News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge dismisses majority of GitHub Copilot copyright claims by nl on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @09:11PM (#41386230)
> And who is to say that people who want to copy your code without adhering to your license terms or pay won't go to extra lengths? or am I missing something here?

It seems like they could just download your code from Github and violate your license like that so.. unclear why they'd bother doing it via copilot.

Re:Judge dismisses majority of GitHub Copilot copyright claims by paulryanrogers on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @10:21PM (#41386622)
Copilot cooyright-washes the license. So even we'll behaved devs could unknowingly copy code without complying with the license.
Re:Judge dismisses majority of GitHub Copilot copyright claims by roenxi on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @11:14PM (#41386916)
Although legally there may be a problem, in practice this seems to be a bit of a "so what?" scenario. Our hypothetical dev is using a tool that writes a function. It writes the function. The dev was going to get a function that did what he wanted one way or another so it isn't clear that it makes much difference if the function happens to be a clone of a copyrighted function.

If it were my GPLed code being copied, it doesn't seem to make any difference whether I press copyright claims or not. It won't help me compete against this dev's company. They'd use Copilot to rewrite the code differently. The speed of improvement in code-writing tools doesn't give me much hope that my code is uniquely clever.

Re:Judge dismisses majority of GitHub Copilot copyright claims by cthalupa on Thursday August 29, 2024 @02:00AM (#41387803)
It's unclear to me that that is the case. If I prompt an image generation model specifically to generate an unlicensed picture of Batman, I do not suspect that a judge is going to be sympathetic to the argument that the t-shirt I was selling was made by DALL-E so I should be free of any copyright infringement claims against me.

Why would specifically prompting the LLM to generate similarly copyrighted code be any different? That's what's being discussed here - that people will "go the extra lengths" to intentionally copy your code.

The "It wasn't me, it was the tool, even though I directed the tool quite specifically to do the thing that happened" is not a new defense in the legal systems of the world. We are already generally are able to deal with these without significant issue.

Re:Judge dismisses majority of GitHub Copilot copyright claims by nl on Thursday August 29, 2024 @10:31PM (#41397281)
It's very unusual this happens for non-boilerplate code unless you deliberately disable the duplicate the duplicate filter.
Re:Judge dismisses majority of GitHub Copilot copyright claims by squigz on Thursday August 29, 2024 @06:40AM (#41389362)
> reproduction doesn't usually happen unless you go to extra lengths to make it.
Re:Judge dismisses majority of GitHub Copilot copyright claims by strunz on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @10:36PM (#41386704)
Because then you can blame it on Copilot instead of outright stealing