News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by userbinator on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:10PM (#41285052)
Not a very popular position among Apple users because everything must come only from the App Store for some reason

Because "security" is a great marketing point and they've bought into that completely, thinking that trusting Apple and having it control your life is a good thing.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by t0md4n on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:23PM (#41285166)
I would argue that that’s better than having multiple devices from multiple manufactures and multiple software applications from multiple companies.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by luuurker on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:21PM (#41285610)
The option to buy devices from different brands is there, but you don't have to. Samsung or Google is happy to sell you a phone, a watch, earphones, and maybe some speakers for your home. Heck, Samsung will even sell you a TV, washing machine, and a fridge if you want.

In any case, what I struggle to understand is the position some have when it comes to install apps on iOS. I understand the security angle, but you can do it right (with Apple always in control of the OS and the permissions apps get), still be in the Apple ecosystem, and having the option to install a VPN app after Apple receives a court order to block said app.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by rodgerd on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:17PM (#41285991)
You can buy open hardware running Linux today. Why don't you?

Oh right, the mobile Linux experience is so bad only the most devoted will subject themselves to it.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by qeternity on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:15PM (#41285571)
Why do people do this? Name a device with comparable mass market success that is remotely close to being as secure as the iPhone.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by luuurker on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:31PM (#41285668)
Google's Pixel phones are usually known for having good security (from on-device hardware to fast and long - 7 years - security updates). And in this case you'd able to install the app even if it was banned from the official store... and no, my grandma never sideloaded malware, she uses the Play Store like everyone else.

It doesn't sell as well as iPhones or is only available on a small number of countries, but that's a different question. Most people don't buy iPhones because their security is good... they just want an iPhone.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by qeternity on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:36PM (#41285709)
> Most people don't buy iPhones because their security is good... they just want an iPhone.

You’re misunderstanding why people want an iPhone. There are many reasons, but “they just work” is a common refrain…and security underpins that.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by luuurker on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:52PM (#41286202)
The thing is, your iPhone would still work very well if you sideloaded this app that was banned in Brazil.

Even if you installed something malicious - something that should be a widespread problem on Android but isn't for some reason - the app would still run in the same sandbox that stops it from do a lot of bad things. iOS/Android is not Windows and Apple will always control that sandbox and OS updates.

But I'm not going to insist on this, it's your phone after all... I just look at what happens in some countries where you go from a good situation to a bad one pretty quickly (eg: Russia, some things in the US, etc) and suddenly Apple bans a VPN that lets you read outside news and things like that and you're essentially f*cked. I don't see how being in this position is good for anyone.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by dns_snek on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @08:06AM (#41299253)
> to fast and long - 7 years - security updates

It's worth pointing out that this is a very recent development in Android land that only arrived due to EU regulations.

https://endoflife.date/pixel

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by userbinator on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:35PM (#41285699)
A lot of people are starting to realise that "secure" means "secure AGAINST the user".
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by tptacek on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:01PM (#41285881)
Y... yes? That has always been the premise of Unix systems security?
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by userbinator on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:03PM (#41285899)
Not if the user is the one who actually owns the machine.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by tptacek on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:19PM (#41286004)
Yes, even then. Every sandboxing scheme ever devised has the same premise. That's why tools like Firejail were written. DRM/anticheat and anti-rootkit countermeasures are more or less the same technology.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by dns_snek on Tuesday August 20, 2024 @07:58AM (#41299180)
What GP obviously meant was "secure against the [rightful owner & user of the system]". That's never been the premise of *nix system security where the owner can ultimately do anything, no matter how self-destructive it is.

You're changing the semantic definition of "user" to mean "secure against the [restricted user account]" and thus mocking an argument that was never made.

Guidelines:

> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by darkhelmet on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:18PM (#41285592)
Playing devils advocate for a moment: One reason why is that many app developers truly do not have your best interests at heart. Taking heat for being a gatekeeper sucks, but the downsides of the alternatives are potentially limitless.

Random example: the fuss about the facebook advertising/tracking SDKs back in the day. When apple started giving unique device IDs to each app, this cross-app tracking mesh imploded and they were screaming about lost revenue. Maybe you find billions of dollars worth of tracking to be creepy, maybe not. But if facebook had the option of getting that functionality and revenue back via an easy sideloading or some other frictionless alternative mechanism then the entire app ecosystem that was even remotely related to facebook tracking would have been off the app store in a heartbeat. Instead of being at the mercy of apple, you, and your extended tech-support family would have been at the mercy of facebook.

Apple is no angel, but the potential downsides are limitless. Instead of the facebook tracking example, consider partially or overtly malicious apps that your parents are now installing on their phones (as well as their malware-ridden PCs).

On the other hand, sideloading is a fairly low barrier for technically competent folks. Stuff like iResign and other tools have been around forever. You can grab any pirated/hacked/etc app package, sign it yourself, and sideload it via your dev credentials. But at least you don't have to worry about your parents doing that. Or facebook telling your parents to do that.

Anyway, that's a "for some reason" example. The readership of HN are not the target audience that the app store gatekeeping is there for.

(But don't get me started on fees/commissions/etc - that's indefensible IMO)

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by luuurker on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:19PM (#41286007)
Apple controls the OS and the sandbox apps run on independently of the source of the app. Facebook would be able to tell users "you have to give us location access or the app won't run", but Apple controls what data is given to the app. Facebook could implement something to track users in the background, but the sandbox still kills/freezes the app as soon you hide it. They could implement some kind of tracking, but again, remember that the app runs in a sandbox and Apple controls that sandbox.

This is why a malware app on an iPhone can only do limited damage. It can't access all files, it can't encrypt the storage, it can't launch a DDoS in the background because the OS doesn't let it run, etc. iOS or Android are not Windows.

If you want to know how it works in practice, look at Android. It has supported sideloading for a long, long time. People do install a lot of crap, but that's from the app store. My parents are really bad with tech and never sideloaded anything.

And there are other layers of security too. If you go to a store, buy a Samsung, a Google Pixel, a OnePlus, Nokia, etc, they all come with Google Services, which includes Google Play Protect... essentially an anti-virus that looks at your apps and flags anything that is known to be malicious.

Are there any downsides? Yes. Are they as bad as some say? The Android example tells us that it doesn't have to be that bad.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by hagbard_c on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:37PM (#41286115)
> Are there any downsides? Yes.

There are downsides for Apple to the rate of their 30% cut. That is why they are doing their best to keep sideloading off their devices. Not to protect users - as you already stated there are many other layers of protection in place for that - but to protect their revenue.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by judge2020 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @08:40PM (#41286797)
> They could implement some kind of tracking, but again, remember that the app runs in a sandbox and Apple controls that sandbox.

Sandbox escapes are incredibly common, Apple still controls eliminating your business from iphones if you attempt to use an exploit to pull user data when you distribute through the App Store.

If you can do distribution via your own site, it becomes a whack-a-mole game with Apple - where data exfiltration exploits are found, Apple fixes them in a new update, then we have to wait for people to update.

And until most users update, the at-fault company is busy siphoning data from any user who can't update (e.g. no wifi / limited data plan) or any user who is slow to approve the update dialog. Eventually the company's app will grow to contain an exploit for the last dozen iOS versions that conditionally execute based on the iOS version/feature detection/probing for exploit availability.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by luuurker on Sunday August 18, 2024 @09:01PM (#41286901)
> Sandbox escapes are incredibly common

If iOS' sandbox is that insecure, then they have a problem on their hands.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by judge2020 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @09:32PM (#41287036)
The sandbox is the largest attack surface ever and trying to lock it down from everything forever is basically impossible.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by Gud on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:03AM (#41288517)
And as soon as app X starts exploiting a sandbox vulnerability, apple will patch it.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by judge2020 on Monday August 19, 2024 @09:42AM (#41290987)
Apps without app store review could also start delivering dynamic code packages that aren't included in the binary. There could be targeted attacks via these apps on specific users (say, journalists, politicians and their families, etc) not delivered to everyone; Apple thus can't analyze until it's been delivered to a device they control. App Store rules forbid dynamic native code delivery.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by luuurker on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:43AM (#41291994)
Perhaps journalists and politicians should stick with the App Store (which is what 99% of users do on Android, where you can sideload apps) and use Lockdown Mode.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by jncfhnb on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:41PM (#41285749)
The downsides to not having a vpn in an oppressive regime are limitless
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by 1over137 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:50PM (#41285818)
iOS has IPSec VPN support built-in, you don’t need the App Store or even an Apple ID to have a VPN.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by amritananda on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:08PM (#41285936)
China's Great Firewall is known actively detect and block most VPN protocols and things like SSH tunneling. There are custom protocols designed to camouflage traffic, but they require apps (e.g. Shadowrocket for iOS) which are, surprise, unavailable on the Chinese App Store. IIRC the same sort of blocking also happens in Iran as well.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by WheatMillington on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:16PM (#41285989)
In which case Apple's move here is anti competitive and monopolistic.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by dahart on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:24PM (#41286036)
How do you know Apple is making a move? What if this is a technical glitch?
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by lupusreal on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:21PM (#41286019)
Not quite sure I follow that logic. The point is an iphone can be configured to use a VPN (operated by anybody, not limited to Apple) without requiring the use of apps.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by luuurker on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:45PM (#41286162)
> The point is an iphone can be configured to use a VPN (operated by anybody, not limited to Apple) without requiring the use of apps

A very specific type of VPN, which is easily blocked.

I don't know if it's monopolistic as the comment you replied to says, but in the context of the thread, the build-in support doesn't fix the problem banning apps from the app store creates.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by judge2020 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @08:43PM (#41286808)
I'm not sure a country where they're forcing a company to take down apps would allow them to then get sued for the act of compliance being considered anti-competitive. Obviously whatever Apple does in a specific country can't be used to prove anti-competitiveness in another country since that country doesn't have jurisdiction.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by tptacek on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:00PM (#41285874)
I think one thing that's happening is that people have forgotten (or are too young to have really experienced) the absolute torrent of crapware that preceded the closed mobile app ecosystem. Almost no app developers had your best interests at heart, and some of the few who did ended up selling their apps to developers that didn't. If that risk seems remote now, it's in part because of the App Store.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by userbinator on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:17PM (#41285997)
I remember, and would still prefer that "torrent of crapware" which one could make up one's own mind about, rather than the dictatorship of the walled garden.

It's not like the App Store review process is particularly trustworthy either. There have been plenty of stories here and elsewhere of that.

Almost no app developers had your best interests at heart

Neither does Apple nor the developers of apps in the App Store. In fact, given the fees, they have even less incentive to avoid greed.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by tptacek on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:19PM (#41286006)
Absolutely. I'm glad you have the choice to use platforms that don't block crapware!
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by luuurker on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:59PM (#41286238)
Do you know anyone that has any of that old crapware on their Macs or had their Mac infected by malware in the past 5 or 10 years? I don't. And they can go to a website, download and install any app they want.

What about Android, which lets you sideload apps? How many people do you know that sideload apps or have installed a malicious app from outside the Play Store?

Yes, the App Store was and is important, but you need to look at other platforms if you really think that Apple allowing app sideloading (proper sideloading, not that shit they're doing in the EU) is going to take us back to the days of browser toolbars. iOS is not Windows XP.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by nottorp on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:10AM (#41288548)
> preceded the closed mobile app ecosystem

Just because the app store is closed it doesn't mean it's not full of crapware?

All the "games" are IAP fests. Every time you search for some big name app you get the app (if available) and a bunch of results that are named so deceptively that you're afraid to click on them.

Every week there's another story about a flashlight app that charges a 50/month or 9.99/week subscription.

So tell me how Apple's app curation helps?

> If that risk seems remote now

Maybe to you? I haven't looked at iOS games since the days of the iPad 1, when Apple hadn't pushed all game devs into IAPs yet.

And the few apps I bought, they were mentioned on forums not connected to Apple. And as you said yourself, there's always the chance the app gets sold and the terms change, and the walled garden won't help a single bit.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by tptacek on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:11AM (#41288555)
Who cares if games have IAPs? That's not what crapware is.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by nottorp on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:15AM (#41288572)
Sounds like you don't play games :)
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by tptacek on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:32AM (#41288684)
Not so much, no, but if you'd said in 2005 that there'd be a mainstream platform for general-purpose computing where the worst problem was that a lot of the games had in-app purchases, nobody would have believed you.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by nottorp on Monday August 19, 2024 @04:17AM (#41288975)
Conveniently ignoring the subscription flashlight apps and the still existing chance that apps get sold and become predatory on the next update, I think…
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by felipelemos on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:22PM (#41286022)
> Playing devils advocate for a moment: One reason why is that many app developers truly do not have your best interests at heart.

You are right, and neither Apple does.

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by WheatMillington on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:15PM (#41285983)
I dont understand how you can look at what is happening right now in this very article and say "Apple has my back".
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by judge2020 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:50PM (#41285813)
Part of the appeal is security for those who really need it. As a kid on Windows Vista i eagerly seeked out random hacks for the games I was playing, and ended up getting a few viruses here and there, resulting in my paypal balance being drained a few times (back when Paypal didn't have KYC or when it was easy to defeat). Maybe this was a good learning experience, but getting those viruses could've been much more consequential in a lot of ways and if I had really needed that money it would've been better if I was running something more locked down.
Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by bdw5204 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:05PM (#41285915)
Giving up freedom for "security" is the surest way to end up with neither of them. This situation where the government of Brazil has outlawed VPNs and Apple is collaborating with it to deprive the people of Brazil of their access to a free and open internet is a perfect illustration of this.

The difference between Apple's response and Twitter's response[0] to internet censorship efforts by the Brazilian government also shows why privately owned companies are more likely to stand on principle than publicly traded (i.e. stock market owned) companies which mainly answer to the pension funds and gamblers who control the stock market.

[0]: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cgjv857plevo

Re:Apple might be implementing a VPN censorship order in Brazil by rodgerd on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:15PM (#41285981)
Yeah, remember how great computers were in the 90s? So secure and usable.

I get that a lot of nerds long for the day when "desktop computer janitor" was a well-paid job and normal people couldn't use a computer effectively for any length of time. But that doesn't mean it was a good time.