News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by debacle on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:29AM (#41367308)
For those who don't want to read, they distill the cacao juice, mix it with the pureed husk, and then use that instead of sugar in the chocolate. The process is more expensive than using sugar itself, which is the cheapest part of chocolate production.

Then there's some romantic pontificating that this will somehow alleviate West Africa from modern day colonialism/child slavery or lower the price of chocolate.

So no, Swiss scientists have not made a chocolate breakthrough.

Buy your chocolate from companies that don't use child slavery, even if it's more expensive.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @11:04AM (#41368361)
I don't think it is necessarily "romantic pontificating". They've effectively found (or more likely "refound" given there were probably indigenous recipes like this for centuries) that you can "cider" the chocolate fruit and like apple cidering the most effective (industrial) application of this process will be close to the source of the fruit rather than at an industrial junction of commerce such as Switzerland with access to shipments of both cheap industrial sugar and expensively labored cocoa beans.

Even if the cocoa fruit sugars are more expensive in the markets of Switzerland than other sugars, the cheapest source of sugar at the cocoa plantation itself is still going to be the "leftover"/"waste" fruit. If the recipe these Swiss scientists have come up with is good enough, producers could start to build "whole chocolate" directly near the plantations and better compete in that market directly rather than in the cocoa bean "ingredient" market. That would lower the price of chocolate (more suppliers, shorter supply chains with fewer middlemen).

If there's "romantic pontification" in the article it's as much or more the multiple reassurances that Swiss chocolate would remain relevantly competitive (and not just an expensive reminder of a bygone era) to such a massive increase of suppliers with access to existing "waste" products, should it happen.

ETA: And/or such a process might open up a much larger market for shipping the whole fruit, not just the beans, and moving the expensive labor parts closer to the industrial hubs. That would also obviously alleviate labor problems at the edges (plantations), incentivize reducing/eliminating labor with industrial tools that wasn't as incentivized before, and might also bring production costs down overall (for cheaper, more sustainable chocolate).

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Majromax on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @11:47AM (#41368843)
> Even if the cocoa fruit sugars are more expensive in the markets of Switzerland than other sugars, the cheapest source of sugar at the cocoa plantation itself is still going to be the "leftover"/"waste" fruit.

Not necessarily. Chocolate abhors moisture, so sugars derived from the fruit and pulp will need to be extensively dehydrated. Over some range of energy and capital costs versus refined sugar cost, it may still be more expensive to have "whole fruit" processing on-site than to import refined sugar for processing.

> If the recipe these Swiss scientists have come up with is good enough, producers could start to build "whole chocolate" directly near the plantations and better compete in that market directly rather than in the cocoa bean "ingredient" market.

Is the expense of sugar really what makes the rest of the production chain (roasting, grinding, and final processing) infeasible on-site?

> And/or such a process might open up a much larger market for shipping the whole fruit, not just the beans, and moving the expensive labor parts closer to the industrial hubs.

If you're contemplating shipping the whole fruit without processing, I think this would still be infeasible. The fruit is wet, which would vastly increase the shipping cost per kilogram of final chocolate. Shipping the raw fruit might also require a cold chain, depending on how likely it is to ferment or spoil en-route.

You can analogize this to bulk shipments of sugar, where as I understand it early-stage milling is done near the sugar cane/beet plantations to remove most of the moisture. The raw cane sugar is largely dry, and it can be cost-effectively transported to sugar refineries for further processing.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @02:14PM (#41370854)
> Not necessarily. Chocolate abhors moisture, so sugars derived from the fruit and pulp will need to be extensively dehydrated.

Right. Definitely a place in this story where most of the questions are in the specifics of the process/method implied. About the only specific we get in the article is that the process seems to involve gelling (jello-ing?) the fruit pulp/rind in some way. I'm sure there are interesting twists involved that will be in the scientific literature and/or patents.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by nervousvarun on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:36AM (#41367369)
Know this article was concerned with fair labor, but heavy metals are also a concern with chocolate (at least for North America).

https://www.health.harvard.edu/heart-health/heavy-metals-fou...

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by XzetaU8 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:53AM (#41367528)
Indeed, heavy metals in chocolate is a real issue

a more recent CR test here: https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/a-third-o...

and one from Bryan Johnson (anti-aging tech millionaire): https://youtu.be/RzWWOQMLttE

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by tomComb on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:20AM (#41367851)
I'm a fan of CR and of independent testing. I'm sorry that the attempts to bring independent testing to the supplements industry haven't done better.

But they too fall victim to the need to exaggerate every story to get better headlines.

In this case, they came up with ridiculously stringent standards allowing them to suggest danger where there isn't.

On the other hand, it is good that the outliers get scolded and hopefully they improve their processes as a result.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by okr on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:41AM (#41367420)
Just curious, how to identify the companies, that use child slavery? Is there a logo on the packaging? How does it look like?
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Vinnl on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:43AM (#41367438)
It's fairly hard to do, but the ones that make an effort will generally at least have the Fair Trade logo. (UTZ is an weak industry-initiated alternative that does not cut it, as I understand it.)
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by yourusername on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:35AM (#41368005)
It's all of them. Tony Chocolonely's whole image is to be as fairtrade as possible and even they admit that they can not guarantee no forced labour was used in their production chain.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by systemtest on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:46AM (#41368143)
They could easily insource their entire operation in order to guarantee slave free chocolate, but you would end up with very expensive chocolate. That is probably why they dropped their "100 percent slave free" slogan. They still need to make a profit and at the moment you can only do that with slave labour.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by tomComb on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:33AM (#41367982)
Yes, looking for fair trade labelled products is important, and I also believe it is important to look for the International Fairtrade Certification Mark ...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Fairtrade_Certif...

As with any such program, if it is implementing effectively then some companies will chafe at the requirements and try to develop their own fair trade program more to their liking.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by jgeada on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:44AM (#41368117)
The logo for "child labor was used in the manufacture of this chocolate" looks exactly like the Nestle logo
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by not_math on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:57AM (#41367585)
There's a John Oliver episode about the chocolate industry, you can check it out on YouTube.

Of course there's no logo saying the chocolate is made with child slavery, I hope you didn't mean to be snarky here.

There are initiatives to try to alleviate the problem, the only example I have in mind right now is Tony's Chocolonely (which explains the problem and their solution on their website) but I'm sure others could come up with other initiatives.

The trends from top companies of chocolate is that they try to do as little as possible to alleviate the problem of child slavery in chocolate production.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by ScoobleDoodle on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:28AM (#41367937)
I assumed the logo would be on the ones without child slavery. Similar to the organic logo.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Biganon on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:05AM (#41367668)
> Of course there's no logo saying the chocolate is made with child slavery, I hope you didn't mean to be snarky here.

...?

Quality labels are a thing, why couldn't an independent NGO overwatch the production?

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by cogman10 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:40AM (#41368062)
It's expensive, easy to bypass, and has little enforcement teeth.

Expensive because you need to pay an inspector (ideally multiple to avoid corruption) to visit these farms.

Easy to bypass because the kids aren't working the fields all the time and there's plenty of warning an inspector is coming.

And the enforcement mechanism is you don't get the label... But like there's plenty of buyers for slave chocolate so that mostly means a minor hit on income.

NGO inspectors are better than nothing, but we should be clear eyed in how much they can solve. The only way to significantly reduce slave labor is harsh penalties on companies that trade in slave goods. That was pretty much the only thing that collapsed the ivory market.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by systemtest on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @12:33PM (#41369456)
You could buy a large plot of land in Ghana or Nigeria. Start a large cacao plantation. Hire locals to do the labour intensive work for you. And then fly in management from Western European countries to oversee the operation and to make sure that no children set foot on the plantation.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by yunwal on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:33AM (#41367350)
Just curious, what are those companies? Is fair trade a good indicator or just marketing?
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by xnx on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:36AM (#41367378)
There may be others, but this brand has made it their focus: https://tonyschocolonely.com/us/en/our-mission
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by systemtest on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:44AM (#41368119)
Their original slogan was "100 percent slave free" and they changed it to "towards 100 percent slave free" a while back.

Nowadays their slogan is "Crazy about chocolate. Serious about people".

They seem to constantly weaken their slogan.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Rinzler89 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:40AM (#41367415)
Yeah but the question is where's the proof that they actually put that into practice. Because all large corporations are full of ESG and greenwashing messages on their websites but we all know the reality is different. Missions statements are cheap.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Vinnl on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:46AM (#41367462)
Tony's Chocolonely is an interesting brand, because its origin lies in a Dutch TV show investigating consumer goods. At some point, the presenter ("Tony" [1]) decided to sue himself for buying slave chocolate, and then decided to see how hard it actually is to make slave-free chocolate - and Tony's Chocolonely was born.

As I understand it they're less strictly idealistic than they used to be so as to be a profitable business, but at least it wasn't an attempt at fairwashing an existing brand.

[1] Actually Teun (van de Keuken), but that doesn't work well in English.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Rinzler89 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @01:34PM (#41370335)
>van de Keuken

Ha, Neuken in de Keuken, is the only Dutch I know.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Vinnl on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @06:04AM (#41377845)
Turns out that "in the kitchen" (or "of the kitchen", in this case) is actually regular vernacular as well :)
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by xnx on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:41AM (#41368078)
Very reasonable to be skeptical of these kind of things, but this company seems to be the real deal: https://tonyschocolonely.com/us/en/annual-fair-reports
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by _a_a_a_ on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:31AM (#41367957)
What kind of proof would you want?
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Rinzler89 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @11:07AM (#41368398)
Something more than "trust me bro". Something like a third party auditor confirming their claims.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by mkesper on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:10AM (#41367731)
Have a look here, table should be understandable without knowing german: https://makechocolatefair.org/nachhaltigkeitssiegel-fuer-sch...

As suspected, UTZ guarantees are weakest by far.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by gs17 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @12:01PM (#41368989)
> table should be understandable without knowing german

The "Ja" and "Nein" parts are, but I don't think, for example, "Rückverfolgbarkeit" is understandable without knowing German (having to know "UTZ" means "Rainforest Alliance" is a different issue).

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Rinzler89 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:36AM (#41367376)
>Buy your chocolate from companies that don't use child slavery, even if it's more expensive.

Which are those? Because most of those "made from Fairtrade/ethically sourced cocoa" labels you see on most chocolate bars are worth exactly dogshit.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Moru on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:43AM (#41367441)
This one is a serious one [0]. It's a small local chocolate producer that has close contacts with other small cacao producers and buys directly from them.

[0] https://nordicchocolate.se/chokladbutik/

Oh, and the flavour and texture is great. Lindt has nothing on these ones :-)

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by jefftk on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:00AM (#41367618)
How do you know their practices are better than at your typical artisanal chocolate company? The kind of claims they're making don't look unusual to me.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Moru on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:12AM (#41367746)
Not sure what you mean with artisanal, english is not my native tongue. But she is a local legend here. Been passionate about chocolate since a kid and has worked hard to build a supply chain that works to her standards. Was on the news a few times showing the local sources of her cacao. And after tasting the chocolate I believe everything she says. :-)
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by LtWorf on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:35AM (#41367367)
> Buy your chocolate from companies that don't use child slavery, even if it's more expensive.

What if they use child slavery but pretend not to and just charge more? Plenty of those cases got revealed.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Lendal on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:55AM (#41367553)
You left out why sugar is the cheapest part.

Subsidies.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by sophiacamille on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:06AM (#41367671)
Isn't sugar just relatively cheap to produce and can be locally grown in Europe?
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:48AM (#41368166)
One of the biggest sources of the world's sugar today is corn (as High Fructose Corn Syrup), which is a rather expensive "concentration" process but is heavily subsidized in the United States by a large number of interlocking subsidies in US's strange, complex multi-grade corn system which leads to "cheap" access of lots of "waste" corn that that is "cheap as free" enough that the expensive "concentration" efforts are still profitable at cheap costs.

One of the "best" sources of "plain" white sucrose (versus fruit's heavier balance of fructose) is sugar cane, which is a plant that prefers sub-tropical regions and often islands at that and historically required massive plantations with slave labor to get cheap and today involve massive expensive industrial harvesters and international cooperation of subsidies, grants, and colonial legacies.

Maple trees grow in northern climates and real Maple syrups are expensive today as a number of subsidies expired and demand outpaced production and even available supply.

Other fruit syrups compete against the primary uses of their fruits.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by snovv_crash on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @11:22AM (#41368571)
To add: in Europe there is a large percentage of sugar coming from beets, which wouldn't be used for food otherwise.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by LtWorf on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @03:45PM (#41372075)
Why write such a long comment about USA agriculture in reply to someone speaking about european agriculture?
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @04:40PM (#41372748)
I started from USA agriculture because it dominates import/exports, but I did a winding expansion to North American and Pacific Island and Caribbean sources and then finally much of the remainder of the world's sources (though I said "fruit" and definitely forgot about beets, which few would classify as a fruit, that is something I missed). It's a global market and you can't talk about how cheap refined sugar is without starting from the cheapest/highest-volume sources of it. (Just like you can't talk about European oil prices without starting at OPEC/Middle East and then the US Gulf Coast even if you eventually wanted to just talk about Scottish off-shore oil prices. The other forces are bigger so they have an impact on the market prices.)
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @09:55AM (#41367554)
> or lower the price of chocolate.

In the US, I can't even really buy chocolate anymore. About 3 or 4 years ago, it suddenly changed flavor... now it tastes like brown-colored wax to me. It was sudden and noticeable, and if I looked through old posts I could narrow it down to a particular month. This was across the board for all things Nestle and Hershey. Maybe if I got some snobby Eurochocolate, but I wouldn't know where. And sometimes I just like (or want to like) the candy bars I'd get as a kid. It's not the only food that's undergone one of these "now with 10% less sawdust" scenarios, Kraft mac'n'cheese comes to mind.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by jl6 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @12:17PM (#41369199)
“Waxy” is the normal taste for chocolate produced using vegetable oil instead of cocoa butter or otherwise skimping on the dairy content (one of the main reasons why cheap US chocolate is so awful), but I don’t think that’s new in the last 3-4 years.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by Maken on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:09AM (#41367705)
3-4 years ago was the COVID epidemic. Are you sure you are not suffering loss of smell?
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by mattmaroon on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:21AM (#41367855)
That seems about 1 trillion times more likely than that all of the chocolate sold here (made by many disparate producers) suddenly changed.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:46AM (#41368144)
Looks like it happened earlier than I remember.

https://www.today.com/food/chocoholics-sour-new-hersheys-for...

So no, not a trillion times more likely. But it's interesting that that's your first conclusion.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by mattmaroon on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @02:47PM (#41371272)
I’ll be honest I didn’t really read your comment far enough to get to where you said just two companies. You said you can’t buy chocolate in the USA and we have a wealth of chocolate. I guess being a foodie when someone mentions buying chocolate to me I don’t even think of Nestle or Hersheys, anymore than I’d think of Folgers and Maxwell House if someone said “I can’t buy coffee because it all changed”.

Guess I should read deeper before replying.

I recently was at a chocolate farm in Central America and they did talk about this change.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @05:02PM (#41373006)
> I’ll be honest I didn’t really read your comment far enough to get to where you said just two companies. You said you can’t buy chocolate in the USA

Those two companies account for some large fraction of marketshare in the US. And since I didn't grow up eating $10/bar Geflaggersverkenfunkenderassen swiss chocolate, those hold little appeal anyway. Thanks though for admitting you just kind of ignored what I said, I figure that goes for the downvoters too.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by mattmaroon on Thursday August 29, 2024 @08:26AM (#41390074)
I mean to be fair your wording didn’t help. You started saying you can’t even buy chocolate here.

Bud and Miller own about 2/3 of the beer market but I can find 100 craft beers within a block of me. Same with chocolates. If I said that all the beer suddenly started tasting bad it would be basically the same statement you made and a reasonable person would think the problem was something to do with me. People of course skim comments so when you lead with that, it’s natural.

There was not a point in living memory where you couldn’t buy much better chocolate than Hersheys in any grocery store. So your statement doesn’t make much sense.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:42AM (#41368084)
One could be forgiven for thinking that, but about a year later I found articles talking about how they decided to remove cocoa butter from their recipes because it cost too much.

The mac'n'cheese thing was funny too. There were half a dozen reddit threads with people complaining that it started tasting different. Then, completely oblivious, Kraft does a press release a few months later about how they changed the formula and it was so successful no one even noticed. Whatever minuscule amount of cheese they used in the powder cost too much and was replaced with god knows what.

Substitution-flation made everything taste like shit, and no one even said anything.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by mattmaroon on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @02:51PM (#41371314)
In the food industry (and probably others) this is called salami slicing. You take one thin slice off the salami and you can’t tell the difference. Then a little while later you do it again.

Eventually the salami is half the size it used to be and nobody notices until they get the original again.

Most Americans eat garbage all day so when it gets a little garbagier they can’t tell.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by kbolino on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @11:02AM (#41368337)
Multiple varieties of "snobby Eurochocolate" are sold prominently in the candy and/or snack aisles of my podunk town's Walmart and grocery store. I've never had any trouble getting it, and with domestic candy prices having gone through the roof since the pandemic, the price difference isn't as much as you might think.
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by debacle on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:37AM (#41368030)
A Hershey bar is like a dollar. You can find good chocolate bars for $2-3 and there's no real difference between a $7 chocolate bar and a $20 chocolate bar (unless you're buying it right at the chocolatier).

The cost of "upgrading" your chocolate to good or even great will run you about $100 a year. Worth it, in my books.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by jncfhnb on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:09AM (#41367704)
It’s not snobby to buy food that isn’t produced by the largest, most evil food corps in the world.

It has relatively little to do with Europe either.

Go for Tony’s imo.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by 1986 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:06AM (#41367676)
Changed suddenly 3-4 years ago... long COVID?
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by the_real_cher on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:01AM (#41367623)
Did you try whole foods?

Thats where my hippy parents get their chocolate and I mean that in a positive way.

Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by freeone3000 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:08AM (#41367694)
Did you happen to get infected with COVID-19 during that period?
Re:Have Swiss scientists made a chocolate breakthrough? by pengaru on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @10:26AM (#41367918)
Skimpflation has impacted many things.