The only way for a trademark to be generic is if its utilized by large swaths of the market for advertising (i.e “Taco Tuesdays”) or is overly generic and descriptive (i.e. “crab fries”). Techdirt is neither utilized by large parts of the market nor is it generic and/or descriptive.
The intended point of a trademark is essentially to prevent scams. E.g. nobody is allowed to sell something called an "apple computer" except apple. The interest doesnt change with time. (In contrast the theoretical point of copyright and patents is to allow people to recoup r&d costs. Eventually at some point the holder has had a fair shot at recouping the cost, so there is a time limit)
Imagine if "PC compatible" got trademarked in 1997.
This is why I think that companies should lose their trademarks in case of scandals, e.g. privacy infringements or security breaches. This is a much better punishment than fines which are often just a slap on the wrist. And to the consumer, a scandal often feels similar to being scammed.
A trademark is a symbol of trust. And companies who are not trustworthy should not be able to use it.
<https://247wallst.com/special-report/2021/11/04/companies-th...>
<https://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2023/08/identity-crisis-...>
That said, your stripping suggestion is interesting.
That's also happened: Aspirin, escalator, cellophane, laundromat, kerosene, thermos, and zipper are all former trademarks now considered generic terms.
And if it was granted in the late 60s, that’s what 30 years after Superman? Shouldn’t it have been common by then?