And who is to say that people who want to copy your code without adhering to your license terms or pay won't go to extra lengths? or am I missing something here?
It seems like they could just download your code from Github and violate your license like that so.. unclear why they'd bother doing it via copilot.
If it were my GPLed code being copied, it doesn't seem to make any difference whether I press copyright claims or not. It won't help me compete against this dev's company. They'd use Copilot to rewrite the code differently. The speed of improvement in code-writing tools doesn't give me much hope that my code is uniquely clever.
Why would specifically prompting the LLM to generate similarly copyrighted code be any different? That's what's being discussed here - that people will "go the extra lengths" to intentionally copy your code.
The "It wasn't me, it was the tool, even though I directed the tool quite specifically to do the thing that happened" is not a new defense in the legal systems of the world. We are already generally are able to deal with these without significant issue.
Only expressive software is protected by copyright and sometimes that interpretation should be handled by a jury.
AFAIK but IANAL, I can go look at a solution in a GPLed library and then code that solution in my proprietary code base. As in, "oh, I see, the used a hash map for that and a list of this, and locked at this point. I'll code up something similar". As along as you don't "copy the code" you're fine.
Am I wrong?
Is it just a matter of scale? (hey there LLM, re-write all of OpenOffice into ClosedOffice).
Because humans are human. We are rewarded extra super duper rights that inanimate things, such as a computer program, are not rewarded.
I think we should therefore work to demonstrate this is not the case, which is very hard to do. No idea why we would work under the absolutely insane, never-before-seen assumption that computer programs deserve human rights. I don't know where this line of reasoning started, or why, but at it's core it's so unbelievably preposterous (and against the very wellbeing of mankind).
And again, I have to ask: why? Why would you think that putting tons of time and effort into tricking the model into repeating memorized code is going to be a better investment than just using it normally to implement the functionality you want?
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2202.07646
Personally, I would not rely on blogs like "developer-tech.com" for unbiased information about "AI" litigation.
I would read the order and draw own conclusions.^1 (Note the plaintiffs are attempting to file an interloctory appeal re: the dimissal of the DMCA claims.)
1 https://ia904708.us.archive.org/6/items/gov.uscourts.cand.40...
No doubt I am in the minority but I am more interested in the contract claims, which have survived dismissal, than in the DMCA ones. If plaintiffs can stop the "training" of "AI" through contract, then in theory DMCA violations can be avoided.^2
2 For example, license terms which specifically prohibit using the licensed source code to train language models.
Is there a "fair use" defense to contract liability.^3
3 https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2006/05/16/0...
NAL, but in common law jurisdictions and maybe others there can be various implicit terms to any contract, like fair dealing.
Also if you can literally claim fair use, unless you signed a contract waiving that right (if that's even possible), it doesn't matter.
Heck, most software licensing in the USA is purporting to grant you rights that you already have from the Copyright Act. That's right, in US law you own the authorized copy you receive. The license claiming that you don't is questionable at best. To be fair the courts somehow have managed to become divided on this, but the plain language of the law itself is crystal clear, explicitly granting the right to make additional copies as necessary for execution.
Also that hardly matters when the fake license can still be "enforced" via lawfare. Most everyone is going to choose to pay up rather than fight a protracted legal battle against Microsoft.
I think it would be extremely hard to make claims against GitHub for training AI with code on GitHub, assuming GH has the typical "right to use data to improve service" clause that usually shows up on free-service EULAs.
But Microsoft is selling a service capable of such reproduction. They're selling access to an archive containing copyrighted code.
To me it's the equivalent of selling someone a DVD set of pirated movies. The DVD set doesn't "reproduce" the copyrighted material unless you "prompt" it to (by looking through the set to find the movie, and then putting it in your DVD player), but it was already there to begin with.
The closest thing to what you are suggesting is the Napster ruling, where a critical part was that the whole service was only about copyright infringement. In the Github case most people are using it to write original code which is not a copyright violation so there is substantial non-infringing use.
But what I think doesn't matter. The judge disagreed with that interpretation too.
In particular this:
An amended version of the complaint had taken issue with GitHub’s duplication detection filter, which allows users to “detect and suppress” Copilot suggestions matching public code on GitHub.
The developers argued that turning off this filter would “receive identical code” and cited a study showing how AI models can “memorise” and reproduce parts of their training data, potentially including copyrighted code.
However, Judge Tigar found these arguments unconvincing. He determined that the code allegedly copied by GitHub was not sufficiently similar to the developers’ original work. The judge also noted that the cited study itself mentions that GitHub Copilot “rarely emits memorised code in benign situations.”
I think this is the key point: reproduction is the issue, not training. And as noted in the study[1] reproduction doesn't usually happen unless you go to extra lengths to make it.
[1] Not sure but maybe https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3597503.3639133? Can anyone find the filing?