up for debate. And the way the conservative movement uses the term is overwhelming well-documented at this point.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by shaneofalltrad on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:43PM (#41690947)
This comment is probably the most correct reason "woke" has a negative tone now, because they chose to use it as a way to ignore their behaviors or associations that might not be the most empathetic of others, aligning it with this "woke" movement allows them to turn their back on the topic. Hard for those that care about topics to engage in bringing to light when half the Country puts your comment on blast for being too "woke". It's like Idiocracy at it's infancy.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by spinach on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:07PM (#41690566)
It's usually used to mean identity politics, isn't it? The origin of the word has it's roots in racism, but now it's come to basically mean all forms of identity politics.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Monday September 30, 2024 @02:55AM (#41694278)
No, it’s an adjective to describe a person. Someone who is “awake” to the structural oppression around them.

I guess you could call structural oppression “identity politics”, but that seriously feels like a dog whistle.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by lazyeye on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:52AM (#41694610)
Or phrased differently, someone who views everything through the prism of "oppressor/oppressed".
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:31PM (#41701761)
That is not a correct way to rephrase the definition I gave. Saying everything gets viewed through “oppressor/oppressed” is wrong and disingenuous. It implies that they are looking for something that isn’t there rather than noticing something that’s already there.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by lazyeye on Monday September 30, 2024 @05:59PM (#41702588)
Either that or the opposite is true.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by razakel on Monday September 30, 2024 @11:50AM (#41698559)
All politics fundamentally concerns identity.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by dotnet00 on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:16PM (#41690686)
I'd like to counter this, but yeah... lots of people just throw "woke" and "DEI" around for everything not good, it's extremely painful to see.

- Boeing sucks at building stuff: blame woke hiring

- SpaceX has a landing failure: blame DEI hires at suppliers

I wouldn't be surprised if they shout at the sky screaming about woke clouds when they get caught in rain without an umbrella

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by falcolas on Sunday September 29, 2024 @06:48PM (#41691526)
DEI is a replacement word, especially when used in the phrase "DEI hire". It's a replacement for Black, more specifically "N**r".

It's been really weird to see "Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion" become a hate word.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by Izkata on Sunday September 29, 2024 @11:07PM (#41693144)
Both of those mean "hiring based on identity politics instead of ability to do the job" (though different sub-groups, the first being activists and the second being the groups the activists focus on). It's not a simplistic "not good".
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by dotnet00 on Sunday September 29, 2024 @11:52PM (#41693384)
I know that's what those are supposed to mean, but that's not how the average poster on social media seems to use it.

Like with my example of the SpaceX landing failure, it was a booster that had flown over 20 times, had flown a trajectory at the edge of its performance, the leading theory (IIRC) was/is that some components on the legs finally wore out too much. Testing these limits has been one of the side-benefits of Starlink launches on used boosters.

So, seeing a bunch of people stupidly freaking out about this being due to DEI just shows that they don't actually know what "DEI hiring" is as a complaint.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by Jensson on Monday September 30, 2024 @01:39AM (#41693895)
> I know that's what those are supposed to mean, but that's not how the average poster on social media seems to use it.

This applies for every single word, average poster on social media are dumb. Toxic masculinity is similarly misused etc.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by lazyeye on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:50AM (#41694603)
But this in no way negates the thesis that a hiring policy based on membership of groups rather than merit alone, might mean that people are less competent and more mistakes happen.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Monday September 30, 2024 @04:32PM (#41701773)
Thankfully that “thesis” doesn’t need negating, because so far it’s been completely unsupported.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by zer8k on Monday September 30, 2024 @05:38PM (#41702460)
[CITATION NEEDED]
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Monday September 30, 2024 @06:09PM (#41702673)
I haven't seen a single citation in this thread to support it, you're welcome to provide some here
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by lazyeye on Monday September 30, 2024 @09:08PM (#41703741)
Lol
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by collingreen on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @11:59AM (#41710147)
I don't know if you're for or against the comment you're replying to with the same message and I find that delightful.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by allarm on Wednesday October 02, 2024 @02:57AM (#41717916)
It’s a simple logic though, let me help you: if you hire someone based on attribute A, you can't know with certainty that their attribute B is sufficiently developed. You’re welcome.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Wednesday October 02, 2024 @12:45PM (#41722538)
That’s just clearly not true! Nobody hires on a single criteria, and evaluating one criteria does not prevent you from evaluating another.

The only way your argument holds water is if you think minorities are just not up to the job.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by allarm on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:40PM (#41779828)
I think you should re-read my comment, until you understand it.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Monday September 30, 2024 @02:58AM (#41694293)
Neither of those things mean hiring someone who doesn’t have the ability to do the job. Which is clearly wrong because of course minorities are able to do these jobs
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by mpweiher on Monday September 30, 2024 @03:25AM (#41694437)
No it is not true that "of course minorities are able to do the job".

Just as it is not true that "of course majorities are able to do the job".

Just as it is not true that "of course minorities are not able to do the job".

Just as it is not true that "of course majorities are not able to do the job".

What minority/majority/gender or other group you belong to simply is not relevant.

For most highly skilled jobs, most people are not able to do the job, completely irrespective of which group they belong to otherwise ("otherwise" meaning: unless your grouping is "people who can do the job" and "people who can't do the job").

So the only or at least overriding criterion in hiring should (must?) be: can they do the job? (Do they have the skills, training, temperament, work ethic, etc.)

When reasonable people complain about DEI hires, what they are complaining about is "ability to do the job" not being the first, foremost and preferably only criterion used to select the hire. This is a reasonable complaint.

Of course there are also racist assholes, who complain about DEI hires because they believe a-priori that someone with a minority background can't do the job. That is to be condemned, obviously.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by jazzypants on Monday September 30, 2024 @12:29PM (#41699044)
It's just not a real thing. People don't get hired for their race in highly specialized jobs. It's just racist nonsense.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by zer8k on Monday September 30, 2024 @05:43PM (#41702502)
Actually, they do, regularly. But you've used the term "highly specialized jobs" which is unassailable. No matter which example I provide you can provide an even more specialized job that hires less people over a longer timeframe due to the skill gap.

I can tell you with certainty it happens in tech. This is probably not "highly specialized" but unless I am to ignore the very obvious anti-white anti-male undertones of the monthly all-hands HR segments the sorting algorithm based on victim hierarchy is well and truly alive. I work for a coastal company though so perhaps this effective is magnified significantly.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Wednesday October 02, 2024 @12:51PM (#41722608)
> …but unless I am to ignore the very obvious anti-white anti-male undertones…

Are there really anti-white anti-male undertones, or is it just a problem for you when anyone else is centered?

“Trust me bro it happens at my company.”

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by mpweiher on Friday October 04, 2024 @03:18AM (#41738700)
Don't know, how does "My boss said ‘we didn’t need another White guy.’ Say what?" work for you?
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by mpweiher on Wednesday October 02, 2024 @03:44AM (#41718178)
DuckDuckGo said no. But when I reapplied as a black lesbian who can’t speak English, they wanted me.

https://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/pw8622/duckduck...

Similar thing happened to me, though I didn't do the experiment.

And no, I am not "crying about it". But it is a real thing.

A executive recruiter working for an American company here in Europe told me that if she comes up with a white/male candidate, she has to get approval from the US head-office.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by superb_dev on Wednesday October 02, 2024 @12:49PM (#41722581)
Your evidence so far:

- A 3 year old Reddit post on r/conspiracy of a dead link

- Trust me bro, someone told me once

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by mpweiher on Thursday October 03, 2024 @04:13AM (#41728409)
I have provided personal and anecdotal evidence, which I never claimed was more than anecdotal evidence. And the reddit link was describing something that happened to me personally in almost exactly the same way, so a first hand account by two separate people. Now you can accuse me of lying...I guess you do you.

Anecdotal evidence is sufficient for "this does happen".

Whereas the absolute claim that this 100% does not happen was "trust me bro"

The US legal system seems to agree that this happens:

White male employee wins $10M in race discrimination lawsuit

https://www.hrmorning.com/news/white-male-race-discriminatio...

Or how about this: "As a recruiter, do you have any experience of a 'no white men' policy?"

19% answered "yes, explicit policy", with another 20% saying "implicit guidance"

https://resources.workable.com/stories-and-insights/no-white...

"My boss said ‘we didn’t need another White guy.’ Say what?"

https://archive.is/NvPJD#selection-431.0-431.58

"To be clear, the candidate was eminently qualified, had made it through multiple rounds of interviews, and was the clear favorite among almost everyone who spoke with him. Further, it’s not like he lost out to someone else — they simply didn’t hire him, and the company started the hiring process all over again!"

This stuff is easy to find and verify.

Re:America is becoming less "woke" by DasIch on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:00PM (#41690496)
FYI the "left" has introduced woke 90+ years ago in the 1930s. It merely increased in popularity.
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by FrustratedMonky on Monday September 30, 2024 @11:39AM (#41698442)
Technically, didn't they introduce it in 1861?
Re:America is becoming less "woke" by HDThoreaun on Monday September 30, 2024 @12:42PM (#41699211)
The problem with "wokeism" is that it isnt very nuanced though. Sure the academic form of it is, Ive read Kendi and found him quite nuanced. But the political movement formed on the backs of these academics works is decidedly lacking in nuance. It continuously misinterprets the academics who started the movement and then makes litmus tests around those mistaken interpretations. It very much is a populist movement