News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by codetrotter on Monday August 19, 2024 @04:51PM (#41294484)
> set the user agent header to the googlebot one

Also, how effective is this really? Don’t the big news sites check the IP address of the user agents that claim to be GoogleBot?

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by mdotk on Monday August 19, 2024 @05:02PM (#41294566)
This. 12ft has never ever worked for me.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by HKH2 on Monday August 19, 2024 @09:44PM (#41296061)
I know one website it works well on, so I still use it, but yes, most others fail.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by dutchmartin on Monday August 19, 2024 @05:34PM (#41294762)
If you would host that server on Google cloud, you would make it a lot harder already.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by jsheard on Monday August 19, 2024 @05:40PM (#41294793)
https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/...

They provide ways to verify Googlebot IPs specifically, anyone who cares to check wouldn't be fooled by running a fake Googlebot on Googles cloud.

Likewise with Bingbot: https://www.bing.com/webmasters/help/how-to-verify-bingbot-3...

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by ZoomerCretin on Monday August 19, 2024 @06:09PM (#41294966)
I sincerely hope the antitrust suit ends this practice soon. This is so obviously anticompetitive.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by cogman10 on Monday August 19, 2024 @06:17PM (#41295037)
How?

I also think the antitrust suit (and many more) need to happen for more obvious things like buying out competitors. However, how does publishing a list of valid IPs for their web crawlers constitute anticompetitive behavior? Anyone can publish a similar list, and any company can choose to reference those lists.

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by arrosenberg on Monday August 19, 2024 @06:25PM (#41295079)
It allows Google to access data that is denied to competitors. It’s a clear example of Google using its market power to suppress competition.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by 8organicbits on Monday August 19, 2024 @06:50PM (#41295221)
Hmm, the robots.txt, IP blocking, and user agent blocking are all policies chosen by the web server hosting the data. If web admins choose to block Google competitors, I'm not sure that's on Google. Can you clarify?
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by GreenWatermelon on Monday August 19, 2024 @06:57PM (#41295269)
A nice example is the recent reddit-google deal which gives google' crawler exclusive access to reddit's data. This just serves to give google a competitive advantage over other search engine.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by sroussey on Monday August 19, 2024 @08:06PM (#41295582)
Nope. That deal was for AI not search.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by darkwater on Monday August 19, 2024 @09:32PM (#41296013)
Antitrust kicks in exactly in cases like this: using your moat in one market (search) to win another market (AI)
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by dns_snek on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @04:42AM (#41298086)
This is false, the deal cuts all other search engines off from accessing Reddit. Go to Bing and search for "news site:reddit.com" and filter results by date from the past week - 0 results.

https://www.404media.co/google-is-the-only-search-engine-tha...

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by wahnfrieden on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @09:01AM (#41299683)
What do you think search is
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by not2b on Monday August 19, 2024 @08:04PM (#41295574)
Well yes, the Reddit-Google deal might be found to violate antitrust. Probably will, because it is so blatantly anticompetitive. But if a publication decides to give special access to search engines so they can enforce their paywall but still be findable by search, I don't think the regulators would worry about that, provided that there's a way for competing search engines to get the same access.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by arrosenberg on Monday August 19, 2024 @08:31PM (#41295696)
Which is it? Regulators shouldn’t worry, or we need regulations to ensure equal access to the market?
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by immibis on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @06:48AM (#41298755)
regulators wouldn't worry if all search engines had equal access, even if you didn't because you're not a search engine
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by arrosenberg on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @10:35AM (#41300470)
And if I had wheels, I would be a car. Theres no equal access without regulation.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by paulddraper on Monday August 19, 2024 @07:29PM (#41295411)
It's not anticompetitive behavior by Google for a website to restrict their content.

Whether by IP, user account, user agent, whatever

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by arrosenberg on Monday August 19, 2024 @08:36PM (#41295718)
It kind of is. If Google divested search and the new company provided utility style access to that data feed, I would agree with you. Webmasters allow a limited number of crawlers based on who had market share in a specific window of time, which serves to lock in the dominance of a small number of competitors.

It may not be the kind of explicit anticompetitive behavior we normally see, but it needs to be regulated on the same grounds.

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by paulddraper on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:07PM (#41296379)
Google's action is to declare its identity.

The website operator can do with that identity as they wish.

They could block it, accept it, accept it but only on Tuesday afternoon.

---

"Anticompetitive" would be some action by Google to suppress competitors. Offering identification is not that.

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by arrosenberg on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @01:18AM (#41297047)
Regardless of whether Google has broken the law, the arrangement is clearly anticompetitive. It is not dissimilar to owning the telephone or power wires 100 years ago. Building operators were not willing to install redundant connections for the same service for each operator, and webmasters are not willing to allow unlimited numbers of crawlers on their sites. If we continue to believe in competitive and robust markets, we can't allow a monopolistic corporation to act as a private regulator of a key service that powers the modern economy.

The law may need more time to catch up, but search indexing will eventually be made a utility.

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by immibis on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @11:08AM (#41300772)
Google is paying the website to restrict their content.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by paulddraper on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @06:41PM (#41304844)
In a specific case (Reddit) yes.

And that has an argument.

But in the general case no.

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by bdd8f1df777b on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:16PM (#41296426)
If you can prove a deal made by Google and the website then you may have a case. Otherwise it is difficult to prove anything.
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by victorbjorklund on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @03:10PM (#41302985)
Which sites that allows Google to index their content blocks Bing and other search engines (not other bots just scraping for other purposes)?
Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by zo1 on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @04:50PM (#41303913)
It's clearly meant to starve out competitors. Why else would they want website operators to definitively "know" if it's a GoogleBot IP, other than so that they can differentiate it and treat it differently.

It's all the guise of feelgood stuff like "make sure it's google, and not some abusive scraper" language. But the end-result is pretty clear. Just because they have a parallel construction of a valid reason why they're doing something, doesn't mean they don't enjoy the convenient benefits it brings.

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by KennyBlanken on Monday August 19, 2024 @05:51PM (#41294851)
yes, where "cares" means "the lost revenue is greater than the cost of development, QA, and computational/network/storage overhead, and the impact of increased complexity, of a function that figures out whether people are faking their user agent."

It's probably orders of magnitude greater than the revenue loss from the tiny minority of people doing such things, especially given not everyone who uses tools like these will become a subscriber if blocked, so that cuts the "lost" revenue down even further.

Re:13ft – A site similar to 12ft.io but is self hosted by jsheard on Monday August 19, 2024 @05:54PM (#41294881)
Even if it's not worth an actual site operators time to implement such a system themselves, WAFs like Cloudflare could easily check the IP address of clients claiming to be Googlebot/Bingbot and send them to CAPTCHA Hell on the sites behalf if they're lying. That's pretty low hanging fruit for a WAF, I would be surprised if they don't do that.

edit: Indeed I just tried curling cloudflare.com with Googlebots user agent and they immediately gave me the finger (403) on the very first request.