Low humidity drying the nose out seems to be why planes and winter are when SARS-CoV-2 and flus are so contagious.
I've been using a generic nasal inhaler when flying, but it's not clear if that would work in practice.
> nitric oxide nasal spray as the nose is the major area to protect
Reading your comment you would believe a nitric oxide nasal spray would be a good preventative when flying?
Thus, wearing a face mask will not effectively keep your nasal passages moist during a high altitude flight.
If only we had better air systems to go with these $1,000 tickets , but that's demanding a lot from the makers of 737max and such :p
My less empirical info is that airflow in a plane mostly goes from being input above your head, and exhausted from the pressurized cabin at your feet, meaning you have less exposure to anyone not in your row.
Remember that aircraft pressurization systems were designed to be smoked in, other than the newest designs. They needed enough airflow to not totally choke out passengers on a cross country or cross atlantic trip.
I'm not saying this is the case necessarily for planes, but I'm just trying to provide context for how proxy measures of air quality may not tell the full story.
Most systems lead to a dry throat due to bad filter designs and improper humidity regulation which is a shame.
Given all the other discomforts of flying, wearing a respirator is a minor problem. Passengers are not likely to have long, emotional conversations during a flight where a mask might be uncomfortable or inhibit communication. But there is the food/drink issue, if someone considers those to be important.
That obviously depends on how you define a "mask", a "medical mask" has a very different efficacy from an N95.[1]
[1]: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/coronavirus/i...
I started wearing N95s on flights since KF94 ear loop masks would hurt my ears after a few hours. Inadvertently realized during fit-testing that the KF94s let so much air around the edges that they were much less effective than I had assumed, so I basically just use my N95 when needed indoors anywhere. Also found that other 3M mask models didn't fit my face as effectively (failed the test almost immediately).
Highly recommended to go with fit-tested N95s (if not already using something even better like a respirator).
Edit: I should mention I've flown SF to Toronto a few times since the pandemic started and air quality on planes is quite terrible despite what airlines say. Lowest CO2 concentration around 1800 ppm, and highest I've seen has been 3000+ ppm (during boarding). (420ppm outdoor average at sea level, and anything about 1000ppm I'd wear a mask indoors.)
I am also curious how you connect CO2 levels to pathogen levels. Would a carbon filtration system adjust the CO2 levels at the same rate as pathogens?
As sneak also replied, it's just a proxy: higher CO2 correlates to higher chance of breathing in pathogens, but doesn't take into consideration filtration.
they aren’t directly correlated, it’s just a proxy. ventilation reduces both.
It’s worth noting in this context that masks have been shown to protect the wearer, not just to prevent the wearer transmitting viruses. See e.g. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7106e1.htm
Influenza may be a seasonal virus, but SARS-CoV-2 is not. There can be and in fact are "summer waves" driven by new variants, not weather.
Source e.g.
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20240719-why-covid-19-is-...
"Covid-19 doesn't follow normal seasonal patterns, like other respiratory viruses – waves of infection can happen at any time of year."
Now that's not the sole reason for transmissions of course, but weakened outer defenses help infections a lot.
Covid by far is no longer a "winter only" thing. The US has a record covid wave [1], so does Germany [2] and the UK [3].
Unfortunately politicians worldwide have pretty much given up preventing Covid transmission, mostly due to the serious backlash from shortsighted large employers and the far-right - some places like Nassau County (NY, US) even ban people from wearing masks [4] to protect themselves. Not to mention large parts of the population itself - try wearing a mask in public these days, people will either look at you like you're some sort of madman or they'll just outright assault you [5].
And all of that despite serious indicators that even minor measures like air filters in kindergartens and schools massively reduce sick times... it's truly maddening, air filters don't impact anyone, they're cheap to operate. But people don't want any kind of reminder of the lockdown era, they sometimes even violently respond to that.
We regulate literally everything needed for survival... our water gets tested to make sure it's free of contaminants, food and medicine production of all kinds has to comply with very strict requirements, noise polluters such as cars, trucks and heavy machinery get regulated... but the air we breathe? Nothing except particulate emissions from cars and industry gets regulated. Children have to learn in schools no matter how hot, humid, CO2-overloaded or moldy it is. Workers enjoy barely any protection as well. And it takes a massive amount of mold for a residential building to be declared unfit for living, maintaining air-condition installations (especially filters) isn't a requirement, which means landlords can get away with a lot of shit... It's a disgrace how far we have all fallen.
[1] https://edition.cnn.com/2024/08/16/health/covid-largest-summ...
[2] https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2024/07/17/bxrf-j17.html
[3] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ck5g2jk0730o
[4] https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2024/08/27/nassau-mask...
[5] https://www.newsweek.com/will-keenan-attacked-wearing-face-m...
I'd say they haven't even tried before. They just implemented authoritarian measures such as lockdowns that had little to no effect, but simply served those politicians' own self-serving purposes (e.g., being perceived as men of action or deploying these measures due to ulterior motives).
Anyway, what do you suggest? Lockdowns and civil rights restrictions forever? For trying to avoid an illness at all costs that not only wasn't particularly dangerous to begin with for the general population, but also is very much manageable today, particularly considering that most people are vaccinated now (or at least have the opportunity to get vaccinated).
> due to the serious backlash from shortsighted large employers and the far-right
Yeah, right. It's employers and the far-right, of course, not people wanting to move freely without the government interfering with every aspect of their daily lives.
Lockdowns and similar authoritarian measures simply aren't sustainable - nor have they ever been.
I literally wrote what I suggested and what you're asking: mandate air purifiers (and ventilation/AC in general...) for public and educational buildings. Additionally to that and specially for the US: introduce unlimited paid sick time, just like every other Western country already has.
And maaaaybe introduce by law a ban on knowingly sending sick kids to kindergarten/schools. It's utterly insane to watch every year how the weeks after major holidays are filled with "colleague X is out sick, caught a bug from their kids". If there is one thing every parent in my social circle is cursing about, it is all the tons of bugs their kids bring home from school because other parents can't be arsed to let their kid spend a few days at home watching TV - and it's not just covid. Lice, ordinary flu, hand-foot-mouth or whatever it's called in English, measles, ordinary fever, vomit/diarrhea...
> For trying to avoid an illness at all costs that not only wasn't particularly dangerous to begin with for the general population
In the US alone, 1.2 million people died of COVID. That's far from "wasn't particularly dangerous".
> but also is very much manageable today, particularly considering that most people are vaccinated now (or at least have the opportunity to get vaccinated).
Vaccines aren't perfect, even including them about 3-5% of the infected have a risk for debilitating long-covid (i.e. ME/CFS). It's not a gamble I want to take part in.
Implementing such highly useful measures hasn't been tried, though, at least not at any meaningful scale. Everything politicians tried was about more restrictions and ever more severe lockdowns.
> Vaccines aren't perfect, even including them about 3-5% of the infected have a risk for debilitating long-covid (i.e. ME/CFS). It's not a gamble I want to take part in.
Again, I'm totally fine with that. I'm myself still getting vaccinated once a year with an updated vaccine and I occasionally still wear masks depending in the setting (cramped indoor spaces, particularly during cold season).
If people personally want to avoid that risk that's perfectly ok. Demanding others behave in a certain way (e.g., by enforcing restrictions on their freedom of movement) is not, though.
Oh it has been tried, at least here in Germany the federal government gave financial aids to schools and kindergartens. And public offices like parliaments have had them ever since... but in schools? Parents demanded they be taken offline as "the pandemic ended", or schools bought the loud-ass versions...
Viruses spread prior to any indication of infection. By the time any kid in daycare has a fever, the class is already infected and spreading to others. Also, a huge number of viral infections just result in runny noses.
Sure but pretty much any daycare worker you ask can tell you stories about a kid barely able to stand that just got dumped on their front door, or ones that have been obviously given quite the hefty dose of medication and "suddenly" get worse in a matter of 2-3 hours once the medication wore off.
And that is frankly anti-social behavior, for me it would be grounds to yeet the parents from the daycare effective immediately.
> Also, schools serve as daycare taking on the legal liability for handling kids, allowing parents to work.
In Germany we have "Kinderkrankentage" - sick days for your child that you as a parent take to care for your kids.
> Not to mention that efforts to prevent abuse of this unlimited paid sick time would be another huge resource sink.
EVERY Western country has such a policy and survives just fine. If the US fears it being abused, well, maybe do the decent thing and give them a similar amount of vacation PTO?!
> Florence currently provides support to about 2,000 working families in 23 wards and four cities in Tokyo, Kawasaki, and Yokohama cities in Kanagawa Prefecture, and Urayasu and Ichikawa cities in Chiba Prefecture.
I have read tons of articles on these types of benefits, but never seen them successfully implemented on a national, universal level. The main problem being voters not wanting to prioritize spending on kids, or at least prioritizing spending on older population groups rather than kids (since that is who the voters are).
Damn, which countries offer that? And do they actually, in reality, and not just on paper? I live in Europe and while theoretically you can have paid sick time, in reality your employer will just fire you (sometimes), you literally cannot be sick without such dire consequences (so I have heard from the mouth of employers).
Firing someone is very hard in Germany unless it's about closing up shop or intentional action against the employer (shit like theft or vandalism).
How about ANY mandatory PTO/Sick time at all?
This pisses me off every time I think of it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_annual_leave_b...
I think there are only 5 countries with as little legally mandated leave as the US (aka 0): Kiribati, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Nauru and Palau.
So, the ground is shifting on this in the USA, at least at the state level.
But the US didn't connect many useful strings.
It couldn't, structurally not. In the EU a lot is already harmonized by EU law, but in the US? Congress has been gridlocked for decades now thanks to (predominantly Republican) obstructionism and the states can't be arsed to work on constitutional amendments either.
Had all states had restrictions/"lockdowns" in 2020-2022 that were as strict as the strictest state's mitigation measures, we would have saved ~360k more lives[1].
1: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama-health-forum/fullartic...
That's a completely different argument, and one that really can't be objectively measured (e.g., how do you value a life saved?). But lockdowns were effective at saving lives in 2020, and since we knew nothing about SAR-CoV-2 and had limited treatment options there was basically no other option. Nobody (other than you) has mentioned reinstating lockdowns.
I still stand by that claim. Compared with alternative, less restrictive measures, lockdowns achieve very little, especially when considering the massive downside they come with.
Like you said, lockdowns were justified in early 2020 when we knew very little about COVID-19. Later, though, they amounted to nothing more than authoritarian virtue signalling.
> Nobody (other than you) has mentioned reinstating lockdowns.
Not explicitly. More often than not that's what people mean when they're saying that politicians have given up on fighting Covid.
> More often than not that's what people mean when they're saying that politicians have given up on fighting Covid.
I know a lot of people in public health and disability spaces, and every person I know that talks about the failure of public health around the covid pandemic is referring to the dismantling of surveillance (e.g., testing), the lack of investment in next generation vaccines and treatments, the failure to upgrade ventilation and filtration, and removing mask mandates in targeted places (like emergency rooms). I haven't heard anybody in the US discuss lockdowns in years. I haven't even heard people talk about broad (i.e., outside healthcare) mask mandates in over a year. You need to get "mitigations = lockdowns" out of your head, that's not what people are "implying" when they discuss fighting covid.
I find this kind of argument - which indeed seems to have become quite fashionable during the pandemic - to imply that dissenting opinions aren't supported by science to be pretty offensive, particularly when recent revelations (e.g., in Germany, since that country has been mentioned in this thread) have shown that quite often mandates were driven by politics rather than being supported by science.
> targeted places (like emergency rooms).
While ERs aren't the first places that come to mind, because for the most part they don't treat patients with communicable diseases, there's nothing that keeps hospitals from implementing such mandates. I'd welcome that, because as should have become obvious from this this thread I'm very much in favour of wearing masks.
> that's not what people are "implying" when they discuss fighting covid.
While they don't have any actual expertise on the matter, there still is a small but very vocal #ZeroCovid bubble (e.g., on the social network formerly known as Twitter) that quite literally implies that - and little else - for fighting COVID-19 today.
Unless I missed something, you have yet to share the science that supports your view. I'm not bowing out of discussing this because we have different opinions, I'm bowing out because I shared a study (and could provide more) and you responded by shifting goal posts and standing by your claim, not by responding in kind with similar studies or different interpretations of the data. There's not much discussion to be had if we're not working from a shared understanding of data and facts, and those data and facts aren't driving our opinions and beliefs. Anyway, best of luck out there!
There you go:
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9368251/
- https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S026427512...
- https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/sweden-covid-and-excess-... (Sweden being "notorious" for not having mandated lockdowns)
Comparing excess mortality in Sweden and Germany (which had numerous lockdowns): https://ourworldindata.org/explorers/covid?tab=chart&Metric=...
[1] https://yle.fi/a/74-20062381
[2] https://www.newscientist.com/article/2398713-schools-cut-cov...
According to the CDC, “As of August 16, 2024, we estimate that COVID-19 infections are growing or likely growing in 27 states, declining or likely declining in 4 states, and are stable or uncertain in 17 states.”
Source: https://www.cdc.gov/cfa-modeling-and-forecasting/rt-estimate...
I'm stating that this is odd from my perspective. If I were doing that I'd be saying "you're a hypochondriac"
Please learn to spoken
You might have a genuine question but it was rude to frame it has an assumption or accusation. Furthermore your follow up is dismissive of the whole community. Please reflect on your behaviour and try to do better in future.
For sake of being nice I'll assume you're being nice rather than condescending.
Again, no this is not an accusation but let's rephrase,
RFC: Given above information. If I interpret it one way I understand you to be imunocopromised which is missing, Or if I interpret it another way I find your actions to be as one might describe as extreme hypocondrea aka non sensical unless I'm missing some detail.
The reasonable responses from a normal person are;
Yes, I am I forgot to mention;
I just don't want to get sick, this is my level of risk assessment which may differ from yours;
No, see third or fourth alternative you didn't consider.
There is no subconscious bias here, other than to explain my clear bias in understanding. I'm explaining why it makes no sense to me and asking if they can clarify. Again I'm not saying a person is behaving a certain way other than the community is deciding to read heavily negatively into a short paraphrased question. This is the attitude as to why things like irc died...
When I read what you wrote, I see an accusation and a pithy open window. "Are you broken or dumb?" -- and moreso the comment you replied to said "exciting development; i keep my nasal passages and throat moist for the same reasons." Like, your comment barely follows. Except to say that taking preventative measures that appear backed by studies is a form of delusion.
A sensible action based on a sensible observable short term impact is sensible behaviour. I.e. dry throat or not having dry throat, is sensible. I fail to see a problem with logic or opinion here, this is cut and dry and goes no further.
Deciding to take actions which amounted and contributed directly to social calls to shut down schools, damaging economy, making politics even more toxic under the banner of "latest study shows". Is clearly extremely bad think. This has damaged the lives of an entire generation of children because of "what if" fear... I know I'm busy seeing the fallout in teaching.
The daily mail is famous for citing bacon will kill our cure you citing bad latest statistical/biology papers. The BBC in the UK is now just as bad. US media is hitting this low regardless of bias or ownership. All selling the same "worry that an undefined chance of a badly defined thing may kill you if...". This is extremely damaging. Why did the entirety of society end up like their comment sections?
They make the claim so we'll have to see. I currently use a nitric oxide nasal spray as the nose is the major area to protect (and also use probiotic lozenges of the k12 strain for the throat).
--- “The vaccine offers potent protection against transmission, prevents reinfection and the spread of the virus, while also reducing the generation of new variants,” Dr Liu said.
“Unlike the mRNA vaccine which targets only the spike protein, CDO-7N-1 induces immunity to all major SARS-CoV-2 proteins and is highly effective against all major variants to date.
“Importantly, the vaccine remains stable at 4°C for seven months, making it ideal for low- and middle-income countries.” ---